Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers I need solidarity before I leave the profession

339 replies

Soniastrumpet1984 · 24/01/2025 17:38

I love teaching. I have done it for 22 years.
I am sick of parents moaning. Today has put the tin hat on it.
Here's my situation (this is not exact but an approximation as close to similar as I can get it without putting actual details.)
Let's say I've been teaching French bakery recipes to my cooking club. A local French bakery has offered to host 5 students( in its tiny kitchen) on Saturday morning at 7.30am before they open so they can watch the pastry chef making the items. This is a total favour and just a nice thing they do not have to do. They did this as on my way to work, I was chatting whilst waiting to get my coffee. I as a teacher have agreed to give up my Saturday morning to take them. Every child in cookery club was offered the experience, by email with their parent copied in. It was NOT first come first served, they were clearly told if there's more than 5, we will draw out of a hat. There were more than 5 interested , so I wrote them all on pieces of paper and trotted next door to a different teacher, who came and drew 5 names out. Now I have Two parental complaints demanding to see photos of the slips and why didn't I video the draw and provide evidence. I know it's Friday and I'm tired but fuck I want to leave.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ridl14 · 01/02/2025 23:47

VodkaCola · 25/01/2025 07:44

I'm not a teacher anymore, I left 4 years ago. One of the reasons was all the unpaid extra work I was doing.

One example, I ran 2 recorder clubs after school. I had limited spaces due to only having 30 recorders, so did the names out of a hat thing in front of my class. Parents moaned (but no one offered to buy their child a recorder.) Another parent who's son did get a place moaned that I hadn't started the club that same day. (I needed to send letters home first to inform parents!)

I arranged for them all to play one morning as the rest of the school were walking into, and then out of assembly. The main assembly was led by a colleague and wasn't about the music. A group of parents complained that I hadn't let them come and watch.

So I arranged another assembly where the main event was the recorder groups playing, and invited parents. One complained that they were at work so couldn't come.

So the following year I didn't run the clubs. Parents moaned of course but I had just been pushed too far.

I'm so sorry, this sounds so demoralising and exhausting! I'm still a teacher - I wish leadership would support us to give honest feedback about why the clubs aren't running, just as you described. I'm sure it wouldn't stop people moaning but wish I could give people the bigger picture sometimes.

saraclara · 26/01/2025 19:30

porridgebath · 25/01/2025 18:53

They don't complain if people don't thank them

Oh they do. If they've gone the extra mile for a customer who just walks away without acknowledging them, l they absolutely do moan.

Both my kids have worked in retail and other customer facing jobs, and people who can't be bothered to say thank you are very much resented.

Longma · 26/01/2025 19:09

Do teachers think that working parents receive thank you mails all the time doing our jobs? I don't...

A large amount of the time during a residential is unpaid time. Most school don't pay teachers extra for giving up their evenings, weekends or overnight.

A simple thank you for taking care of your child for several days, including overnight, when it's a lot of unpaid time, isn't difficult - sure;y?!

Longma · 26/01/2025 19:07

It's not their fault your friend died though. If you can't do your job because of it then take time off

But the poster could likely do her job.
The email she returned to doesn't sound like part of her job - not if it was something the parent could have sorted easily.

And unless she'd gone and got a sick note from her GP, how can she take time off? In many schools you're lucky if you can even take half a day unpaid leave to attend the funeral of a friend, let alone longer!

Matronic6 · 26/01/2025 19:05

brummumma · 24/01/2025 20:32

It's not quite the same as a nativity is it though? Everyone has some part to play in the nativity and not everyone wants to play Mary most kids are happy with a reading or just a singing part not every kid wants a starring role. What you arranged was an activity that very few children could attend but you knew would be popular? Names in a hat is just a crap way of doing it as most kids (and obviously their parents!) think it's a bit of a rubbish system. Surely a baking competition would have been more appropriate?
I'm Not saying what the parents have done is right - it's batshit - but you've caused the issue here yourself.

Complete example of the of attitude that teachers get. Your idea of a baking competition is more likely to exclude kids. Children from families of lower income may not have a lot of baking supplies or afford new ones. You would also get some parents who would just do the baking for them. It would favour kids with more available parents and higher income household.

OP, pulling names out of a hat is completely random. There was no fairer way to do it. I wasn't surprised you got complaints. I used to run a really fin art club for free and supplied all the materials. Only 10 kids could partake, over 60 applied so did pull names and got the same complaints. Never did a fucking club again. Parents today are so entitled and one of my main reasons for leaving the profession.

Longma · 26/01/2025 18:58

Lookingfornewdirection · 25/01/2025 07:50

Why does there have to be competition so often for little kids? Can’t it be a pumpkin exhibition instead of competition? Or baking without selecting a winner - everyone can taste other kids stuff etc…these are just examples but I would love more this kind of thinking vs always making it a competition.

Set one up then.
Join the PTA or volunteer for it. Offer to organise, run and supervise the exhibition. Most PTAs are crying out for volunteers to help run things.

DoggoQuestions · 26/01/2025 18:38

porridgebath · 26/01/2025 17:28

So do I. I haven't ever said I didn't.

So why not teachers?

You thank a bus driver for doing the part of their job they're paid for, but refuse to thank a teacher for part of the job they're NOT paid for, going out of their way, working for free, just to give your child a positive experience on a trip/residential?

What possible reason can there be for that?

porridgebath · 26/01/2025 17:28

converseandjeans · 26/01/2025 17:27

@porridgebath

That's a shame. I say thank you to postman, bus driver, cleaner in school, GP, shop staff, footie coach, waitress, bar staff - basically anyone who does something nice for me.

So do I. I haven't ever said I didn't.

converseandjeans · 26/01/2025 17:27

@porridgebath

That's a shame. I say thank you to postman, bus driver, cleaner in school, GP, shop staff, footie coach, waitress, bar staff - basically anyone who does something nice for me.

porridgebath · 26/01/2025 16:42

converseandjeans · 26/01/2025 16:29

@Sugarcoldturkey

I get the impression that @porridgebath agrees with thanking people - but thinks it's not needed for teachers. And thinks we're all a load of whingers because we are saying it would be appreciated. Personally I think anyone that does something positive deserves a thank you - regardless of whether it's paid or voluntary.

No. I think a thank you is a nice to have but not essential for anyone

converseandjeans · 26/01/2025 16:29

@Sugarcoldturkey

I get the impression that @porridgebath agrees with thanking people - but thinks it's not needed for teachers. And thinks we're all a load of whingers because we are saying it would be appreciated. Personally I think anyone that does something positive deserves a thank you - regardless of whether it's paid or voluntary.

Sugarcoldturkey · 25/01/2025 22:40

@porridgebath Would you thank a babysitter? Would you thank a family member after they've looked after your child for a week?

Do you ever say thank you to cashiers or waiters? Do you give a quick nod and smile to your child's football coach when you pick them up?

If the answer is no, then at least you're treating teachers like everyone else, but I do think it's a shame that we've lost those small every day gestures of appreciation.

Han86 · 25/01/2025 21:11

sadlater · 25/01/2025 20:11

Yes. They tend to bring things in fairly regularly. Such is life.

That seems excessive...or is it different children getting a treat each day? In my son's class the teacher picked a child each day who had done whatever behaviour they were focusing on and they got to select something from the reward box - this had sweets but also stationery items. My son always chose a pencil rather than a sweet as he is that way inclined.

porridgebath · 25/01/2025 21:00

converseandjeans · 25/01/2025 20:59

@porridgebath

They don't complain if people don't thank them

Well no neither do I usually but it is just surprising that after being away all week overnight parents just grab & go.

It seems that parents are expecting trips & residentials. As another poster mentioned the younger staff are working far more to rule & don’t care as much about stroppy emails. Maybe they have the right idea?

The issue with that of course is that some students won't ever go away as their parents aren't able to (or don't want to) facilitate it. So their children might not ever go on a residential or a trip to London.

Yeah they've got the right idea.

converseandjeans · 25/01/2025 20:59

@porridgebath

They don't complain if people don't thank them

Well no neither do I usually but it is just surprising that after being away all week overnight parents just grab & go.

It seems that parents are expecting trips & residentials. As another poster mentioned the younger staff are working far more to rule & don’t care as much about stroppy emails. Maybe they have the right idea?

The issue with that of course is that some students won't ever go away as their parents aren't able to (or don't want to) facilitate it. So their children might not ever go on a residential or a trip to London.

sadlater · 25/01/2025 20:11

Cakeandusername · 25/01/2025 19:11

Are you in Uk? I’m surprised at a teacher buying and giving sweet treats weekly there’s usually school policies re healthy eating.

Yes. They tend to bring things in fairly regularly. Such is life.

Cakeandusername · 25/01/2025 19:11

sadlater · 25/01/2025 19:00

We have done everything everyone has suggested and more. The difficulty is that her teacher is not concerned about her missing out and so it gets us nowhere. We just have a teacher that thinks dietary requirements are something to not concern herself with period.

Are you in Uk? I’m surprised at a teacher buying and giving sweet treats weekly there’s usually school policies re healthy eating.

sadlater · 25/01/2025 19:00

Han86 · 25/01/2025 18:01

Are the staff aware of her allergies?

Parents at our school are generally really good and the sweets they bring in for birthdays are ones that can usually be given out to all children. One of our children also has a box of treats the parents provided for any occasion where the sweets are not ok for their child so they aren't left out.
At the end of year generally anything given to the children is not food related e.g. bubbles.

Not sure why you don't talk to the staff so they know what they could offer, or provide a few bits yourself.

We have done everything everyone has suggested and more. The difficulty is that her teacher is not concerned about her missing out and so it gets us nowhere. We just have a teacher that thinks dietary requirements are something to not concern herself with period.

Sherrystrull · 25/01/2025 18:54

I've brought my children up to thank freely. Manners cost nothing. We thank shop staff, sports coaches, waiting staff, someone holding a door etc. it's better that way than being a dick.

porridgebath · 25/01/2025 18:53

converseandjeans · 25/01/2025 18:01

@porridgebath

There we go then, you enjoy it

I enjoy giving students the opportunity to do something that helps them. I think the amount of work it involves is worth it. But a thank you on collection would be really nice. I wouldn't be expecting a big fuss or an email or a card. Just a smile & a wave when they collect.

I always thank people like bus drivers, waitresses, shop staff. So it's not too hard to do. They are also being paid to do their job.

They don't complain if people don't thank them

Tutorpuzzle · 25/01/2025 18:25

I find this thread fascinating having returned to supply teaching (primary) after a long break. @porridgebath , your wishes are very much coming true. Teaching is now as dull as ditchwater. Everything (honestly, everything) is ‘taught’ from an expensive scheme on PowerPoint slides. Residential trips are rare. There are far fewer class day trips and almost no clubs (unless there are paid-for ones run by external agencies.) Quiet children are left to flounder in giant classes full of SEND.
Most younger teachers I’ve got to know simply don’t care about anything parents say (they love the emails from ‘those’ parents, as it gives them something to laugh about at the pub). They like the children and want them to do well, but they just do the job as set out by the schemes and go home (or to the pub.) And good on them.
So, OP, I would honestly just do the bare minimum in school. And maybe run your lovely club privately, for actual money.

VodkaCola · 25/01/2025 18:02

First me it's not about being thanked, it's about being moaned at and complained about for the most ridiculous things. Which is even more annoying when I've given up my own time to put on extra activities and experiences for no extra pay. So I don't do it any more. I have 25 years classroom experience across the 3 primary key stages, that experience is now lost.

PersephoneSmith · 25/01/2025 18:01

TheMeasure · 24/01/2025 22:07

@Embroideryemma "The head called me out for emailing the teacher at 10:30 at night. As though I have a choice about when to squeeze life admin in."

You WHAT? Emailed at 10.30 at night??? Of COURSE you have a fucking choice when to do that.
Well done that Head for calling you out. That was outrageous behaviour on your part.

I can’t tell if you are joking or just being a twat

converseandjeans · 25/01/2025 18:01

@porridgebath

There we go then, you enjoy it

I enjoy giving students the opportunity to do something that helps them. I think the amount of work it involves is worth it. But a thank you on collection would be really nice. I wouldn't be expecting a big fuss or an email or a card. Just a smile & a wave when they collect.

I always thank people like bus drivers, waitresses, shop staff. So it's not too hard to do. They are also being paid to do their job.

Han86 · 25/01/2025 18:01

sadlater · 25/01/2025 15:50

Of course it doesn't but the reality is that at school (and elsewhere) she gets so many less nice things than she would get if she did not have a serious medical condition despite our best efforts. When a teacher gives Easter Eggs to every child but mine she feels left out. She never gets anything at school when others don't. Today all her friends are going out for dinner to somewhere she can't go. Tomorrow she will be at a Christening and will take food but for a child their own food is never as nice as the buffet. Food is a very social thing and serious food allergies are hard. Having to check labels, ask questions in restaurants, and constantly worry about being very ill is not fun. And that's without the realities of a restricted diet.

If the staff all went out for a party tonight to a place that excluded only you you might be okay about that but many wouldn't. A teacher thinking one child should be left out of an activity which everyone else is attending without a second thought I find difficult and certainly in my work setting we would not think this was okay.

Are the staff aware of her allergies?

Parents at our school are generally really good and the sweets they bring in for birthdays are ones that can usually be given out to all children. One of our children also has a box of treats the parents provided for any occasion where the sweets are not ok for their child so they aren't left out.
At the end of year generally anything given to the children is not food related e.g. bubbles.

Not sure why you don't talk to the staff so they know what they could offer, or provide a few bits yourself.

Swipe left for the next trending thread