Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel so lonely visiting my parents

264 replies

lonelydaughter · 03/03/2025 21:25

I grew up in a wealthy but emotionally distant family. My parents would say things like “I love you” and ask for kisses when we did see each other, but those moments were brief. They preferred to spend their free time reading or watching TV rather than actively engaging with me. If I wanted to be around them, it was on their terms: I’d go to their room or office, where they’d continue their activities while I quietly sat nearby. If I didn’t want to do that, I’d just go to my own room and play alone. The living room was rarely used.

Now, as grandparents, they want me to visit, but only for short periods. They’ll happily see my daughter (she’s 3) at mealtimes, but outside of that, they’re back to their books and screens. If I suggest an outing, like a trip to the farm, they decline because she’s “too young,” might have a tantrum, or walks too slowly, cries unpredictably. Their version of spending time with her is letting her climb on their bed or sofa while they scroll on their phones or read, occasionally swatting her away if she blocks the screen. They might put on some music for her to dance to or at best read her a short book, but after an hour of hanging out, it’s, “Alright, maybe go outside before we all go mad?” Even a simple walk is out of the question: she walks too slowly, stops too much, gets distracted by everything.

I feel guilty for not visiting more because I know they’d be sad. When we are there, they shower us with “I’ve missed you,” “Give me a kiss,” “I love you both so much,” and “You’re the best daughter and granddaughter.” But the reality is, every visit leaves me feeling lonely and exhausted. I’m solo parenting 22 hours a day, just without the support of friends like I have at home and without seeing my husband in the evening if I visit during the week when he works.

To avoid a drip feed, they are incredibly generous financially, they’ve helped me buy a house, promised to cover my daughter’s private school fees, and often give large gifts for birthdays and holidays.

By contrast, my in-laws don’t have a huge house, but DH’s childhood was filled with stories of quality time together. With our daughter, they’re the same—they’ll get on the floor to play, make crafts, read, tell stories, and sing songs. They’d love to go to the farm with us and often do. The difference is stark and it makes me feel so let down. I don't know whether to cut down the visits and disappoint my parents, or keep it up but be unhappy every visit.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cheesyfootballs01 · 07/06/2025 21:59

They are who they are OP.

You can’t change how that and it seems like they were the same when you were young so why do you think they will magically change?

A couple of hours away is easily done as a day trip - or 2 days max. I definitely wouldn’t be going for nearly a week every month!

Coco1379 · 07/06/2025 21:45

Might they have been brought up with distant parents themselves, where ‘Nanny’ had the care of the children and saw the parents at tea time, or something like that?
Or it might just be that they cannot express their love in that way, but they obviously care for you by being generous.
My mother and father had routines that wouldn’t change if I visited, and when my mother came to my house she would want to iron or dust or something. She didn’t get that I just wanted her to come and see me.

Mere1 · 06/03/2025 05:54

Shubbypubby · 05/03/2025 22:45

Looking after your own child isn't solo parenting- it's parenting. If you're healthy and a generally competent adult there isn't a basic need to have another parent, friends or your own parents also looking after your child at the same time as you. It's completely different to raising a child on your own- being a solo/single/lone parent, where the entire responsibility for everything is on you.

This is the way I see this too.

icallshade · 06/03/2025 03:27

People grandparent differently OP.
Sounds to me like you've got the best of both worlds- a loving, fun family (in laws) and tonnes of financial support (your parents)
You explain that you've never had the type of relationship your craving from your family so it's unsurprising that things haven't changed since having your child.
Perhaps cut the visits to a day trip (leave early snd come back late? A couple of hour drive each way isnt too bad if it's all day.

I would be very grateful in your circumstances as both mine and in laws family see us exceptionally sporadically and offer no support financially or otherwise.

LittleCharlotte · 06/03/2025 01:53

I think this is quite common, when you become a parent yourself, to look back on your own childhood and realise how you missed out. Yes money is great but it sounds like you were lacking love and affection and you see that playing out with your own child now. It's not fun to spend time with people who aren't going to be a bit understanding that a baby (which she is) has tantrums.

If I were you I'd cut the visits down a little, and I'd also look for a "surrogate" grandparent perhaps closer to home. An older friend who appreciates spending time with the little one, and you. I don't mean to forget about your parents, but it sounds like it could help fill a void for you both. A kind older role model is very important to a child (and as someone in their 40s I think it's important to me too!).

Feelinadequate23 · 05/03/2025 23:38

They’re not small kid people OP, got to just accept that, I’m afraid.

4-5 nights at a time every month is insane! I don’t know anyone who spends nearly that amount of time with GPs, even when they get on really well! The irony is that you’re only able to do this because they fund you to be a SAHP!

you need to get more set plans in your routine which mean you can only go for 2 days at a time. Is DD not in pre-school at all? Could she not do a few mornings a week? Then throw in a swimming lesson and a music class and suddenly you can’t do more than one overnight at a time unless it’s over a weekend. Would you want to go back to work part time at all?

I would make a plan to slowly dial back the visits so they don’t notice so much. From now on make a plan on the fourth day so you can only stay 3 nights. Then throw in pre-school from September so then you can only go for 2 nights. From Nov/Dec add an extra thing and then it will be one night only other than weekends.

I would also strongly suggest turning down the help with private school fees - you really don’t want to feel controlled in this way for the next 14 years!

Wordau · 05/03/2025 23:09

This sounds like my PIL and to an extent my parents.

They just don't know how to connect with our DC unless it's completely on their terms.

Be grateful you have one set of GPs who do!

2Rebecca · 05/03/2025 23:06

Do you challenge them on their behaviour? 4 nights a month sounds a lot to me. I would cut it down to a couple of nights and if they moan say "I suspect 2 days is plenty as you spend most of your time on your phones". Are you jealous because with a toddler you get no time to yourself? Toddlers are boring to most adults. Fine for 10 minutes. Your parents may be better as she gets older. You seem to resent your parents just getting on with their lives whilst you are there. They are who they are. If you are bored and lonely there shorten the visits or take more stuff to do/ go out for a few hours even if they won't go

Bigearringsbigsmile · 05/03/2025 22:48

You have posted this exact post before I am sure. They enable you to a sahm don't they?

Shubbypubby · 05/03/2025 22:45

Looking after your own child isn't solo parenting- it's parenting. If you're healthy and a generally competent adult there isn't a basic need to have another parent, friends or your own parents also looking after your child at the same time as you. It's completely different to raising a child on your own- being a solo/single/lone parent, where the entire responsibility for everything is on you.

emanresu24 · 05/03/2025 16:56

BogRollBOGOF · 04/03/2025 07:29

YANBU

As the Beatles sang "Can't buy me love"
It's hard when parents aren't interested in your life and won't compromise at all.
It won't magically be better when DD is past toddlerhood because they're not that kind of people and they haven't worked to build up a bond with her.

You can work on social connections in your general life to ease lonliness. It may be worth considering working some of the time to add structure to your life.

DM has no relationship with DS1. Quite frankly she doesn't like him because he's autistic and doesn't conform to her narrow ideas about how a child should be (seen and not heard- she wants to monologue at me and doesn't want to hear from him). And he doesn't like her because everything is her way and doesn't accomodate his needs. He's always struggled around her because the house is a sensory assault with TVs and radios on full blast, then he's "naughty" for melting down 🙄 She has a long history of playing favourites in close and extended family and does the same over my children and I'm not rushing to facilitate that. We're at the point where she only sends DS2 love at the end of a phone call like DS1 doesn't exist. (Yes it's complicated and she probably has her underlying reasons but I can't fix her, just what I do and to protect my DCs.)

It's ok to establish a comfort level of the relationship you want with them. You can decide to go less frequently. You can rearrange the structure of visits: mine did not react well to the journey, faffing in the house then going out to eat so I shifted it to travelling earlier then going to the nearby park to burn energy before going to the house which put the DCs in a better mood to cope.
If you can broaden the purpose of the visit and spend less time with these emotionally constipated people that raised you, it will make it easier to manage.

I know how this feels. My mother has the same views, she also wants to monologue at me. I can see where the autism came from!

Delphiniumandlupins · 04/03/2025 21:07

thepariscrimefiles · 04/03/2025 19:11

It may not be particularly onerous but it's not enjoyable. Her parents want OP and her daughter to visit frequently but they don't actually want to be in their company. They seem like duty visits where nobody enjoys themselves so I'm not sure why her parents insist on it.

OP needs to ask them. Parents are demanding and not being challenged.

Delphiniumandlupins · 04/03/2025 21:03

LameBorzoi · 04/03/2025 19:23

In a tidy grandparents' house? For almost a week a month? Sounds like a nightmare.

I agree the visits should be shorter. If the parents object they're not seeing enough of their DD and DGD then it adds weight to "doing more when we're together".

Burntt · 04/03/2025 20:52

I think cut the visits down to 2ish days. Or do more visits but much shorter each time?

Like you said they love you they cut have this barrier in how they express it.

BUT remember how it felt as a child and let that influence the way you spend time with your children. My parents never played with me or spent time with me and I'm making a real effort to not parent that way!

LameBorzoi · 04/03/2025 19:23

Delphiniumandlupins · 04/03/2025 19:01

But entertaining your own 3 year old child for a day or two, even single-handed, isn't particularly onerous.

In a tidy grandparents' house? For almost a week a month? Sounds like a nightmare.

irregularegular · 04/03/2025 19:16

I've read now that you go for 4-5 days once a month. I think that's a lot without good company. Take it down to 2-3 days and I think it would be much easier. I'd get bored from 4-5 days!

LizardQueeny · 04/03/2025 19:14

ItsaMOBone · 04/03/2025 17:45

I haven’t read any contempt in any of the OP’s posts @arethereanyleftatall . She’s clearly a dutiful and loving daughter who is confused by the mixed messages from her parents. They want her to visit frequently, and stay a long time, but don’t want to spend much time with her or their granddaughter. They are hugely financially generous but not generous with their own time. I find the OP’s position completely reasonable,

It's (genuinely) interesting how differently people have understood the OP's posts. Seems to be about 50% loving daughter with awful unloving parents, 50% loving (albeit reserved and elderly) parents with a sneering and ungrateful daughter. Possibly the truth is somewhere in the middle.

irregularegular · 04/03/2025 19:13

I don't think it is that unusual for them not to interract with your daughter that much. It could be a lot worse - they could be positively nasty! I'm not sure how much and how long you are visiting for, so it is hard to know whether it would be reasonable to cut down or not. Could you make more of your visits with your DH so you have more company? Or just accept that when you spend time there, you will need to entertain your daughter yourself, rather than expect them to be closely involved, even including going outside for walks and to play. Presumably if you were at home with her you would also spend some time just with her without friends or DH.

thepariscrimefiles · 04/03/2025 19:11

Delphiniumandlupins · 04/03/2025 19:01

But entertaining your own 3 year old child for a day or two, even single-handed, isn't particularly onerous.

It may not be particularly onerous but it's not enjoyable. Her parents want OP and her daughter to visit frequently but they don't actually want to be in their company. They seem like duty visits where nobody enjoys themselves so I'm not sure why her parents insist on it.

Delphiniumandlupins · 04/03/2025 19:01

thepariscrimefiles · 04/03/2025 07:19

OP has said that she takes her daughter to places/activities while she is visiting her parents, but there are fewer suitable places to visit than at home and she doesn't have any mum friends so feels more lonely and isolated doing this alone with her daughter.

But entertaining your own 3 year old child for a day or two, even single-handed, isn't particularly onerous.

Angels1111 · 04/03/2025 18:44

I can completely relate as my PIL are exactly like this. What a PP said about their preference being we all coexist in the same house vs my difficulties in trying to parent by myself in someone else's house hit the nail on the head.
It actually made it harder than just being at home because at home my toddler would totter around and keep himself entertained for a bit whereas at PILs he was in a less familiar environment so wanted more attention which only I gave him after the initial hour.
It took me a long time to understand that "a couple of hours at the most" was quite simply their social capacity - because they never verbalised it for themselves and didn't understand why I wouldn't just want to hang around at their house while they went to their rooms/out - so our visits are much shorter now and I've filled my cup with friends/family that do interact with DC more. Even though they live an hour away, I've worked out that driving an hour, visiting for two, and then driving back was better for us all.

ItsaMOBone · 04/03/2025 17:45

I haven’t read any contempt in any of the OP’s posts @arethereanyleftatall . She’s clearly a dutiful and loving daughter who is confused by the mixed messages from her parents. They want her to visit frequently, and stay a long time, but don’t want to spend much time with her or their granddaughter. They are hugely financially generous but not generous with their own time. I find the OP’s position completely reasonable,

jolota · 04/03/2025 17:01

It sounds like they are interacting with their granddaughter in a similar way to how they raised you?
If so, I'm not sure you can expect any change from them without a difficult conversation & it feels like you're avoiding anything like that because there's a financial incentive to keep them happy.

Threeboystwocatsandadog · 04/03/2025 17:00

If I’m being honest, I’m not a very “hands on” granny. Dsd would have liked me to do some regular childcare but I really didn’t want to. I have done holiday cover, inset days, sickness and other emergencies though. I actually found the early year’s easiest as we could do swimming, soft play, farms etc. He’s 13 now and I haven’t a clue what to do with him!

Threeboystwocatsandadog · 04/03/2025 16:34

In the next year or two your daughter will be going to nursery/school and that will naturally curtail your visits. You will be restricted to weekends and holidays. She will also likely be invited to parties and have some activities at the weekends. As she gets older your parents may begin to enjoy her company (although I wouldn’t hold my breath on that one) or at least going out for a meal with you both.

It sounds as if they have always been this way. I think you just need to be grateful for the things they can give you and be glad that you daughter has another set of grandparents that are more fun.