Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that spending billions on UK transport infrastructure is crazy?

105 replies

YarkYark · 22/02/2025 17:42

God, my AIBU sounds like I'm a journalist (I'm not) but this drives me crazy.

During and after the pandemic this country proved pretty adequately that business can carry on pretty much as usual without endess face to face meetings. I used to go to many of these, both in the UK and abroad, inevitably it meant hours or days of travel and associated costs, often all for the sake of a few hours where little would be decided - except the date of the next jolly. Actual decisons would likely be done over the phone the next day.

So why, why, why does this country need to be investing is super high cost projects like HS2 and a third runway for Heathrow. Why will there continue to be a need for people to travel to do business when we shoud be investing in a world leading internet infrastructure and cut out all the travel nonsense and associated issues?

What am I missing?

YABU: Of course UK needs to improve its transport links, otherwise we'll never grow as a country.

YANBU: You're right, we're thinking like its the 1990s, get with the future, Britain.

OP posts:
deplorabelle · 22/02/2025 17:53

Did you not notice most of HS2 got cancelled in a shameless fire sale by the outgoing sunak govt? It's why our rail infrastructure will remain abysmal

NDHz · 22/02/2025 17:51

Well, just off the top of my head:

  • tourism is a thing
  • WFH is decreasing and people who were WFH are moving to hybrid
  • infrastructure projects have always been used as a means to boost the economy - since medieval times. The money paid for the project circulates, paying for labour and goods, which get taxed, and also are used to pay for secondary labour and goods
Toastandmarmiteplease · 22/02/2025 17:50

Um, what? I know everyone on Mumsnet works from home but the majority of people in this country have to travel to work.

And public transport at the moment is abysmal. Not to mention that public transport is not only for getting to work.

TizerorFizz · 22/02/2025 17:49

It was not true that business thrived in the pandemic. It clobbered business. Yes, we need far better East to West rail in the North. Some cities are cut off from faster lines altogether. We need seemless connections and flowing motorways. Business is often about components and shipping out goods. Time is money and efficiency is key. We have serious issues with parts of our infrastructure and it’s not solved by the ludicrous HS2. If we want a northern powerhouse, we need better infrastructure and that’s not just IT!

username299 · 22/02/2025 17:49

Are you saying that because you don't want to travel, other people shouldn't have the ability to travel?

Due to the cost of housing many people live in cheaper areas and commute. Meeting people is conducive to good working relationships.