Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To emphasise that neurotypical kids have different needs to neurodiverse kids

120 replies

DevilledEgg · 04/02/2025 22:23

I mean of course I'm not unreasonable. I'm just sick of seeing comments on here (everywhere actually, but I'm here the most) from perfect parents basically saying "well my neurotypical kids slept through the night by 1/share rooms fine/no not to hit their baby brother/eat what's offered etc etc so there's no reason your kids can't"

Telling parents of disabled children that they're shit parents because their DISABLED children don't behave like non disabled children is so fucking destructive.

And it happens all the fucking time

😭

OP posts:
mondaytosunday · 05/02/2025 16:36

I've only come across this once when a relative's partner could just not get his head around the fact you cannot discipline an autistic child in the same way. But then he's the type that would, when told a vegetarian was coming for dinner, just fish out the meaty bits and serve them what's left.

FoolishHips · 05/02/2025 16:36

MrWise · 04/02/2025 22:51

God almighty, I've just legged it over here because the thread from the OP sleeping in her lounge so the ND kids can be separated, is making my head implode. The number of replies insisting two autistic kids can share a room (one has PDA) is unreal. I give up.

I haven't seen that thread for a while but I used to sleep in a cupboard so that my two didn't have to share :).

My idiotic BIL with two very neurotypical DDs used to say that he'd look after my DS for a week and solve all the problems :/

hazelnutvanillalatte · 05/02/2025 16:36

genesis92 · 05/02/2025 10:11

99% of MN children are ND in some way now.

50% of people are predicted to get cancer...is cancer not real then?

Newsenmum · 05/02/2025 16:26

Also think I may step away from this thread for a bit. It’s exhausting and upsetting and none of us wanted our kids to be like this.

Newsenmum · 05/02/2025 16:25

TheAntisocialButterfly · 05/02/2025 16:17

Yes, this.

For those asking how ND kids go on to manage in an adult world, the adult world is vastly different from childhood and the rigidity of school due to power and autonomy.

As an adult I can WFH, work flexitime, work in a low stimulation environment, work in an area associated with my specialist interest, I could work in a creative role or become self-employed. I can choose what I want to eat, what I want to wear, who I want to socialise with...

Compare that to school with all of its demands and fixed ways of being. Most schools offer more or less the same thing. Think about any school you or your child has experienced. Much the same.

But jobs and adult lives can look vastly different. 9-5 office job vs self-employed art therapist. Veterinary nurse vs train driver. Freelance website creator vs electrician.

There's lots of scope in adulthood to move away from the things you hate and find a space to thrive.

All of this. You also need to remember that we’re talking about children. A lot of adults can’t actually help with these things. I’d love to share some links to show how painful a lot of these children find certain sounds and sights and how much harder their lives are. If you see a kid ‘behaving badly’ and you find it a bit awkward or eye rolling then thank your lucky stars.

BackoffSusan · 05/02/2025 16:23

Argh not other ASD bashing thread. You're lucky @messymummy5. If you've met one kid with ASD, then you've met one kid with ASD. It presents differently in all kids and don't count on your kids behaviour being down to your parenting. If it's that simple, tell me where I'm going wrong. We have a 4yo. He's been aggressive since he was 18 months, we have ups and downs but despite trying every piece of parenting advice, punishment, consequence - nothing changes. We have been seeing a psychologist for 9 months, trying different parenting techniques, guess what, nothing changes. We leave tried everything. And you know what it's bloody hard, exhausting, relentless all of the time. You're lucky you to have to experience that. Here's a typical day - get up for school. DS has extreme fussiness about food. He will not eat if he's hungry, he'd rather starve. He will only eat 1 type of bread, on a particular plate. He is extremely fussy about clothing and usually the kicking starts whilst we get dressed. He doesn't want to go to school, or leave the house most of the time. All transitions are hard. I dread the school run. Usually that involves, crying, hitting, pulling my hair. School is the only respite. When we pick him up, he is usually wiped out from holding it together all day. When we get home we deal with the food fussiness. He also hates going to the toilet, has chronic constipation, hates washing, or anything to do with his hair and takes 2 hours to fall asleep because he's so wired. Most nights he ends up pooing his pants. It's exhausting, all consuming and drains me of all my energy. So sure if you can tell me how to magically parent these things away because I'm doing a terrible job, let me know.
What your friends probably need is a less judgemental friend and someone that can understand how hard it is. You will see a fraction of what's really going on.

Newsenmum · 05/02/2025 16:23

“Coming down hard” on a kid who is seriously struggling is never going to work.

TheAntisocialButterfly · 05/02/2025 16:17

Crazycatlady79 · 05/02/2025 14:59

We are all Neurodiverse, though; we are not, however, all Neurodivergent.

Edited

Yes, this.

For those asking how ND kids go on to manage in an adult world, the adult world is vastly different from childhood and the rigidity of school due to power and autonomy.

As an adult I can WFH, work flexitime, work in a low stimulation environment, work in an area associated with my specialist interest, I could work in a creative role or become self-employed. I can choose what I want to eat, what I want to wear, who I want to socialise with...

Compare that to school with all of its demands and fixed ways of being. Most schools offer more or less the same thing. Think about any school you or your child has experienced. Much the same.

But jobs and adult lives can look vastly different. 9-5 office job vs self-employed art therapist. Veterinary nurse vs train driver. Freelance website creator vs electrician.

There's lots of scope in adulthood to move away from the things you hate and find a space to thrive.

Createausername1970 · 05/02/2025 16:11

Nursingadvice · 04/02/2025 23:28

I think you’re well meaning, but this attitude is quite harmful. If you came down hard or enforced strict boundaries and consequences on my asd/pda child they would have spent 3 hours throwing things and swearing at you.
It really is such a wide spectrum. That’s not to say your parenting hasn’t had a positive impact, but it doesn’t mean everyone with more challenging ND children are lesser parents. They just have different children with different needs.

I wouldn't let my ND son get away with things either, but I absolutely did not "come down hard" on him.

Tried it a few times, it backfired majestically, and I had twice the faff to deal with.

There are ways and means of parenting ND children and a lot of it is about forethought and thinking about what was likely to happen.

If I could avoid the triggers then I definitely would, but if I couldn't, then I said "we need to do xyz today but you won't like it because blah blah, so what should we do to get xyz done?"

I found that worked.

But if it hadn't, I would have tried a different approach.

They are all different in their quirky little lives.

TheSunnyLemonViewer · 05/02/2025 15:59

I’m always nervous of being judged a bad parents because my child isn’t developing typically, mostly by other parents, so I get it OP. And I agree that parents to NT children do and should enter the chat when we are talking about raising ND children and how they are treated in educational settings. Surely by now we all know someone who is ND, and certainly there are more people out there than they know themselves who are also ND, just not diagnosed and totally unaware. The one thing that gets me the most actually is much of the bad behaviour in schools is coming from so-called typically developing children. Much of bullying comes from NT children too as they often know how to socially navigate the complexities of targeting another child using verbal manipulation etc.

I find a lot of people on here worryingly quick to blame SEN children for ruining their perfect little darlings education when all children should have equal access to education, when in reality it’s always the disabled having to accommodate the needs of the non-disabled. It’s as simple as having a child’s needs met in a setting, but that seems to be the crux of the issue. It’s not a one size fits all situation. You can’t force a square peg into a round hole.

Newsenmum · 05/02/2025 15:56

ERthree · 05/02/2025 15:35

Children are children, NT does not trump ND and ND doesn't trump NT. Everyone has a reason to complain, ND parents because many NT parents really don't grasp how hard life with a ND child can be and NT parents because many ND parents expect the world to revolve around their child's needs and limitations.

wtf we don’t expect the world to revolve around our kids 😂 it’s just constant pain

Newsenmum · 05/02/2025 15:55

Yup. I used to hate myself so much and then I had a NT child and was like ohhh… so this is what it could be like! And also, kind of nice to confirm it’s not because of me. I’m also a SAHM. Mumsnet will make me feel so shit about that. I don’t actually have much choice.

tacoxx · 05/02/2025 15:50

chargeitup · 05/02/2025 14:49

So you think all autistic dc or all adhd or all audhd dc are the same?

You'll learn.

I don't understand this comment. It says that the spectrum is wide and the children diverse in the post!

Ponderingwindow · 05/02/2025 15:43

One of the most important things I have learned as the parent of a ND child is to not be rigid in my parenting. You must parent to the needs of your child, not according to some set of preconceived ideas.

the truth is this is the reality for all children. All children deserve parenting curated just for them, even NT children.

ERthree · 05/02/2025 15:35

Children are children, NT does not trump ND and ND doesn't trump NT. Everyone has a reason to complain, ND parents because many NT parents really don't grasp how hard life with a ND child can be and NT parents because many ND parents expect the world to revolve around their child's needs and limitations.

Crazycatlady79 · 05/02/2025 14:59

Goodnightelizabethgoodnight · 04/02/2025 23:32

Oop, hang on... another one

everyone is neurodiverse

🏆

We are all Neurodiverse, though; we are not, however, all Neurodivergent.

PrincessPeache · 05/02/2025 14:56

miniaturepixieonacid · 05/02/2025 12:58

I genuinely did not know this. I teach in a school with a hugely high proportion of ND children (non selective prep school so we get a lot who can't cope in state schools) and we refer to them as neurodiverse all the time! So, is it the case that everyone is neurodiverse but only people with ASD, ADHD, Dyslexia, PDA, ODD etc are neurodivergent? I've never used the word neurodivergent.

It’s not so much that everyone in neurodiverse, but any group of people will be neurodiverse. It’s the same as diversity in any other sense of the word ☺️ because everyone’s brains are different. Neurotypical brains are still different from each others so they are diverse, but they share a majority of common characteristics which make them ‘typical’. Neurodivergent brains aren’t on that ‘typical’ spectrum.

chargeitup · 05/02/2025 14:54

Thunderpants88 · 04/02/2025 23:47

it makes me sick. It is the arrogance. The sheer arrogance and snideness of parents of NT children. I wouldn’t be short in telling them where to go and how uneducated they are being. My nephew is ND and I want to punch a lot of “well meaning” people and their comments. They do not have a single clue.

Reading comments on here it would seem some of the harshest critics are those with ND dc who don't have the same challenges as yours who then feel authorised to assert that it's your poor parenting as their ND dc doesn't do these things.

chargeitup · 05/02/2025 14:51

somewhereinsuburbia · 04/02/2025 23:14

I have one ND and one NT child. What pisses me off more than this is parents of ND kids assuming that parenting NT kids is a breeze. My NT son kicks off just as much as my ND child. Won't eat certain things. Is rude. Won't do homework. And yes I am sure he isn't secretly ND. All kids can be challenging.

But challenging in a way that most of the world understands and tolerates is a universe away from challenging in a way that much of the world judge as rude or hostile or fucking weird.

As you with a ND child should know.

chargeitup · 05/02/2025 14:49

messymummy5 · 04/02/2025 23:05

I do think at times there is an element of parenting in it as well. I have a neurodiverse son, with autism and adhd and while i understand the spectrum is very wide and the children diverse, he is a polite and generally well behaved child (it is often commented on by teachers etc). I do believe that is in part down to my parenting as I still have fairly high standards for his behaviour, despite his diagnoses. From when he was v young I would not let him get away with things like hitting his sister or anyone else (I would come down hard on that kind of thing). I have other parents I know who have kids with the same diagnoses who seem to let them get away with everything, with no consequences and I think that doesn't help

So you think all autistic dc or all adhd or all audhd dc are the same?

You'll learn.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 05/02/2025 13:28

I’m AuDHD.

The outcomes of a lot of poor parenting can look like (LOOK LIKE, for the people at the back) ADHD or autism. And that’s terrible for everyone.

Crazycatlady79 · 05/02/2025 13:13

Honestly, I'm fucking sick of seeing Neurodivergent vs Neurotypical bashing.
I've voted YABU because I'd say the majority of people are as empathic as they can be, whilst getting on with their own stressful, difficult, fucked up lives.
AuDHD lone parent (Mum) to AuDHD twin girls, aged 7.
Parts of parenting my girls on my own - especially the first 5 years - was arrant fucking hell. I've been kicked, scratched, bitten, punched, headbutted on multiple occasions by Twin 2.
That's only a facet of my ND parenting sob story.
I don't see much perfect parenting nor perfect NT child rhetoric on here.
Not here so much, but on Facebook, I see parents of ND children making excuses for often deplorable behaviour.
I think its swung the other way, wherein a lot of parents use their children's Neurodivergence as an excuse for letting them get away with behaviour.
I've done my fair share of shitty parenting, but I've also worked my butt off with my girls and I'm bloody proud of them as individuals.

Oioisavaloy27 · 05/02/2025 13:11

messymummy5 · 04/02/2025 23:05

I do think at times there is an element of parenting in it as well. I have a neurodiverse son, with autism and adhd and while i understand the spectrum is very wide and the children diverse, he is a polite and generally well behaved child (it is often commented on by teachers etc). I do believe that is in part down to my parenting as I still have fairly high standards for his behaviour, despite his diagnoses. From when he was v young I would not let him get away with things like hitting his sister or anyone else (I would come down hard on that kind of thing). I have other parents I know who have kids with the same diagnoses who seem to let them get away with everything, with no consequences and I think that doesn't help

I agree with you on this especially when you see the way some of the people treat their children and hold them back from doing things because will cause them to meltdown when in fact it causes more problems in the long run.

miniaturepixieonacid · 05/02/2025 12:58

PrincessPeache · 05/02/2025 11:00

Completely agree with you OP.

But also want to flag the difference between neurodiverse and neurodivergent.

Neurodiversity is the natural variety of human brains, while neurodivergence is a person whose brain processes information differently. Our children are neurodivergent.

I genuinely did not know this. I teach in a school with a hugely high proportion of ND children (non selective prep school so we get a lot who can't cope in state schools) and we refer to them as neurodiverse all the time! So, is it the case that everyone is neurodiverse but only people with ASD, ADHD, Dyslexia, PDA, ODD etc are neurodivergent? I've never used the word neurodivergent.

MyUmberSeal · 05/02/2025 12:54

genesis92 · 05/02/2025 10:11

99% of MN children are ND in some way now.

It really does seem that way.