Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or is Brother being a Billy big balls?

144 replies

NomadicEthusiasm · 01/03/2025 22:45

DF has a significant birthday much later this year, late October..DB contacted me to ask if I'd go in on a weekend stay for DF and DM somewhere as gift. I didn't reply immediately, got a sarky tumbleweed gif 16 hours later. Responded with 'sounds good'. I didn't commit, I basically had a million and one other things in my mind, not a birthday 8 months away.
He went ahead and booked it, nowt to pay until a week before, so free cancellation. But it's £440.
Now, we are higher earners than DB and his wife, but, live in a much more expensive part of the country, huge mortgage, we have two teens, they're child free. We all grew up poor, so whilst we are still budget supermarket shoppers and have one crappy car, we have one nice holiday w eye couple of years and don't have to worry about bills. We are in a much better position than many, but we are still careful, but for the grace of god and all that.
We don't spend money like that on birthdays. Nor do my parents. They gave me £50 fory 40th.
I said I'd need to speak to DH. DB immediately started messaging that it shouldn't be a problem, I had months to save and they spent £300 on one night for DM's last big birthday etc.
He was unquestionably rude.
I have a very strained but civil relationship with my parents. He is geographically and emotionally much closer. I moved out a few weeks after my 18th, moved country and never went back to live. He lived with them until he was 32. Largely rent free. I get why he wants to spoil them. Although he really doesn't have the money.
We value time and experiences together over money. He is about what looks good on Instagram primarily.
I left it as no rush, we will consider it. He has now, 2 days later, said don't worry if you're going to be petty, we will pay for the whole stay. I replied saying probably for the best. We will sort something else. Not to mention, if we visit, we have to pay for plane tickets, hire car, airport parking and dog boarding before we even get there.
He clearly thinks I'm pathetic and tight.

OP posts:
friendlycat · 01/03/2025 23:50

newkettleandtoaster · 01/03/2025 23:48

It's £220.

It's a big birthday.

In your own words you're a high earner.

I'd just pay it and move on.

I have to agree.

I think this would be the best thing. You did say “sounds good 👍 “. Sorry but to me that reads you’re in agreement.

NomadicEthusiasm · 01/03/2025 23:49

I agree that I wasn't clear. I wasn't enthusiastic in my response but it wasn't a no.
His initial message was a voice note that I wasn't able to listen to immediately. Then I did whilst busy (at shops), tried to call he responded by saying he didn't want to wake his dog (I have mentioned this up thread but not in OP).
I'd rather have had a conversation.
I definitely messed up with sounds good. In my defence I know full well that if I'd said hold off, I'd have had a tirade

OP posts:
newkettleandtoaster · 01/03/2025 23:48

It's £220.

It's a big birthday.

In your own words you're a high earner.

I'd just pay it and move on.

NomadicEthusiasm · 01/03/2025 23:45

friendlycat · 01/03/2025 23:40

Am I correct that you are being asked to contribute £220 for the cost of your parents to spend 2 nights away to celebrate your DFs significant birthday?

If so and you can afford it, it doesn’t sound preposterous. You also did confuse matters with your brother with your initial response to his suggestion. Why did you say “sounds good “.

What would you normally spend on a significant birthday. Will it make your parents happy. Is it worth falling out over £100 if that’s what you would normally spend etc etc ???

I'm not sure it would make my dad happy really. It isn't to celebrate his birthday as such hey are already going on a holiday for his birthday. In amfact DB was a bit annoyed with SM.as she asked him not to book it in the actual day as she was starting to look at holidays.

OP posts:
friendlycat · 01/03/2025 23:44

rookiemere · 01/03/2025 23:15

OP you responded "sounds good " to your DB.

Any reasonable person would take that as agreement, so it's no great surprise your DB booked it.

And now you're rescinding on your agreement, he has obviously decided it's easier just to pay for it than have any hassle. Frankly I don't blame him.

Normally I am a great proponent of other people not spending your money, but the way it reads and bearing in mind this is from your point of view, I think your DB did his best in a tricky situation.

Agree.

NomadicEthusiasm · 01/03/2025 23:41

ForPoliteHam · 01/03/2025 23:38

YABU.

It's your father
It's a significant birthday

..and you can't be bothered, really.

You see, I disagree. I don't think that throwing money at a situation means you are better, or care more. But I asked for opinions and that is yours.
In any case I'll be spending £300 or thereabouts to visit him with my dcs

OP posts:
friendlycat · 01/03/2025 23:40

Am I correct that you are being asked to contribute £220 for the cost of your parents to spend 2 nights away to celebrate your DFs significant birthday?

If so and you can afford it, it doesn’t sound preposterous. You also did confuse matters with your brother with your initial response to his suggestion. Why did you say “sounds good “.

What would you normally spend on a significant birthday. Will it make your parents happy. Is it worth falling out over £100 if that’s what you would normally spend etc etc ???

Orders76 · 01/03/2025 23:40

But if you don't agree, id say 'generally sounds good but please don't book until we talk'

CurlyhairedAssassin · 01/03/2025 23:38

Without reading the rest of the thread, I'd say it's your own silly fault for not engaging with his initial enquiry. You kept him waiting then gave a non-commital "sounds good" without further question. What was he supposed to do with that?!
He was trying to be organised, get some plans made. And things like that DO need planning for.

Most people would have replied in a more timely manner than you did, and expanded on "sounds good" by asking what he was thinking of and what kind of cost was involved.

ForPoliteHam · 01/03/2025 23:38

YABU.

It's your father
It's a significant birthday

..and you can't be bothered, really.

NomadicEthusiasm · 01/03/2025 23:33

1apenny2apenny · 01/03/2025 23:31

So to summarise he is the golden child and wants to do the big show for your fathers birthday and wants you to pay half whilst probably making it known he's done all the organising.

Like you OP we don't spend that kind of money on birthday presents. For some reason I always feel that if anything a parent should spend more on a child but there's no logic to that.

I do think you should have perhaps said you don't want to do joint immediately it was suggested however you've done it now do that's that. And no I don't think you're tight, do your own thing.

In a nutshell. Yes.

OP posts:
1apenny2apenny · 01/03/2025 23:31

So to summarise he is the golden child and wants to do the big show for your fathers birthday and wants you to pay half whilst probably making it known he's done all the organising.

Like you OP we don't spend that kind of money on birthday presents. For some reason I always feel that if anything a parent should spend more on a child but there's no logic to that.

I do think you should have perhaps said you don't want to do joint immediately it was suggested however you've done it now do that's that. And no I don't think you're tight, do your own thing.

Stickystickysticky · 01/03/2025 23:25

As in most arguments/ upsets/ family fall outs , it's the lack of clear communication on both sides that has caused this. Fair enough if the cost is more than you are happy to pay, but you if you'd just added 'let's have a chat before booking' or he'd said. 'Are you happy for me book something' then you wouldn't be feeling this way.

NomadicEthusiasm · 01/03/2025 23:24

Hercisback1 · 01/03/2025 23:23

You said sounds good, and cba to reply properly.

So he can plough ahead choosing a pricey hotel and bill me for half without checking budget?

OP posts:
Hercisback1 · 01/03/2025 23:23

You said sounds good, and cba to reply properly.

NomadicEthusiasm · 01/03/2025 23:21

sourpuss23 · 01/03/2025 23:17

I think this is all very subjective and complex op. It surrounds you and your family dynamics which nobody here will understand like you do. Of course some people would spend that amount on their parents without a second thought. You don't want to and that's fine. You have your reasons.

I do think it would have been better to communicate more clearly with your db originally though. You say he was spoiling for a fight but maybe he just wanted a quick response so he could go ahead and book something.

I'd rather have a phone conversation to avoid these misunderstandings. But he didn't want to wake the dogs so I text 🙄

OP posts:
NomadicEthusiasm · 01/03/2025 23:19

Winterjoy · 01/03/2025 23:18

£440 for two people (married so presumably sharing a room) for one night does seem excessive!

Edited

To be fair, it is 2 nights. Albeit in Oct in a cold/very rainy area.

OP posts:
NomadicEthusiasm · 01/03/2025 23:19

Winterjoy · 01/03/2025 23:16

Do you actually know what is being booked/seen the price directly? With the strained relationships all round and you being the higher earner is it possible you're paying the lions share of the gift without realising (and that's why it seems so much?)

Interesting you say. Since I posted this I have looked it up. I don't think he's lying, the price he quoted is through a third party site. But direct with the hotel it is actually £90 cheaper.
Also to be clear. He and I earn about the same. My husband earns more. But again, we're not talking six figures or anything!

OP posts:
Winterjoy · 01/03/2025 23:18

£440 for two people (married so presumably sharing a room) for one night does seem excessive!

sourpuss23 · 01/03/2025 23:17

I think this is all very subjective and complex op. It surrounds you and your family dynamics which nobody here will understand like you do. Of course some people would spend that amount on their parents without a second thought. You don't want to and that's fine. You have your reasons.

I do think it would have been better to communicate more clearly with your db originally though. You say he was spoiling for a fight but maybe he just wanted a quick response so he could go ahead and book something.

NomadicEthusiasm · 01/03/2025 23:17

Devianinc · 01/03/2025 23:16

But do you want to go. If your being forced then that’s not fun.

I wouldn't be going anywhere. It would be paying to send my parents

OP posts:
Winterjoy · 01/03/2025 23:16

Do you actually know what is being booked/seen the price directly? With the strained relationships all round and you being the higher earner is it possible you're paying the lions share of the gift without realising (and that's why it seems so much?)

NomadicEthusiasm · 01/03/2025 23:16

rookiemere · 01/03/2025 23:15

OP you responded "sounds good " to your DB.

Any reasonable person would take that as agreement, so it's no great surprise your DB booked it.

And now you're rescinding on your agreement, he has obviously decided it's easier just to pay for it than have any hassle. Frankly I don't blame him.

Normally I am a great proponent of other people not spending your money, but the way it reads and bearing in mind this is from your point of view, I think your DB did his best in a tricky situation.

The sounds good was to a general principle. I thought we might research options and make a choice together.

OP posts:
Devianinc · 01/03/2025 23:16

NomadicEthusiasm · 01/03/2025 23:00

Fair point. I think I have somehow over and under explained.
Am I being tight? Is it normal to spend £££ on parents birthdays rather than give a smaller, hopefully thoughtful gift, if technically you COULD afford it?

But do you want to go. If your being forced then that’s not fun.

rookiemere · 01/03/2025 23:15

OP you responded "sounds good " to your DB.

Any reasonable person would take that as agreement, so it's no great surprise your DB booked it.

And now you're rescinding on your agreement, he has obviously decided it's easier just to pay for it than have any hassle. Frankly I don't blame him.

Normally I am a great proponent of other people not spending your money, but the way it reads and bearing in mind this is from your point of view, I think your DB did his best in a tricky situation.