Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is he not in school

205 replies

Jackanorystory1 · 28/01/2025 23:15

Cousin has an autistic (non verbal) son. He went to childcare 1 day a week whilst she worked and has now stopped. They mainly stay home each day.
Dad is not in the scene at all. They live in a high rise so have no garden. DS will be 5 in March and he has not yet started school so has no friends and no one to play with. She doesn't take him to any groups so he is with her all day every day.
6 months ago she had another baby. DD from the same man as DS1.
DS1 has not yet started school and when I asked her why she claimed that he didn't have a place. Now I'm under the impression that all children receive a school place.
This must be harming the child by keeping him at home all day and not mixing.
Is it not against the law to keep your child at home.
I really do not know what to do. I would like to ask her what is going on but she tends to fly off the handle so quickly. Aibu to think that this is harming her child.

OP posts:
FranticFractions · 29/01/2025 09:55

x2boys · 29/01/2025 09:49

Based on my own experience of having a non verbal teen, and I mean completely non verbal not verbal in some situations and not other ,s most of the non verbal children I know including my own present as extremely disabled and csn only communicate in a very basic manner, and that's despite in having years of speech therapy and going to special school, s catered to their needs.

Speech therapy won't work if a person can't speak. It's a fine motor skill processing difficulty. There's probably a very normal level of intelligence within your child, with fully formed thoughts and ideas.

Try looking into communication techniques based around spelling, letter boards, typing, which use gross motor skills as opposed to fine.

FranticFractions · 29/01/2025 09:52

YoungGunsHavingSomeFunCrazyLadiesKeepEmOnTheRun · 29/01/2025 09:42

Can't be that exhausting if she decided to have another baby! What a silly decision.

She may have got pregnant accidently, many people do, and been unwilling to have an abortion. Or the dad may have promised to stick around and be in a relationship and changed his mind, leaving her with 2 kids and without his support.

I'm autistic and don't get these parents who keep popping them out and then moaning about it as if it wasn't their choice to add stress to their lives.

Theres no saying this woman is moaning, it's currently her cousin moaning.

Anyway, her poor child. There's no correlation between intelligence and being non-verbal so he's probably got plenty of awareness and many thoughts of his own, but I doubt his mother is giving him the opportunity to learn to communicate by spelling/typing. He'll probably end up stuck in misery with people who think he's stupid because he can't talk.

You doubt that a loving, caring mother, by ops own description, isn't giving this 5yo child opportunities to learn? You have absolutely no basis for that thought, and op doesn't even know what goes on outside of the 4 hours or so month she is there. Op, with all her judgement, doesnt sound like the type of person anyone could approach for advice or with any difficulties, so I imagine theres a lot she doesnt know.

So that poster is correct, you've pretty much made things up to suit whatever your own agenda is.

I don't think "many people" get pregnant accidentally if they're taking precautions. If you don't take precautions and have sex, you know that pregnancy is possible. Yes there's a small chance she didn't actively choose to have another child.

My agenda is the autistic child's agenda. Life with autism is painful, and if the child can't communicate that in a way that is understood, life must be so much more painful.

FiveWhatByFiveWhat · 29/01/2025 09:50

To people saying this child isn't on anyone's radar - how did he get his diagnosis then? Even going private (which it doesn't sound like the mum could afford) would mean assessments and reams of paperwork. If NHS it takes referrals from gp/HV/paediatric and numerous calls and assessment processes. So he must be on the radar somewhere. Or is @Jackanorystory1 saying he isn't formally diagnosed?

Like a previous poster said, if the mum has a new baby she'd have been at hospital/midwife appointments? HV would be in contact. Who took her older child while she was giving birth to the youngest?

@Jackanorystory1 in one post you can't offer support and know nothing about Sen children but in another you see them every 2 weeks - how then do you know absolutely nothing about his needs/situation? Where is the dad in all of it? He has nothing to do with it all apparently but came back after a few years to knock the mum up a 2nd time, then disappeared again??

She likely is totally overwhelmed and needs support. Like, actual support, not random, inaccurate comments of "well surely any school is better than none" and the like.

x2boys · 29/01/2025 09:49

FranticFractions · 29/01/2025 09:09

Can't be that exhausting if she decided to have another baby! What a silly decision.

I'm autistic and don't get these parents who keep popping them out and then moaning about it as if it wasn't their choice to add stress to their lives.

Anyway, her poor child. There's no correlation between intelligence and being non-verbal so he's probably got plenty of awareness and many thoughts of his own, but I doubt his mother is giving him the opportunity to learn to communicate by spelling/typing. He'll probably end up stuck in misery with people who think he's stupid because he can't talk.

Based on my own experience of having a non verbal teen, and I mean completely non verbal not verbal in some situations and not other ,s most of the non verbal children I know including my own present as extremely disabled and csn only communicate in a very basic manner, and that's despite in having years of speech therapy and going to special school, s catered to their needs.

YoungGunsHavingSomeFunCrazyLadiesKeepEmOnTheRun · 29/01/2025 09:42

FranticFractions · 29/01/2025 09:31

Enlighten me - what was incorrect?

Can't be that exhausting if she decided to have another baby! What a silly decision.

She may have got pregnant accidently, many people do, and been unwilling to have an abortion. Or the dad may have promised to stick around and be in a relationship and changed his mind, leaving her with 2 kids and without his support.

I'm autistic and don't get these parents who keep popping them out and then moaning about it as if it wasn't their choice to add stress to their lives.

Theres no saying this woman is moaning, it's currently her cousin moaning.

Anyway, her poor child. There's no correlation between intelligence and being non-verbal so he's probably got plenty of awareness and many thoughts of his own, but I doubt his mother is giving him the opportunity to learn to communicate by spelling/typing. He'll probably end up stuck in misery with people who think he's stupid because he can't talk.

You doubt that a loving, caring mother, by ops own description, isn't giving this 5yo child opportunities to learn? You have absolutely no basis for that thought, and op doesn't even know what goes on outside of the 4 hours or so month she is there. Op, with all her judgement, doesnt sound like the type of person anyone could approach for advice or with any difficulties, so I imagine theres a lot she doesnt know.

So that poster is correct, you've pretty much made things up to suit whatever your own agenda is.

FranticFractions · 29/01/2025 09:31

normanprice62 · 29/01/2025 09:26

You are so clueless

Enlighten me - what was incorrect?

normanprice62 · 29/01/2025 09:26

FranticFractions · 29/01/2025 09:09

Can't be that exhausting if she decided to have another baby! What a silly decision.

I'm autistic and don't get these parents who keep popping them out and then moaning about it as if it wasn't their choice to add stress to their lives.

Anyway, her poor child. There's no correlation between intelligence and being non-verbal so he's probably got plenty of awareness and many thoughts of his own, but I doubt his mother is giving him the opportunity to learn to communicate by spelling/typing. He'll probably end up stuck in misery with people who think he's stupid because he can't talk.

You are so clueless

comedycentral · 29/01/2025 09:22

FranticFractions · 29/01/2025 09:09

Can't be that exhausting if she decided to have another baby! What a silly decision.

I'm autistic and don't get these parents who keep popping them out and then moaning about it as if it wasn't their choice to add stress to their lives.

Anyway, her poor child. There's no correlation between intelligence and being non-verbal so he's probably got plenty of awareness and many thoughts of his own, but I doubt his mother is giving him the opportunity to learn to communicate by spelling/typing. He'll probably end up stuck in misery with people who think he's stupid because he can't talk.

There's no need for that, what an awful thing to say.

FranticFractions · 29/01/2025 09:09

Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 29/01/2025 00:50

Being a special needs mom is exhausting.

You have stated you know nothing about it.

Stay out of it and just listen to her.

Can't be that exhausting if she decided to have another baby! What a silly decision.

I'm autistic and don't get these parents who keep popping them out and then moaning about it as if it wasn't their choice to add stress to their lives.

Anyway, her poor child. There's no correlation between intelligence and being non-verbal so he's probably got plenty of awareness and many thoughts of his own, but I doubt his mother is giving him the opportunity to learn to communicate by spelling/typing. He'll probably end up stuck in misery with people who think he's stupid because he can't talk.

x2boys · 29/01/2025 08:55

JimHalpertsWife · 29/01/2025 08:37

Genetic link
Mum does go to supermarkets or out, ever
Mum doesn't engage with family who raise issues
Mum is a germaphobe

No - the above isn't a direct indicator of autism, but there is autism in the family, the Mum clearly has her own issues based entirely on what OP has written. I'd hedge my bet that Mum is undiagnosed autistic too.

Genetic links doesn't always mean its inherited from a parent
My son has a rare chromosome disorder a micro deletion thought to be the underlying cause of his complex disabilities including autism, it wasent inherited from either me or his dad but is quite literally a genetic issue
Nobody has any idea wether this mother is autistic or not paticularly based on very little information.

Calelladreaming · 29/01/2025 08:39

Skipthisbit · 29/01/2025 00:06

Ffs … child dies from neglect or abuse and MN is full of how did it happen, what about family, why did no one do anything.
Poster asks advice about if it’s normal not to have a school place and the reaction is non of your business, stay out of it etc

Children with SEND are exponentially more likely to suffer abuse or neglect either deliberately or because parent(s) can’t cope.

But yeh just stay out of it, say nothing and don’t question anything 🙄

100% this ^

JimHalpertsWife · 29/01/2025 08:37

x2boys · 29/01/2025 08:19

Based on what exactly????

Genetic link
Mum does go to supermarkets or out, ever
Mum doesn't engage with family who raise issues
Mum is a germaphobe

No - the above isn't a direct indicator of autism, but there is autism in the family, the Mum clearly has her own issues based entirely on what OP has written. I'd hedge my bet that Mum is undiagnosed autistic too.

HollyBerryz · 29/01/2025 08:37

It can be very hard getting a specialist place and I can imagine it's very easy for some children to be left with nothing if they don't have parents who frankly know the law and how to advocate and challenge. I do and even my own autistic children have had periods of time with no proper education due to local authority failures.

Have a chat with her, find out why, point her to some support or help her. If she has her own difficulties she may be entitled to a free advocate who can help.

Look at Ipsea and sossen for info

mashingwachine · 29/01/2025 08:37

He is 4 years old, he must have had agencies involved in diagnosing him? I know there is no actual support after the fact, but how has this woman navigated a diagnosis by age 4 for a child who has never been in a nursery setting? It's bloody hard to evidence things for a diagnosis with no third party information so must have engaged with the agencies etc at some point.

housethatbuiltme · 29/01/2025 08:35

I mean who WANTS to go to the supermarket with 2 small children?

Its not a wonderful life experience, its usually a bloody nightmare best avoided. I stay home with the kids while DH does the shopping, most people with the option too do this or get delivery its hardly 'odd'.

A SEN 5 year old at the cinema?

Most 5 years olds are only just getting that level of concentration and still struggle never mind one that got learning difficulties.

These aren't even standard 'must do' things with non autistic children so why you expect them of a single mam of 2 young kids with SEN is bizarre.

normanprice62 · 29/01/2025 08:27

Unless you watch them 24/7 you have absolutely no idea if they go out or not. He doesn't attend child care anymore as he is school age. He most likely doesn't have a school place as there's a huge shortage of send places. The local authority give parents the run around, ignore deadlines and couldn't care a less if children are out of school. Even if she hadn't applied for a place the ehe team would be in contact. I'm sure people believe if you don't send your child to school no one checks on them.

Personally my son has been out of school for two periods. 7 months and 18 months due to lack of placements. The amount of fighting it takes you couldn't even imagine.

His needs are very different and you are comparing him to the average child. The cinema and shopping would by my autistics child's idea of pure hell. We probably spend a lot more time at home than most. He's happy, healthy and fed.

Karmaisagod · 29/01/2025 08:25

Your cousin should have applied for a school place for her child to start school last September. If she hasn't been offered a place, it's because she didn't apply and/or the local authority are not aware of her child. Once the child reaches statutory school age (5), your cousin will be required to ensure he's in receipt of suitable education. This could be home schooling, but a setting is by far the best place to have him assessed. If he's profoundly autistic, a nursery would have been able to already start the relevant steps to have him assessed.

I am readind a lot of nonsense on this thread, and it is alarming. Please support your cousin by encouraging her to apply for a school place immediately while also contacting her local SENDIASS team and requesting support. If she won't do either of these things, I would suggest you look into reporting to the LA yourself. The child must be visible, and mum must be supported.

Saker · 29/01/2025 08:23

Some strange answers here, I know you are just concerned for your cousin's son and if in 5 years it was found that he had been kept cooped up in the flat and not gone to school and social services were unaware etc, you would be criticised for not having questioned it. Of course children with special needs have to go to school or be officially home-schooled just the same as other children. She can't just keep him at home indefinitely unless she is home-schooling and that would need to be properly organised, not just keeping him at home. However obviously this might all be underway and at this point I would hope that the local authority are involved and she has support from social services etc and that she will be supported with finding him a school place or deciding the most appropriate setting. He may need an EHCP which is hard to get these days but if he is severely affected it should be less difficult. So I think all you can do is ask really and offer any help you can.

Ineedsleepnotsugar · 29/01/2025 08:21

Perhaps you can help by having the children one day on the weekend.

x2boys · 29/01/2025 08:19

JimHalpertsWife · 29/01/2025 07:35

Mum is likely autistic too.

Based on what exactly????

MolluscMonday · 29/01/2025 08:16

Jackanorystory1 · 29/01/2025 00:15

@Seaside31 I couldn't contact them as they may remove them from her. They are healthy and fed and loved with no danger present. She does not drink smoke do drugs or have anyone around them like that. Those were not my concerns.

Hi OP, if you’re telling us the whole truth and he really isn’t ever leaving the flat or interacting with the world or people at all, then this would be a concern in itself- not to take them off her but to support her.

Has she got a Health Visitor, as there’s a newborn?

x2boys · 29/01/2025 08:11

NewFriendlyLadybird · 29/01/2025 07:13

The right school, with the right support, possibly. But as PP have pointed out, these are as rare as hen’s teeth. The wrong school, with no support, would be extremely damaging for him.

They are not as rare as hens teeth but are very variable depending on area
In my LA we have four special, s schools, two primary and two secondary ,one primary and one secondary cater for children with moderate to severe learning disabilities and the other two cater for children with severe to profound learning disabilities
We also have several autism Hubs
I realise we are luckier than a lotcof LA,s
But it is very area dependent.

Bex268 · 29/01/2025 08:09

Jackanorystory1 · 28/01/2025 23:42

I do not know anything about sen children, so this is all new to me. So what will happen if a school cannot be found. Does he just stay at home forever?

Yes, you clearly don’t and yet you’re still offering judgement. We kept our son behind a year to get his EHCP finalised and hopefully a specialist school named for him to start a year later. Her son would likely only get a place in mainstream without an EHCP and I as a parent of an autistic child who has no words will absolutely not send him. Do you know how terrifying it is sending a nonspeaking autistic child to a mainstream school where there is unlikely to be one to one support throughout the day? Have you any idea? It keeps you up at night, every night, terrified.

sounds to me like she cares for her son’s wellbeing deeply and needs some extra support to ensure he has the right provision for September - this will be very difficult to do without a nursery or preschool’s support.

staying inside admittedly day after day with no outdoor space must be very hard - my child wouldn’t cope - he is out all day every day, but a lot of autistic child can’t cope with that and prefer to stay at home - everyone is so different. It might be that the world is scary to him. How do you know he never goes out?

thepariscrimefiles · 29/01/2025 08:08

Jackanorystory1 · 28/01/2025 23:28

I work FT have children and live 45 mins away so I can give no help.

Im worried for the child's welfare being stuck at home all day everyday with no one else other than his mother & a baby.

Surely school would be beneficial for him.

So, do you know that there is a school place available that meets his needs but she is just refusing to send him?

Other posters with experience of children with this level of SEN have made it clear that school places for children with severe learning disabilities are like hen's teeth.

I think you are being judgemental without having all the facts.

meh2025 · 29/01/2025 08:04

meh2025 · 29/01/2025 06:40

For any person with complex needs, making any change can feel enormous. It helps to chunk it down into small battles, but she probably needs assistance just prioritising what needs to be changed before she can actually move foward.

You seem to think that just dragging the child off to school, assuming one will take him, will fix things.

It won't.

It may in fact create a whole raft of other problems. If she is germaphobic (I presume you mean she experiences OCD) she might find it unbearable to have to deal with the situation of picking up and dropping off from school. There could be escalating complications from any intervention which she does not agree to.

The mother has needs that must be addressed before the children's situation can be changed.

As the children are not in danger, this is not a break down the door and change things scenario, this is a one brick at a time scenario and will take time. I very much doubt you are suitably trained to counsel her and help her improve their lives.

If you are genuinely concerned, contact your local social services, make it clear you want to remain anonymous and outline that your cousin needs resources and support, ask them to make an assessment and ask for advice from them, not mumsnet.

And what do you mean by flies off the handle? Do you just mean she reacts negatively when you are nosy and judgemental? Or do you mean something serious?

Swipe left for the next trending thread