Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A man undressing in front of a woman without her consent is an act of intimidation and control. Men do not acquire consent by identifying as women

748 replies

SernieBanders · 04/02/2025 17:56

How and why has it become anything but voyeurism and control?

What on earth can be done to reverse the madness?

Trans staff should always be given dignified, adequate, separate changing spaces. Females should never feel cowed, silenced, intimidated into putting up with a man looking at them half naked.

Background.
https://www.scotsman.com/news/scottish-news/why-scots-nurse-sandie-peggie-has-taken-nhs-fife-to-tribunal-over-dr-beth-upton-transgender-dispute-4974664

(Phrase inspired by a tweet from x.com/SonyaDouglas )

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
EasternStandard · 08/02/2025 08:50

I have said repeatedly on here that I do not think anyone should have to undress in front of someone if they don't want to.

Ok so keep changing rooms for single sex

It seems to me that many women see all men as a threat, and they just aren't. If women avoid going for a walk alone, going to a pub alone, sitting next to a man on a bus etc. they are needlessly limiting their life. Unfortunately, the big scary headlines are far more eye-catching than the rather dull details of the statistics.

This is unrelated to single sex CR. It's up to women how they feel walking alone or on a bus

It's not really up to anyone else to dismiss

borntobequiet · 08/02/2025 08:49

LillyPJ · 08/02/2025 07:14

Mainly men. But those figures are misleading because it includes a vast range of things. Don't just believe the headlines; look into the details of the statistics and you'll be surprised how rare it is that women are attacked. We limit our lives needlessly and that's a shame.

Limiting what we do (for example, not walking alone at night) is a factor in reducing attack. So it could be argued that it’s a successful strategy.
Whether we should have to do this or not is another issue.

Slothtoes · 08/02/2025 08:09

Got here too late to vote but I totally agree with your opening OP.

Pussycat22 · 08/02/2025 08:05

GailBlancheViola · 04/02/2025 18:03

Absolutely. It is abuse pure and simple to force women to undress in front of men.

Women are human beings worthy of rights.

What do the people who promote, agree and condone this think it says about them? I know what I think it makes them and it is not a description they would like.

I'd strip totally naked, that'd serve em right!!!

sanluca · 08/02/2025 08:02

I disagree, based on my experiences. I don't feel safe next to strange men on a bus, or walking in the dark. Too many bad experiences.

Am I afraid of men? No. Am I wary? Yes. I do not trust men I don't know.

Do I appreciate you telling me that my instinctive reaction is on me and I should suppress it? No

Instead of telling women to change their behaviour, tell men and see where it gets you. Namalt. I would never so why should women feel like that. I am not responsible for other men. It is not that bad. You are just scaremongering.

And round and round we go

LillyPJ · 08/02/2025 07:45

sanluca · 08/02/2025 07:22

I don't see not wanting to strip in front of men as needlessly limiting my life.

I acknowledge you don't mind nudity with the opposite sex, LillyPJ, but you also have to acknowledge other women do mind and we have the right to comfort and dignity too.
It should not be a choice between stripping in the presence of men and not being able to work.

I have said repeatedly on here that I do not think anyone should have to undress in front of someone if they don't want to. It seems to me that many women see all men as a threat, and they just aren't. If women avoid going for a walk alone, going to a pub alone, sitting next to a man on a bus etc. they are needlessly limiting their life. Unfortunately, the big scary headlines are far more eye-catching than the rather dull details of the statistics.

sanluca · 08/02/2025 07:22

I don't see not wanting to strip in front of men as needlessly limiting my life.

I acknowledge you don't mind nudity with the opposite sex, LillyPJ, but you also have to acknowledge other women do mind and we have the right to comfort and dignity too.
It should not be a choice between stripping in the presence of men and not being able to work.

LillyPJ · 08/02/2025 07:14

ItsAToughie · 07/02/2025 22:47

1 in 4
women have been subjected to some form of
sexual violence since the age of 16.

798,000 women across England and Wales are raped or sexually assaulted every year.

That’s 1 in 30 women.

And these are the cases that are reported. Terrifies me to think about the true figures.

Who do you think is doing the raping and assaulting @LillyPJ ??

Mainly men. But those figures are misleading because it includes a vast range of things. Don't just believe the headlines; look into the details of the statistics and you'll be surprised how rare it is that women are attacked. We limit our lives needlessly and that's a shame.

Pussycat22 · 08/02/2025 06:57

GailBlancheViola · 04/02/2025 18:20

There are people who are absolutely determined to have non consenting women and girls remove their clothes in front of men and boys who claim they are women/girls.

Edited

I'd strip absolutely naked if I was put in this position , the trans person would never come in the changing room again!!!

eulittleb831 · 08/02/2025 06:52

CheekySnake · 05/02/2025 10:34

A man can genuinely believe he's a woman and still use a female changing room because he enjoys intimidating and controlling the female users. The two things are not mutually exclusive. Believing that he's a woman doesn't stop him using the male changing room, for example, or asking for alternative provision. It doesn't stop him from having awareness of and consideration for the needs of other people.

And the only way that a man can believe that he's genuinely a woman is if he believes that 'woman' is entirely detached from biology. In which case he knows full well that there's a fundamental difference between him and the female users of the female changing room. If 'woman' has no link to biology, then why does it need it's own changing room.

If he actually believes that he's female and there is no difference then he is delusional and needs psychiatric help because he's lost his grip on reality.

And it beggars belief that a qualified male Doctor - apparently who was (and is) married to a person called Zoe in Cupar, Angus - believes he is a female.

To reiterate what I have stated before, I would strongly question his ability to rationalise and make decisions in other areas if Brian/Frank thinks he is a woman because he says so and dresses like one. Whatever drugs or GRC or certificate of achievement he may hold, he will never be a woman.

user902101 · 08/02/2025 01:13

@LillyPJ I found the witness statement by Maya Forstatter very eloquent and succinct in summarising the relevant nudity issues. Obviously you have had a positive cultural experience of male nudity but statistically it results in a higher risk of problems: https://sex-matters.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/signed-Maya-Forstater.WS_.pdf

ClioMuse · 08/02/2025 00:18

I use a mixed sex changing area at my swimming pool as that's all that's on offer - cubicles that don't have doors that reach floor to ceiling. I would much prefer, and it's much safer, to use a women's changing area. Women need single sex spaces.

ClioMuse · 08/02/2025 00:14

DisabledDemon · 07/02/2025 23:37

I have the greatest of sympathy for anyone who feels that they're trapped in the wrong body - it must be hell.

However, if you are a man who has not undergone surgery/are taking the required drugs, you do not get to share a changing area or toilets with me.

Unfortunately transitioning doesn't lower sexual assault rates so you are not safer when a man is taking cross sex hormones and has had surgery

DisabledDemon · 08/02/2025 00:12

Totallymessed · 07/02/2025 23:52

No-one is trapped in the wrong body. They may be uncomfortable or unhappy with their body, but people politely pretending they can change sex hasn't helped anyone. Surgery or drugs can't change their sex.

I'm not saying that you can. Your DNA is your DNA and that can't be altered.

But an intact man in a women's changing area is a definite no-no for me.

Totallymessed · 07/02/2025 23:52

DisabledDemon · 07/02/2025 23:37

I have the greatest of sympathy for anyone who feels that they're trapped in the wrong body - it must be hell.

However, if you are a man who has not undergone surgery/are taking the required drugs, you do not get to share a changing area or toilets with me.

No-one is trapped in the wrong body. They may be uncomfortable or unhappy with their body, but people politely pretending they can change sex hasn't helped anyone. Surgery or drugs can't change their sex.

DisabledDemon · 07/02/2025 23:37

I have the greatest of sympathy for anyone who feels that they're trapped in the wrong body - it must be hell.

However, if you are a man who has not undergone surgery/are taking the required drugs, you do not get to share a changing area or toilets with me.

BarneyRonson · 07/02/2025 23:22

Male aggression, this time with added lippie and a frock.

YANBU

Chickensilkie · 07/02/2025 23:06

@CheekySnake thanks for that. Years ago I'm sure I saw him on oprah winfrey, saying no is a word that's very important. If someone isn't taking no for an answer why not.
I'm going to get a copy for my girls to read

Totallymessed · 07/02/2025 22:57

LillyPJ · 07/02/2025 21:34

There are societies/tribes where nudity is perfectly normal. They don't instinctually feel threatened by the opposite sex. What happened to you was horrendous but that isn't indicative of society as a whole.

I'm sure there are plenty of societies with different norms around dress, but the idea that this is because the people there exist in beautiful equality where men don't assault women is simply magical thinking.

It has no relationship to reality. No society anywhere, at any point in history, has been free of male VAWG. I find it hard to believe an adult could actually have this level of delusion tbh. It seems very unbelievably naive.

ItsAToughie · 07/02/2025 22:47

1 in 4
women have been subjected to some form of
sexual violence since the age of 16.

798,000 women across England and Wales are raped or sexually assaulted every year.

That’s 1 in 30 women.

And these are the cases that are reported. Terrifies me to think about the true figures.

Who do you think is doing the raping and assaulting @LillyPJ ??

AnSolas · 07/02/2025 22:03

LillyPJ · 07/02/2025 21:34

There are societies/tribes where nudity is perfectly normal. They don't instinctually feel threatened by the opposite sex. What happened to you was horrendous but that isn't indicative of society as a whole.

Can you give some examples?

DuesToTheDirt · 07/02/2025 21:59

LillyPJ · 07/02/2025 21:34

There are societies/tribes where nudity is perfectly normal. They don't instinctually feel threatened by the opposite sex. What happened to you was horrendous but that isn't indicative of society as a whole.

There is no society where men don't rape women. There is no society where men don't sexually assault women.

EasternStandard · 07/02/2025 21:35

SnoopysHoose · 07/02/2025 10:16

During her evidence, Ms Peggie confirmed she had called Dr Upton a man and said she believed the medic was a biological male.
She acknowledged that this would be considered harassment under NHS Fife's diversity and equality guidance

Harassment? 🙄

Exactly. How are women meant to deal with this?

Compelled speech, forced to lie, to comply and validate

McCarthy meets Orwell

LillyPJ · 07/02/2025 21:34

Totallymessed · 07/02/2025 09:52

Tbh, I actually think it's the opposite - that women are "trained" to ignore their instincts.

I also happily went around thinking I could trust all men unless they were actively abusive, and that my male friends were no more of a sexual threat than my female friends. Until I was raped by one of the men who I thought I was completely safe around. I guess that was my "advanced training"?

There are societies/tribes where nudity is perfectly normal. They don't instinctually feel threatened by the opposite sex. What happened to you was horrendous but that isn't indicative of society as a whole.

PrawnofthePatriarchy · 07/02/2025 20:33

Placemarking.