Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How Can The World Stand By While Trump Sucks Up To Putin?

330 replies

Nolieinforme · 19/02/2025 20:28

OK, so this probably isn't an AIBU, but I'm speechless that Trump is behaving like a bully and seems to be getting away with it.

He just lies. "Zelensky is a dictator" "Ukraine started the war" "Putin has done nothing wrong" etc, etc. I can hardly believe what's been said on the news today.

Why are the rest of the world letting this happen? If America want's to align themselves with Russia, then we should be returning the Chagos Islands without the huge sum of money promised, closing all the US airbases in the UK, closing the US embassy, and expelling their diplomats, etc, etc.

Trump is a madman and what is going to happen if no-one stands up to him? If this was anyone else they just wouldn't get away with it.

OP posts:
FireandRain23 · 20/02/2025 17:31

In the UK there were NO elections between 1935 until 1940 because of WW2. The Election timed for 1940 was postponed for 5 years.

So if Trump agrees with Hitler that Churchill was a Dictator he will surely remove his bust from The Oval Office and replace him with one of his boss, Putin.

trainermush · 20/02/2025 17:30

Husband just saying to our DS (22) to prepare for conscription, is this how our military is going to be boosted?

Can we afford to lose so many young people? I think it's a cheek to expect young people to fight after the way they have been shafted over the years.

BoredZelda · 20/02/2025 17:25

On 25th January, the New York Times reported that he still has the support and trust of Ukrainians but by a very slim majority-52% and that he is increasingly blocking out advisers who think differently to him.

Trump's approval rating is currently 46.5%, unfavourable is at 48.1%

Zelensky at 57% is doing much better with his people than Trump is.

Nolieinforme · 20/02/2025 17:21

Husband just saying to our DS (22) to prepare for conscription, is this how our military is going to be boosted?

OP posts:
trainermush · 20/02/2025 17:20

Trump has also showed up how weak Europe are as a world power in any sense. We depend on the U.S for military support and most of the technology we use daily, Boycotting the U.S would be like kicking ourselves in the face. Anyone here fancy never using Apple, Microsoft, Facebook and Twitter ever again (and the list is longer really)?

I agree with this, we don't have a choice

The best we can do is work a lot harder to build up our own military and technological capabilities, but that would mean real sacrifice and hard work. It remains to be seen whether sclerotic Europe (including us) are up for the challenge.

Unfortunately I think we will be arguing over who should make the sacrifice & work harder for some time.

Alexandra2001 · 20/02/2025 17:19

Newbutoldfather · 20/02/2025 16:46

Trump is not necessarily wrong about Ukraine, though the way he has done it has been in his own crass style.

Ukraine needs to be settled according to the realities of the situation, minimising the risk of nuclear conflagration. This is no more Chamberlain than us deciding sensibly not to send troops into Hungary and Czechoslovakia when their uprisings were put down by Russia in Cold War. Nukes have forever changed the calculus and I am amazed how many don’t realise this. It is the same reason we haven’t tried regime change in N Korea.

Trump has also showed up how weak Europe are as a world power in any sense. We depend on the U.S for military support and most of the technology we use daily, Boycotting the U.S would be like kicking ourselves in the face. Anyone here fancy never using Apple, Microsoft, Facebook and Twitter ever again (and the list is longer really)?

The only alternative is China, and we don’t want to go there.

So, whilst Trump is truly scary, in the short term we can’t confront him. The best we can do is work a lot harder to build up our own military and technological capabilities, but that would mean real sacrifice and hard work. It remains to be seen whether sclerotic Europe (including us) are up for the challenge.

He is completely wrong, he said Ukraine attacked Russia!! He also carried on with total garbage about Ukraine, US aid, gave away all of the 'Wests negotiating levers..... its as if Trump is a deep sleeper Kremlin mole....

The US gains a great deal from Europe, not least in trade, military bases, intelligence sharing, culture... its not a one way street.

If we cannot rely on the Yanks, then quite honestly, what is the point in allowing them access to our territory? why?

Yes agree with your last paragraph, we in Europe have relied on NATO's art 5, thinking it was written in stone, Trump has shown its written on loo roll.

Zebedee999 · 20/02/2025 17:17

Nolieinforme · 19/02/2025 20:28

OK, so this probably isn't an AIBU, but I'm speechless that Trump is behaving like a bully and seems to be getting away with it.

He just lies. "Zelensky is a dictator" "Ukraine started the war" "Putin has done nothing wrong" etc, etc. I can hardly believe what's been said on the news today.

Why are the rest of the world letting this happen? If America want's to align themselves with Russia, then we should be returning the Chagos Islands without the huge sum of money promised, closing all the US airbases in the UK, closing the US embassy, and expelling their diplomats, etc, etc.

Trump is a madman and what is going to happen if no-one stands up to him? If this was anyone else they just wouldn't get away with it.

I don't endorse Trump's tactics here at all but the UK is hardly in a position to throw stones.
Our current ruling party when last in power created a dossier of lies to take us into an illegal war that killed 500,000. Just a few months back that same party voted to kill 4,000 old people by removing WFP (their own figures).
Meanwhile you complain about Trump "behaving like a bully"... surely we should start much closer to home with our own Labour party who get away scot free with killing thousands?

trainermush · 20/02/2025 17:15

@FireandRain23 I haven't moaned about the benefits bill.

trainermush · 20/02/2025 17:14

We can no longer afford to be an economy that exists to support only the unemployed, disabled or elderly

So now you agree pension spending isn't insignificant 😆

We have other dire needs that require urgent funding and we can’t simply continue to raise the tax burden as it is very high as it is.

The tax burden is high for higher earners vs other European countries. We tax the lower & middle earners less but the problem with raising taxes for them is the distorted housing market & crappy wages.

What would you suggest we do @Wildflowers99 to reduce the benefit spend?

BoredZelda · 20/02/2025 17:14

It’s not the elderly driving it. We now spend more on non-pension benefits than pensions. Look up the increase in benefits claims, it’s terrifying

Even if this were true, (and it's not) the vast majority of those who are of working age, who claim benefits, are in work. They are in low wage jobs, or in "zero hours" contracts, meanwhile the companies who employ them are making £billions of profit. The government is subsidising these companies by letting them get away with not paying people enough.

FireandRain23 · 20/02/2025 17:14

trainermush · 20/02/2025 17:04

National insurance is like any other kind of insurance - it pays out when you’re too old or sick to work.

Is anyone debating that? All I have said is that demographics matter.

I’m just reacting to the usual moaners about the benefits bill, not you personally.

trainermush · 20/02/2025 17:10

@Wildflowers99 We devalued salaries, reduced investment and boosted assets after the crash primarily houses which has become the only real growth in our economy. Many people didn't notice their salary was falling behind inflation because their house value increased even though ever increasing house prices don't help the majority. We now have low wages, high taxes, high housing costs and public services needing more money. Is that what you meant @pentangles?

C152 · 20/02/2025 17:09

ExpensiveBiscuits · 20/02/2025 14:01

In the end, every war has to end with a peace treaty, a negotiation, unless one side wins outright.

Ukraine has had a lot of money from Europe and the USA and that money can't keep going on for ever. It just can't because many countries can't afford to keep doing so.

Trump may be the only one who can begin to broker some sort of deal. Clearly, Russia and Ukraine both need to be involved.

.It is all very well to trot around the world, meeting leaders, demanding money from what seems a never ending source but peace is always better. This is a chance, an opening salvo, to bring it to an end. It's a long way from perfect but it's a start.

Anyway, the UK can't afford to give more and is everyone happy with Sir Keir saying he is willing to put boots on the ground? What boots? How many? If it drags on will people be happy for conscription to be introduced. He can't supply soldiers long term without conscription.

Of course, he may just have said this because he got carried away dressing up in camouflage. .Who knows, He might have costed it all out and have a clear plan.

I suppose if the rest of the world is willing to keep paying and willing to put conscripted soldiers on the ground-albeit only the UK has said this, then that's what will happen.

The majority will rule-as it should but at some point, maybe years down the line, a table will be brought in and people will have to sit around it.

This sounds reasonable, but it isn't. Ukraine wouldn't need millions for military and rebuilding support if Russia hadn't invaded. And I don't just mean their full invasion in 2022, but the start of their invasion in 2014. Why isn't the narrative that RUSSIA is costing the world millions (not to mention lives lost). It is not Ukraine's fault they were invaded and they now stand (almost alone) defending the rest of Europe. Russia could end the war today and pay reparations to Ukraine. We all know they won't, but why isn't there more uproar about what RUSSIA is costing, not statements about how much is being spent on Ukraine, or what Ukraine is costing other nations. Ukraine isn't costing other nations anything. They are saving our freedom at the cost of their lives and their country.

Why does the Western World seem so certain that appeasement will work this time, given their experience last time? It's infuriating.

Trump doesn't want to broker a deal. He will do what Putin tells him to do.

CloudPop · 20/02/2025 17:09

Horriblevirusagain · 20/02/2025 14:12

Trump is amazing. The changes he is making is all for the American people. Sadly we are stuck With Two Tier Starmer. Vile man who hates the British people including farmers and the elderly. Sends all our taxes overseas and does nothing for the homeless or Farmers or people struggling on low wages. Hopefully Reform will sort out this shower of shit!! We can learn a lot from Trump especially as he is giving back taxes that were fraudulently claimed to his people. And kicking out the violent illegals what is there to hate!!

Giving taxes back to who ?

EasternStandard · 20/02/2025 17:05

Newbutoldfather · 20/02/2025 16:46

Trump is not necessarily wrong about Ukraine, though the way he has done it has been in his own crass style.

Ukraine needs to be settled according to the realities of the situation, minimising the risk of nuclear conflagration. This is no more Chamberlain than us deciding sensibly not to send troops into Hungary and Czechoslovakia when their uprisings were put down by Russia in Cold War. Nukes have forever changed the calculus and I am amazed how many don’t realise this. It is the same reason we haven’t tried regime change in N Korea.

Trump has also showed up how weak Europe are as a world power in any sense. We depend on the U.S for military support and most of the technology we use daily, Boycotting the U.S would be like kicking ourselves in the face. Anyone here fancy never using Apple, Microsoft, Facebook and Twitter ever again (and the list is longer really)?

The only alternative is China, and we don’t want to go there.

So, whilst Trump is truly scary, in the short term we can’t confront him. The best we can do is work a lot harder to build up our own military and technological capabilities, but that would mean real sacrifice and hard work. It remains to be seen whether sclerotic Europe (including us) are up for the challenge.

Yep this is close to my view

trainermush · 20/02/2025 17:04

National insurance is like any other kind of insurance - it pays out when you’re too old or sick to work.

Is anyone debating that? All I have said is that demographics matter.

Wildflowers99 · 20/02/2025 17:04

trainermush · 20/02/2025 17:03

Oh and let's all ignore the elephant in the room in the UK, that our housing stock is all we have left, which is why we are so unhealthily obsessed with it and terrified of it dropping a couple of thousand in value.

Yep

That post made literally no sense at all. Can anyone elaborate?

trainermush · 20/02/2025 17:03

Oh and let's all ignore the elephant in the room in the UK, that our housing stock is all we have left, which is why we are so unhealthily obsessed with it and terrified of it dropping a couple of thousand in value.

Yep

trainermush · 20/02/2025 17:03

@FireandRain23 There is an awful lot of rhetoric around "net takers" which is one of the posts I replied too. There is nothing wrong with pensioners or anyone being a net takers. I was just making the point that the amount of net takers will increase when you have an ageing population. Thats it..

Wildflowers99 · 20/02/2025 16:58

Newbutoldfather · 20/02/2025 16:46

Trump is not necessarily wrong about Ukraine, though the way he has done it has been in his own crass style.

Ukraine needs to be settled according to the realities of the situation, minimising the risk of nuclear conflagration. This is no more Chamberlain than us deciding sensibly not to send troops into Hungary and Czechoslovakia when their uprisings were put down by Russia in Cold War. Nukes have forever changed the calculus and I am amazed how many don’t realise this. It is the same reason we haven’t tried regime change in N Korea.

Trump has also showed up how weak Europe are as a world power in any sense. We depend on the U.S for military support and most of the technology we use daily, Boycotting the U.S would be like kicking ourselves in the face. Anyone here fancy never using Apple, Microsoft, Facebook and Twitter ever again (and the list is longer really)?

The only alternative is China, and we don’t want to go there.

So, whilst Trump is truly scary, in the short term we can’t confront him. The best we can do is work a lot harder to build up our own military and technological capabilities, but that would mean real sacrifice and hard work. It remains to be seen whether sclerotic Europe (including us) are up for the challenge.

100% this. Unfortunately the world right now is not the place for lofty ideals and falling on your sword for the sake of principle. The only people in the UK Trump admires are the Royals, I feel now is their moment to step up and do some urgent schmoozing so we get a good tariff deal and soften Trump toward our point of view a little. The British public have been woefully self defeating with their pro-Gaza, anti-West, anti-American sentiments because they thought it was a luxury protected from the cold light of day by our military. I fear we are in for a shock as to what would happen to us without American allegiance and a proper military.

C152 · 20/02/2025 16:52

CustardySergeant · 20/02/2025 13:06

I posted this on another thread

Sadly, that is so very true.

FireandRain23 · 20/02/2025 16:52

Wildflowers99 · 20/02/2025 15:53

Haha, he should! No doubt Trump would call it a rigged election or something 😒

Doubtless!

C152 · 20/02/2025 16:52

ExpensiveBiscuits · 20/02/2025 13:41

I think he's calling Zelensky a dictator because Zelensky has cancelled elections, which is the type of things dictators tend to do.

Several polls-not all- are showing that his popularity has fallen, so a cynical person might not marvel at the fact that the elections are cancelled.

Now, now, don't go repeating the crazy dictator's (Trump in this instance) false statements. Zelensky is not a dictator and hasn't cancelled elections. He was elected for a 5 year term, which was due to end in May 2024. However, Ukraine has been in a state or martial law since Russia's invasion and elections cannot take place under martial law. Zelensky has vowed to hold elections once the war ends. (Which is more than Trump has done. He not only broke the law in an attempt to stay in power the first time, he's threatened to remain in power this time, even though the Constitution prohibits this.)

BIossomtoes · 20/02/2025 16:51

Wildflowers99 · 20/02/2025 16:46

The majority of people claiming UC do not work.

38% of UC claimants are in work. That’s an awful lot of employers who are being subsidised.

Wildflowers99 · 20/02/2025 16:46

WookieMama · 20/02/2025 16:26

Surely what’s terrifying is that jobs do t pay people enough money to live, if in work people didn’t need benefits this would be much less of an issue 🤷‍♀️

The majority of people claiming UC do not work.

Swipe left for the next trending thread