Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My beloved pet is becoming a problem

285 replies

99problems99 · 04/03/2025 17:34

Firstly I’m fully aware of the fact ‘a pet is for life’. So please be kind i am desperate for some
constructive advice.

4 years (almost 5), I purchased a pedigree British long hair cat. She is the most beautiful girl, she was welcomed into the home and we love her. She was from a reputable registered breeder and cost me £950. Money wasn’t the issue I just dreamed of her for so long.

From the start she was always very particular with food.. no problem.. I just chopped and changed when she lost interest. She’s had the best of the best since the day she arrived. She’s groomed every day, she has lots of toys, up to date with vaccinations and is solely indoor. She has treats and cuddles (when she allows). She’s always been a little anti social and doesn’t like ‘new people’ until she has investigated them fully. Some she decides she doesn’t like at all and can be quite snappy and scratchy.

When she arrived my now 9DS was 4. They were fine together.. I’ve since had another boy who is 18m. She is awful to him. I’ve taught gim
to be gentle, he’s noisy of course but she used to just leave the room. Now it’s like she’s antagonistic towards him. I watch his every move but she has snarled at him and has scratched lightly twice. I’m on edge all of the time.

I teapot of course love her, but the safety of my son is paramount, I can’t settle knowing she may just get so fed up of him and hurt him. I suppose as he gets older this might settle but I don’t know what to do.

any advice is welcomed and please be kind this is breaking my heart I wouldn’t even know where to start if I ever considered rehoming her. I have posted in some local groups I am in for her breed and people have been so horrible.. as if i am saying she’s disposable now I have another child.. it’s not the case but I have to be realistic.

YABU- thinking of rehoming
YANBU- completely understandable to re home.

thanks for reading.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
thecatneuterer · 23/03/2025 18:04

Is she spayed? Unspayed indoor cats can become very aggressive and basically psychotic

StrikeAlways · 08/03/2025 21:26

99problems99 · 08/03/2025 07:16

I keep doing this I don’t know how to use this bloody thing. Ha ha so sorry I did this to another lady too. Now can you tell me how the flip i actually reply to the people who are mean 🤣 sorry xx

Click ‘Quote’ on the left under their post

GoldBeautifulHeart · 08/03/2025 18:20

Cat behaviourist.

Until then try feliway, a plug in to calm her. Also make sure she has many high places to jump onto so she can be away from him. Even on same level might antagonise her.

Cats need high up spaces to feel safe.

WiddlinDiddlin · 08/03/2025 18:05

Jumpingthruhoops · 08/03/2025 12:09

Well, whatever he did, worked. So I'm inclined to believe what I've seen with my own eyes over the musings of some random on the Internet! 🤷‍♀️

Qualified animal behaviourist randomer... but yes, it does seem to work because TV editing is very much a thing.

Most methods will appear to work if you edit out all the bloopers and fuck ups, and just use the bits gathered by tiring an animal out working with them all day, filling their house with a bunch of strangers (tv crew) and exhausting them.

Suit yourself, by the way, cats are not dogs, I don't know if you've noticed that. You can find a lot more information on why Graeme Hall is very much considered a joke within the dog behaviour/training community if you do a quick google.

WiddlinDiddlin · 08/03/2025 18:03

99problems99 · 08/03/2025 07:16

I keep doing this I don’t know how to use this bloody thing. Ha ha so sorry I did this to another lady too. Now can you tell me how the flip i actually reply to the people who are mean 🤣 sorry xx

hit the 'quote' button directly below someones post to reply with a quote of their comment, it will still appear at the end of the thread though.

Hitting the reply button anywhere within a thread will just put a reply at the end of the thread.

Jumpingthruhoops · 08/03/2025 12:09

WiddlinDiddlin · 08/03/2025 05:27

That isn't how cats think @Jumpingthruhoops - and don't take animal behaviour advice from Graeme Hall, his qualification is a self certified agreement that he has trained x dogs for x hours and an annual fee. He's on TV because he's good in front of a camera, not because he actually knows what he's talking about.

Simply not responding to unwanted behaviour leaves animals frustrated and owners suffering, its a massive over simplification that doesn't give the animal direction or management, which means the chances of them guessing the desired behaviour is very low!

Well, whatever he did, worked. So I'm inclined to believe what I've seen with my own eyes over the musings of some random on the Internet! 🤷‍♀️

99problems99 · 08/03/2025 07:16

Didimum · 07/03/2025 22:44

I’m replying to someone that quoted me and have only replied twice on this whole thread – so no, not accurate.

I keep doing this I don’t know how to use this bloody thing. Ha ha so sorry I did this to another lady too. Now can you tell me how the flip i actually reply to the people who are mean 🤣 sorry xx

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddlin · 08/03/2025 05:27

That isn't how cats think @Jumpingthruhoops - and don't take animal behaviour advice from Graeme Hall, his qualification is a self certified agreement that he has trained x dogs for x hours and an annual fee. He's on TV because he's good in front of a camera, not because he actually knows what he's talking about.

Simply not responding to unwanted behaviour leaves animals frustrated and owners suffering, its a massive over simplification that doesn't give the animal direction or management, which means the chances of them guessing the desired behaviour is very low!

Jumpingthruhoops · 08/03/2025 01:48

99problems99 · 04/03/2025 17:43

He can be sitting on the sofa next to him and she bats at him and makes like a growling noise at him. I show him when he does try to touch her to be gentle and if he does every touch her when I’m with him he is so gentle but she just bats at him without her claws.

She's straight up jealous, OP.
Presumably, your youngest cries and gets attention? Your cat has noticed this, so behaves in a way that she knows will get her the same attention.
Sounds like she'd got very used to being spoilt and, now your attention is elsewhere, she doesn't like it.
There was a dog just like this on C5's Dogs Behaving Badly. The trainer encouraged the owners not to respond to bad behaviour but to always reward their pet when she's good, so that she knows this is the behaviour that will give her the attention she craves.
Hope this helps in some way.

Didimum · 07/03/2025 22:44

99problems99 · 07/03/2025 20:20

Why don’t you just move along, you seem
to be looking for an argument.

I’m replying to someone that quoted me and have only replied twice on this whole thread – so no, not accurate.

99problems99 · 07/03/2025 20:20

Didimum · 07/03/2025 10:02

Hiding from a stranger isn't being "snappy and scratchy' – which means scratching and biting. That is NOT a pleasant cat, so your cat hiding isn't relevant.

Why don’t you just move along, you seem
to be looking for an argument.

OP posts:
Didimum · 07/03/2025 10:02

StrikeAlways · 07/03/2025 01:15

Many cats are suspicious of strangers. Siamese cats (of which I have had many and currently have two) are very loving to the humans in their family, but wary of strangers. One of mine will go to some people who visit the house if they have been there a little while, my other one hides until strangers have gone. They are both very pleasant cats!

Hiding from a stranger isn't being "snappy and scratchy' – which means scratching and biting. That is NOT a pleasant cat, so your cat hiding isn't relevant.

Coffeeishot · 07/03/2025 08:52

99problems99 · 06/03/2025 21:03

She is pleasant just a little misunderstood I feel. lol

Oh she's beautiful 😍

VenusClapTrap · 07/03/2025 08:31

99problems99 · 06/03/2025 21:03

She is pleasant just a little misunderstood I feel. lol

She’s gorgeous

StrikeAlways · 07/03/2025 01:17

99problems99 · 06/03/2025 21:03

She is pleasant just a little misunderstood I feel. lol

She’s beautiful. Those who describe her as unpleasent don’t understand cats.

StrikeAlways · 07/03/2025 01:15

Didimum · 06/03/2025 13:23

She’s always been a little anti social and doesn’t like ‘new people’ until she has investigated them fully. Some she decides she doesn’t like at all and can be quite snappy and scratchy.

Don't blame you for seeing the best in her – we all do with our own pets. But that's not a pleasant cat.

Many cats are suspicious of strangers. Siamese cats (of which I have had many and currently have two) are very loving to the humans in their family, but wary of strangers. One of mine will go to some people who visit the house if they have been there a little while, my other one hides until strangers have gone. They are both very pleasant cats!

ForeverLoveCeltic · 06/03/2025 23:31

Our cat was a traveller, an adventurer; at first it was traumatic when she stayed away, sometimes a few days, tried keeping her home but this stressed her hugely. She was often seen near the train line that ran through a distant part of the city , on a few occasions hopped onto a train and got off at the next stop. She would return home unabashed at the worry she'd caused, eat lots and sleep for hours till the whole scenario was repeated over and over. Blossom was a cat who thought she was a tiger. 💚

ForeverLoveCeltic · 06/03/2025 23:11

"Not trainable and hiss, claw
and bite" Not great really when you think about it.....🙈

ForeverLoveCeltic · 06/03/2025 22:53

This sounds like the (beautiful, pedigree)cat my grandson got for his 5th birthday. From the beginning he adored her and she, in her aloof way him. She was an outdoors cat, fearless and quite feral almost. Very territorial too. She was always a bit of a madam, demanding of attention but only on her terms. When she was 5 they got a working Cocker, Wonderful sweet natured boy but Blossom of course wasn't happy, it took her a year to get used to him then she bossed him to bits, took over both his beds. Every so often she would swipe at him with her claws out, she in this time became aggressive with us too, scratching and biting if you so much as stroked her the wrong way. This lasted till she was about 15, our lovely vet said some cats are naturally aggressive at times. She had to be anaesthetised to have her long thick coat shaved twice a year, she was like a kitten afterwards and very affectionate for a while till the coat got so thick again, it was an odd scenario. She was extremely healthy, very fit & slender, never ill at all and lived till 21. We assumed having the dog triggered her aggression , maybe your dc2 has done the same and you can only keep them apart. Apologies for this very long post, 💚

Mybabyloveswires · 06/03/2025 21:08

My toddler is 18 months and we rehomed a cat 4 months ago. The cat has never been around little people before and was petrified by our noisy clumsy toddler and would often hiss and swipe at her. I just taught the toddler not to go near that particular cat. My toddler now walks around the cat giving it a wide birth and the cat hasn’t hissed or swiped at her for 2 months. They are both very respectful of each other and keep out of each others ways. The cat will come round and accept the toddler when the toddler will be more predictable.

99problems99 · 06/03/2025 21:04

CleansUpButWouldPreferNotTo · 06/03/2025 11:50

Well, @99problems99 , there's much sensible advice been given here around handling the problem and refocusing your cat's attention away from your toddler and seeing him as a good thing. I understand why some people are saying rehome her, but I'd hold off for a bit until you try a few possible solutions. You're obviously on top of your DC's safety, so I think you have time to work on your cat.

Are you aware of the cat whisperer Jackson Galaxy? Check out his youtube channel, he has helped many problem cats and their human families: https://www.youtube.com/@JacksonGalaxy/videos

Best of luck, I hope it works out for all of you.

I haven’t heard of him but will check that out! Thank you so much x

OP posts:
99problems99 · 06/03/2025 21:03

Didimum · 06/03/2025 13:23

She’s always been a little anti social and doesn’t like ‘new people’ until she has investigated them fully. Some she decides she doesn’t like at all and can be quite snappy and scratchy.

Don't blame you for seeing the best in her – we all do with our own pets. But that's not a pleasant cat.

She is pleasant just a little misunderstood I feel. lol

My beloved pet is becoming a problem
OP posts:
99problems99 · 06/03/2025 21:00

Sunburstclocklover · 06/03/2025 10:35

As a total cat person I urge you to consider rehoming her. My mother took my much loved cat when Puss randomly attacked my then 9 month old daughter.
Puss was fine with the older children and the baby, until she started to crawl. Puss used to sit beside baby when she was lying on the floor get changed and even bathed.
In middle of the night I was up with baby and changed her. Left her on floor in sitting room. Puss came with me into the kitchen. Baby showed me that she had learnt crawl by following me! She was crawling up the hall focusing on me , so happy that she could crawl when Puss went berserk! She howled and hissed and ran at baby jumping up with claws out straight for baby's head and face. I just managed to grab and save baby. Puss obviously saw 'crawling baby' as a different creature from kicking legs on floor baby! Puss would have done real damage. Rehomed very happily to live a long life with grandma! I still got to see her when we visited.

O wow, bless baby I’m glad you managed to save the baby from an attack. It does scare me, I’ve never seen her approach him voluntarily only ever if he comes to her.. but not worth the risk. Keeping them apart for now. Thank you for commenting xx

OP posts:
DearDenimEagle · 06/03/2025 15:19

I’ve not read all the posts, but there are ways to make her feel safe..like those walkways and cat paths up and along walls so she can get out of the way.Some are quite elaborate but a few strategically placed shelves to let her climb up the wall and nest up high might go a way to letting her stay.

My beloved pet is becoming a problem
My beloved pet is becoming a problem
My beloved pet is becoming a problem
pollymere · 06/03/2025 14:39

My cat is a "Rehomed" one. The owner was going into a Care Home. However, we then found her Mum was bullying her so she's petrified of cats. And that she had scratched children. She has a terrible habit of tapping your face to get your attention but forgets she has claws. She's just stupid rather than it being malicious. Her Mum didn't teach her the necessary skills. She's petrified of all but four people. She will run and hide at the sound of the front door or if we have visitors. Luckily she adores our Vet.

Your cat was showing that she's scared of people when you got her. Maybe she was mistreated by the Breeder? She may also not have been able to learn things from her Mum either. Give her somewhere safe to hide and make sure she's still getting plenty of cuddles. We have cushions on windowsills etc. We also make a loud noise if she goes to scratch our face and she does it far less. Ignoring her afterwards has also made her realise we don't like the behaviour.

Now she's beginning to just sit and miaow at us instead! Although she's very good at batting a mobile phone out of your hands...

I don't think she needs to be Rehomed unless she really does need a quiet environment without children in and some cats need that. Could you invest in a Catio or Safe Outdoor Space so she can go outside and sit in the sunshine or sniff plants? This is my cat's favourite thing to do.