Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone else's full wage just going on living expenses?!

181 replies

maria2bela1 · 01/02/2025 08:08

My partner and I both work, have 3 young children. We crunched some numbers yesterday and my partners whole wage (which is a decent one, over 50k) goes on outgoings! I just can't believe it, we pay high rent in London (2k) then our gas/elec bill is sky high at £230 a month. Sorry having a rant but this is insanity. How are we ever supposed to save for a house? I honestly feel like the only way around this is to leave London, but our family and friends are here so not nice for the kids.

OP posts:
boxyboxs · 01/02/2025 13:05

I bought at 21, low interest rates and borrowing up to 5 times my salary, it was very easy to get a mortgage for everyone I knew around the same age

Lots of 21 yr olds are still at uni or just finished so don't have the deposit. How did you save yours and what rent did you pay? Post 08 you couldn't borrow 5 times your salary unless you were a high earner.

Besides I haven't said there aren't any FTBs in their 20s, I just statistically it's not the norm...

MissDeborah · 01/02/2025 13:04

The only surprise is that you are surprised at this.
London is expensive

I find it odd that you " crunched the numbers" and only just realised after 3 children that getting on the property ladder in London would be impossible.
Bizarre

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 01/02/2025 13:02

boxyboxs · 01/02/2025 11:44

Low interest rates were around from 2009 so those of us now in our mid thirties did have many years with the low rates and had the whole of our working lives with these rates until they rose again a couple of years ago. Property prices were lower too than they are now.

In order for this to be true people had to be buying their first property in their 20s at a time where lending criteria really tightened up and when the best rates were not necessarily available to those with high LTV.

I bought at 21, low interest rates and borrowing up to 5 times my salary, it was very easy to get a mortgage for everyone I knew around the same age

boxyboxs · 01/02/2025 12:57

Tbh i think is partly because many young people want to skip out the step of buying a flat. They all seem to go straight to buying a 3-bed house as a first property whereas I'd bet a lot of people in their 50's now who bought in their 20's did so by buying a small flat eg 1 or 2 bed, then selling it to upgrade to a house in early 30's. Some of it is choices people make now.

That makes complete sense though! Often a 2 bed flat in z2/3 is the same price as a house in z4/5 and as FTBs are older if they want dc they need space now. And why potentially pay 2 lots of stamp duty? Plus many flats in London have not increased in value post Brexit. The ladder concept doesn't really work now.

Taigabread · 01/02/2025 12:50

1apenny2apenny · 01/02/2025 09:16

The thing I always notice about these threads is people mention paying for days out. If you're struggling for money you don't have days out, it's simple.

I'm in my 50's, school holidays were spent mainly at home, meeting friends. Summer holidays were with grandparents and a week or two camping, this included some visits or 'days out'.

I do think that the mentality these days is all wrong. If you don't have the money you go without or cut your cloth. I also agree with others re 3 children, when they get to be teenagers is astronomical.

This. Op you live in London, there are so many free museums etc in London. 'days out' that incur more cost should be no more than maybe once a year as a real treat in the context you are trying to save for a house deposit? Surely a secure home for your children comes way ahead of a few days out. Every penny counts.

Newbie1011 · 01/02/2025 12:46

You're getting a rough ride on here OP. I have three children in London too, and yes of course, it's very expensive, and got substantially more so.
Of course it would have been cheaper and more sensible to stick with two but sometimes these decisions are not straightforward /are taken by the heart not the head. Not everyone has the luxury of time to save for a house deposit before their fertile years are over etc. The important thing is what do you do now?
Realistically I do think probably you'll have move out of London if you want to buy a home. It's a tough one if all your friends and family are here.
There's nothing wrong with renting while you make the decision and while your kids are happy. Yes it's expensive but just by being in London you're 'buying' access to great schools, parks, amenities, cultural capital, in our case an amazing, walkable local community which our kids hugely benefit from. Of course these things exist elsewhere but there's a reason why London works really well for so many families and it's popular to live here.
A lot of people we know in London with kids are hanging on by a thread on interest-only mortgages, which isn't THAT different to renting, especially now that property prices have stalled.
I do think it's rubbish that parents who work hard and earn £50kish a year feel so hard up IMO. Only 40 per cent of people in the UK are net contributors of tax, I don't think it's surprising that a lot of people at the bottom/ middle of that group wonder why so much is being asked of them and why they can't afford a slightly better standard of living.

Taigabread · 01/02/2025 12:41

boxyboxs · 01/02/2025 11:47

"Over 50% of UK ‘Baby Boomers’ owned property by age 30, however, this figure has plummeted as less than 30% of millennials"

The majority of millennials aren't on the housing ladder before 30...

Tbh i think is partly because many young people want to skip out the step of buying a flat. They all seem to go straight to buying a 3-bed house as a first property whereas I'd bet a lot of people in their 50's now who bought in their 20's did so by buying a small flat eg 1 or 2 bed, then selling it to upgrade to a house in early 30's. Some of it is choices people make now.

Taigabread · 01/02/2025 12:38

maria2bela1 · 01/02/2025 08:08

My partner and I both work, have 3 young children. We crunched some numbers yesterday and my partners whole wage (which is a decent one, over 50k) goes on outgoings! I just can't believe it, we pay high rent in London (2k) then our gas/elec bill is sky high at £230 a month. Sorry having a rant but this is insanity. How are we ever supposed to save for a house? I honestly feel like the only way around this is to leave London, but our family and friends are here so not nice for the kids.

'Over 50K' in london is not a high wage particularly when you have 3 children.

Pleasealexa · 01/02/2025 12:29

Having three children isn’t affordable on this kind of income in London, nor is buying a house tbh

Sadly, London (and many European cities) are no longer affordable for many people. It is just mostly for the very rich, those with inheritances and social housing. I know young people on 40k salaries in London who house share so the idea of a family house and supporting 3 children would just be a far away dream.

Inheritances are enabling many people to get on the housing ladder plus super rich people from outside the UK. I'm not sure what the answer is as with an increasing population housing will continue to increase.

If I was the poster I would seriously consider moving away from London, it's what people have had to do and their are lots of other places in the UK that can offer a lovely lifestyle.

heyhopotato · 01/02/2025 12:26

That's a lot - not including groceries my total household outgoings are half your mortgage and we have the heating on 24 C all the time in winter and the aircon on in summer and have a higher household income.

It sounds like you're torturing yourselves by living in London.

Zippidydoodah · 01/02/2025 12:16

ShortWide · 01/02/2025 11:27

@Zippidydoodah “I’m assuming you don’t work”

@YouMustBeTheWeasleys “Agree with this”

Erm, read the first six words of the OP.

My partner and I both work

Oops! Sorry op.

westisbest1982 · 01/02/2025 12:14

Shared ownership could be something worth exploring. The deposit would be relatively small and give OP and her family the security they don’t currently have.

BettyBardMacDonald · 01/02/2025 12:08

maria2bela1 · 01/02/2025 08:08

My partner and I both work, have 3 young children. We crunched some numbers yesterday and my partners whole wage (which is a decent one, over 50k) goes on outgoings! I just can't believe it, we pay high rent in London (2k) then our gas/elec bill is sky high at £230 a month. Sorry having a rant but this is insanity. How are we ever supposed to save for a house? I honestly feel like the only way around this is to leave London, but our family and friends are here so not nice for the kids.

Choosing to have three children on a moderate wage in one of the most expensive cities in the world? Not sure why you are so shocked. Did you not run the numbers beforehand?

boxyboxs · 01/02/2025 12:06

I’m in my mid thirties now and most of us in my circle are on to our next houses now, having bought small houses or flats in our twenties. No one I knew got any help, we certainly didn’t for our first house. We saved in our twenties, bought houses

The reason so many 20 somethings struggle to get on the housing ladder is because of high renting costs & deposit size. You obviously had a high salary & cheaper rent if you could save up a big enough deposit in a few years. I'm not sure how much of it is just choice...

westisbest1982 · 01/02/2025 12:05

Heatherbell1978 · 01/02/2025 09:55

What is your joint income? Not sure why you're comparing to DH alone when you're both working and expenses are joint. £2k a month rent is astronomical.

I’m also wondering what their joint income is and why OP doesn’t mention her salary. Maybe she works part-time.

boxyboxs · 01/02/2025 12:01

Well yes lots of us did. I’m in my mid thirties now and most of us in my circle are on to our next houses now, having bought small houses or flats in our twenties

But I am referring to statistics, you understand how that is a little wider than your own experiences?

Whelmed · 01/02/2025 12:01

i relate to this. it's despiriting. my wages have nearly doubled in the past 10 years but i'm struggling just as much as i did 10 years ago!

Unpaidviewer · 01/02/2025 11:55

We couldn't afford the lifestyle we would want so we don't live in London. Same with DCs, we only have 1.

Overthebow · 01/02/2025 11:50

boxyboxs · 01/02/2025 11:44

Low interest rates were around from 2009 so those of us now in our mid thirties did have many years with the low rates and had the whole of our working lives with these rates until they rose again a couple of years ago. Property prices were lower too than they are now.

In order for this to be true people had to be buying their first property in their 20s at a time where lending criteria really tightened up and when the best rates were not necessarily available to those with high LTV.

Well yes lots of us did. I’m in my mid thirties now and most of us in my circle are on to our next houses now, having bought small houses or flats in our twenties. No one I knew got any help, we certainly didn’t for our first house. We saved in our twenties, bought houses, chose to have kids after buying and are now able to go on holidays and days out with our kids as we got on the property ladder first before doing these things. Not possible for everyone but in lots of cases it is the choices people make that can make the difference.

boxyboxs · 01/02/2025 11:47

"Over 50% of UK ‘Baby Boomers’ owned property by age 30, however, this figure has plummeted as less than 30% of millennials"

The majority of millennials aren't on the housing ladder before 30...

boxyboxs · 01/02/2025 11:44

Low interest rates were around from 2009 so those of us now in our mid thirties did have many years with the low rates and had the whole of our working lives with these rates until they rose again a couple of years ago. Property prices were lower too than they are now.

In order for this to be true people had to be buying their first property in their 20s at a time where lending criteria really tightened up and when the best rates were not necessarily available to those with high LTV.

biscuitsandbooks · 01/02/2025 11:43

Honestly, some people need to get off their high horses. As if it's that easy to completely uproot an established family and relocate to the opposite end of the country.

I don't think anyone is suggesting it's easy, but if you're not a high-earning family, you often don't have a choice. DH and I had to buy in a rural coastal town because we couldn't afford anything else - we prioritised getting on the property ladder over other things. Other people make different choices because they'd rather be closer to family or amenities.

boxyboxs · 01/02/2025 11:40

Plus many millennials suffered from wage stagnation which really stepped up a notch after the 08 crash.

boxyboxs · 01/02/2025 11:39

It’ll only be the very youngest millennials who won’t have been able to buy because of their age. Millennials are from 1981 to 1996. I’m mid way and most my age have been fine buying houses as long as we made his choices.

Er no, you just need to look at average age of FTBs.... I'm an older millennial and only bought with help, 6 figure help...

bifurCAT · 01/02/2025 11:36

Never understood this.

The classic "I want kids, we'll find a way to make it work" mentality.

It's never the "we both make a good living, we save £1000 a month, ok, NOW we can afford kids and have stuff left over for holidays, etc"...

Swipe left for the next trending thread