Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unsolicited parenting advice

53 replies

TicklishSheep · 29/01/2025 12:44

I’m a FTM to a lovely almost five month old baby boy.

I’m really struggling with the amount of unsolicited advice I’m receiving from both my parents and my in-laws. Every time I see them I get comments about everything under the sun, but mainly about DS’s sleeping and naps. Things like “you just need to put him down”, “crying is good for his lungs”, “you’re spoiling him” (by contact napping, as this is currently the only way he will sleep during the day…trust me, I’ve tried), “why don’t you just put him in his room and see what happens”, and “he should be in his own room” etc etc.

I think it comes from a good place (maybe they think it’s helpful?), but it is starting to really stress me out and make me dread seeing either set of parents to be honest. His sleep is not something I’m worried about so I don’t know why they feel the need to comment at all, let alone repeatedly. DS usually sleeps through the night and has a couple of naps on me or DH or in his buggy during the day. We don’t mind. He’s only four months old and if that’s what he needs to nap at the moment, it doesn’t bother us at all. He’s only little once. Sleep training is not something I’m comfortable with, let alone just leaving him alone to cry.

My usual approach is to say something non committal like hmm maybe. Then just ignore them and hope they get the hint and stop. But the problem is they don’t seem to be getting the hint. I’ve even tried to gently explain why we’re doing what we’re doing (we want to create a secure attachment, SIDS guidelines etc) but the response was oh well see how well that works when he’s 4. But he’s not 4, he’s 4 months old…

There’s been a lot of other “advice” too that honestly I think is dangerous, like we should put whiskey on his gums to help teething, give him an ice block to chew on and so on. Then there’s the comments that are just irritating, like “he doesn’t look tired to me” when we’re trying to get him to nap (he definitely was tired).

Am I being unreasonable (are they just trying to help)? How can I get them to stop or at least cut down on the amount of comments/advice… do I need to be more blunt? I just don’t want to hear it anymore :(

OP posts:
givemushypeasachance · 29/01/2025 13:00

"We're good, thanks."

"No, I don't think so."

"That's not the recommended guidelines these days."

"Look if you want to be helpful here is some washing up to do/laundry to fold..."

If you've got a close relationship with them then just tell them - hey I know you probably just want to be helpful by offering these sorts of comments but I find them stressful. We're doing things this way because XYZ, the guidelines say this, I want to do it that way. If I'm struggling then I will ask for help. I'm confident in what I'm doing but this commentary is stressing me out, please stop. How you can help is XYZ.

anniegun · 29/01/2025 12:56

Just politely explain that you appreciate where they are coming from but the unsolicited advice is stressing you out unnecessarily . A bit of straightforward communication is probably all that is needed before you jump to the go no contact /leave your husband recommendations that will appear on this thread

WannabeMathematician · 29/01/2025 12:52

I have found that you just have to say “no I’m not doing that” sometimes. The non committal thing just leads to my dad to “hint” more as he feels like you’ve not actually assessed his advice.

I did have to practice saying it to myself in the mirror before the first time.

My SiL had twins and took her mum with her to see the doctor when they were sick to hold one of them and casually asked about weaning. Her mum said the twins should be on baby rice by 4mo and the doctor happily shot that down.