Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend's one night stands to get pregnant

317 replies

Polkadotbikinininii · 03/03/2025 14:03

I know this is none of my business. I won't say anything to her unless she brings it up again. I will NEVER say anything to anyone else.

My friend is late 30s and long term single. She has always wanted kids and is very aware of her age.

She told me drunkenly the other night that a few years ago she started having one night stands with the hope of getting pregnant.

She says that she is open with the men about what she is doing as she has no interest in tricking or trapping them. She is happy to nevet see them again and be a single mum.

She thinks she's done it about 25 times in the last few years. Apparently only a few have said no. Most of the men just want reassurance that she won't go after them for money/relationship. 🤨She said 2 men have said they would like to stay in touch if she gets pregnant.

She is stunningly beautiful and funny so I can well imagine that most men will be so impressed with themselves for getting her in bed that they aren't thinking straight enough to say no.

She is very capable of looking after hererself/a child. She has a strong family network who will make sure the child is sorted if something happens to my friend.

She said that the men who don't want anything to do with any child are deadbeats and she wouldn't want them in their life anyway. I asked about what happened if the ones who are interested turn out to be deadbeats and she said that could happen with any pregnancy. I asked about the child that won't know who their dad is and again, she said it's better than a deadbeat who won't support the child and let's them down.

She reassured me that she does do STD tests and never puts herself at risk. Apparently she is very strict with herself and if she is "going out to make babies" she doesn't drink at all and apparently if she has never bought anyone back when drunk.

I asked why she doesn't use donated sperm. She said she doesn't like the idea of it being medicalised and all the pressure of it and that she was also having fun.

She pointed out that any one night stand could result in a baby with a stranger and at least this way, the baby will be wanted.

I couldn't explain why I think this is all just so yukky. She accused me of slut shaming and pointed out that the men she takes home will be bragging to their friends every time they get a woman in bed and that lots of women take home more men than she does and plenty of people don't use protection.

Ignoring the risks, I don't think it's the taking people home that made me purse my lips. It's the intention behind it. It's irrational but I feel like maybe an accidental baby from a very short relationship is a better idea than a wanted baby after a one night stand?

ARE unreasonable- your friend will make a great mum and there will be good support for her and any baby. She has told you she isn't taking any risks.

ARE NOT unreasonable - getting pregnant ON PURPOSE from a one night stand is grim. She should be exploring other options.

OP posts:
TattooGuineaPig · 03/03/2025 16:10

Sorry if someone has mentioned this already, but this stopped me in my tracks

"She reassured me that she does do STD tests and never puts herself at risk."

So she tests the one night stands BEFORE sleeping with them?

Duggeewoof · 03/03/2025 16:03

Your friend is talking bollocks. And I absolutely would judge her.

KimberleyClark · 03/03/2025 16:03

Hwi · 03/03/2025 15:38

I am against having sex before marriage, but in this case I think she is doing the absolutely right thing - she is in her 30s, fertility falling. And life is pointless without either biological or adopted kids for normal people (nuns and priests excluded as they have a higher meaning). All my clever female mates who either did not have or adopt children, deeply regret it now in their 40s. It is OK for men to dick around with this decision and then sprog off in their 60s, but our fertile age is very short. She is doing the right thing. She is honest and upfront and unlike some second wives on here who 'had have accidents' and then bemoan their elderly husbands do not engage with child rearing, she deceives nobody. Good luck to her and I hope she is successful in her plan.

What a load of nonsense.

ForRealCat · 03/03/2025 16:01

Praying4Peace · 03/03/2025 15:57

Makes my blood run cold at the thought of a baby being conceived with a planned one night stand.
If friend desperately wants to be a parent, why doesn't she consider adoption or fostering?

Why does a couple who want a baby not consider adoption, or a couple going through IVF? Because on a fundamental level we recognise its different. This Fostering is not this woman's solution

Crazycatlady79 · 03/03/2025 16:00

Hwi · 03/03/2025 15:38

I am against having sex before marriage, but in this case I think she is doing the absolutely right thing - she is in her 30s, fertility falling. And life is pointless without either biological or adopted kids for normal people (nuns and priests excluded as they have a higher meaning). All my clever female mates who either did not have or adopt children, deeply regret it now in their 40s. It is OK for men to dick around with this decision and then sprog off in their 60s, but our fertile age is very short. She is doing the right thing. She is honest and upfront and unlike some second wives on here who 'had have accidents' and then bemoan their elderly husbands do not engage with child rearing, she deceives nobody. Good luck to her and I hope she is successful in her plan.

life is pointless without either biological or adopted kids for normal people

What a load of arrant, antiquated BS.

Naunet · 03/03/2025 16:00

Hellskitchen24 · 03/03/2025 15:57

We have no idea what she is saying to these men. If she says she is on the pill then they may be foolish enough to believe that. Also condoms aren’t foolproof anyway.

Yes I'm pretty sure men are aware condoms aren't fool proof. There's nothing to suggest shes telling men she's on the pill, but it's irrelevant, men know how babies are made, if they dont want to end up with an unplanned baby, they should wear a condom. They are just as responsible for this as women are, they are not being 'deceived'.

ForRealCat · 03/03/2025 15:59

If she's been at this a few years and still not pregnant its obviously not working for her and she needs to change approach. My guess would be she's desperate for a child and when shes had a few drinks she risks it, rather than it being a real approach to getting pregnant

Tristan5 · 03/03/2025 15:58

Polkadotbikinininii · 03/03/2025 14:03

I know this is none of my business. I won't say anything to her unless she brings it up again. I will NEVER say anything to anyone else.

My friend is late 30s and long term single. She has always wanted kids and is very aware of her age.

She told me drunkenly the other night that a few years ago she started having one night stands with the hope of getting pregnant.

She says that she is open with the men about what she is doing as she has no interest in tricking or trapping them. She is happy to nevet see them again and be a single mum.

She thinks she's done it about 25 times in the last few years. Apparently only a few have said no. Most of the men just want reassurance that she won't go after them for money/relationship. 🤨She said 2 men have said they would like to stay in touch if she gets pregnant.

She is stunningly beautiful and funny so I can well imagine that most men will be so impressed with themselves for getting her in bed that they aren't thinking straight enough to say no.

She is very capable of looking after hererself/a child. She has a strong family network who will make sure the child is sorted if something happens to my friend.

She said that the men who don't want anything to do with any child are deadbeats and she wouldn't want them in their life anyway. I asked about what happened if the ones who are interested turn out to be deadbeats and she said that could happen with any pregnancy. I asked about the child that won't know who their dad is and again, she said it's better than a deadbeat who won't support the child and let's them down.

She reassured me that she does do STD tests and never puts herself at risk. Apparently she is very strict with herself and if she is "going out to make babies" she doesn't drink at all and apparently if she has never bought anyone back when drunk.

I asked why she doesn't use donated sperm. She said she doesn't like the idea of it being medicalised and all the pressure of it and that she was also having fun.

She pointed out that any one night stand could result in a baby with a stranger and at least this way, the baby will be wanted.

I couldn't explain why I think this is all just so yukky. She accused me of slut shaming and pointed out that the men she takes home will be bragging to their friends every time they get a woman in bed and that lots of women take home more men than she does and plenty of people don't use protection.

Ignoring the risks, I don't think it's the taking people home that made me purse my lips. It's the intention behind it. It's irrational but I feel like maybe an accidental baby from a very short relationship is a better idea than a wanted baby after a one night stand?

ARE unreasonable- your friend will make a great mum and there will be good support for her and any baby. She has told you she isn't taking any risks.

ARE NOT unreasonable - getting pregnant ON PURPOSE from a one night stand is grim. She should be exploring other options.

Her morals and behaviour, like those of the men involved, could not be any lower - utterly reprehensible, consigning a child to a life of lies and an unknown father.

Hellskitchen24 · 03/03/2025 15:57

Naunet · 03/03/2025 15:53

Sorry, are you suggesting a man who knowningly has unprotected sex, doesn't know he could end up with a baby?!

We have no idea what she is saying to these men. If she says she is on the pill then they may be foolish enough to believe that. Also condoms aren’t foolproof anyway.

Praying4Peace · 03/03/2025 15:57

Makes my blood run cold at the thought of a baby being conceived with a planned one night stand.
If friend desperately wants to be a parent, why doesn't she consider adoption or fostering?

BeaAndBen · 03/03/2025 15:56

She’s an idiot. With sperm donation she has the health and medical history of the child’s father. She can select for things that matter to her, and she would be protecting her own health and that of any resulting child.

Shagging strangers in the hopes a pregnancy is unnecessarily risky behaviour. If she’s serious about having a child she should take responsibility for doing so with the best possible outcomes.

DazedDragon · 03/03/2025 15:56

YABU - the men are consenting to this so nothing wrong with that.

But YANBU to be concerned. An STD check after EVERY partner?!?! This is a huge risk to her sexual health.

And not to mention if she has done this 25 times at least, no doubt when ovulating, and she still hasn't got pregnant, then there is perhaps something not so fertile about her?

Quiverfullof · 03/03/2025 15:54

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Naunet · 03/03/2025 15:53

Hellskitchen24 · 03/03/2025 15:48

It’s totally different. A man who has been a sperm donor knows he will have biological children out there. He will be informed when a woman has a live birth from his donations. As anonymous sperm donation is now illegal in most of Europe, he can anticipate that his donor conceived children may contact him in 18 years time. He of course has no legal or financial obligations to them.

This is totally different to a man that has biological children he knows nothing about because he had a one night stand with a woman whose sole intention was getting pregnant. That’s deception.

Sorry, are you suggesting a man who knowningly has unprotected sex, doesn't know he could end up with a baby?!

Catza · 03/03/2025 15:51

Nanny1983 · 03/03/2025 14:20

The poor child who will be involved in this . Your friend obv thinks her need to have a child outweighs the child’s need for a Dad .
Imagine the child growing up and finding out this information .

If my experience is anything to go by, the child will be absolutely fine. That's how my parents conceived me - one night stand. I sincerely wish I never knew my father, he was an absolute arse and my mum didn't want to have anything to do with him. It was only on my grandparents' insistence that "a child needs to know their father" that I got to meet him.

RedVelvetIcing · 03/03/2025 15:51

Of course she is putting herself at risk. Vile.

pinksheetss · 03/03/2025 15:50

Don't think she's being safe just by doing STD tests, doing them after the fact doesn't help if she catches them especially if it's something that's worse than just an antibiotic to clear

Quiverfullof · 03/03/2025 15:50

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Hwi · 03/03/2025 15:49

Makebelievedream · 03/03/2025 15:39

That's a good point. She's at least vetting them for looks.

But how would a child conceived that way feel? Or do you lie to your children about something like that, would that be ok?

It's understandable not to want to use a sperm bank - expensive, some medical procedures you'd probably rather not go through and the lack of information at least about the looks of the donor.
But I think the future feelings of the child need to be considered. This method doesn't scream future child happy with their relationship with their dad.

You are making a sensible, wonderful point. But have you forgotten maybe, that we live in a world where children are supposed to fit with adult desires, unfortunately, not the normal way around - adult fitting their desires around children. As one prominent child rights campaigner said - we live in a world where children are just superimposed on whatever picture an adult wants - thus lies about it being better to divorce than live with a husband you stopped finding sexually attractive, lies about non-biological males being no danger for children, that two mums and two dads are the same as a mum and a dad, etc. etc. So unfortunately you are right, but this is not the world we live in these days. Black is white and white is black, I am afraid.

MissDoubleU · 03/03/2025 15:49

AnneLovesGilbert · 03/03/2025 14:15

She says that she is open with the men about what she is doing as she has no interest in tricking or trapping them

And a load of pigs just flew over my garden. Absolute bollocks she tells them. She’s taking for an idiot and she’s awful.

Yes but any man having unprotected sex with a stranger is well aware there is a pregnancy risk. Open and upfront or not, it’s down to them to wear a condom or risk pregnancy. If they’re raw dogging, they know the risk is there. They have all the agency to say “if you won’t agree to a condom I won’t be having sex” - they just don’t care. A vast ocean of men don’t.

Quiverfullof · 03/03/2025 15:48

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

YesHonestly · 03/03/2025 15:48

So she’s done this for years, slept with at least 25 men and not gotten pregnant?

I assume if she is intentional about getting pregnant, she’s doing this when she knows she’s in her fertile window? I’d encourage her to speak to her GP for some tests.

Hellskitchen24 · 03/03/2025 15:48

beAsensible1 · 03/03/2025 15:39

Its not any different to using a sperm donor

It’s totally different. A man who has been a sperm donor knows he will have biological children out there. He will be informed when a woman has a live birth from his donations. As anonymous sperm donation is now illegal in most of Europe, he can anticipate that his donor conceived children may contact him in 18 years time. He of course has no legal or financial obligations to them.

This is totally different to a man that has biological children he knows nothing about because he had a one night stand with a woman whose sole intention was getting pregnant. That’s deception.

ParrotParty · 03/03/2025 15:47

I would bring up with her that using donor sperm has some level of medical checks. She doesn't know if the one night stands have diabetes, have had cancer and it runs strongly in the family, mental health issues which are hereditary, autism or adhd which may be hard for her to handle if she's neurotypical etc.
When in a relationship hereditary risks are mitigated as you want a child with that person, but if just using any sperm she might as well aim for a higher chance of a healthy baby.

maximalistmaximus · 03/03/2025 15:46

It's so much better than 95% of relationships on Mumsnet.