Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum and DH being horrid about getting more cats

388 replies

FloydWasACat · 01/02/2025 06:30

OK, so background is: DH became quadroplegic just under four years ago. I work p/t as we also have 2 children and even though he has carers in I still to do a lot.

Around 8 months ago we had to put our 16 year old cat to sleep. We have another one who is gentle and loving who is 9 and I have noticed that she just seems lonely now.

I told DH that I was thinking of getting another cat from a rescue centre, he went apeshit at me. I would be paying and doing everything and frankly, there is no joy in my life nowadays and both DC would be happy too.

I may have overstepped but Cat Protection League advertised about two 14 month old girls. I put myself forward for them. I genuinely will be the one paying and doing everything. I KNOW our cat will be fine with them otherwise I wouldn't have even considered it.

When I was at work yesterday my DH told my Mum what I was thinking of doing. I got the most abusive phone call from her telling I was 'fucking stupid and an idiot' and 'I forbid you to have them' etc. I am 48 yrs old and after what has happened to DH I just think what the hell, you only get one life and it's giving a loving home to animals in need if care.

AIBU??

Sorry, that was very long. Just feel a bit lonely right now. Thanks if you got through all of that

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Anonymouseposter · 03/02/2025 11:01

OP has been advised to do something for herself, which is good advice but getting two young cats isn't something purely for herself, it's something that will impact on the whole family.
Usually when a couple are making a decision it is the person who doesn't want to change things that ends up getting their way. That applies from big things like planning another baby to smaller things.
Initially I thought the husband was very wrong to involve OP's mother and that her mother was extremely out of order.
There isn't really an excuse for the way her mother spoke to her and she can't forbid her but now I am wondering if her Mum was at her house talking to her husband while OP was at work because she was helping in some way and that having more pets would also affect her?
It sounds like the issues go much deeper than the disagreement about cats. OP says she is on her own because he is put in his room at 9pm, why doesn't she go in and talk to him, watch TV and chat? OP and her husband don't sound to have much empathy with each other's feelings.
I think everyone involved is having great difficulty adjusting to this distressing situation.
I would still like to know what going ape-shit looked like before calling it abuse. I could understand him saying that we can't bloody afford it and the last thing we need is two fucking cats.

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2025 10:46

Starling7 · 03/02/2025 00:18

Just because her husband is disabled doesn't mean he has the ONLY say. It is absolutely not horrible if someone who is a carer does something for herself, that she needs. You should be ashamed of yourself for saying that.

He’s not getting a say though is he ? OP wants the cats and seems to be pressing ahead with that despite his objections. It makes me wonder what else he’s been forced to accept against his wishes simply because he hasn’t the physical agency to assert himself. The situation sounds quite emasculating for him.

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2025 10:43

NorthSouthLondon · 03/02/2025 10:39

No.
She needs to talk to her husband about and IF he wants to talk to lawyers, do so.
It's his portion of inheritance and they are his brothers.
My brother lives in our parents' house with his family, and yes, it is a better place and life than we have. It would be great to have our share, and maybe but something small for ourselves. But I have my good reasons not to demand money, with our without lawyers.
And I would not accept any interference with that.

The OP resents that the money is not available, and she might have good reasons. So she can try and talk her husband into that.
But it's not a case of her getting two cats and a bossy lawyer in, because now that's how we roll.

It's a delicate situation for everybody in the house, putting strains on everybody. And nobody asked for it.
But reducing her husband to a burden with no agency is not the way forward (not suggesting that this is the op's plan, but it would be yours, that's what you are suggesting, and it is wrong).

OP: I can see you are, very understandably, in a bit of a dark place. And stuck. Does your husband feel stuck too, with no perspectives in life?
If there a way that could change, with your help, so in the end you all end up more proud of each other, long term?
I understand it can be a long journey and difficult, but maybe there are good examples, people who went through similar things and managed to improve things a bit, or even a lot. People you could seek advice from our at least read about, looking for solutions?
This is what helped me out in the past, when I felt everything was dark and that I didn't have in myself any miracle to make a difference.
I wish the very best to both of you and to your children.

I agree with most of your post, but I do think it’s important for her DH to get his share of the inheritance given that his care needs are ongoing. It could make a difference to the way he’s living now by buying in better care, or be put away in case he needs full time care at any point.

Weemammy21 · 03/02/2025 10:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

NorthSouthLondon · 03/02/2025 10:39

Phthia · 01/02/2025 07:25

DH says we can't afford anymore pets but when his parents both died around 6 years ago he was supposed to get 1/4 of the house. He never did anything about it so his two older brothers are living still mortgate-free and won't leave.

You need to talk to a probate solicitor about this and maybe ask them to come to visit your husband to help sort this out.

No.
She needs to talk to her husband about and IF he wants to talk to lawyers, do so.
It's his portion of inheritance and they are his brothers.
My brother lives in our parents' house with his family, and yes, it is a better place and life than we have. It would be great to have our share, and maybe but something small for ourselves. But I have my good reasons not to demand money, with our without lawyers.
And I would not accept any interference with that.

The OP resents that the money is not available, and she might have good reasons. So she can try and talk her husband into that.
But it's not a case of her getting two cats and a bossy lawyer in, because now that's how we roll.

It's a delicate situation for everybody in the house, putting strains on everybody. And nobody asked for it.
But reducing her husband to a burden with no agency is not the way forward (not suggesting that this is the op's plan, but it would be yours, that's what you are suggesting, and it is wrong).

OP: I can see you are, very understandably, in a bit of a dark place. And stuck. Does your husband feel stuck too, with no perspectives in life?
If there a way that could change, with your help, so in the end you all end up more proud of each other, long term?
I understand it can be a long journey and difficult, but maybe there are good examples, people who went through similar things and managed to improve things a bit, or even a lot. People you could seek advice from our at least read about, looking for solutions?
This is what helped me out in the past, when I felt everything was dark and that I didn't have in myself any miracle to make a difference.
I wish the very best to both of you and to your children.

Weemammy21 · 03/02/2025 10:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

PersephoneSmith · 03/02/2025 09:30

Yeah, definitely get the cats, he can leave you if he’s not happy about it. Sounds like your life would be much more pleasant without him.

beAsensible1 · 03/02/2025 06:46

I don’t understand how the only way to “do something for yourself and be happy “ is to acquire a living thing.

he is the one who is the house 24:7 with the animals , no one else. But his opinion doesn’t matter?

DiduAye · 03/02/2025 01:24

As a carer myself I completely understand how shit it is Tell your Mother to butt out ! I am not "part of the LTB brigade " but perhaps all of you would be happier Your husband has no right to treat you badly or take his anger out on you Being quadriplegic isn't an excuse to be abusive

VastOtter · 03/02/2025 00:48

Cats are not hard work at all, and three is the magic number. I think the OP deserves to be becatted of an evening after the kind of days she’s no doubt having, and enjoy the safety in numbers, and the joy they will definitely bring her and her children. If husband was ok with 2 before, it shouldn’t be a huge issue. I couldn’t bare it if I was forbidden my cat quota, life can be so shit, so 3 cats are non negotiable, as they mitigate shitness every single day.

Starling7 · 03/02/2025 00:18

Agix · 01/02/2025 06:33

Just because your husband is quadroplegic doesn't mean he doesn't get a say what goes on in his home or whether you get more pets or not! He said he didn't want to, and you went and did it anyway. That's horrible of you, really. YABU.

Just because her husband is disabled doesn't mean he has the ONLY say. It is absolutely not horrible if someone who is a carer does something for herself, that she needs. You should be ashamed of yourself for saying that.

Andymeda · 02/02/2025 23:54

I’ve been where you are now and get where you are coming from. It’s an endless and tough treadmill. Your feelings are not unreasonable but imo this is not about whether or not to get more cats. Log onto carers uk forum and look at the posts from others in your situation and you’ll see there are many dealing with what you are also tackling. You may find it useful to post there as well and you will find an empathetic and supportive response from people who truly get how tough and complex the caring situation is. Whether you post or not the forum is good for practical tips about day to day coping and it helps you feel less lonely.
take care and take heart, you are far from being alone in this space 💕💕💕

Tryingtokeepgoing · 02/02/2025 22:12

Teddybear23 · 02/02/2025 19:07

I absolutely love animals and life would be very empty without them. I don’t blame you one bit for wanting to give 2 cats a loving home. It is very kind of you and like you say, YOU are the one who will be looking after them. I really can’t understand your husband’s reason for saying no? And your mum needs to keep her nose out - it’s your life not hers.

You really can’t understand why a quadriplegic might not want two young cats jumping and clambering over him, when he’s got no ability to remove them or encourage them away…?

The cats aren’t the real issue here though I don’t think; the OP and her husband need proper support and counselling, individually and together, to work through the situation they find themselves in which is of neither of their choosing.

Incidentally, google reckons a cat is £1,500 to keep - so two additional ones is another £3k…which as a commitment of family money probably needs some form of agreement?

https://www.moneyhelper.org.uk/en/blog/everyday-money/what-is-the-average-cost-of-owning-a-cat

Joystir59 · 02/02/2025 21:25

Three dogs is immensely different to one dog. Don't be ridiculous.

diddl · 02/02/2025 20:35

SixtySomething · 02/02/2025 19:53

Some strange questions here!
Cats mostly don't need to be constantly looked after. Three cats will look after each other in many ways.
I think OP stands a good chance of judging whether her cat is lonely from its behaviour.

What's strange?

I feed my cat when he asks, throw away what he doesn't eat & wash his bowl & let him in & out when he wants.

Also when he was younger cleaned his litter tray as soon as he used it.

There's probably workarounds for that but he certainly didn't/doesn't require no input!

I2amonlyhereforTheBeer · 02/02/2025 20:34

I can't agree with going ahead and getting 2 new cats without your partner consenting to it. He's already lost a massive amount of control - he "gets put into his room at 9pm every night". It seems like his opinion doesn't matter, and neither does he.

I've had many cats and I don't see how you can be sure the new cats will get on with your current one. They often don't. Cats are expensive. We spent thousands on our lovely rescue cat due to various mishaps. We got some of it back on insurance, not all. The insurance rates were high too.

I understand you must be having a pretty awful time. But are new cats the answer? I would want to focus on the current one.

Sakura7 · 02/02/2025 20:32

FloydWasACat · 01/02/2025 06:47

Thank you all for replying from both sides. I probably am being unreasonable bit I just feel that I have to do something for myself for once and cat just follows me around everywhere since Eva went and I genuinely know she will be fine.

My Mum has always been like this to me when she disagrees with any decision I make that doesn't involve her.

DH has told me we can't afford any more pets, I work and it would all be coming out of my wages. They wouldn't be in the way of him in any way at all. He is just very angry now, which obviously I get, but it's not exactly the greatest life for me either.

I look after everyone and do everything, so why am I so out of order when it would also make my 9 and 15 Yr old happy too? They are going through this as well.

You're not out of order at all OP.

You don't deserve to be berated like that when you're doing so much for others.

I honestly can't see why it's such a big deal if you're going to look after them and pay for them (and you had already been a multiple cat household before your eldest one passed).

Danielle9891 · 02/02/2025 20:28

To be fair 2 extra cats are quite a lot of work. Yes, you're paying but it will be whoever is in the house more than will deal with them most. I've got one lazy cat who is so laid back (I would have 10 of him) and then I've got my other cat who is a very vocal spoilt cat that demands I feed him every hour and won't eat food that has been sitting in his bowl for more than 15 minutes. I'm on maternity at the moment and his demands are getting worse. He will literally knock everything off the shelves, fireplace and benches if I don't give in. 😂 Done cats are very hard work and are expensive once you consider insurance, food and that.

JJM24 · 02/02/2025 20:25

Get the cats! Feck the two of them.

carchi · 02/02/2025 20:23

I do hope that you get to read this message because I just want to say that you really need to stick up for yourself or you could become incredibly unhappy possibly depressed if this situation continues. Please stand up to your husband and mother and get the cats. You are not a child you are a grown woman who has every right to make her own decisions. You also deserve a life and your mother and husband are really ridiculously selfish but I am not sure that you realise how much they are manipulating you. They need you more than you need them so be aware of that and be strong for yourself

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 02/02/2025 20:06

Joystir59 · 01/02/2025 07:18

What will three cats give you that your one cat doesn't? Imagine the conversation was about going from having one dog to having three? What is it about people needing lots of cats?

One dog or three dogs isn't really any different.

Teenagehorrorbag · 02/02/2025 20:00

Sorry OP - sounds very hard for you all!

I wouldn't go against my husband for big decisions, but if you have always had cats and he does like them, it seems a no-brainer. And as you say - you do the work, you pay for everything, and children are keen. I'm sure your DH will come round.

My DH has never been a cat person and always complains (mildly) when they cost (me) money, or scratch things etc. But he's happy enough when they curl up on his lap!

I've always had two at a time for the same reason as you are thinking. We lost one in the summer and after that my boy was very clingy and off his food (no-one to compete with) so the DCs and I found another female at a local cat charity. Mentioned it to DH and he was definitely not keen. Did we take any notice? Not a bit. Majority vote won.....😀!

We got her just before Christmas and my ginger boy is much happier! And she sleeps every evening on DH's lap!

Go for it! And as you say - especially with what you are all going through, little things for yourself can help make things bearable. Tell DH you aren't going against him as such but it's going with the majority vote.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 02/02/2025 19:59

Let your mum have your DH and you get the cats.

Joking aside, life is too short so if the cats will give you a bit of joy (in a life which seems to be dedicated to a difficult DH and situation) then get them.

Tough titties to your DH really, and your mum.

llizzie · 02/02/2025 19:59

SixtySomething · 02/02/2025 19:48

Sorry, I find that rather an unusual question. Lots and lots of people have cats and it doesn't make them love their family less. 🤷‍♀️

I am sorry if you think that. It was not intended. People do indeed love animals. I did. They need devotion as well as food and inoculations and vet bills.

The OP has a cat which she is devoted to who could live another 9 years. One of mine was 18. She says she thinks this cat is lonely since the older one died. How does she know? Does the cat never go out?

She says she is lonely after her DH has been put to bed at 9. She doesn't mention interests they share. Just mentions she has children.

Something about her post just made me wonder why she needs two more cats.

That is what made me think she is not happy with the love she gets from her family and is looking elsewhere for comfort. I know that cats are a comfort. They know it too. One cat, two children and a disabled DH and she still needs something more?

SixtySomething · 02/02/2025 19:53

diddl · 02/02/2025 19:42

She's already said the cat is lonely.

She might not be right though.

If Op works out of the house-who is looking after the 3 cats?

Some strange questions here!
Cats mostly don't need to be constantly looked after. Three cats will look after each other in many ways.
I think OP stands a good chance of judging whether her cat is lonely from its behaviour.

Swipe left for the next trending thread