Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Addressing the elephant in the room; people abusing NHS, health and social care.

163 replies

Floogal · 08/02/2025 20:40

I have seen a number of threads (here and on Facebook) bemoaning and worrying about the state of the NHS and social care in the UK. But what about how the general public treats it? Over the years, so many people used these services incorrectly, or even abused it in wanton fashion. There has been recent discussion about people who go to A&E mob handed. As well as a lady forcibly being evicted for overstaying at hospital

www.mumsnet.com/talk/_chat/5270258-woman-evicted-from-nhs-hospital-ward-after-being-stuck-for-18-months

I have been working at a council run rehabilitation unit. The majority of patients stay here after being discharged from hospital. They usually stay for around 3 weeks before they're well enough to go home (or sadly sometimes residential or nursing care). However, there is a noticeable minority of patients who seem to treat the place like a hotel. Eg,, staying in bed all morning, watching TV all day in their rooms, Refusing to join in group exercise classes, chatting on their mobiles. Socialising with their visitors for hours on end. I mean, they have plenty of free time in the afternoon and evening to chill out.
Indeed, some of the conversations I've heard make them seem entitled. For example , "I should like some tea and cakes brought to my room for when my guests arrive". Another lady kept ringing her bell as a carer made her tea in a mug, she wanted it put in a China cup. Another male patient turned away a physiotherapist who came in to see him. His reason for turning her away was "I haven't finished reading my morning paper". The best one was this woman complaining that she expects room service and that she's worked and paid her taxes. They're meant to be there for rehabilitation, not the Downton Abbey experience!
Also there are other patients who are ready to go home but are very reluctant to leave. Most likely as they get 3 free meals and company and attention. Which is understandable if they're lonely at home. But that's not what the service is for.
I believe this also contributes to the problem of bed blocking in hospital as patients can't leave hospital due to a lack of space at rehab.

OP posts:
PocketSand · 09/02/2025 17:16

@Crispynoodle my mother was admitted from home following s stroke. She was disturbed and delusional. Drs misread the notes and thought arthritis said Alzheimer's. She deteriorated whilst in hospital to an alarming degree, physically and mentally. She received no treatment for the stroke and her rheumatoid arthritis medication was stopped. The ward had no knowledge despite being a patient in the same hospital for the last 15 years.

The hospital wanted a care home. She did not. We had POA and she was discharged home with no care package. The NHS finally agreed continuing care but she died before it was put in place. We paid for private carers but it was not enough. When the community nurse arrived to deliver end of life support she hugged me and cried. And railed about lack of care and leaving families with inadequate support.

We took mum home because she was dying in full view due to lack of support but no one cared. We couldn't stop her dying but at least we cared, shared memories and photos of when she was young, she spent time with her children and grandchildren. Not to avoid care home costs and protect inheritance. So insensitive.

TankFlyBossW4lk · 09/02/2025 17:08

NoTouch · 09/02/2025 11:33

Having such contempt for your patients must make it difficult to perform or enjoy your job. Perhaps it is time for a career change.

Not a helpful post. Got to ask yourself why the NHS is finding it difficult to recruit. Who's going to look after you?

TankFlyBossW4lk · 09/02/2025 17:06

tiredwardsister · 09/02/2025 16:26

I used to have to put up with endless written complaints about the wrong type of sandwich filling; we used to have ham cheese tuna egg, all made off the premises and completely out of my control, the view out of the window; onto another NHS building, how comfortable or not the arm chairs are, being offered a dessert spoon instead of a soup spoon to drink their soup, being offered breakfast too early: about 8 am, no croissant (I kid you not) only white brown toast, no fruit in the individual jam pots, the fact that they couldn’t swap peas for sweetcorn off the lunch time menu (again all prepared off site and outside of my control), insufficient variety of fruit at meal times apples, bananas and oranges were standard, the quality of the tea and coffee offered even more about the hot chocolate so I removed it, don’t get me started on those small cartons of orange for breakfast people wanted apple so were constantly complaining, or the variety of the biscuits available cheap digestive and bourbons. I could go on. In the end I resigned taking 30 + years experience in my field (still in the NHS but in a less demanding role) as I spent so much of my time replying to crappy complaints like this.

Would it be very controversial to say we should have a mechanism of saying this is not a sensible use of resources for the NHS to answer this complaint? I really think it's death by a thousand cuts within the NHS workforce. It takes huge amounts of time to respond to these petty complaints. If we could have a triage level of "just out of our control", it would actually save a lot of time. We could ask them to speak with their MPs at their weekend surgeries instead 😂

ScaryM0nster · 09/02/2025 17:04

I do think that there’s a lot that the NHS and social care services could learn from the private sector about setting standards, commitment and individually accountability.

Almost no private provision takes patients on without being clear about the terms, whereas that seems standard within public services.

Making the expectations clear up front would also make it a more positive working environment.

I feel your frustrations OP. They echo mine as a tax payer.

TankFlyBossW4lk · 09/02/2025 17:00

TheEllisGreyMethod · 09/02/2025 16:09

You wouldn't believe the number of patients who decline my input because it isn't a convenient time (for example because they haven't finished the paper, don't like moving before 11) who then turn around and file a complaint that they weren't seen that day. It's thankless.

I have seen what you mean. It's interesting because I rarely see this in the private sector.

TheEllisGreyMethod · 09/02/2025 16:34

RandomButtons · 09/02/2025 16:11

I’m genuinely so sorry to hear that.

Also angry. It took 5 months to be seen by NHS physio for shoulder injury that has massively affected my ability to work. I’m self employed and it cost me a lot of money (I had to go private so as to not loose my only income)

This is also very frustrating for me - I triage the new referrals so am aware of how many people are desperately waiting for an unacceptable amount of time. And then I regularly have mornings where 6 out of 8 will decline or fail to turn up. We do have a strict two declines and your out policy, but if someone complains then that policy is always forgotten by management and we get the blame. Genuinely sorry you had to go private, it isn't acceptable.

CdcRuben · 09/02/2025 16:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Floogal · 09/02/2025 16:31

RandomButtons · 09/02/2025 16:11

I’m genuinely so sorry to hear that.

Also angry. It took 5 months to be seen by NHS physio for shoulder injury that has massively affected my ability to work. I’m self employed and it cost me a lot of money (I had to go private so as to not loose my only income)

Exactly, people abusing services slows it down for other people.

OP posts:
Floogal · 09/02/2025 16:30

tiredwardsister · 09/02/2025 16:26

I used to have to put up with endless written complaints about the wrong type of sandwich filling; we used to have ham cheese tuna egg, all made off the premises and completely out of my control, the view out of the window; onto another NHS building, how comfortable or not the arm chairs are, being offered a dessert spoon instead of a soup spoon to drink their soup, being offered breakfast too early: about 8 am, no croissant (I kid you not) only white brown toast, no fruit in the individual jam pots, the fact that they couldn’t swap peas for sweetcorn off the lunch time menu (again all prepared off site and outside of my control), insufficient variety of fruit at meal times apples, bananas and oranges were standard, the quality of the tea and coffee offered even more about the hot chocolate so I removed it, don’t get me started on those small cartons of orange for breakfast people wanted apple so were constantly complaining, or the variety of the biscuits available cheap digestive and bourbons. I could go on. In the end I resigned taking 30 + years experience in my field (still in the NHS but in a less demanding role) as I spent so much of my time replying to crappy complaints like this.

Almost laughed reading that. Unbelievable pettiness and entitlement.

OP posts:
tiredwardsister · 09/02/2025 16:26

I used to have to put up with endless written complaints about the wrong type of sandwich filling; we used to have ham cheese tuna egg, all made off the premises and completely out of my control, the view out of the window; onto another NHS building, how comfortable or not the arm chairs are, being offered a dessert spoon instead of a soup spoon to drink their soup, being offered breakfast too early: about 8 am, no croissant (I kid you not) only white brown toast, no fruit in the individual jam pots, the fact that they couldn’t swap peas for sweetcorn off the lunch time menu (again all prepared off site and outside of my control), insufficient variety of fruit at meal times apples, bananas and oranges were standard, the quality of the tea and coffee offered even more about the hot chocolate so I removed it, don’t get me started on those small cartons of orange for breakfast people wanted apple so were constantly complaining, or the variety of the biscuits available cheap digestive and bourbons. I could go on. In the end I resigned taking 30 + years experience in my field (still in the NHS but in a less demanding role) as I spent so much of my time replying to crappy complaints like this.

ApiratesaysYarrr · 09/02/2025 16:25

Yougetmoreofwhatyoufocuson · 08/02/2025 21:18

Here’s something for you to think about regarding the NHS and wasting money: according to the Wiley library of endocrinology, the average cost of Levothyroxine costs the NHS £2500 a year per patient (2021) I admit that I just googled that and it came up on the first page and looks legit. I am in Portugal and have just bought myself 2 months supply of Levothyroxine for the princely sum of €7.50. In the past I used to use a private prescription to buy Liothyronine, it would cost £30 a month. My doctor didn’t want to prescribe it because it would cost the surgery £500 a month. One would think that the NHS has you know that thing of bulk buying making stuff cheaper. How much are they paying everyday for overpriced drugs that no one is checking up on? As in, is no one in charge? The mind boggles at the sheer numbers.
The NHS like one of those massive dinosaurs with a very long neck and a tiny brain at the top.

Levothyroxine and liothyronine are 2 different drugs, so you are comparing 2 different things. Example of where a drug manufacturer was inflating the price of their drugs (at bottom of page)

Also, different drugs cost different prices in different countries is not a surprise. Supermarkets have bulk buying power, but the price of food varies between even neighbouring countries.

Liothyronine

An update on L-T3 liothyronine for the management of hypothyroidism

https://www.btf-thyroid.org/liothyronine

RandomButtons · 09/02/2025 16:11

TheEllisGreyMethod · 09/02/2025 16:09

You wouldn't believe the number of patients who decline my input because it isn't a convenient time (for example because they haven't finished the paper, don't like moving before 11) who then turn around and file a complaint that they weren't seen that day. It's thankless.

I’m genuinely so sorry to hear that.

Also angry. It took 5 months to be seen by NHS physio for shoulder injury that has massively affected my ability to work. I’m self employed and it cost me a lot of money (I had to go private so as to not loose my only income)

TheEllisGreyMethod · 09/02/2025 16:09

RandomButtons · 08/02/2025 20:46

Staying in bed all morning and watching TV and talk g to thier relatives - what’s the issue with that? Not everyone wants to socialise with people they don’t know.

People not wanting to go home because of loneliness also totally understandable.

Guy who refuses NHS physio should be struck off the list however. Back of the queue for physio for him.

People wanting to be waited on hand and foot likewise. Cold cups of tea for them.

You wouldn't believe the number of patients who decline my input because it isn't a convenient time (for example because they haven't finished the paper, don't like moving before 11) who then turn around and file a complaint that they weren't seen that day. It's thankless.

Floogal · 09/02/2025 16:04

Toucanfusingforme · 09/02/2025 09:53

I’ve worked in similar set ups. Obviously you want patients/clients to be happy and relaxed, but that’s completely different from taking the piss. You are in there for rehab, it’s not a rest home. Some people love it because it’s more sociable and supportive than home (understandable) but doesn’t have the negative connotations of being in a care home. They would happily live in that half way situation indefinitely given the choice. But there is a large queue of people who also need those facilities so you don’t want them to get too comfortable!

Exactly. The majority of patients are cooperative. But it only takes one or two people abusing the place to have a knock on effect.

OP posts:
AquaPeer · 09/02/2025 13:14

Meandhimtogether · 09/02/2025 12:47

I worked as a GP receptionist before I retired.
We used to have a sign saying how many appointments were missed.
At one point it was over 100 for a 4 week period.

Many were repeat patients who didn't turn up.
You couldn't refuse to give them an appointment as they maybe really
poorly. All you could do is tell them about missing appointments.

Sign got removed as there were too many complaints that we were trying
to embarrass everyone. There were no names or clues if it was an adult
or child or even male or female.

People need to be accountable for themselves and not waste resources.

Your bosses were massive whimps if they were pushed into removing the sign by some random complaints- surely the point of the sign was to embarrass people?!

either that or they realised it wasn’t effective

UnhappyAndYouKnowIt · 09/02/2025 12:53

There is a difference between patients who are discharged into a care or nursing facility to rest and recover and those who are discharged into rehabilitation settings.

One involves rest and the other involves increased physical activity.

Meandhimtogether · 09/02/2025 12:47

I worked as a GP receptionist before I retired.
We used to have a sign saying how many appointments were missed.
At one point it was over 100 for a 4 week period.

Many were repeat patients who didn't turn up.
You couldn't refuse to give them an appointment as they maybe really
poorly. All you could do is tell them about missing appointments.

Sign got removed as there were too many complaints that we were trying
to embarrass everyone. There were no names or clues if it was an adult
or child or even male or female.

People need to be accountable for themselves and not waste resources.

Gingernaut · 09/02/2025 12:30

IWillAlwaysBeinaClubWithYouin1973 · 09/02/2025 12:02

I'm still struggling to understand how the link to the report of the woman with severe mental health issues is illustrative of the OP's point? (Edited to say I see I'm not the only one so not worth going over it, its clear its not relevant)

Edited

The patient has a ^personality disorder', not considered to be a treatable mental illness.

She can't be sectioned for 'being herself'

Gingernaut · 09/02/2025 12:27

SummerFeverVenice · 09/02/2025 11:51

No, she was offered 1 option only and as is her right, she raised the concern that the 1 option offered was to a place that she has distressing memories of as bad things happened to her there. Our rights have been eroded, you used to be able to have a choice of a few options, then it was right to reject first two options, now it’s you get 1 option and you have no choice- take it or die on the streets homeless. I am sure this is in preparation for go where we say or it’s straight to the euthanasia clinic.

When someone one's mental and physical needs, their behaviour and attitude are so extreme, that only one facility was prepared to take her on, Hobson's choice is all you're going to get, especially after over 500 days in a hospital bed

wheretoyougonow · 09/02/2025 12:26

It's obviously ok to disagree with the op but personal comments are totally unnecessary.

I agree with you Op. Having just spent 12 weeks in hospital I was astounded by some patients behaviours. One particular highlight was a very capable lady who went home the next day (before anyone comments there is NO privacy on the wards) having a go at a nurse late at night as she had requested tea and toast 10 minutes ago. Right next to her was a lady in acute medical distress with nurses and doctors working on her. They were clearly not going to prioritise tea and toast !!!!

Gravitasdepleted · 09/02/2025 12:18

@Yougetmoreofwhatyoufocuson
The patent for levothyroxine expired in March 2024, which probably explains why it's much cheaper now.

Flopsythebunny · 09/02/2025 12:14

BeardofHagrid · 09/02/2025 08:51

I know a lady who has made it her life’s work to mug off the NHS. It’s disgusting and they should start blacklisting people like that.

I have said for a long time that we should all be allowed up to ten free GP appointments per year, then after that pay £30 or so. It would put off a lot of the malingerers.

And it would stop people like me with disabilities, cancers and life limiting conditions from getting the medical help that I need to stay alive. I there are times that I need weekly gp appointments that I couldn't go to if I had to pay

Jossjt · 09/02/2025 12:12

This is what happens when you give something of value to people for free. The majority of the people in this country do not contribute to the cost of public services. They are net takers. Until people are made to contribute to the cost of services they use, nothing will change.

Not to mention that NHS is basically a broken, money pit. It keeps getting more money from a dwindling number of people who actually contribute to just fritter it away.

AquaPeer · 09/02/2025 12:08

ViolinsPlayGentlyOn · 09/02/2025 11:46

So how are this older cohort failing to take on personal responsibility in your view?

Or is the issue actually simply one of the current demographics we have, and not one about personal responsibility at all?

I think you might be losing track of who you’re responding to/ why you’re responding to them. I didn’t say that older people are failing to take responsibility. I responded to a user who said the problems in the nhs were partly attributable to people who don’t take personal responsibility

IWillAlwaysBeinaClubWithYouin1973 · 09/02/2025 12:02

I'm still struggling to understand how the link to the report of the woman with severe mental health issues is illustrative of the OP's point? (Edited to say I see I'm not the only one so not worth going over it, its clear its not relevant)

Swipe left for the next trending thread