Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think London has become a parody of itself?

281 replies

NattyBrickMember · 24/02/2025 08:32

Everything is overpriced, gentrification is out of control, and the chaos somehow feels unbearable and iconic at the same time. AIBU to think London has become a caricature of what it used to be - like a city pretending to be itself for tourists and TikTok?

OP posts:
spoodlesee · 24/02/2025 10:28

@Staringatthemoon it's an edge which gives an excitement because things are slightly unpredictable.

Crumpies · 24/02/2025 10:28

MojoMoon · 24/02/2025 10:24

I say this as a middle aged person but everyone who says "ooh it was more vibrant, more optimistic, cooler, more cutting edge, livelier 20 years ago", do you not think that is maybe because you were also all of those things then?

If your complaint is that London isn't vibrant or optimistic enough, I'm not sure moving to a village, small market town or to the seaside is going to provide you with that sense of optimism or vibrancy instead.

Perhaps we all just got older?

Although the population of Londoners below 25 has declined in recent years due to Brexit (fewer young Europeans coming to work from a year or two in casual jobs), cost of living and higher student fees/debt encouraging more students to stay at home, it is still a much younger and more vibrant place than anywhere else in the UK.

25 years ago middle aged people were also complaining about gentrification, rising cost of housing, the Islington metropolitan elite (this was Blair's era) or Britpop recycling cliches of the 1960s and not being as cool as the punk movement was.

It's the circle of life.

Yes I think this is the core of it. We are older, no longer in the scene and craving something quieter, more affordable and bigger and London just doesn’t meet those needs for many of us.
25 year olds are still having a ball in London !!

spoodlesee · 24/02/2025 10:27

yes it's the sense of creativity which has been steamed out of it. Lots of music venues and clubs are gone.

you need youth & energy for that, new blood. That is what is being lost. I'm visiting Manchester next week to see a relative at uni, apparently that's the new London.

spoodlesee · 24/02/2025 10:26

Tbf this thread probably has the wrong demographic for discuss re nightlife, buzz etc

MojoMoon · 24/02/2025 10:24

I say this as a middle aged person but everyone who says "ooh it was more vibrant, more optimistic, cooler, more cutting edge, livelier 20 years ago", do you not think that is maybe because you were also all of those things then?

If your complaint is that London isn't vibrant or optimistic enough, I'm not sure moving to a village, small market town or to the seaside is going to provide you with that sense of optimism or vibrancy instead.

Perhaps we all just got older?

Although the population of Londoners below 25 has declined in recent years due to Brexit (fewer young Europeans coming to work from a year or two in casual jobs), cost of living and higher student fees/debt encouraging more students to stay at home, it is still a much younger and more vibrant place than anywhere else in the UK.

25 years ago middle aged people were also complaining about gentrification, rising cost of housing, the Islington metropolitan elite (this was Blair's era) or Britpop recycling cliches of the 1960s and not being as cool as the punk movement was.

It's the circle of life.

PollyIndia · 24/02/2025 10:23

peanutbuttertoasty · 24/02/2025 09:18

I grew up having fun in Shoreditch, going to raves in car parks etc. it was fun. Now much nicer but utterly sterile. I think the most interesting creatives and people doing innovative things fucked off years ago. The startup scene is dead too.

It's dead in Shoreditch, but it's not dead in London. My mate has a club called the cause in Canning Town, massive, open until 6am, full of young people, best queer night in town called adonis adonis adonis. I promise you, it's not dead, we just aren't going to the raves anymore! Also Fold near Cause. And the hackney restaurant scene is the best I've found, up there with New York. I'm a bit further east, and we have very few chains, but lots of amazing small businesses, brilliant community. I'm nearly 50, and there's parties that happen every weekend somewhere in my postcode for people of my age - dancing, fun. Plus I go to the theatre in town as often as I can to see world class shows, there's incredible music, the museums and galleries are world class.
I agree, it's too expensive, and I worry about what will happen for young creatives, and people who keep the city running, when junior lawyers and bankers struggle to buy property. Central London is not good these days, but thats partly a transition away from the high street being for retail. That's happening in every town and city. And there's nowhere late night to go in central London unless you are a soho house member. But it's been 20 years since central London was the place to go for a proper night out anyway. But I agree, post pandemic, things just haven't reopened in the same way.
The public transport system is amazing though. I can get into Oxford Circus in 20 mins, and I'm 5 mins walk from the start of epping forest.
So it's not perfect, never has been, but it's still an amazing city, you just have to get out there and experience it.

LazyArsedMagician · 24/02/2025 10:22

Patterncarmen · 24/02/2025 09:32

Come to Lincolnshire. The nearest bus stop is 3 miles away from me, and the bus runs once an hour. At least now it is only £3…I was paying £9 return to get to work. Thirty miles took 90 minutes on the rural roads.

Lol.

30 miles often takes me 90 minutes on the M62 and M6. Or train Liverpool-Manchester costs me £20 and is late every. single. time.

(Although transport links are undoubtedly much better here in a city)

TitusMoan · 24/02/2025 10:22

ImRonBurgandy · 24/02/2025 08:43

I've seen this episode
Roz: Frasier, this is my cousin Jen. She's visiting this week, remember?Frasier: Oh, yes, of course. So how are you enjoying Seattle? Jen: Well, I've been living in London, so Seattle seems a little lame. No offense.Frasier: Oh, none taken. So you like London? Jen: Not really. It's like a parody of itself.Frasier: How so? Jen: Oh, you know, double decker buses, bobbies, little pubs. It's like EPCOT but even fakier. So I bailed. Went and spent some time in Florence.Frasier: Ah, Firenze. How is she? Jen: I gotta say, Florence is over. It was probably cool, before all the Americans found out about it.Frasier: You mean three hundred years ago? Jen: Exactly. That's why I'm going to Vietnam. Americans have never even heard of it.Frasier: Ah. Well, you know, I'm afraid I have to bail on this conversation

Genius writing

spoodlesee · 24/02/2025 10:22

Do people really not notice the overcrowding or do they not travel by public transport? the traffic on the roads?
We used to have the best high street shopping in the world.

In which areas is gentrification pushing people out with its empty flats? (we've already asked for some evidence!)

Don't know if there are empty flats but Brixton locals have campaigned for years about gentrification. Definitely empty investment flats in Vauxhall.

LadyTable · 24/02/2025 10:20

I've lived here all my life and I think it's the most amazing city.

It hasn't changed that much OP, no matter where in London you live.

Westfacing · 24/02/2025 10:19

I can assure you there is still nothing all the gentrified about Stoke Newington - unless a Lidl is generification.

You obviously haven't been to Stoke Newington Church Street in recent years - it's gentrified to the hilt!

Newmeagain · 24/02/2025 10:18

CheekySnake · 24/02/2025 09:05

I live in a town close to London and the stink of weed is a daily thing now. That's definitely new. I hate it.

I love London, I love being able to go in whenever I feel like it. Originally from the north. Never going back.

I agree. I am a Londoner. There are a few things that have become an issue in the last 5 years that are probably not unique to London - the cannabis smell, dog shit everywhere and e-bikes and e-scooters being a total menace.

But otherwise it is a great city to live in. Housing is very expensive but other things are not.

spoodlesee · 24/02/2025 10:17

* London has always been expensive*

Plenty of parts were cheap in the 80s/90s

Crumpies · 24/02/2025 10:12

I first lived in London 25 years ago and now just visit for work. I don’t think it’s changed more than many other capital cities. Across the world, the rich are getting richer and the poor getting poorer and cities are just a microcosm of this.
Compared to Paris, Rome or New York, London is way more ‘real’

What has changed is that when I first arrived I could afford Islington, by the time I left I could only afford Stoke Newington despite being on a much higher salary.

I can assure you there is still nothing all the gentrified about Stoke Newington - unless a Lidl is generification.

spoodlesee · 24/02/2025 10:12

It's not as young anymore which is a shame, I think some of the buzz as gone.

peanutbuttertoasty · 24/02/2025 10:11

Allihavetodoisdream · 24/02/2025 09:28

You meet cockneys every day when you live here. And also other kinds of Londoners. Plenty of working class communities here, too. I think be honest and say what you mean. You mean white people, don’t you?

I do live here and have done for decades thanks. A lot of cockneys moved out to Essex when gentrification set in and they could no longer afford business rates etc. I have friends whose families this includes. There are TV documentaries about it. No need to be so aggressive.

BatchCookBabe · 24/02/2025 10:09

As other posters have said @NattyBrickMember Of course London isn't the same as it used to be 3-4 decades ago, but then again, nowhere is. Even my little town (several miles from my village) has increased from 10,000 people to 17,000 in 15 years, all the banks have shut, there is no public transport to and from the surrounding villages, and the high street has had a load of shops go in the past 5-6 years..

It now consists (largely) of a load of eateries, nail technicians, barbers, hairdressers, and vape shops, also a Greggs, a Specsavers, and around 7 or 8 charity shops. It used to have a Peacocks, a B & M, a WH Smith, 2 shoe shops, an Argos, a Poundstretcher, a New Look, a Wilkos, a butchers, a bakery, a jewellers, and 4 or 5 quirky gift shops and a few other shops... they have ALL gone. The biggest shop the high street has now is a big Card Warehouse. Oh and there is a building society and a post office!

There is a big B & M and a Home Bargains and a huge Morrisons and an Aldi and a Lidl and an Iceland, and a few other shops and retail outlets including McDonalds, but they are on a retail park 1 mile from the centre/main high street. No good for people who don't have cars! All they have is a small Tesco Express in the high street.

NOWHERE is the same as it was 30, 40+ years ago. I lived in London in the mid to late 1980s, and back then people said it's not the same as it was in the 1950s and 1960s! Go figure!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Scoobyblue · 24/02/2025 10:07

I live in London and love it. My children are away at university and, although they are having a great time, want to come back to London afterwards. They will have to live at home for a while due to the sky high property prices but, for them, that doesn't outweigh the draw of coming back.
The central tourist areas can be a nightmare - I really wouldn't go to Big Ben, Buckingham Palace etc but there are lots of things to do and places to see outside of there.
Public transport is brilliant. Neither child has learnt to drive despite my nagging because they have absolutely no need to in London.

Inkystain · 24/02/2025 10:06

NattyBrickMember · 24/02/2025 08:49

Lived in London all my life - 32 years. Maybe it depends on which part of London you’re in, but to me, the changes over the years have been hard to ignore.

And how old are you now?🤔

Inkystain · 24/02/2025 10:05

Let me guess, you live hundreds of miles from London and haven’t visited for years? If ever

TempsPerdu · 24/02/2025 10:05

I agree with a fair bit of what you say OP. DP and I are London born and bred but will hopefully be moving out later this year. I don't actively hate it, but much preferred it in the '90s and early '00s when everything felt vibrant, optimistic and edgy (as opposed to dirty and sketchy), and the cultural vibe was a lot more organic and less pre-packaged and commercialised.

A few random observations (we live in an outer northern suburb, not one of the posher parts, and last visited the centre on Saturday):

  • Might be an age thing, but the sheer volume of people has become a bit overwhelming (for us). It just feels overcrowded now, and at times this seems to make people aggressive as they compete for limited space.
  • There are barely any functioning public toilets. DD7 nearly had an accident as we couldn't find anywhere for her to use the toilet around the Monument/Tower of London area - we ended up queuing in Starbuck's with what seemed like half of London.
  • Tourists are massively pandered to, and IMO things have become too commercialised - the centre in particular can feel very sanitised and Disneyfied. A lot of the cultural scene feels derivative and cynical, but I don't think that's specific to London.
  • However, sanitised and Disneyfied is preferable to what you now experience in some of the suburbs (including my own), which is increasing grime, crime and a sense of urban decay. When I was growing up the suburbs were largely much nicer, cleaner and more affluent than most of inner London; this has now completely flipped.
  • Public transport: It has, post-Covid, become much harder for us to access more central areas due to less frequent trains (we often have only one an hour from our overground station at weekends, and the nearest Tube station is a bus ride away). There are often no drivers at weekends so trains are cancelled, and using London for anything other than work feels like a struggle, so increasingly we don't bother. It took us 2.5hrs to get home from a recent trip to the Science Museum with DD, and 1.5hrs, 4 Tube lines and a bus to get back this past Saturday, due to a fatality that caused all the overground lines to go tits up. Increasingly it just doesn't feel worth the hassle. We had to get off one of the Tubes and wait for the next one as two hoodies, clearly high on something, were riding Santander bikes up and down the carriage and intimidating people.
  • All the Cockneys, including much of my own family and all my parents' friends are now out in Essex and Herts, and have been for years. My elderly parents have clung on where we live now, but are likely to follow us when we move out.

London just isn't our favourite place any more tbh, and most of our childhood friends have concluded the same and moved on too.

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 24/02/2025 10:03

PenneyFouryourthoughts · 24/02/2025 10:02

I came to London from a rural area in 1997. It's changed a lot since then but the city has constantly evolved for good or bad throughout it's 2000 year history.

I can no longer afford to live there as a single person and am planning to leave as soon as I can. But my London -born daughter says London is where it's at to pursue a career in her chosen creative industry, and she's happy to live in a tiny bedsit for silly rent prices to pursue that.

My parents still live to visit the city and they are in their 70s whereas I am pretty much done with the place. Maybe it's my age, maybe I want a different life, maybe the grass seems greener elsewhere...but I think the cost of living is a major issue, alongside with the sense that, apart from the touristy areas, London is being neglected quite a bit. Too many developments are being thrown up without considering the location population. Too many people wanting scant resources from the NHS. Too many parks and open spaces left to rot. Schools are closing & merging as families run to cheaper areas to live. Toi many cheap caffs closing down to make way for s Gail's. The place lacks a sense of future. Yes, maybe the 1970s are rolling around again?

Ugh I hate Gail’s!

PenneyFouryourthoughts · 24/02/2025 10:02

I came to London from a rural area in 1997. It's changed a lot since then but the city has constantly evolved for good or bad throughout it's 2000 year history.

I can no longer afford to live there as a single person and am planning to leave as soon as I can. But my London -born daughter says London is where it's at to pursue a career in her chosen creative industry, and she's happy to live in a tiny bedsit for silly rent prices to pursue that.

My parents still live to visit the city and they are in their 70s whereas I am pretty much done with the place. Maybe it's my age, maybe I want a different life, maybe the grass seems greener elsewhere...but I think the cost of living is a major issue, alongside with the sense that, apart from the touristy areas, London is being neglected quite a bit. Too many developments are being thrown up without considering the location population. Too many people wanting scant resources from the NHS. Too many parks and open spaces left to rot. Schools are closing & merging as families run to cheaper areas to live. Toi many cheap caffs closing down to make way for s Gail's. The place lacks a sense of future. Yes, maybe the 1970s are rolling around again?

ClairDeLaLune · 24/02/2025 10:01

neverknowinglyunreasonable · 24/02/2025 08:45

I live in London and this is 100% what is happening. All London residents meet up once a month to make sure we all understand the plan and are sticking to it. Logistically this is a nightmare as we need a room big enough to hold 8 million people. We usually meet when Coronation Street is on because we know northerners are busy then so they won't notice.

We all then make sure that London, and everyone in it, is pretending to be London. A few people have asked if this is a waste of time as London is in fact London whether we pretend or not. We drive those dissenters to the north (someone just past St Alban's) and leave them there to fend for themselves. I could get in serious trouble for revealing this. Please tell nobody.

😂😂😂

EasternStandard · 24/02/2025 09:59

Bland? Have you ever been to the National Gallery? The Portrait Gallery? The V&A? The Science Museum? The Natural History Museum? Museum of London? Kensington Palace?...........

I'm less about shopping than this so it still is good as @LeticiaMorales says

Also @LondonPapa post too

There are various issues no doubt, but it's still good in many ways