Trans men are women according to Gender Critical Movement

All because I said some of the posts about toilets are nonsensical I’ve had nothing but alerts to messages all day telling me how wrong I am, how irrational and stupid I am etc etc. funny I notice it’s the same people on all these threads who act this way and gang up on anyone who disagrees with them on any point even if it’s a minor one. It’s ridiculous. May as well just discuss among yourselves. There is no point anyone else getting involved in such threads.

Mammalian sex is binary
it is determined at conception
it never changes
https://www.hfea.gov.uk/treatments/embryo-testing-and-treatments-for-disease/

From your posts over a couple of threads I’m not sure you know what you’re talking about never mind me.

A smiling emoji on a post I found amusing is just unforgivable abuse isn’t it? Oh I’m going to hell that’s for sure. Lol.

oh you again. What ? Do you even know what I am talking about when I said who actually cares ? Because I wasn’t referring to the topic of the thread

all bullying is wrong….Hidden bullying is gutless

Why do you keep popping up on threads you don’t care about to tell people that you don’t care?

Edited to add - these threads 🤔

Gosh who actually cares ? The thread should really have moved on from this by now. I was openly mocked by you on this thread before I used any emoji. This is what happens when you treat people with disrespect you see. You get disrespected in return I’m afraid .

I see. And you are accusing people of bullying you while it is you who is bullying others?

And now you are just resorting to more personal attacks.

You’ve already mentioned this several times . Think this is the third time now you’ve raised it. Yes i laughed with a silly emoji on one of your posts that amused me. “Hidden bullying” is no worse than open mocking which is what you engage in.

FrippEnos

Given that they have failed to define gender, Its going to take the a while to redefine what "hate" means, other than that its a view that they disagree with.

The Earth is flat

"No it's not, it's a spheroid."

Waaahh! Why do you hate me?! Why do you want me to die?!!

And I am talking about the laughing emoji reaction that is hidden from everyone else's view on a post that was not humorous at all. Just a form of hidden bullying.

Can I ask, what is the solution that you, personally, would like to see proposed?

Because we have heard from other female transgender people, but it is always useful to hear from as many as possible. Even if we don’t agree, but fully understand each other’s position and identify what is misinformation.

OP. Yes, you are, in fact, being unreasonable.

HTH.

Nope you are responsible for your own actions.

OP - are you trans?

Because I am. And I'm asking you to stop. Just stop and think about the reality of things for a moment.

You're not helping the trans community, you're genuinely doing more harm than good.
Regardless of treatment or surgery - I will always be a woman. I've changed my name and title. My post gets delivered to "Mr ChangedUsername". I wear mens clothing, mens deodorant, mens aftershave. I shave my face and chest. My social media states that I'm male. I have a piece of paper that states I am my Wife's Husband.
But my medical record? That states that I'm female. That I was born with the name A and changed it to B and that I have been diagnosed - key word there - with gender dysphoria.

And I'm fine with that. Because it's a necessity. Because if anything happens to me and I need life saving treatment in hospital, I'd want them to give me the correct medication for the sex I am.

But all this - the pronouns and the "trans people are biologically the sex they wish to be" - it's ridiculously harmful to those of us who are trans and just want to get on with our lives quietly. We look like a joke.

This isn't caused by GC people. It's caused by the trans community screaming from the rooftops that they demand the world agrees with them and changes everything around to accommodate them - even if that takes from others and endangers the safety of women and children.

As for the mental trauma of being misgendered. I get it. Honestly, I do. But it isn't up to the whole world to change to accommodate trans people. You have to work on yourself, and get to a place where you can cope with your own life.
Yesterday I got a parcel delivered from Amazon. The man handed it to me and said "Here you go sweetheart, have a good day."
I didn't scream or shout, or demand he uses my pronouns. I said "Thank you, you too." And strangely, life went on.

It is indeed.

It's mindblowingly misogynistic.

Nevermind the lived experience of the women on here who have experienced sexual assault and rape.

It's all about protecting the male people who declare themselves 'women'.

We can abso-fucking-lutely see who the men are, can't we?

I see. So I became the scapegoat for other's actions?

Again, good to know this so that I understand the accusations and the laughing reaction emoji.

They haven't. You are spot on.

There is no logical possibility that they have ever had an experience as a 'female' because there life is only ever lived as a male and for some of that life, a male who has a belief that they are female, that doesn't reflect material reality.

Given that they have failed to define gender, Its going to take the a while to redefine what "hate" means, other than that its a view that they disagree with.

Could you post an example of the hate please?

and yet the gender Identity side is based firmly in stereotypes.

Be whatever "I" you want to be. Just leave me out of it.
I don't owe you validation.
I, especially, don't owe you the right to dictate my identity in order to validate your own.

I am just a woman. I am not a non-trans woman/female. I am not a CIS woman/female. I am not a Cis gendered heteronormative female. Nor am I any other remix of these things and certainly not called so in order to allow men to call themselves just "woman".

Oh, and this no penis=female thing. If we are talking about genitals only, and completely ignoring the existence of chromosomes, I think you will find VAGINA=female. Barring illness, disfunction, accident, injury and developmental issues women have a vagina, not just lack of penis.

You completely erase females altogether with that one. Your example equates to man or not-a-man, completely ignoring all other female sex characteristics.

I am a woman. I am not a "not-a-man". There's a lot more going on than just a lack of penis.

You are dragging it all down to dick or no dick.

So much of the trans ideological argument is little more than misogyny mixed with homophobia.

In many countries, we had a nice moment where you could be gender nonconforming and be left alone. Now, you have people pushing the gender nonconformist to take hormones and get surgery. It's like some kind of conversation therapy to pressurise people, who don't conform to shallow stereotypes, admit they're actually the opposite gender.

Eddie Izzard became popular as a man wearing womens clothing. Nobody batted an eyelid. Now, he must be a woman. Even Eddie has bought in to it now, even though he made many routines and statements about the fact he was still a man underneath the dresses and makeup.

Why can't we simply let people be gay, lesbian, bi, etc. Let them wear what they want and just leave them be without trying to pathologise them and fill them full of drugs.