Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex pissed off im changing childcare arrangements. AIBU?

332 replies

Childcare101sans · 29/01/2025 08:27

Background (I have friends on here who will guess who I am with this info - please don’t out me!)

-I left my ex husband after I had an emotional affair with a woman
-I am now live with and in a LT relationship with her
-Ex inherited a house 6-7 years ago which we sold and we bought the family home which he lives in and up for sale
-he see’s the kids 2 hours after work twice a week and every other weekend
-when we broke up, because he earns little, I asked for 50% of the house, will count that as him providing for his kids and he doesn’t need to pay maintenance

Ive just found out I have a new job, I have moved up in my career rapidly and will be getting a higher paid banding.

It means I’m less flexible and have to be in the office 9-5 M-F

We currently and have never had childcare on Fridays, so I collect our primary age son from school every Friday and either keep him if it’s my weekend with the kids or drop him to his dads later if it’s his weekend.

Ive asked my ex if he will collect him from school on his Fridays and I will have to somehow figure out my Fridays since I will be starting this new job.

He’s gone mad.
He hasn’t said yes or no.
He’s just said “so I lose out on work and money while you go to work for more money?” (He’s self employed)

I feel like I’m providing for the three kids on a day to day basis and 4 hours less a month for him isn’t that much of a hit.

I live rurally and I’ve been searching for 2 weeks for alternative options.
No after school clubs.
No friends available for that time.
No other childminders or teens of friends that could help. My older kids work/don’t drive unable to help.
Im still trying to find alternatives but failing.

Am I being unreasonable changing the goal posts to benefit the fact that I have a new and better paid job?

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 29/01/2025 12:33

Childcare101sans · 29/01/2025 11:44

Punishing my ex?!

You do realise that if this goes to court I will be awarded likely more than 50% of the equity AND child maintenance?

Do you think courts do that to punish one of the parties?

No, the courts do this to make sure the children are provided for. Nothing more, nothing by less.

The fact that you have a home where you currently live with your partner and dc could mean that you wouldn’t automatically be awarded 50% of the equity, especially as you have a higher income than him,

biscuitsandbooks · 29/01/2025 12:28

@GabriellaMontez I wasn't talking about what would be considered in a legal settlement - I was referring to all of OP's comments about how awful her ex's behaviour was - yet she chose to marry him, have three of his children over a fairly decent timespan and stay 25 years.

It just reads as though she's trying to excuse her affair by saying she was in a miserable marriage anyway - like men do every single day on here and women call them out on it.

Over40Overdating · 29/01/2025 12:27

Your mistake here @Childcare101sans was giving context to your split. Now your lazy co parent, who you’ve been subsidising and doing favours for is going to be a poor hapless victim to you the big bad harlot.

I’m going to guess that part of the motivation for your emotional affair was rooted in being married to a man who prioritises an unreliable, badly paid job over being financially stable and saw childcare and all associated costs as not his business.

Not taking maintainence and doing all the leg work to facilitate his contact time was another booboo. He’s the one who wants everything on his terms and you’ve been giving it to him. Hopefully this is the beginning of the real world starting to come in for him.

Perhaps when he starts moaning about how much money he’ll loose for 2 afternoons a month, you could share the childcare bills you’ve accrued whilst he’s been off living a majority child free life, doing as he pleases.

If he wants to act from bitterness, let him. And use the your rights under the terms of your divorce to get everything you are entitled to.

GabriellaMontez · 29/01/2025 12:23

biscuitsandbooks · 29/01/2025 12:15

OP hasn’t said a single word about abuse.

Her posts just read as though she’s trying to justify her affair by going back and talking about the awful things he did before they even married - like I said above, it’s no different to all the men on the “relationships” board who try and say they’ve never been happy in their marriage and that’s why they were forced to go off with Rachel from accounts.

it stinks of re-writing history, that’s all, and that’s something that would go down like a pile of cold sick if it came from a man:

She's openly admitted her affair.

But however morally repugnant you may find it, it's irrelevant.

Moral failings wont be considered in the divorce settlement.

biscuitsandbooks · 29/01/2025 12:22

You shouldn’t have bought a house with his inheritance if you knew you wanted out of the relationship

Exactly.

timetobegin · 29/01/2025 12:21

It’s unclear what assets you brought to the marriage but £400k equity on his part isn’t nothing. What happened to your pension? Everything you had and everything he had should have been split surely?

Why you are splitting is fairly unimportant. What you spent while married is spent.

Namerequired · 29/01/2025 12:19

How much of the inheritance is the equity in the home? You said it was only 6/7 years ago and you are in a long term relationship. You shouldn’t have bought a house with his inheritance if you knew you wanted out of the relationship. Inheritance is usually exempt from assets too is it not?
If they equity came from both of yous working long term that’s different.
However on your actual question yes he should sort childcare for his Fridays and all days he has the children

VotingForYourself · 29/01/2025 12:19

This has NOTHING to do with it. Keep it factual. Facts to do with the kids the money the assets

-I left my ex husband after I had an emotional affair with a woman
-I am now live with and in a LT relationship with her

BringMeTea · 29/01/2025 12:19

These kind of threads are brilliant for bringing the menz crawlies out... 😂 You are definitely NOT being unreasonable OP. Congratulations on your promotion. 💐

VotingForYourself · 29/01/2025 12:17

Childcare101sans · 29/01/2025 08:57

That was the discussion.

That wasn't a discussion

WoolySnail · 29/01/2025 12:16

Rosscameasdoody · 29/01/2025 11:26

Because this is MN and posters will pick an OP apart and concentrate on something totally irrelevant to the advice you’re looking for. In this case it’s because you happened to mention that your ex inherited a house and posters have skimmed past the fact that it was sold to buy your joint marital home, and that you contributed to that, because the narrative is that you cheated on your ex and then made off with half his inheritance !!

People also seem to mentioning op diddling him by having 50% of the house instead of maintenance because he's on a low wage. But op could divorce him, get 50% of it in the settlement anyway and make him pay maintenance, even if it was a paltry amount 🤷‍♀️

biscuitsandbooks · 29/01/2025 12:15

Rosscameasdoody · 29/01/2025 11:48

Leaving isn’t easy. Takes on average over five years to pluck up the courage to actually do it - longer if the partner is abusive. Let’s not pretend it’s the easiest thing in the world to up and leave with three kids, on your own.

OP hasn’t said a single word about abuse.

Her posts just read as though she’s trying to justify her affair by going back and talking about the awful things he did before they even married - like I said above, it’s no different to all the men on the “relationships” board who try and say they’ve never been happy in their marriage and that’s why they were forced to go off with Rachel from accounts.

it stinks of re-writing history, that’s all, and that’s something that would go down like a pile of cold sick if it came from a man:

FishMouse · 29/01/2025 12:12

I don't think you're BU asking him to cover 4 school pickups a month. That's minimal, yes inconvenient but that's kids for you.
Even if you were still together you would still have a childcare problem on Fridays, if both of you were working.
Can your child walk to his dad's house from school with a friend and their parent/carer, if it's too far to walk to yours? Or could your partner pick your child up on those days? Has your ex any family who could help?
What you did during the marriage has nothing to do with it, your ex still needs to do his share of caring for your joint child. He is lucky you're doing the lion's share, even on his days, as well as providing for them forevermore.

ByQuaintAzureWasp · 29/01/2025 12:10

He's being unreasonable. Have you thought of asking to finish early on Friday and work the hours lost by staying late other days?

If you've looked at above and it's not possible, he needs to either pay maintenance or step up and lose a couple of hours work - you should never have started dropping them off, he should have collected them.

Soontobe60 · 29/01/2025 12:10

Childcare101sans · 29/01/2025 11:08

Anyone?

The details around your divorce are irrelevant.
Have you completed a financial order yet?
Also, it’s interesting that you say you’ve “found out you gave a new job”. In reality, you searched, applied and interviewed for a new job then told your ex once you got it.

biscuitsandbooks · 29/01/2025 12:09

@Rosscameasdoody yes, I know - she still had the affair though. Totally unnecessary.

Soontobe60 · 29/01/2025 12:09

Childcare101sans · 29/01/2025 09:46

We are selling our house for £470k and we will split the amount 50-50

After paying off everything we will get about £200k each

In the area I am in for the kids schools, I can get a 2 bed flat, with a mortgage

He can move further afield and get a 3 or 4 bedroom place, as the children are with me the majority of the time. He could make that work with ease but I could not unless I change the children’s schools and move out of area, and even then I wouldn’t get much more for my money.

How much was his inheritance that paid for the house?

vivainsomnia · 29/01/2025 12:07

You've offered him an exceptionally good deal and he's still making life difficult for you
Not so sure. We don't even know about their pensions!

RogerF · 29/01/2025 12:06

The thing is - getting more maintenance funding wouldn't solve the problem would it? There just isn't any available childcare options (and yes that really does happen esp in rural areas). That's why I think "paying" him not a bad idea- maybe not pay as in a pay slip etc etc, but just something to sweeten the deal- much as many of us subsidie our partners /give them gifts/buy the car etc etc - to make our working life easier and life good for the children

Foreverhope1 · 29/01/2025 12:05

"On you basic point it’s not unreasonable to try and change arrangements for the children to better suit your needs but you do have to be careful how you manage the question and the expectation because you’re not a team anymore and what’s good for you might not be good off him and the other way around."

This 👆🏼

The how you got to this point only serves to derail the post. Your later drip feed of having your LTP help with childcare should have been in your original post.

ChateauMargaux · 29/01/2025 12:04

You were married - you are going through a divorce, the family assets (the house - but also possibly pensions) should be divided on a needs basis, with the starting assumption being 50/50. Again, the starting assumption regarding the time spent with parents should be 50/50. Where the agreement is not 50/50, there should be a payment made from the party with less contact to the party with more contact.

Who did what to end the marriage is largely irrelevant in the eyes of the law.

vivainsomnia · 29/01/2025 12:03

At least one of your free children will not be considered as a child when divorcing. Maybe the second either.

In all likelihood he would only be paying maintenance for 2 children not 3 and maybe only one or soon one.

If you separated only a couple of years after his inheritance which fully paid for the family home, it's not at all a given that you'd be entitled to 50%.

You make it sound like you need extra money to house his children, but you are talking about one child for sure maybe two for a few more years.

UndermyShoeJoe · 29/01/2025 12:02

I think when it comes to childcare you’d be stupid to rely on an ex despite being the parent to just change their work because you changed your work.

The choices you make in your home shouldn’t force changes in the other.

littlemousebigcheese · 29/01/2025 12:00

He should be paying maintenance regardless of how little he earns, it's not right that he does bare minimum in terms of contact and also pays fuck all. Claim because it's important he realises he has a moral and legal obligation to HIS children and even a token amount is crucial in ensuring he remembers that.
I also agree that it's not childcare, it's parenting and it's not fair that it's all on you to manage everyone and everything. Can your partner help at all on Friday? Absolutely no after school club?

Rosscameasdoody · 29/01/2025 11:58

ColourBlueColourPurple · 29/01/2025 11:45

What's fairly clear? That she didn't have an affair? She did, and that's my point. If a marriage is on the rocks for whatever reason, then you try and fix it or you leave. You don't cheat. Unless you're a sneaky person with poor morals.

Edited

I meant it’s fairly clear that the accusation of lack of morals isn’t warranted. Lots of moral outrage and pearl clutching here, with very little to go on as to what’s happened in the past. OP says she was on the point of leaving anyway. Without knowing the details we’re not in a position to judge her reasoning. And it wasn’t the point of her post.