Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why anyone rushes to pay off their student finance?

267 replies

ChoppedChorizo · 11/02/2025 17:56

A couple of friends of mine make regular overpayments with a view to paying it off quicker. Some have used inheritance to clear it. I don’t understand the motivation? The lot gets written off if you haven’t paid by X number of years.

Mine has continued to increase - I started uni in 2012 so my fees were around £7k per year. Plus living. It sits around £23k now.

Ive earned well enough but did a post grad (self funded) two years of training on the job and then had children and so two years of mat leave.

I don’t see the motivation to pay it off sooner.

OP posts:
Catza · 14/02/2025 09:07

Willwetalk · 14/02/2025 08:19

You took out a loan, from the tax payer. You agreed to pay it back. Just do it.

Who is this mysterious "taxpayer" who gives out student loans and pays for public services? People throw it around as though it's a separate entity from the rest of us - public sector workers and people with student loans. I pay taxes so evidently I am the very same taxpayer who gives out loans and pays my own salary...
I didn't agree to "pay back" the loan. I agreed to make regular repayments on any income above the threshold. The difference is subtle but it's there.

Jmaho · 14/02/2025 08:54

Horserider5678 · 14/02/2025 08:41

student loans aren’t cheap if you’re on plan 2 it’s currently 7.3%. Whilst mortgage lenders won’t specifically ask about your loan, when they see your payslip it will count towards affordability!

I posted near enough the same pages back. Got told I'm financially illiterate and that I don't know what I'm talking about. According to a poster there are no deductions made, the loan is cheap and you're financially illiterate if you think it's not. Oh and never use a bank for a mortgage, use a broker because brokers lend you the money yourselves without any questions, just need to know your net pay!

ChoppedChorizo · 14/02/2025 08:53

@celticprincess I’m sorry to hear that. That’s part of my reluctance to repay it. I have only just starting earning over the threshold and me and DH are always chopping and changing financial plans. I think I’ll leave it for now and reassess in a year or so.

@Horserider5678 yes - others have said the same. I hadn’t appreciated how expensive it is for plan 2.

@LetMeStopWhatImDoingToFixTheProblemYouMade i agree it’s a national scandal. Mine has stayed the same since graduating and then grew over mat leave. That seems unfair in itself - maternity should surely be a time exempt of interest. Yet another way women miss out!

OP posts:
ChoppedChorizo · 14/02/2025 08:48

Willwetalk · 14/02/2025 08:19

You took out a loan, from the tax payer. You agreed to pay it back. Just do it.

I am 🤣 on exactly the terms I agreed too. I just have options with those terms I’m exploring in this post.

OP posts:
Horserider5678 · 14/02/2025 08:41

ChoppedChorizo · 11/02/2025 18:05

I have the means to repay it I have just never considered it a priority because I understood it was such a “cheap” loan that it’s should be the last thing to clear. Ie AFTER paying off your mortgage but I am happy to be corrected if I’m mistaken.

student loans aren’t cheap if you’re on plan 2 it’s currently 7.3%. Whilst mortgage lenders won’t specifically ask about your loan, when they see your payslip it will count towards affordability!

MystyLuna · 14/02/2025 08:35

I used to get annual statements for my student loan and no matter how much I paid off each year the internet was almost exactly double what I paid (just a few pence different). So each year it just went up and up.
I paid it from 2004 until 2011 when I stopped working when I had my son.
I then started paying it again in 2021 when I returned to full time work.
I haven't received a statement from the student loan company since 2010 so I dread to think how high it is now.
I don't think I want to know how high it is.
Only another 21 years until I am 65 and it gets written off.

celticprincess · 14/02/2025 08:31

I paid mine off and kid of regret it. This is because I didn’t realise then that I would become a single parent working part time and claiming UC. When I left uni I got a full time job. I bought a house and then a year or so later sold it to buy another with my partner. I decided to use some of the equity gained from the first house to pay off my loan. I didn’t put it towards the next house as we needed to go in equal. However fast forward many years and we divorced after 2 children, I was made redundant and then offered a part time role so I then claimed UC to top me up. I’m still in that role 10 years later and earning no where near the repayment threshold. However I’ve since done a masters and taken a masters loan and have just left the repaying to when o ever earn enough.

Many people treat it as like another ‘tax’ deduction from salary though and the monthly amount can be rather small depending on earnings.

Jmaho · 14/02/2025 08:29

@surreywilds so you don't have a mortgage from a bank? Your broker lends you the monies??
And this bean counter underwrites mortgages exclusively from brokers! From all over the UK!

LetMeStopWhatImDoingToFixTheProblemYouMade · 14/02/2025 08:29

I left uni in 2008 and I genuinely think the SLC is the scam of our times. We were all told it would be like buying a cd each week or buying shopping now and paying for it in line with inflation. It simply isn't that.

I left with £12k debt. As it was a recession, it took a while for me to earn enough to pay it back. By the time I did, it was £16k. I've been paying over a decade and it's still more than the initial £12k. Imagine if that was at today's costs of £54k leaving uni!

I have no issue with taking a loan and paying it back but the payment terms are unclear if not misleading.

mitogoshigg · 14/02/2025 08:28

It's accumulating interest. If you earn enough to be paying off in full then you will pay less overall if you pay off quicker. It all depends if you're likely to pay off in full though!

SlinkySprings · 14/02/2025 08:28

You need to do the maths on your individual circumstances surely.

What do you earn and will you likely have to pay it off or will some (and if so how much) get written off.

Apply the interest rate and see if it's worth it. If you're having to pay the whole lot off and paying interest on it then whether it affects affordability on anything else isn't really the point - it's interest you could avoid paying if you paid the loan off.

TimeForATerf · 14/02/2025 08:25

In answer to the OP my DD did an NHS degree 2015-2018 so her tuition was funded by the NHS. Her loan is therefore maintenance only and she only got the minimum (which was also less than the minimum for a non NHS degree) and we were expected to sub her.

She therefore was in an extremely privileged position of finishing university with a debt of around 13k. 8 years after graduation she only has a couple of grand left on her loan and I keep telling her the interest rate is awful and she should be over paying it. She doesn’t.

DS did a standard degree and even on the minimum maintenance loan his debt is huge and I would never suggest over paying that.

Willwetalk · 14/02/2025 08:19

ChoppedChorizo · 11/02/2025 18:50

Almost everyone has a degree. I earn more than the threshold (and actually quite a way in excess) I only do 3 days so I actually pretty good!! Nonetheless the interest on my mortgage debt is 5x more than my student finance per month - so we overpay that instead.

You took out a loan, from the tax payer. You agreed to pay it back. Just do it.

ChoppedChorizo · 14/02/2025 07:32

GRex · 13/02/2025 23:09

mortgage broker...... I would NEVER go to a bank for a mortgage, no-one whose serious about buying and selling property does
Awwwww, that's delightfully funny. Someone talking down to a mortgage underwriter who doesn't realise their mortgage broker put the details into a bank or building society system to get checked... by the mortgage underwriter. It could even be cute if the ignorant one wasn't so rude.

Yes I don’t think anyone disputes that but it obviously enables you to select the best deal for you.

OP posts:
GRex · 13/02/2025 23:09

mortgage broker...... I would NEVER go to a bank for a mortgage, no-one whose serious about buying and selling property does
Awwwww, that's delightfully funny. Someone talking down to a mortgage underwriter who doesn't realise their mortgage broker put the details into a bank or building society system to get checked... by the mortgage underwriter. It could even be cute if the ignorant one wasn't so rude.

BornSandyDevotional · 13/02/2025 22:45

qwertyasdfgzxcv · 13/02/2025 18:23

I don't think plan 1 is written off till over 60 and you have to repay once earning over 24k (or something similar), so if you are always going to earn over that amount you might as well overpay to reduce the interest. That's only specific to the plan I am on. I've been paying off since 2007 ish and not only have £4 left. I did more than one degree

I was plan 1 too and it took me what felt like forever to pay off. If I could have got rid sooner, I would. I cleared it the same year my eldest went to university. I didn't know that other plans hit differently until reading this thread. So I do thank the OP for raising it and I do now understand more. I do think education should be fully accessible and - if not free - affordable. It's all quite depressing really!

surreywilds · 13/02/2025 22:42

Jmaho · 11/02/2025 23:38

So because you've had several mortgages you know better than someone that has underwritten mortgages for the best part of 25 years?? I don't know a single lender who works using net income! It varies so much from person to person. So someone who puts in extra to their pension would be able to borrow less, what??? We use gross income and the bank I work for and many many others categorically deduct student loan if its on your payslip whatever you may think.
I've read some rubbish on here but someone trying to tell you what you do in your day to day job takes the biscuit!

My mortgage broker works on Affordability , whats so hard for you to understand that?

I know all the retail bean counters in banks look at gross salary, I would NEVER go to a bank for a mortgage, no-one whose serious about buying and selling property does, and you know that.

And what I say about it being a cheap loan stands, any financially literate person knows this also.

qwertyasdfgzxcv · 13/02/2025 18:23

I don't think plan 1 is written off till over 60 and you have to repay once earning over 24k (or something similar), so if you are always going to earn over that amount you might as well overpay to reduce the interest. That's only specific to the plan I am on. I've been paying off since 2007 ish and not only have £4 left. I did more than one degree

IKnowAristotle · 12/02/2025 22:17

I think my initial comment has been taken more seriously than intended and as I stated subsequently - I pay exactly what I am required to pay. Despite doing that for the past 21 years, my student loan balance is the same as it was when I left university.

Another flippant comment for people to froth over: Hate the game, not the player!

XenoBitch · 12/02/2025 16:05

ChoppedChorizo · 12/02/2025 15:54

@Zusammengebrochen your commitment to my posts, as a stranger to you on mumsnet, is commendable. Although we’ve not agreed on this post your trolling with laughing emojis has given me a chuckle this afternoon.

I saw a post on another thread where Zusammengebrochen put a laugh react where someone said they were autistic.
They were pulled up on it, and they said they found it funny.

ChoppedChorizo · 12/02/2025 15:54

@Zusammengebrochen your commitment to my posts, as a stranger to you on mumsnet, is commendable. Although we’ve not agreed on this post your trolling with laughing emojis has given me a chuckle this afternoon.

To wonder why anyone rushes to pay off their student finance?
OP posts:
ChoppedChorizo · 12/02/2025 15:37

ThePartingOfTheWays · 12/02/2025 14:48

But a tax that you don't have to worry about if you had the prudence to go to university before a certain date, or to have parents who'll pay it upfront for you. Only for the profligates who don't tick those boxes!

Absolutely - it’s criminal. Education was always a right of betterment that should be available to all. I honestly never gave much thought to taking a student loan, it was just what you did if you went to uni and that was free choice to make based on whether you want to. The expense must be so much more prohibitive now.

OP posts:
ThePartingOfTheWays · 12/02/2025 14:48

ChoppedChorizo · 12/02/2025 10:36

I hadn’t really considered the profit element of the interest because when I took the loan (and historically) it was so low. But reading what other people are paying on Plan 2, which is something I hadn’t engaged with before I can see that it is now a tax of sorts, rather than a the loan that was sold to us for the benefit of our education.

But a tax that you don't have to worry about if you had the prudence to go to university before a certain date, or to have parents who'll pay it upfront for you. Only for the profligates who don't tick those boxes!

Zusammengebrochen · 12/02/2025 14:42

Catza · 12/02/2025 07:54

I am repaying "some of it". I am repaying what I am required every month. I don't know how you managed to establish that I pay nothing since I stated many times that I pay 9% over the threshold as per my contractual agreement.
I would have thought reading comprehension was high on a list of requirements for a degree....

There's so many different replies - it's good you are paying some back, but a few posters definitely don't plan to.
Addled brains today, sorry.

ChoppedChorizo · 12/02/2025 12:07

Catontoof · 12/02/2025 11:44

I'm in same position not in a position to even pay into a pension fund because of it. I don't get how it's oegal
to put this much interest on and keep hoping one day someone will do something until then I pay £250 each month and they keep piling on the interest

Corr I’m sorry it’s having such an impact. That’s terrible.

OP posts: