Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can I just do what I want for my Birthday?

93 replies

wediblinooo · 17/02/2025 11:37

My birthday was last weekend, (mid 40s, I'm used to them by now, nothing special, it wasn't a 'big one' or anything). I wanted to go out with my partner to the local pub. My mother called me in tears yesterday because I didn't invite my parents, saying that I always used to enjoy family birthdays and that she doesn't like my BF and thinks he is trying to isolate me.

Just a bit of back story, I DID always used to like family birthdays when it was a 'big' occasion, my parents, brother, SIL, partner etc. Three years ago however my DB and SIL had a baby and they stopped inviting me to family events. I would always go to family events with my dog, and they didn't want him around the baby. Fine, but rather than telling me this, they just stopped inviting me to family events. I would still go up and visit them (I had never taken my dog to their house) and because of this I wasn't aware that there was an issue. Me and partner just stopped being invited.

I was devastated when the penny finally dropped that we were being cut out. But their baby, their home their rules. Fine. So knowing I wouldn't ever have the whole family for dinner, I would prefer it to me just me and BF. All my parents talk about is my niece, which I find just completely tone deaf, and quite frankly a little dull. There seemed to be no interest in what I wanted to do- just my mum being upset that she missed out on an outing. Usually I am happy to take them out and include them, but on this time, I just wanted something local where we could get a taxi home and have a bottle of wine to celebrate, rather than driving round to them.

My brother and SIL used to be what made family events fun, if they aren't part of the picture anymore, and my parents haven't made effort to reconcile us am I in the wrong here? And isn't sobbing down the phone and having a complete meltdown taking things a bit far?

OP posts:
Sunat45degrees · 17/02/2025 13:13

Your family very clearly have serious communication issues. If you genuinely are the kind of person who is fine if their dog can't come (and we all know there are loads of people who are NOT okay with that), then your DB was really poorly behaved not to just say something. Ditto, when he started asking your parents nto to invite you or refusing to com eif you were there, why didn't they ask him? So yes, very bad communication (which might even be worse if it turns out the dog is NOT the issue, they're just using that as an excuse. )

Meanwhile, this poor communication and slightly odd expectations are a problem again with your birthday. Surely if your mum wanted to see you for your birthday she'd have said somethign in advance, asked what you were doing etc. Similarly, surely it would have come up from you, "Argh, it's 43 this year. Not doing anything big. BF and I are going to go to the pub, drink to much and get a cab home - but perhaps we can have some cake when I next come up to yours? I'll bring my favourite chocolate mousse cake".

I mea, these are all fairly normal communication points for a family that, by th esounds of things, generally spend a decent amount of time together.

SinkToTheBottomWithYou · 17/02/2025 13:12

So they are not excluding you from family events, just choosing to see you and your brother separately? Or are they only seeing him+family but not you?

Very odd behaviour from your brother, I agree, but you seem to be blaming your parents for it, which is unfair.

RhiWrites · 17/02/2025 13:11

HamptonPlace · 17/02/2025 13:05

birthdays are for children...

People don’t stop having birthdays at the age of 18.

Children’s lives are full of celebrations of their achievements, progression to the next school class, getting a good mark or a swimming certificate.

Adults are lucky to get one day that’s about them. Birthdays are it.

PinkPonyClub25 · 17/02/2025 13:08

If it mattered that much why didn't your mum arrange something for your birthday? YANBU. Tell her to get over herself.

BeaAndBen · 17/02/2025 13:07

I agree, @sandyhappypeople - OP’s mum doesn’t seem to like the boyfriend, so o wonder if that’s a factor.

I wouldn’t necessarily want a dog around a baby or toddler either, so if their perception is that OP and dog are a package deal, choosing to come separately to see your parents is a practical option.

It doesn’t sound like they instructed your parents not to invite you, precisely, more that they avoided coming and your mum spotted the pattern and talked to them about it.

You talk about your niece as Boring, so that might be part of it as well - they get that you aren’t that fussed about their baby and they are not happy to be with your dog.

Families sometimes hit phases of being very much out of synch. Then life moves forward and things change again.

Do whatever you like on your own birthday and don’t read too much into the rest of it.

HamptonPlace · 17/02/2025 13:05

birthdays are for children...

Whoarethoseguys · 17/02/2025 13:01

You are not being unreasonable to do what you want on your birthday. But I don't think your brother and sister in law are unreasonable not wanting a dog at family events either, neither would i. Though they are unreasonable not to tell you what the issue was
It all sounds unnecessarily dramatic due to lack of communication.

sandyhappypeople · 17/02/2025 12:59

wediblinooo · 17/02/2025 12:45

They didn't say to anyone it was because of my dog! They would just ask is wediblinooo coming? And then say because of baby they rather just stop in and see how things go and doing a flying visit and change plans etc. It was only after about 14 months my parents realised the dog was an issue, and so my parents stopped issuing joint invites and at 2 years I found out.

Anyway. This is a by the by. The question was can't I just go to the pub for my birthday for a quiet dinner with my partner.

How do you know it is the dog that is the issue if no one has specifically said that though?

Are you sure it's not because of your partner? If they are isolating you because of the dog issue, why would your mum be so convinced that it is your partner that is isolating you and not the other way round?

I'm not saying any of it is right, but it sounds like none of you can communicate to save your lives! How long have you been with your partner?

wediblinooo · 17/02/2025 12:58

kitchenplans · 17/02/2025 12:47

Actually, they didn't. They said they weren't going themselves if OP (and her dog) were going. It wasn't their decision to leave OP out, it was whoever was hosting/organising the event.

It does seem odd to me that OP wasn't simply asked to leave her dog at home. I do wonder why everyone chose to do that rather than talk to her.

OP would you have happily left your dog behind if asked without question? Or would you make a big drama about it and fall out with everyone?

I've never really cared about whether the dog comes with me or not! He never came to my Brother's home because it was a London flat, he came to my parents because they missed having a dog and enjoyed walking him after Sunday lunch. I spend a lot of time with my dog, I need him for work, so I do like to give him break and leave him at home when I can.

I certainly would've asked why I was being asked to do something different- I think that's just curiosity, if something changes or we're asked to do something different we all ask why don't we?

OP posts:
OldChairMan · 17/02/2025 12:56

Anyway. This is a by the by. The question was can't I just go to the pub for my birthday for a quiet dinner with my partner.

It's not really 'by the by' though, is it? Of course you can do whatever you want for your birthday, but there's all this undealt with bad-feeling behind this situation. You seem unwilling to address it fully.

godmum56 · 17/02/2025 12:55

ManchesterLu · 17/02/2025 12:50

I'm 34 and I'm still at the stage of having to plan something for the whole family on my birthday because they get pissed off if I don't.

I need to learn to stand up for myself. All I want to do on my birthday is go out somewhere with DP and then chill in the evening - not entertain people!

The way to do it is to do it

ManchesterLu · 17/02/2025 12:50

I'm 34 and I'm still at the stage of having to plan something for the whole family on my birthday because they get pissed off if I don't.

I need to learn to stand up for myself. All I want to do on my birthday is go out somewhere with DP and then chill in the evening - not entertain people!

ChowMoWan · 17/02/2025 12:49

kitchenplans · 17/02/2025 12:47

Actually, they didn't. They said they weren't going themselves if OP (and her dog) were going. It wasn't their decision to leave OP out, it was whoever was hosting/organising the event.

It does seem odd to me that OP wasn't simply asked to leave her dog at home. I do wonder why everyone chose to do that rather than talk to her.

OP would you have happily left your dog behind if asked without question? Or would you make a big drama about it and fall out with everyone?

Either way, they didn't let her know there was an issue, so she couldn't do anything about it, which I think is really unfair!

ChowMoWan · 17/02/2025 12:48

Your mother has a bit of cheek accusing you BF of trying to isolate you from your family, when effectively she's been doing (along with B and SIL) that by not inviting you to events, and not telling you why so you can sort it.

kitchenplans · 17/02/2025 12:47

ChowMoWan · 17/02/2025 12:42

But they did this without telling OP that the issue was the dog. They didn't give her the chance to leave the dog at home, they just excluded her wholesale!

Actually, they didn't. They said they weren't going themselves if OP (and her dog) were going. It wasn't their decision to leave OP out, it was whoever was hosting/organising the event.

It does seem odd to me that OP wasn't simply asked to leave her dog at home. I do wonder why everyone chose to do that rather than talk to her.

OP would you have happily left your dog behind if asked without question? Or would you make a big drama about it and fall out with everyone?

wediblinooo · 17/02/2025 12:45

kitchenplans · 17/02/2025 12:38

They didn't ask for you to not be invited. They said they wouldn't come if your dog was there, which they are perfectly within their rights to do. The event organisers are the ones who obviously decided they valued your DB, SIL and nieces company more than yours (that's probably down to wanting to see DN tbh rather than favouritism between DB and you).

Whilst there's a lack of communication all round, you are being really, really childish and petty about this, which is a situation which could be very easily solved by you just agreeing to leave your dog at home in future.

They didn't say to anyone it was because of my dog! They would just ask is wediblinooo coming? And then say because of baby they rather just stop in and see how things go and doing a flying visit and change plans etc. It was only after about 14 months my parents realised the dog was an issue, and so my parents stopped issuing joint invites and at 2 years I found out.

Anyway. This is a by the by. The question was can't I just go to the pub for my birthday for a quiet dinner with my partner.

OP posts:
anon12345anon · 17/02/2025 12:43

Your brother and his wife sound like absolute arseholes, so I'd go nc with them.

Your mum obviously prioritises your brother over you (would her reaction have been the same if it was you that had the child and they had the dog?- I suspect not)..... I'd take a huge step back from your mum, and start putting yourself first x

ChowMoWan · 17/02/2025 12:42

kitchenplans · 17/02/2025 12:38

They didn't ask for you to not be invited. They said they wouldn't come if your dog was there, which they are perfectly within their rights to do. The event organisers are the ones who obviously decided they valued your DB, SIL and nieces company more than yours (that's probably down to wanting to see DN tbh rather than favouritism between DB and you).

Whilst there's a lack of communication all round, you are being really, really childish and petty about this, which is a situation which could be very easily solved by you just agreeing to leave your dog at home in future.

But they did this without telling OP that the issue was the dog. They didn't give her the chance to leave the dog at home, they just excluded her wholesale!

Saggyknickers · 17/02/2025 12:42

No way would I be driving to see my dps on MY birthday! YANBU.

kitchenplans · 17/02/2025 12:38

wediblinooo · 17/02/2025 12:33

I haven't tried to sort it because I was so hurt that my DB and SIL deliberately asked for me to be kept away from family events for 2 years. When I found out I told them that it was incredibly hurtful and not their place to ask other family members to not invite me to their homes because of their preference to keep my dog away from their child. They refused to accept that they were in the wrong and we haven't spoken since.

They maintain that they are right to keep the dog away from the baby, I maintain that if that was what they wanted they should have told me rather than going behind my back.

They didn't ask for you to not be invited. They said they wouldn't come if your dog was there, which they are perfectly within their rights to do. The event organisers are the ones who obviously decided they valued your DB, SIL and nieces company more than yours (that's probably down to wanting to see DN tbh rather than favouritism between DB and you).

Whilst there's a lack of communication all round, you are being really, really childish and petty about this, which is a situation which could be very easily solved by you just agreeing to leave your dog at home in future.

kitchenplans · 17/02/2025 12:34

wediblinooo · 17/02/2025 12:16

That's the long and short of it. Dog was always welcome in my parents house so would come with me, wasn't welcome in brothers, so wouldn't. Rather than risking a row by telling me my dog wasn't welcome in my parents house they would say that they would only attend if I wasn't invited.

Now you know what the issue is, have you made it clear to both your DB and SIL and to your parents that you're happy to leave your dog at home for future family events?

Because surely that would solve the problem, and everything could go back to how it was.

Regarding your birthday - you can do what you want. But if you usually do something with your DM and DF and have just stopped inviting them I can see why she's a bit upset. Bit overdramatic tbh, but I suspect she's more upset about the whole situation of not being able to have both you and your DB around at the same time, or family events that everyone (except your dog!) goes to. Ultimately your parents have been put in an awkward spot by two sets of adult children who are acting like toddlers sulking if they can't get their own way without communicating .

wediblinooo · 17/02/2025 12:33

Nanny0gg · 17/02/2025 12:27

But why haven't you discussed this with any of them?

Why did they think there'd be a row?

Why haven't you tried to sort it?

I haven't tried to sort it because I was so hurt that my DB and SIL deliberately asked for me to be kept away from family events for 2 years. When I found out I told them that it was incredibly hurtful and not their place to ask other family members to not invite me to their homes because of their preference to keep my dog away from their child. They refused to accept that they were in the wrong and we haven't spoken since.

They maintain that they are right to keep the dog away from the baby, I maintain that if that was what they wanted they should have told me rather than going behind my back.

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 17/02/2025 12:27

wediblinooo · 17/02/2025 12:16

That's the long and short of it. Dog was always welcome in my parents house so would come with me, wasn't welcome in brothers, so wouldn't. Rather than risking a row by telling me my dog wasn't welcome in my parents house they would say that they would only attend if I wasn't invited.

But why haven't you discussed this with any of them?

Why did they think there'd be a row?

Why haven't you tried to sort it?

Commonsense22 · 17/02/2025 12:26

Your mum is unreasonable but you should just tell her all you have said in this post.

hopeishere · 17/02/2025 12:25

So have you spoken to your brother about it?

Swipe left for the next trending thread