Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so angry sorting out my parents stuff

706 replies

DazedorBemused · 28/01/2025 10:27

I've just cleared another carload of stuff from my parents attic. They were born either side of WW2, and talked. Talked so much about rationing, poverty, striking, unions, etc.
My brother was occasionally ill as a child. To compensate he had fancy Lego, computers when they first came out, hand held video games.
The contrast between his pricy toys and my enjoy your family board game type stuff is obvious.
Then my parents got into collecting stuff - porcelain, dinner services, up scaled their Christmas decorations again and again.

I'm sorting through all this stuff and finding receipts for expensive trivial stuff in the early 90s when I was at uni, working two term time jobs and full-time in the holidays and I'm a 50 year old woman upset at having to go to the tip again.

OP posts:
irregularegular · 28/01/2025 20:11

AnonymousBleep · 28/01/2025 13:42

Those figures are stuck in my head for some reason - can't remember my own pin number but can remember that! Probably because I spent so much of those years worrying about money!

I specifically remember that my parents gave me £800 per term. I think that was what you got as a grant if your parents wer low income. I didn't get a grant and didn't take the loan as it was pretty much too small to bother with in 1990-93. and I didn't really need it. I actually did manage on £2400 a year with some vacation work, no term time work. But I lived very very frugally! And to be honest probably benefitted from an older employed boyfriend!

irregularegular · 28/01/2025 20:03

Angularline · 28/01/2025 11:10

I'm sorting through all this stuff and finding receipts for expensive trivial stuff in the early 90s when I was at uni, working two term time jobs and full-time in the holidays and I'm a 50 year old woman upset at having to go to the tip again

I am your age and at Uni at the same time and I did not need to work two term time jobs. Grants were being phased out, so you got at least some money and student loans were cheap. No tuition fees. I never had a job in the term time but I did get jobs in the summer holidays. I lived in a small room in a not very nice flat to live cheaply. I live largely within my means and Ieft uni with about 3k of debt. I got nothing at all from my parents, who could not have afforded to give me anything anyway.

I was at Uni then too. The maintenance grant was reduce in line with your parents earnings. I got no maintence grant. If your parents earning reasonable money but chose not to give you anythng, you would certainly need to work. In fact it was potentially worse then than now as there was no (or minimal - like £200) student loan.

Thepossibility · 28/01/2025 20:01

My mum has just had this with my Nan. They always pleaded poverty. Make a big show of not being able to afford nice groceries. Recently mum found out they have many thousands saved in numerous bank accounts. House paid off. Shockingly much better off than any of their five children who have been helping them!

NotthinglikeaBondGirl · 28/01/2025 19:58

TheLovleyChebbyMcGee · 28/01/2025 19:35

I feel for you, I really do. My parents are both still alive, but not in good health so its making me think forward. My brother is the golden child, but doesn't want to help them with day to day stuff, which I sort of get. But his kids are older and he likes an hour closer.

The relationship between our parents is breaking down and I don't know how to help it, they are both being stubborn. But I can see him 'helping' to clear the house by removing things he sees as valuable then leaving me to do the heavy lifting on wading through all the junk.

I must be heartbreaking seeing all the things your parents spent so much money on reduced to peanuts in the charity shop

My brother too put his head in the sand. All he was interested in was 'his books' (my parents always said that he would get the books, me my father's collection off Staffordshire figures - most of which were damaged beyond being of any value because he had dementia and would drop them).

My brother rarely visited my parents (despite being only about 50 miles away motorway all the way) and, because I lived within walking distance of their house I did all the caring - taking them too/from medical appointments, arranging medications, calling in to make sure they were OK, doing their shopping etc etc. So he said that as long as I didn't touch his books all the rest was up to me and refused to have anything to do with clearing the house as it would upset him 😡I packed the books into boxes & told him when they were ready to collect. He took some and then told me that he had taken what he wanted & I could get rid of the rest. Thanks mate - more for me to do(!) Oxfam bookshop were very grateful. 😉

Fingeronthebutton · 28/01/2025 19:56

Maggyfs
a generational thing
Not in my house it isn’t. I’m 78 with 3 daughters. I hate stuff and toot
I don’t hoard anything and I’ve never owned one of those awful glass cabinets 😱
My daughter and my granddaughter love most of my clothes, of which there aren’t enough to fill a 3rd bedroom like some people Ahhhhh!!!
They might fight over my Jack Vettriano paintings, though.

HeadNorth · 28/01/2025 19:51

Stuff is so meaningless, it is heartbreaking to choose expensive tat over supporting a child through tough times.

One of my children trained as a nurse during covid and practically her first job on her first placement was to put a deceased ladies stuff in the incinerator as there were no relatives to claim it. It was an expensive handbag and purse, scarf, gloves etc. My DD said the woman had been lonely and difficult and very proud and possessive of her stuff in hospital. My DD cried for her as she fed it in - ‘precious’ stuff is actually worse less than the sum of fuck all compared to friends & family.

TheLovleyChebbyMcGee · 28/01/2025 19:35

I feel for you, I really do. My parents are both still alive, but not in good health so its making me think forward. My brother is the golden child, but doesn't want to help them with day to day stuff, which I sort of get. But his kids are older and he likes an hour closer.

The relationship between our parents is breaking down and I don't know how to help it, they are both being stubborn. But I can see him 'helping' to clear the house by removing things he sees as valuable then leaving me to do the heavy lifting on wading through all the junk.

I must be heartbreaking seeing all the things your parents spent so much money on reduced to peanuts in the charity shop

Juliagreeneyes · 28/01/2025 19:34

istheheatingonyet · 28/01/2025 19:20

@ElizaMulvil what an interesting post.

Except it’s muddled, and confuses a lot of prewar and postwar life. Education, health and the welfare state changed several times between the silent generation and the late boomers, and lots of that post has jumbled up everything from the 30s to the 70s. In reality, if you were born just before the war your experience was much more like the boomers than the silent generation. And only urban children were evacuated, and not all of those - those that were evacuated were largely born in the twenties and early thirties.

OP is talking about her parents’ behaviour to her when she went to university in the EARLY NINETIES. At that point the war was FORTY SEVEN years earlier, and her parents had accumulated money, a house and tons of stuff. At what point do we say that someone’s behaviour nearly fifty years after WWII is no longer excused by the war? Come off it everyone with the Blitz spirit like so many of Monty Python’s Four Yorkshiremen. The war stopped them giving her cash in 1992? After 47 years of them then experiencing the longest economic boom conditions in modern history?

ilovesushi · 28/01/2025 19:34

I would be raging too in your shoes.

But I wonder if the experience of WW2 and rationing had an impact on their spending and collecting habits. I only say that because my MIL was born before WW2 and lived through terrible poverty in her childhood and youth. She used to bulk buy things like tins of fancy biscuits and fruit cakes, and store them in an upstairs wardrobe. No one ever got to eat them because they'd be years out of date. She wasn't a hoarder in general, just this one aspect and we put it down to her going hungry in her early years.

Possibly a similar manifestation from your parents, because logically it just doesn't make sense.

xxx

IsawwhatIsaw · 28/01/2025 19:32

NotthinglikeaBondGirl · 28/01/2025 19:15

Me too!

My DPs died within 12 months of each other. They had a 4 bedroom house that was full of papers (they were both academics & I had about 60 years-worth of papers, theses, research papers etc to get rid of) clothes, books, photographs and general STUFF. It took months to sort through and get dispose of. I only discovered Wills 6 months after they died as they were in a pile of general papers and, if I hadn't been so careful about sorting through, I'd have thrown them away.

I am gradually sorting through my stuff getting rid of things that will be of no interest to my DS. I have categorised, dated, labelled the photos and filed them into a smallish box getting rid of duplicates and pictures of people who he wouldn't know of, sorted through clothes that I no longer have a use for & sent them to charity shops and am now selling the majority of my Art Deco ceramic collection on EBay. I have all my important documents in a file clearly labelled.

I don't want to leave the kind of mess for my DS that my DPs left for me.

My ILs were academics as well… huge house and so many books and clutter the house walls were affected, bulging outwards. It was hoarding.
It made me think about not wanting to inflict such a task on our DCs.
I’ve made a start but need to do more.

Sillysaussicon · 28/01/2025 19:31

I get it. I'm sorry you've got all this to process and deal with.

NotthinglikeaBondGirl · 28/01/2025 19:28

Juliagreeneyes · 28/01/2025 19:14

It was used more by boomers than any other generation - to do quals part-time, for women, for retraining, just for interest and for the sake of education (I know; how quaint!) - but also it was the easiest and most affordable way to do a lot of vocational training diplomas in, for example, social work, policing, accounting, all sorts of stuff, often not necessarily degree level but higher vocational, and these courses were often paid for by employers rather than the student.

For boomer-age women in particular it was fantastic as a route for re-entering the workplace when older.

And it was very affordable until the full tuition fees rise: since then it charges the full £9+k cost like any other university.

My DM (born 1940) was very proud of being one of the first OU students - her student number was 00030. Her father didn't believe higher education for daughters was worth the money as they would only get married, have children & give up work. She did her A'levels, and paid her own way through teacher training (then not a degree profession). She also helped to finance her sisters through university because their father refused to do so. So, as soon as she could, she enrolled into the OU, did several degrees through them and ended up being awarded her PhD at the age of 72. 😇

pikkumyy77 · 28/01/2025 19:28

I want to thank everyone for these fascinating posts. My 92 year old parents have a lot that needs dealing with and this has caused me to reflect on the importance of downsizing at some point myself (64) so my dds don’t have to deal with it. My father has a large collection of actual antiqities which he hasn’t been able to sell off and which I can’t afford the taxes on. This has rather focused my mind on the uselessness of everything.

I think i went into house owning and decorating rather naively—my dd’s generation will have smaller spaces and less security. My “stuff” —no matter how beautiful—will have nowhere to go and no easy resale value.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 28/01/2025 19:26

Juliagreeneyes · 28/01/2025 19:14

It was used more by boomers than any other generation - to do quals part-time, for women, for retraining, just for interest and for the sake of education (I know; how quaint!) - but also it was the easiest and most affordable way to do a lot of vocational training diplomas in, for example, social work, policing, accounting, all sorts of stuff, often not necessarily degree level but higher vocational, and these courses were often paid for by employers rather than the student.

For boomer-age women in particular it was fantastic as a route for re-entering the workplace when older.

And it was very affordable until the full tuition fees rise: since then it charges the full £9+k cost like any other university.

Thank you, another very interesting fact I've learned today!

Notgoodatpoetrybutgreatatlit · 28/01/2025 19:26

@DazedorBemused
I am totally in awe of you! I have just sorted my parents estate and sold their house. Same generation as your parents. I couldn't do the house clearance it was too emotionally draining.
I paid someone a lot of money to do it for me.

I did have to go through about 10 years of bank statements for inheritance tax reasons. I started to get annoyed that my parents had so much money and never offered me anything like a deposit for a flat. They didn't work hard for their house they were given it. My mum had more money in her current account when she died than I have ever had in savings. And Holy Moley her income from pension was a decent amount.

It's a tricky thing doing what you have you are much stronger than I was.

Dibbydoos · 28/01/2025 19:25

Talk to a local house clearance company, not all that stuff should go to tge tip. Even if you get a few £00 for it, it'll be better than endless trips to tge tip.

Also, you're not the only one whose parents favoured one kid over you. Your child is hurt, but to move on you as an adult need to move past it. Remember, lingering anger is only hurting you - you are the only person that feels and suffers your anger, occasionally those you're angry with might sense it, but they def don't feel it or suffer it.

Sending a hug from a middle child who like you got shafted for an older brother and younger sister all their life! But I'm fine with it, it's not on me it's on them....

MrsBuntyS · 28/01/2025 19:21

Sorry for your loss OP. Go and get some therapy, it really works. My parents are a similar age as yours and still alive, they were both brought up in very privileged homes and have spent everything. Lots of holidays, never had mortgages so didn’t have ‘big jobs’ just enjoyable ones. Didn’t save for their own futures and just spent their inheritances. I’ve not had any money, no house deposit, paid for both my very small weddings myself. I’m not bitter though. I am very independent and self sufficient, of course they now want me to do the care heavy lifting which I will do. I’ve worked through all my resentment of my older sibling being the golden child and everything that goes with it. I have also just found out that the sibling is in line for another massive inheritance which I am excluded from as that’s ’our culture’. I feel hurt but I can’t do anything about any of the past and I just focus on my future with my little family. You can move past this.

istheheatingonyet · 28/01/2025 19:20

@ElizaMulvil what an interesting post.

istheheatingonyet · 28/01/2025 19:18

Take Care dear OP. Julia Samuels talks some sense about grief.

As an aside , boomer her. Skint boomer with an adult child reappeared in the house. Beware silly generalizations.

NotthinglikeaBondGirl · 28/01/2025 19:15

IsawwhatIsaw · 28/01/2025 10:42

We had 2 homes to sort through. One was a huge job, we still needed multiple skips after 8 months clearing.
my DM had a small house but it was crammed with disorganised clutter,
we’ve done the tip and charity shops, it’s tiring. Made me not want to inflict this task on our DSs so I’ve got rid of a load of stuff recently.

Me too!

My DPs died within 12 months of each other. They had a 4 bedroom house that was full of papers (they were both academics & I had about 60 years-worth of papers, theses, research papers etc to get rid of) clothes, books, photographs and general STUFF. It took months to sort through and get dispose of. I only discovered Wills 6 months after they died as they were in a pile of general papers and, if I hadn't been so careful about sorting through, I'd have thrown them away.

I am gradually sorting through my stuff getting rid of things that will be of no interest to my DS. I have categorised, dated, labelled the photos and filed them into a smallish box getting rid of duplicates and pictures of people who he wouldn't know of, sorted through clothes that I no longer have a use for & sent them to charity shops and am now selling the majority of my Art Deco ceramic collection on EBay. I have all my important documents in a file clearly labelled.

I don't want to leave the kind of mess for my DS that my DPs left for me.

Twizzletoe · 28/01/2025 19:15

WearyAuldWumman · 28/01/2025 15:17

Yes… My cousins are urging me to have a clear out to save bother for their kids. They’ve also told me to appoint a solicitor as my executor. That being the case, I’ve said that they should just get a house clearance firm in… though I am getting my paperwork in order and I’m decluttering for my own benefit.

They’ve heavily hinted that I should also organise a direct cremation. I’m considering planning the full works, even if I’m the only bugger there! (I’m a widow with no children and no siblings.)

Good grief talk about cold. I would do the solicitor for executor. Leave it all to good causes and none of it to them!

Juliagreeneyes · 28/01/2025 19:14

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 28/01/2025 18:46

Surely all generations benefited from very low fees for OU courses. IIRC, Wilson introduced it in the 1960s. At that point I'd have expected most people taking advantage of it to be born before the 1940s. Even when the dreaded boomers did do an OU degree that would probably have been because they left school without much in the way of academic qualifications..

It was used more by boomers than any other generation - to do quals part-time, for women, for retraining, just for interest and for the sake of education (I know; how quaint!) - but also it was the easiest and most affordable way to do a lot of vocational training diplomas in, for example, social work, policing, accounting, all sorts of stuff, often not necessarily degree level but higher vocational, and these courses were often paid for by employers rather than the student.

For boomer-age women in particular it was fantastic as a route for re-entering the workplace when older.

And it was very affordable until the full tuition fees rise: since then it charges the full £9+k cost like any other university.

ElizaMulvil · 28/01/2025 19:13

Juliagreeneyes · 28/01/2025 15:16

Right, but that is all about a generation a bit older than OP’s parents, isn’t it? Boomers grew up in an expanding economy, and the few years of hardship in the 70s and early 90s were massively outweighed by a long boom over that period which hugely inflated the value of their houses, pensions, assets, and inflated away debt. They will also have benefited from all sorts of state subsidies that we won’t be getting. You’re talking about a generation of people who had free education (university and vocational/further education), started work in an expanding job market, bought first houses in their early twenties and saw their mortgages inflated away and their houses rise way beyond economic fundamentals, benefited from tax allowances and early pensions as well as being able to cash in on privatisation windfalls, etc.

If OP’s parents were spending money on trivial things and acquiring a whole house full of stuff then they were hardly poor. Yet your post is all about how they feared ending up like their parents’ generation (the wartime generation). But — they didn’t! They lived through the longest peacetime and boom economy of modern history, with only a mild blip of the three day week and a six-month spike in interest rates in 1990 - hardly a terrible fate when you consider the increase in their housing assets of something like twenty times or more what they paid in real terms.

So - why didn’t they grow up, stop whingeing about wars they never fought in, count their blessings and stop hoarding expensive crap and trying to pretend to their kids that they had it so tough? Because - factually and objectively - they really didn’t have it so tough at all, and I’m sick of pretending that they did.

Her parents were born either side of WW2 so 1930s 40s. Boomers is a misnomer.
It covers far too wide a span. Children born 1940s would have been wrenched from their families and evacuated to live with strangers. 1940s chidren experienced real shortages and traumatised parents. University education was rare. Many unis discriminated against women e.g. Oxbridge, Medical Courses. School leaving age had just risen from 14 to 15. The vast majority of children went to Secondary Moderns and had no opportunity to take exams at 16, let alone A levels or Degrees. There was a huge shortage of teachers, partly because a lot if men had died in WW2 or were traumatised and also because the policy pre WW2 was to sack women who married. Women couldn't get mortgages or fill in their own tax form if married. My cousin taught uncertificated in Salford. Uncertificated teachers were supposed to only have half a class. She had 90. My class in supposedly one of the best primaries in Manchester had 56 children.
The past is a foreign country.

Angelbum81 · 28/01/2025 19:10

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

DazedorBemused · 28/01/2025 19:07

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I think there's an awful lot I don't know and I'm going to ask DH to handle the bank statements from the last few years. I can't change any thing.

And I just repeat, they were a product of their time, never easy, took decisions based on what they knew at the time. And I am still angry. And sad.

It has made me a better parent to my own kids. And I fully embrace Swedish Death Cleaning principles with a hefty dose of minimalism

OP posts: