What if Sandie Peggie......... identifies as a Muslim Woman?

I wouldn't have any issue at all working with a trans person.
But if someone who was genetically male insisted on changing in a female space I was changing in, I would feel intimidated and disrespected by them, and it's hard to work with someone who you feel disrespects you.

The issue isn't being trans, it's being disrespectful.

She did everything right. She raised it internally. Followed advice etc.

He complained that she waited outside the room. Complained that she came in the room. Complained she looked at him funny. Complained she didn’t look at him.

You have to hear him to believe the absolute shite he was complaining about.

What sex specific space was she sharing given that there are lockers in the changing room? It sounds like the nurse wasn’t willing to share any space with a trans person as she also refused to communicate in a work capacity.

The nurse seems to have behaved unprofessionally here. Regardless of her views on trans issues, she needs to treat colleagues respectfully in a work setting

but the nurse wasn’t being treated with respect, they were being subjected to bullying and harassment by being forced to share sex specific spaces with a man. The colleague was forcefully trampling on her boundaries. I wouldn’t want to be tolerant of someone who behaved so appallingly and why should I be?

Any man pretending to be a woman is playing dress up. Their needs do not trump the needs of any other woman.

In the hierarchy of oppression Dr Upton is at the top; white with xy chromosomes. It's a brave new world.

Would they? Where would this be said

It was in response to a comment asking the OP why they imagined there might be a difference. An insincere and unconvincing pretence that we don't all know what that difference is.

If she was a Muslim there would be racism against her complaining and people would be saying, if you don’t like it go back to your own country. People would be posting that actually they feel more comfortable changing around men, Muslim women need to get over it.

I'm not sure how it would work if the woman was from a religion where she couldn't share a space with men because surely the mantra is he's a woman - trans women are women. They would tell the woman that she's not sharing a space with a man.

The nurse seems to have behaved unprofessionally here. Regardless of her views on trans issues, she needs to treat colleagues respectfully in a work setting.

It is not sustainable to have a situation where she refuses to communicate with the doctor about patient care.

She may think the transitioning doctor shouldn’t be using the female changing room, but she should have raised her concerns through the appropriate channels rather than being rude.

In any event, there are cubicles in the changing room so this seems to be more a case of ideological and dogmatic views being put before what is best for staff and patients.

You are referring to what would then be a clash of ideologies. Trans vs muslim religion. An interesting debate.
I don’t think that nhs fife would be supporting this male doctor so very publicly if the female nurse was muslim tbh as the optics would not suit.
I am an atheist and don’t believe human beings can change sex so for me any such debate would be rather like asking if a unicorn would beat a dragon in a race.
What is really happening here is that a male is using a female changing room so he is obviously completely in the wrong but apparently this is not reality for some in these dystopian times.

Why on earth would you bring this up in a discussion about a man using a female only space?
I have a pretty good idea why you would, it would just be nice for you to confirm it

I'd blame management for this. The doctor can't continue to use the men's changing room, because he us transitioning and presents as female. They should have addressed the lack of changing space. The Nurse should have been raising this internally rather than let an issue in the workplace affect patient care, especially the care of children.

So a trans person can't continue in their career? You gave to give up everything if you are trans? I'm gender critical and never agreed with self I.D, but what you are proposing is oppression.

If I worked with a man who consistently eroded boundaries and insisted on getting changed in front of me, or being there while I was getting changed, I would struggle to maintain a professional composure when working with them too. That is what happens when men set out to intimidate women.

Well it's the same as that white woman who idenfified as a black woman - Rachel something... she was totally shunned and rejected. Because you can't change your race right?
But men can change their sex is different. Because it's men. right?

OK. Maybe they wouldn't be killed. But I've seen many many cases like the one in the OP. And they never involve religious minorities because of the optics I imagine. There must be a reason, and that is that they're confident the authorities would side with them, whereas in the case outlined by the OP I don't think they're confident they would. And with a teacher in hiding, and Charlie Hebdo and other such cases, they feel there would be a real threat in kicking a hornets nest. They prefer easy targets

"Dr Upton said previous incidents with Ms Peggie had escalated to a stage where it "had the potential to impact care" of patients.
Dr Upton cited an incident on 18 December, where a young child was brought in.
The tribunal was told Ms Peggie refused to acknowledge or look at Dr Upton when discussing the patient."

That's worrying tbf. If the nurse can't accept a trans person to that extent, she shouldn't be in nursing.

I don't think you understand what the OP is asking/saying