Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can we stop talking about men being trapped?

194 replies

ForRealCat · 30/01/2025 14:32

Just from another few threads; we talk about women getting pregnant either intentionally, or accidently and carrying on against the mans wishes and how it "traps" the man. I can see how decades ago this may have been the case, women would get pregnant and any 'decent' man would be expected to step up and marry her. Thus securing a husband and a degree of financial security.

Nowadays I can see why a woman may get pregnant intentionally against her partners wishes, (maybe she wants more kids, feels like se is missing her chance etc), but can we stop talking about "trapping" a man. Very few men nowadays will wed a girl just because she is pregnant, and the financial support he is obliged to provide is to support the child and not the mother.

Very few women find themselves financially better off getting pregnant and claiming child maintenance. So AIBU to think the 'trapped' narrative has had its day.

OP posts:
ForRealCat · 30/01/2025 16:14

MorrisZapp · 30/01/2025 16:04

He didn't want a baby and his long term partner was 'on the pill'. He wasn't involved in the decision to become a father, she made the decision for them both.

I think also the pill fails for any number or reasons, sickness for example. Unless a woman has expressly come out and said to her partner "I wanted a baby, you said no so I stopped taking it" it is worth giving the benefit of the doubt in most cases and believing that the pill failed.

Has she really said to your brother "I was on the pill but stopped taking it" and he reiterated that to the whole family? I bet that makes for an interesting Christmas dinner dynamic. Or is this just a conclusion you came to?

OP posts:
DrinkFeckArseBrick · 30/01/2025 16:14

A lot of men won't marry their pregnant partners. And I agree that it takes two to make a baby.

But a lot of men will stay in a relationship they're not happy in, so that they can see their kids as much as possible. The same with lots of women who are in effect 'trapped' in relationships they'd otherwise leave, because of children, or finances related to having children. Some families can't afford to split and maintain two households. 'Trapped' doesn't always asign blame

AlmostAJillSandwich · 30/01/2025 16:12

A persons desire to have a child, will never trump another persons desire to not have a child.
That you can "see why" some women intentionally get pregnant against their partners wishes is shocking and disgusting. Wanting another child or not wanting to miss her chance to be a mother, does not make it in any way acceptable to get pregnant by deception. She ALWAYS has the option of leaving the man who does not want a(nother) child, and finding a partner who does, or going the sperm donor option alone.
Wanting more children but wanting them to have the same father when he doesn't want more kids, or loving the man she is with and wanting the baby to be his hoping he'll stay after she "accidentally" gets pregnant when he desires to be childfree, or not wanting a donor father because then there's nobody to go after for financial support, are all 100% trapping the man.

Can't you see the emotional effect having an unwanted baby has on any person, regardless of their Gender? Quite rightly women should have the legal right to terminate an unwanted pregnancy, but men don't get the right to choose to end a pregnancy that they don't want, as it isn't happening inside their body. "He can just walk away" is bullshit, he will be forever mentally affected by the fact he has created a life, and theres the massive social stigma of abandoning your child if you don't want to be a parent. It's also a financial commitment he never wanted to have, that hes in for 18 years and affects every aspect of his life. It's not about the money supporting the child not the mother, it's about how that commitment then has a knock on effect and reduces what money he has to sustain the lifestyle he wants, which for some people who choose to be child free, is travel, which quickly becomes unaffordable when theres a child to provide for. Nobody should be allowed to effectively force someone into that position, hence "trapping" being a perfectly fitting term.

Imo in the case of accidental pregnancy, if a woman wants to proceed but the man does not, and the woman decides to continue knowing this, then it should be on the terms that the man is absolved of the legal commitment financially, as the woman is continuing the pregnancy knowing the man doesn't wish to have the child, and has the option to terminate if those conditions do not suit.

If she's intentionally gotten pregnant by lying about being on contraception, how is that any different to a man "stealthing" by taking a condom off mid sex? Stealthing is legally considered rape, because the consent was only given for protected sex. So, a woman lying about being on contraception to obtain unprotected sex by deception makes it sexual assault (since rape specifically requires the perpatrator to use a penis) making the women that do it abhorrent sex offenders.

How can you possibly "see why" someone intentionally commits sexual assault and think it's in any way understandable?!

ForRealCat · 30/01/2025 16:10

MorrisZapp · 30/01/2025 16:04

He didn't want a baby and his long term partner was 'on the pill'. He wasn't involved in the decision to become a father, she made the decision for them both.

Thread is about the narrative of women trapping men in relationships that they don't want to be in by getting pregnant. He was in a long term relationship and has the choice to leave at any point, but chooses to stay therefore he isn't trapped.

OP posts:
MorrisZapp · 30/01/2025 16:04

ForRealCat · 30/01/2025 15:55

If he's not trapped, what's the relevance?

He didn't want a baby and his long term partner was 'on the pill'. He wasn't involved in the decision to become a father, she made the decision for them both.

Dweetfidilove · 30/01/2025 16:03

SouthLondonMum22 · 30/01/2025 15:36

and lying isn't stupid?

Have you been lied to?
Do you know men who've been lied to?
You may want to start public service broadcasts for all the unwitting men...
Abstain or get the snip, because women are out here lying and trapping. You can never be too trusting, because you'll get trapped 🤦🏾‍♀️.

CurlewKate · 30/01/2025 16:01

It's almost as though people have forgotten condoms exist.....

Willyoujustbequiet · 30/01/2025 15:59

There's no such thing as trapping a man into becoming a father. Men are responsible for their own actions. If they don't want to risk a pregnancy they should abstain or have a vasectomy.

I'm utterly sick of women being held accountable for men.

2JFDIYOLO · 30/01/2025 15:57

1 Don't want a baby? - Don't have sex.

2 Want sex with no chance of fathering a baby? - Get a vasectomy.

3 Don't like condoms? - The pill can fail - or be 'forgotten.' See 1 and 2.

And so on.

The presence of a baby is no guarantee he'll stick around. If he wants to naff off he will. And it's not guaranteed he'll pay child support. And if you're not married you have no rights.

ForRealCat · 30/01/2025 15:55

MorrisZapp · 30/01/2025 15:53

He did want long term commitment. He did not want to have a baby at that time, he was still a student. He's a wonderful father, a far better parent than his ex was able to be. He's never said he was trapped, I know it because his ex told me, my mum and my sister.

If he's not trapped, what's the relevance?

OP posts:
ForRealCat · 30/01/2025 15:54

KimberleyClark · 30/01/2025 15:52

It should be on either partner to respect their partner’s wishes if they say they don’t want a baby.

Abortion is hugely traumatic. No woman should be forced to have an abortion on a mans say-so. That's fucking barbaric

OP posts:
MorrisZapp · 30/01/2025 15:53

FiveTreeHill · 30/01/2025 15:45

He's not trapped though is he?

Firstly he was willingly in a longterm relationship, he could have left her if he didn't want to be with her. If she hadn't trapped him would he have kept stringing her along?
Secondly he had condomless sex.

Thirdly he could split. Babies have never stopped men leaving

To imply he's trapped essentially means he was in a long term relationship with a woman, having sex with her but didn't want longterm commitment, so kept stringing her along

He did want long term commitment. He did not want to have a baby at that time, he was still a student. He's a wonderful father, a far better parent than his ex was able to be. He's never said he was trapped, I know it because his ex told me, my mum and my sister.

KimberleyClark · 30/01/2025 15:52

Shushquite · 30/01/2025 14:55

That is an excuse some men use when they want to rewrite history lately. Also not all protection claim 100% efficiency. So yes, some women can get pregnant while their parent doesn't want a pregnancy. Only method that prevents pregnancy is celibacy.

Yes, there are some women who will lie about taking birth control. Men need to wise up and use protection until they themselves are ready.
Not to mention why should a woman who wants a pregnancy bear the responsibility of taking precautions to prevent it. It should be on the person who don't want the pregnancy to take the steps to prevent it.Whether, it is the man or woman who doesn't want it.

It should be on either partner to respect their partner’s wishes if they say they don’t want a baby.

Dotjones · 30/01/2025 15:49

I think the men who let themselves be "trapped" are not necessarily the ones who need "trapping". The arseholes who don't give a shit, won't give a shit.

MissFancyDay · 30/01/2025 15:46

It's virtually impossible to trap a man with pregnancy, just use a condom if children are not wanted under any circumstances.

Everyone knows that the pill can not be effective when ill or if forgotten.

When, oh when, will men take responsibility and stop blaming women for everything.

GoBackToTheStart · 30/01/2025 15:45

The poster said you should not have sex unless you want a baby

Well people shouldn't be having sex unless they accept pregnancy is a possible outcome...because it is.

Unfortunately for men, their ability to control the situation starts and ends with sex, because pregnancy isn't something that happens to them. All they can control is the time before pregnancy occurs. For women, there is an available medical procedure which recognises the fact that pregnancy is a physical thing that happens to her body with extreme physical consequences.

Get rid of abortion and you have a lot of dead and injured women, dead babies, traumatised children being left in the care system, children left with mothers in poverty, and more in between. Whereas the "consequence" for men is that they...may have to pay a paltry child maintenance sum?

Sure, let's encourage men to have sex with zero consequence and just leave it all on the mother. Sounds sensible.

Lying about contraception is immoral, but men have the agency to decide to "double up" and use a condom, or to not have sex. Maybe they should campaign harder for decent male contraceptive options and broaden their choices.

As an aside, how often is it genuinely "she promised she was on the pill and lied to me and didn't take it/took off the condom" as opposed to "i thought she was on the pill but didn't actually ask because I thought she'd tell me/I didn't really care in the moment because it felt better without a condom..."trapped" indeed.

FiveTreeHill · 30/01/2025 15:45

MorrisZapp · 30/01/2025 14:49

Of course some women trap men with pregnancy. My sil did it. If a woman in a long term relationship says she's on the pill do you think men should watch them swallowing it each day or would that be a trust red flag?

He's not trapped though is he?

Firstly he was willingly in a longterm relationship, he could have left her if he didn't want to be with her. If she hadn't trapped him would he have kept stringing her along?
Secondly he had condomless sex.

Thirdly he could split. Babies have never stopped men leaving

To imply he's trapped essentially means he was in a long term relationship with a woman, having sex with her but didn't want longterm commitment, so kept stringing her along

StupidBitchy · 30/01/2025 15:42

I think it's wrong to trick your man into getting you pregnant. But maybe we should all be 100% careful about who we're getting in bed with, men and women.

OutsideLookingOut · 30/01/2025 15:39

DownThePubWithStevieNicks · 30/01/2025 14:46

Come on to make the point @Hodcafesuk has: evidence from the bulk of threads here is that it’s women who are trapped by having children. Trapped in bad relationships, trapped in financial precarity, trapped in domestic drudgery.

This. No one should be trapping anyone but keeping it real with rape too and the fact that men can more easily walk away it is misogyny and internalised misogyny that the focus on mostly on men being trapped.

Diomi · 30/01/2025 15:37

Judging by the very low birth rate in the UK, most people seem be able to prevent having babies if they don’t want them. I doubt that many men are tricked into fatherhood. I think most ‘trapped’ men have just been willing to be careless and take risks.

FOJN · 30/01/2025 15:37

Women are fertile and capable of becoming pregnant for about 24 hours (give or take) in every 28 days. Men can get a woman pregnant every time they have sex.

Unless we want a conversation about men having a say in whether a woman has an abortion or continues a pregnancy we have to insist that mens choices about becoming a parent happen before sex. Those choices are be responsible for contraception but acknowledge it can fail or don't have sex.

No man is "trapped" into becoming a parent.

SouthLondonMum22 · 30/01/2025 15:36

JandamiHash · 30/01/2025 15:27

It’s stupid to not sort your own contraception out anyway if you really don’t want a kid and see it as being “trapped”

and lying isn't stupid?

Dweetfidilove · 30/01/2025 15:31

Are you expecting men to abstain or acknowledge that every sexual encounter has the possibility of pregnancy, and accept they can't compel women to have abortions?
When they can unashamedly run off and leave them holding the baby?

YABU! Most unreasonable 🙃!

JandamiHash · 30/01/2025 15:28

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Women bear the burden of pregnancy so it’s not like they have it easy

JandamiHash · 30/01/2025 15:27

SouthLondonMum22 · 30/01/2025 14:53

Relationships are based on trust. Is it stupid to believe your partner in a long term relationship when she says that she's on the pill?

Like I said, disgusting.

It’s stupid to not sort your own contraception out anyway if you really don’t want a kid and see it as being “trapped”