Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to tell my mum the truth about why DD is not bilingual?

57 replies

BlueSilverCats · 21/02/2025 14:11

For background, me and my mum do not have the best relationship to put it lightly. We muddle along okish for most of the time as long as I keep quite superficial and not engage/end calls when she starts with her bs. She's ok for a while but her ways of thinking always rear up their ugly head.

OH is English, I am not. I'll be honest, I was rather lazy about speaking in my language at home , then she had some SALT issues and my priority was to be understood and be able to communicate properly with her English dad, at school, with her friends etc.

As she grew up, there was another reason, which became more and more important. To protect her from my mum's comments and views , while still allowing them to have a close, loving relationship . That was great when she was little , but she naturally distanced herself a bit as she grew up (teenager now).

My mum is very resentful she can't talk to DD and is always on my case about it, from pitiful "poor me " stuff to petty , vindictive and pointless stuff like " well if she doesn't learn x I won't love her anymore". I just shrug it off or take the blame on being lazy and uncooperative.

Recently we were on a call and she made some disparaging comments over DD's weight (who is a healthy weight according to the NHS) , as she has some very set ideas about weight , with the added disappointment of having a fat daughter. I snapped and I told her this is exactly why I haven't taught DD our language , so she wouldn't be exposed to stupid and toxic comments.

That of course , did not go well. I switch between feeling guilty (because I upset my mum) and being oh well, it is what it is , and she created this situation by being who she is.

OP posts:
KookyPeachViewer · 21/02/2025 14:21

I don't know how you hadn't said it sooner or gone low or no contact already.

Whycanineverthinkofone · 21/02/2025 14:19

I rarely say this but why are you speaking to your mum any more? I know there’s a language barrier for your DD but keep the woman away from her.

aside from the intentional reason, who I do think is fair, it is a shame your child isn’t bilingual. It’s a huge benefit when the are older. I think I’d have kept the child away from your mum completely rather than away from your language.

however you did what you thought was best and have minimised the impact on your child. But I’d still be tempted to call her bluff, if she doesn’t love your child because of the language barrier she can fuck off and make your lives easier by having nothing to do with any of you.

Zusammengebrochen · 21/02/2025 14:19

I get that this might feel quite hard just now, but it's probably best that you did express just how frustrated her comments make you feel. Well done on protecting your daughter from that toxicity too. 💐💐💐

thepariscrimefiles · 21/02/2025 14:17

If your mum is saying that if your DD can't speak her language, she won't love her any more, you and your DD would both be better off if you have absolutely nothing to do with her. She sounds selfish and toxic. Don't feel guilty. Your mum is responsible for your poor relationship by making unpleasant comments about you and your daughter.

arcticpandas · 21/02/2025 14:17

Well done OP!

AnotherDelphinium · 21/02/2025 14:16

YANBU.

Assuming she’s entitled to citizenship etc of your home country it’s a shame she doesn’t speak the language as unless it’s somewhere tiny and remote it would add another string to her bow, so to speak.

However, it sounds like you had a lot going on when she was little so one parent-one language wouldn’t haven’t worked so well for her anyway. Not being exposed to a grandparents slurs are also very valid, and will help your daughters confidence and life too.

If your mum was that determined to speak to her, she’d have learnt English!

JimHalpertsWife · 21/02/2025 14:15

You've done absoloutley the right thi g in safeguarding your dd knowing what would inevitably come her way. Good on you. And if mum didn't want to hear it, then she shouldn't be such a twat.