Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s unfair that some people get inheritance while others start with nothing?

821 replies

ThisCandidCritic · 06/02/2025 14:22

Isn’t inheritance just another way of keeping wealth in the hands of the privileged? AIBU to think we should heavily tax or abolish inheritances altogether?

OP posts:
OMGitsnotgood · 06/02/2025 19:29

We had next to nothing left to us by our parents. We have made our own money and we will leave a lot to our DC. I don't feel bitter about that at all. Hope that helps.

Surgarblossom · 06/02/2025 19:29

Heard it all now 🙄

Supperlite · 06/02/2025 19:28

I’ve never heard anything more miserly and pathetic. I’m not expecting to receive any inheritance, whereas many friends are already benefiting from chunks of money from grandparents or parents to help them on the housing ladder, and there’ll be more when they are bereaved. I’m happy for them, and proud of myself for getting to where I am on my own. I plan that one day I’ll be able to provide for my kids and grandkids.

You should focus less on being jealous and grabby, and make more effort to build up your own capital so you can leave your children something.

itsjustbiology · 06/02/2025 19:26

Sorry OP but what I had to loose for my inheritance was too great a cost to me. My dad always said he was worth more dead than alive and he was! He wanted to help us and look after us when he had gone . Yes inheritance is lovely but I would swap every penny for 5 more minutes with my dad.

Ameliepoulainandthephotobooth · 06/02/2025 19:26

I would rather have my loved ones but sadly all I have is a small inheritance.

Nice of you to post and run though @ThisCandidCritic. Hopefully you are doing something worthwhile that benefits society?!

wipeywipe · 06/02/2025 19:25

I’d find a way to provide for my children, by fair means or foul. I imagine I’d not be alone in my determination.

Your dc will do better though in an environment where they get paid a good salary for their job and where housing costs aren't so disproportionate.

wipeywipe · 06/02/2025 19:23

I don’t understand why people don’t get angrier about it??

I think people worry about getting left behind & it's wrapped up with aspiration. People don't vote for things that penalise what they aspire to be not realising that they just move the goalposts further away from them.

HPFA · 06/02/2025 19:23

I haven't read the whole thread so apologise if the point has already been made.

The difficulty with inheritance at the moment is that it's becoming more and more difficult to access the basic of adult life - a secure home - without parental wealth, whether that comes in the form of lifetime gifts or inheritance.

When your normal averagely hard working person could afford a home in an OK area then maybe they didn't resent the inheritance that gave their friend a slightly better home. It's not the same when the inheritance is making the difference between working for nothing more than to make a landlord rich and being able to live a proper adult life with a secure home. People are right to resent that.

I sometimes wonder how as a society we ever recover from all the bad decisions we've made over the years - the destruction of social housing (and now affordable housing in general), austerity, Brexit.... There are things that annoy me about the current govt. But God, I wouldn't even know how to start fixing things.

Tapofthemorning · 06/02/2025 19:23

1apenny2apenny · 06/02/2025 14:30

So you think it's unfair that my children will inherit from their parents despite the fact that we have both worked hard, when we were younger don't 2 jobs, and gone without and cut our cloth? No doubt you will say we are 'lucky'!

Life is hard and soooooo unfair. We've paid our taxes, never claimed benefits etc. Focus on how the government waste money and subsidise big business.

Hate this "never claimed benefit". Not a boast. Like saying "my kid had 100% attendance record". Cool, you aren't sick. Well done. The Welfare State was created to support people and denigrating it just sickens me.

StoneofDestiny · 06/02/2025 19:23

I inherited nothing. I've worked hard and made sacrifices and sensible decisions all so my children could be helped financially. Unfair - I don't think so. I've paid my taxes, they will pay inheritance tax and my Will on death will be open to public scrutiny. What is unfair is some people dodging taxes, some being 'excused' inheritance tax and some being allowed to have their wills kept secret! Yes - Royal Family and Farmers - looking at you.

Aweecupofteaandabiscuit · 06/02/2025 19:22

Zebedee999 · 06/02/2025 19:13

I assume you have a will that says ALL YOU OWN must be given to HMRC when you die? Including sentimental items etc.
If not then you are a hypocrite, as you only want other people's stuff to go to HMRC and not your own.

All of this.
Unbelievable that people are talking about how awful it is to receive and bestow their own inheritances when the option is there to give away all your own money. Nobody is forcing you to keep it!

BrotherViolence · 06/02/2025 19:21

YANBU at all. I'd prefer it to be banned for anything significant like property. But you'll see plenty of people here think it's an incentive to "work hard" and some kind of basic human right, rather than just entrenched luck and privilege, so I'm sure things will never change.

BIossomtoes · 06/02/2025 19:21

Jenkibubble · 06/02/2025 18:45

Let me pose this scenario to you instead …..
Person A works hard during their life , buys a property , pays tax on their income . Retired . Gets ill and has to go into a care home . They have to fund their care home themself (including if necessary , selling their home )

Person B has been housed in social housing (subsidised by the tax payer ) has not worked and so not paid tax , but relied on welfare benefits . They get ill and have to go into a care home . Their care is paid for by the local authority .

Is THAT a fair system ?

Social housing isn’t subsidised by anyone.

Flossflower · 06/02/2025 19:20

if we didn’t think we could leave any money to our children we would have stopped working much earlier in our lives. If everyone did this it would not be great for the economy.

Aweecupofteaandabiscuit · 06/02/2025 19:19

I’d find a way to provide for my children, by fair means or foul. I imagine I’d not be alone in my determination.
Are you condoning outright thievery by the government and expecting the population to bow down to this?
Madness.

gingerperil · 06/02/2025 19:19

It’s totally unfair. And I expect a large inheritance. I have done nothing to earn it.. my parents inherited significant amount too.. they also did nothing to earn it. It’s just perpetuates inequalities.. helps keep the rich rich. My kids will be given housing deposits from any inheritance we get. Life is so unfair.. I don’t understand why people don’t get angrier about it??

wipeywipe · 06/02/2025 19:18

How you feel about the lottery OP?

🤦🏻‍♀️

Tapofthemorning · 06/02/2025 19:18

ThisCandidCritic · 06/02/2025 14:22

Isn’t inheritance just another way of keeping wealth in the hands of the privileged? AIBU to think we should heavily tax or abolish inheritances altogether?

Of course it's unfair, but life is innately unfair. Do you have children? I can't have them. That's unfair. Do you have a serious illness. I do. Unfair. I wasn't born in a war torn country thought. Or the slums. People there would likely argue their lives are unfair compared to mine. All you can do is change what you can and advocate for equality as best you can.

Daisymae23 · 06/02/2025 19:17

How you feel about the lottery OP?

merediththethird · 06/02/2025 19:15

You can figure it out without much trouble @alwaysontheloo (great user name!) round our way. We live in a part of London where receptionists and gardeners our age simply can’t afford to live without inheritance unless they’re earning loads. I’m no Sherlock but it’s pretty obvious! My neighbours are also quite honest about where the money came from after a few pints down the pub. It’s quite mad that they get 30 hours childcare while living in multi million quid houses without mortgages.

Zebedee999 · 06/02/2025 19:13

ThisCandidCritic · 06/02/2025 14:22

Isn’t inheritance just another way of keeping wealth in the hands of the privileged? AIBU to think we should heavily tax or abolish inheritances altogether?

I assume you have a will that says ALL YOU OWN must be given to HMRC when you die? Including sentimental items etc.
If not then you are a hypocrite, as you only want other people's stuff to go to HMRC and not your own.

Ph3 · 06/02/2025 19:12

hairbearbunches · 06/02/2025 18:25

What people are wilfully blind to is that once you're dead, your assets then become a windfall for someone else. And windfalls should be taxed. Heavily. The dead aren't being taxed twice. They're not being taxed at all. Their beneficiaries are, and yes I think that inheritance tax should kick in at a punitive rate on anything above 200k. For most people this would be a lottery win. For those who think 200k is small fry, have a bloody word!

I have a friend who is about to inherit a very significant seven figure sum, the majority of which has been legally shielded from the taxman. It's wrong on so many levels.

I have to disagree. It’s not wrong. As long as the money has been taxed accordingly before it was left - then it’s not wrong. If you have money to leave your children why should they be punished as long as you paid your taxes before it gets to them?

Anonymouseposter · 06/02/2025 19:11

Life's unfair.
Some people have good health, some people have bad health, some get things handed to them some have no help at all.
The government can tinker and try to even things up a bit but things are inherently unfair.
The best thing we can do is not watch other people over our shoulders. Comparison leads to resentment.
We can of course vote for politicians who veer towards increasing fairness rather than putting more money into the hands of the advantaged at the expense of the disadvantaged.
P.S. the "advantaged" aren't people with small bungalows and 3 bedroomed semis.

wipeywipe · 06/02/2025 19:05

@User28473 we don't all think that.

User28473 · 06/02/2025 19:04

I can't abide the unshakable belief of the middle classes that someone else 'working hard' means they deserve their inheritance. Only a middle or upper class person doesn't realise that working class people work the hardest, thankless jobs for a pittance and little or nothing to leave to their families to break the cycle. I am definitely in favour of high taxes on inheritance.