Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think cooking from scratch is not always cheaper?

314 replies

RainbowSlidders · 02/02/2025 16:55

I would like to start by saying due to allergies I do cook and bake from scratch. I see people on here saying it’s so much cheaper cooking everything from scratch but honestly I think a lot of time it isn’t although it is definitely nicer.

Last night I made spaghetti bolognaise the ingredients cost me over £18 for 6 portions (family of 5 plus 1 portion for dc to take back to uni). How is that cheaper? A jar of sauce is about 75p in Aldi so I can see why people use it and not to mention the extra cost of fuel and the time it takes, 30 minutes on the hob followed by 3.5 hours in the oven.

OP posts:
greencushionsfromikea · 02/02/2025 17:14

Ahhh, looks like you made 'posh' spag Bol. And I don't think you can count garlic bread - that's optional! Also gf also costs a fortune (coeliac dd, I know the pain)
You can def do it for cheaper. Though I'm amazed at the tiny portions some of you have -500g is definitely for 4 people in our house!

Whydoyoucarewhatido · 02/02/2025 17:14

RosesAndHellebores · 02/02/2025 17:07

Assuming there aren't six adults, yes. The op said there were 5 and I worked on the basis of 100g each which is the recommended amount.

Op said 6 portions. Agree if some of them are small children you could get away with less but for 6 adults? Or even teenagers. I’d do 1kg of mince and possibly have some left overs for freezing. Still wouldn’t be £18 though!

BeaAndBen · 02/02/2025 17:14

Of course it isn’t cheaper - who is saying it is?
Good quality ready meals are more expensive than home cooked.

But a jar of value range sauce tipped over pasta is obviously cheaper (and less nutritious and much lest tasty) than slow cooking a meat and vegetable sauce braised in a bottle of wine.

RainbowSlidders · 02/02/2025 17:13

Oh I hate slower cookers they make nothing but horrible mush, that is just my opinion though.

OP posts:
Iloveeverycat · 02/02/2025 17:13

How do you make it then I feed 6
750g mince 1 onion garlic paste tomato puree dried herbs already in cupboard 3 tins tomatoes dried pasta

ComtesseDeSpair · 02/02/2025 17:13

RainbowSlidders · 02/02/2025 17:12

I don’t use tomato purée so blend a full jar of sundried tomatoes into a paste and use that, more expensive but delicious.

But this, like a lot of the things on your list, tip it into the “luxury bolognaise” category. People watching the pennies probably aren’t buying the pricey brand tinned tomatoes, pancetta, or jarred sundried tomatoes - so they can cook from scratch but a lot cheaper.

Zanzara · 02/02/2025 17:13

If you really must cook it for so long OP, (totally unnecessary), buy a slow cooker. Asda currently have a perfectly good and smart 1.8L one for £9. Ignore their suggested serving nonsense, it's 1.8L. It uses 150w per hour, very little energy.

Batch cooking of good quality ingredients is the way to go. Never put your big oven on for just one dish.

ChangingHistory · 02/02/2025 17:12

Simonjt · 02/02/2025 17:07

1/6 of a tin of tomatoes each?
83g of mince each?

Surely your meal is for two adults, would you really make such tiny portions for six people?

Tesco spag bol ready meal is 400g and 18% is meat so 72g of meat in a portion.

Rewis · 02/02/2025 17:12

I always make my bolegnese in the oven. Slow cook for 5h. I just think it tastes nicer 🤷🏼‍♀️

RainbowSlidders · 02/02/2025 17:12

I don’t use tomato purée so blend a full jar of sundried tomatoes into a paste and use that, more expensive but delicious.

OP posts:
Aliflowers · 02/02/2025 17:11

RosesAndHellebores · 02/02/2025 17:00

What on earth did you put in your spag bol. Mine isn't frugal but no way does it come to £18.99.

500g good quality Mince £5.50
Small bottle of Shiraz £3
1 onion £40p
Tin of good quality Tom's 75p
Squirt of tomato puree 35p
Three garlic cloves 15p
Oregano
Black pepper
Salt
Bayleaves probably 20p tops
Packet of good quality pasta £1.50
Grating of parmesan £1

Mixed salad £3

That's about £15 and I could do it for a fiver less and it would still be better than a jar of sauce.

Agree and I make mine with 2lbs of mince to feed 6. We like a meaty sauce though. 2lb of round mince from butchers is €9. Pasatta and tomato puree is from Lidl I think €1:40 combined. Packet of gold pasta €2. I have all the seasonings and extras (onion and garlic) always on hand but can’t imagine they’d cost anymore than 50c. And bag of Parmesan is €1.50. I’m up to less than 15 euro and tbh a lot of time I wouldn’t need to buy Parmesan or pasta as I’d have it on hand.

Completely agree though in a lot of ways in that cooking from scratch can be expensive but to get any sort of comparable quality then yep it can be cheaper.

Rewis · 02/02/2025 17:11

Cooking from scratch is quite a subjective concept. But yeah, ready made stuff is affordable and if we don't only count the direct monetary value then often it pays off with convenience.

Hercisback1 · 02/02/2025 17:11

Nearly a fiver of that is GF stuff which is more expensive.

SleepingStandingUp · 02/02/2025 17:11

In the oven? Did you accidentally make Lasagne??

I agree it can op, because you're actively choosing meat so probably but nicer, you may need to buy new jars of stuff, and your portions are probably larger but I'd say it's possible to do it at shop brought cost if you compromise on what you put in / price per portion the spices etc

Basics meat, passata and no puree, mixed herbs only, onions, dried fusilli or similar, bit of cheddar on top.

RainbowSlidders · 02/02/2025 17:10

500g 3% mince beef £5
pancetta £1.99
2 x tinned pomodorini cherry tomatoes £1.50
parmigiana cheese shavings £1.90
jar sundried tomatoes £1.60
Red wine stock pots £2 (we don’t drink alcohol so don’t have wine in the house and they are cheaper than a bottle)
dried Italian herbs 5p
2 carrots 20p
3 sticks celery 20p
2 onions 20p
garlic 20p
gluten free spaghetti £1.25
gluten free garlic flat bread with cheese £2.50
olive oil 75p
mixture of fresh herbs £1
sea salt 5p
black pepper 5p

I have estimated the cost of oil/herbs/veg as they came out of large packs and yes the garlic bread wasn’t needed but the kids like it.

OP posts:
ChangingHistory · 02/02/2025 17:10

You aren't comparing like with like. Look at the ingredients in a ready meal and the proportion of it that is meat.

Even if it is like for like they can bulk buy the ingredients direct from the farm which will be much cheaper.

Its terrible that people with less money end up having to eat poor quality food AND keep getting told cooking from scratch is cheaper.

foghead · 02/02/2025 17:08

My recipe is
Mince
Tin of tomato
Carrot
Celery
Onion
Garlic
Herbs
Seasoning
Spaghetti
I add a couple of grated courgettes to it usually too.
That probably comes to around £10 if not slightly cheaper and costs me less than 6 ready meals.

ComtesseDeSpair · 02/02/2025 17:08

It’s not always cheaper, and I’m not one of the people who claims to frequent a top quality butcher cheaper than the supermarkets and be able to make ten hearty portions out of 500g of mince - but £18 for bolognaise does sound excessive unless you’re also counting things like buying several types of fresh herbs. Though I’ve never actually made a bolognaise, so perhaps I’m talking shit.

Ultimately, does it really matter? I’m not that invested in what other people put in their gobs. If they like to use an Aldi jar sauce, why not?

RosesAndHellebores · 02/02/2025 17:07

Whydoyoucarewhatido · 02/02/2025 17:05

500g of mince and one tin of tomatoes for 6 portions?

Assuming there aren't six adults, yes. The op said there were 5 and I worked on the basis of 100g each which is the recommended amount.

Simonjt · 02/02/2025 17:07

RosesAndHellebores · 02/02/2025 17:00

What on earth did you put in your spag bol. Mine isn't frugal but no way does it come to £18.99.

500g good quality Mince £5.50
Small bottle of Shiraz £3
1 onion £40p
Tin of good quality Tom's 75p
Squirt of tomato puree 35p
Three garlic cloves 15p
Oregano
Black pepper
Salt
Bayleaves probably 20p tops
Packet of good quality pasta £1.50
Grating of parmesan £1

Mixed salad £3

That's about £15 and I could do it for a fiver less and it would still be better than a jar of sauce.

1/6 of a tin of tomatoes each?
83g of mince each?

Surely your meal is for two adults, would you really make such tiny portions for six people?

Ginmonkeyagain · 02/02/2025 17:07

From.the cooking time I am assumimg maybe the OP used beef shin or stewing steak rather than mince? I do that sometimes for a special occasion to make a really rich, slow cooked, red wine heavy ragu to have with paparadelle. But not for a bog standard meal.

towelsandsheets · 02/02/2025 17:07

But calorie for calorie processed food is miles cheaper than homemade

towelsandsheets · 02/02/2025 17:06

500g mince, 2 tins toms, splash of wine at best for 6 here

Glamorous24 · 02/02/2025 17:06

Why are you putting spag bol in the oven…?

40 mins on the hob cooking slowly is ample.

and ingredients for 6 (I usually get 8 portions out of one pack minced beef) shouldn’t be more than £10 absolute maximum

Whydoyoucarewhatido · 02/02/2025 17:05

RosesAndHellebores · 02/02/2025 17:00

What on earth did you put in your spag bol. Mine isn't frugal but no way does it come to £18.99.

500g good quality Mince £5.50
Small bottle of Shiraz £3
1 onion £40p
Tin of good quality Tom's 75p
Squirt of tomato puree 35p
Three garlic cloves 15p
Oregano
Black pepper
Salt
Bayleaves probably 20p tops
Packet of good quality pasta £1.50
Grating of parmesan £1

Mixed salad £3

That's about £15 and I could do it for a fiver less and it would still be better than a jar of sauce.

500g of mince and one tin of tomatoes for 6 portions?