Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Life as a lawyer

93 replies

nestaarchy · 24/01/2025 14:43

Would love some advice from other female lawyers.

I am a 4PQE lawyer, working at a city firm in disputes. I am really struggling. The partners are constantly making me feel stressed and anxious. I try really, really hard on all the work I do and they are constantly critical. We will discuss what to do, I will send a draft/plan and it will be agreed and then when I draft the letter/email/court document they say, why have you done that? Because it is literally what we have agreed! Then they say, well I've changed my mind. Am I a mind reader?

Sorry for the rambling but I'm feeling so down. I feel like I'm rubbish at my job and I cry so much because it's so stressful. I speak to friends around my age/level and they say they have similar things with partners essentially rewriting work/heavily marking it up and it's not a reflection on me. I just feel like I'm criticised all the time and I find it so demoralising and my self confidence has been absolutely shattered.

Just looking for advice from anyone who's been through something similar. Thanks

OP posts:
Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow · 26/01/2025 12:05

Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow · 26/01/2025 08:34

OK so (in the nicest possible way), this isn’t a firm problem, it’s a you problem.

And I stress it’s not a problem as such - it is totally reasonable not to enjoy the process and to want a different working environment. Issue for you is how you can reframe things to cope with it while you’re waiting to switch (since you say you don’t want to move until post mat-leave). I do think counselling could help to just mentally reframe how you perceive the process.

With drafting, as has been said, the changes likely reflect a hotch potch of: your instructions weren’t particularly clear/they were clear but strategy has now changed/personal style preferences of the reviewer/you have missed some nuances which is completely to be expected given your seniority. I think just let it wash over where you can and see what you can learn from it. The more you can at least emulate their style the fewer stylistic changes will be made at least.

Also, as you become more senior, you should also be trying to add value where possible. I have a 3.5 pqe associate now who is very good at executing what I have told her to do but makes no attempt to add her own points/apply her own mind to what I tell her/pre-empt anything. If I forget something there is no way she will catch it.

Of course you may be doing this already but you might be able to anticipate some of the changes that come as a result of the senior person reflecting if you do the reflecting for them before you hand it in. You can always just do this in square brackets and even if they disagree you look proactive.

SquashedSquashess · 26/01/2025 09:06

I could have written this post OP, I’m in exactly the same position at 4PQE.

I was hanging on for mat pay for the past year, but TTC has taken longer than we’d anticipated.

I’m now actively applying for in-house roles. The pay is as good (if not better) than my current private practice role. I don’t expect excellent mat pay, but we can make do without that. I’ve got to the point where I’ve decided I need to prioritise my wellbeing over potential mat pay.

The Partners I work with are either belittling (blasting my work without giving me the opportunity to explain my approach / thinking, and they often are not across the matter as they are obviously very busy and so miss nuance to cases); or are micro managers who don’t trust me to write a basic two line email without it being reviewed. It is taking its toll on my wellbeing, and I wouldn’t be surprised if this long-term low-level stress is impacting my fertility (I have had irregular periods for the last year).

If you can manage without enhanced mat pay, I’d take a new job and delay TTC for a few months.

HotCrossBunplease · 26/01/2025 08:50

nestaarchy · 25/01/2025 19:12

I am definitely going to try this. I take a lot of handwritten notes but I think I should do more emails to record how discussions are progressing

No, don’t do this! Your supervisors’ inboxes will be overflowing with emails from clients and the other side already. The last thing they need is emails from you repeating every word of the last discussion you had. By all means keep your own file notes and, of course, clarify anything that you are not clear about to the extent that it will stop you getting started on the task, but you’ll just be seen as someone trying to cover your arse if you endlessly document the instructions.

There has been some fantastic advice on here. I would strongly recommend that you find yourself a real-life mentor to talk to. Does your firm have a scheme?

Do you have any PSLs in your firm? They can be good sounding boards.

Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow · 26/01/2025 08:34

nestaarchy · 25/01/2025 19:24

@Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow the anxiety and stress definitely comes from my work mark ups. The partners are actually very nice to me tbh. They speak highly of me to clients and I have quite a big BD budget and always get great feedback on my client management. It's just the work side that makes me really doubt myself

OK so (in the nicest possible way), this isn’t a firm problem, it’s a you problem.

And I stress it’s not a problem as such - it is totally reasonable not to enjoy the process and to want a different working environment. Issue for you is how you can reframe things to cope with it while you’re waiting to switch (since you say you don’t want to move until post mat-leave). I do think counselling could help to just mentally reframe how you perceive the process.

With drafting, as has been said, the changes likely reflect a hotch potch of: your instructions weren’t particularly clear/they were clear but strategy has now changed/personal style preferences of the reviewer/you have missed some nuances which is completely to be expected given your seniority. I think just let it wash over where you can and see what you can learn from it. The more you can at least emulate their style the fewer stylistic changes will be made at least.

TheaBrandt · 26/01/2025 08:09

To be fair I often revisit my own work before sending and change that !

Youve had some good advice on this thread. Do take into account there is no knowing how long TCC will take. Took us a year and my sister 2 years no issues we got there in the end but this timescale could happen.

Ideally hang on in there and use the techniques mentioned above to change your mindset so you minimise upset but if you’re really unhappy it may be some time before a mat leave.

Northerlad · 25/01/2025 22:27

Not all firms are like that. Find a firm with a better culture I promise we are out there!

Keepingthingsinteresting · 25/01/2025 22:17

You’ve had some really good advice @nestaarchy so I won’t repeat it. The only thing I will add is that instead of counselling generally might be worth getting some really focused careers counselling/guidance. There are people who do that for senior professionals and help you really dig in to your values, stressors and preferences and refine your plans. I found it very helpful, though actually didn’t change me job or career as a result, just was able to start thinking differently about some things which mitigated the really painful stuff and allowed me to focus more on what I cared about.

Vettrianofan · 25/01/2025 20:38

Try a job in Tesco - less stress🤗

Elektra1 · 25/01/2025 20:36

Have you asked for feedback from these partners, outside the annual review process? Either they are just dicks (often the case), or there is some mismatch between what you think you're being asked to do and what they actually expect. Lawyers - weirdly - are often not great communicators particularly when it comes to line management.

I'm a litigation partner and I'd be mortified if anyone reporting to me felt as demoralised as you do.

Desperatetodiet · 25/01/2025 20:30

I went in house 8 years ago and have never looked back. Perfect balance of law and home life (kiddies are only little for so long.... they have a happy non stressed mummy!). I just couldn't be doing with the egos, games and presentism at city law firm!
x

Vinvertebrate · 25/01/2025 20:11

I’m an ex-partner in an international firm, now GC - working 9-5 in a female-led global business with a great culture and the pay is the same (mainly because I am virtually guaranteed a decent bonus now). I planned to take mat leave after making partner, but I couldn’t face going back in PP. (Lucky really as DS is disabled). I just quit, and I’ve never looked back. Element of jamminess though in terms of the in-house opportunity popping up at the right time.

Endoftheroad12345 · 25/01/2025 19:43

In house can be stressful
and the work doesn’t stop and obviously the $$$ is not as good, but at what price sanity. I’m a single parent with two primary school aged children and I could not manage my career if I was in private practice

Endoftheroad12345 · 25/01/2025 19:41

Hi @nestaarchy I’m a General Counsel, in-house obviously, unusually I’ve never actually
worked in a firm as went in-house as soon as a graduated but I have instructed many a large firm partner, have hired from top tier litigation teams and was married to a private practice lawyer so I feel well qualified to comment 😂

I don’t think your partner’s behaviour is any reflection on the quality of work. Remember firms are first and foremost businesses with billing targets (as you well know). The incessant and inconsistent mark ups 😬 ndycate to me (a) bill padding by your partners - if they mark up your (perfectly good) work, they get to add more time to the file and (b) insecurity on their part. Really a busy litigation partner should not have the time or the inclination to micromanage to this degree. They should have sufficient work and good juniors in their team that they can effectively delegate. They are not doing so which suggests either not enough work in the pipeline or a lack of maturity as a partner. Their focus should be on BD and strategy with a broad overview of work output quality, not pettifogging mark ups.

I have ended relationships with partners on more than one occasion who could not seem to understand that as GC with 20+ experience I am not looking for track changes on my requests for advice but for strategic advice on (for e.g) how the regulator approaches XYZ issue, X judge’s track record on this issue vs Y judge, the risk if we take X path vs Y path. All partners at law firms claim to be commercially savvy and strategic advisors but I have actually found that very few are. Most have got to where there are by billing the shit out of their clients, often by doing the kind of superfluous shit they are doing right now (fiddling with your work unnecessarily) and they can’t seem to pivot once they make partner. And they typically get no coaching on managing a team so are terrible people leaders.

Start applying for in house jobs now!

Mumlaplomb · 25/01/2025 19:31

Another vote for look to move in-house now if you can. You won’t want to be pregnant working in a super stressy environment if you can avoid it. In house is mostly much more collaborative and less critical/competitive.

nestaarchy · 25/01/2025 19:25

onwards2025 · 25/01/2025 09:30

As others have said 4pqe can be painful, you're not junior and you're not yet in your stride.

Same as others you need to work out if it's certain individual, the firm or the work/law in general and go from there.

I moved at the point of my first mat leave, was 5-6 pqe. I was at the point of needing more control over my work and not be locked into the world and life as an mid level associate. It was the best decision and has worked out very well for me, I'm well out the other side now as partner and try to be fair to the few earners that work with me - I would be pissed if they got touchy about markup as that's par for the course but I like to think I'm nice in the way I deliver it, I don't tell them they are crap etc and try to build them up.

A law career is a long time and you are only at the point of coming out of the start really

How did you find moving after first mat leave? That's what I'm hoping to do if things go (loosely) to plan

OP posts:
nestaarchy · 25/01/2025 19:24

@Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow the anxiety and stress definitely comes from my work mark ups. The partners are actually very nice to me tbh. They speak highly of me to clients and I have quite a big BD budget and always get great feedback on my client management. It's just the work side that makes me really doubt myself

OP posts:
JustMarriedBecca · 25/01/2025 19:24

minipie · 24/01/2025 23:11

Slight tangent but as an ex city litigator- please move jobs NOW. I didn’t, I hung on because we were TTC and I wanted the mat pay and didn’t want to join a new place and then get preg too quickly. In the end it took 11 months to get pregnant… I clung on for 2 kids and then burned out from trying to juggle 2 non sleeping kids with City litigation. At that point I didn’t feel up to interviewing for in house, I became a reluctant SAHM. I really really wish I’d moved at the stage you’re at now, into a job that actually works with kids.

Agree by the way that endless mark ups are the way it is. I’ve had partners remove from the third draft sentences they had themselves inserted in the previous mark up… Does sound like yours are particularly rude about it though. We had a couple of those, they were notorious but luckily I didn’t work for them.

Agree 100% with this.

I had Baby No 1 at a City Firm in a toxic culture. From being asked to start my mat leave a month later than my due date because the partner had approved a favourites holiday to being told it wasn't fair for others to "pick up the slack" when I was 8 months pregnant, had HG and was throwing up in a bin.
There were partners who called all junior female lawyers "Charlotte" and when someone said "that's not my name" said "I don't care"

Get out now. Move firms.

I went back pregnant after Mat Leave No 1, left at 28 weeks (so was back for 3 months max) with Mat Leave No 2.

I spent every day of my pregnancy being sick with anxiety. I have friends who struggled to conceive, left work and then got pregnant instantly. Stress and anxiety do horrible things to your body.

Crushed23 · 25/01/2025 19:23

I'm not a lawyer but was in a similarly high stress City job. It's no exaggeration to say I used to cry on a weekly basis (at least) in the early part of my career. Horrendous hours, unrealistic deadlines and working for ungrateful bellends. It was horrible.

But it does get better, and you will start to feel like you're good at your job. Hang in there.

nestaarchy · 25/01/2025 19:21

scrabblie · 25/01/2025 00:08

Having worked at a couple of different firms with very different partner styles I agree that the partners you work for make a massive difference. I've worked for partners at both end of the spectrum - some completely lovely and others with borderline personality disorders (including stuff you describe).

It's tough because when it's the latter you're mentally exhausted which makes it so much harder to stay resilient and so much easier to crumble and become stressed/emotional. It's a vicious cycle.

It almost sounds like you might care too much? Ie when you get feedback you beat yourself up too much? Definitely not saying it is ok to treat people like shit but if you are dealing with that it can be better to just take a step back to gain perspective.

I've found it easier as I get more experience and build inner resilience - makes it much more easier to just inwardly think fuck you you twat when people are out of order and let it slide off your back. I appreciate good feedback but sometimes it can be so unconstructive! I've also seen really high achieving people being broken. It sucks.

I really do think it could completely change at a different firm but you also need to be sure you're not jumping out of the fry pan and into the fire.

On the flip side, when I've worked for lovely partners, my mental health has been a LOT better (although the training and experience was not so great).

You sort of need to find the perfect balance where you are doing the work you want and not working for utter psychos! Maybe the goldilocks firm doesn't exist but there are definitely firms with better and worse cultures.

I would however 100percent recommend trying to get into a more long term job where you are happier and where you want to return to before you get pregnant (if you are lucky enough to be in that position).

I didn't and whilst I don't regret where I was, life got in the way and I ended up staying in the same job for years longer thank I intended.

I definitely care too much. I need to not allow the feedback to upset me so much. It just makes me feel so rubbish when I really do do my best.

I think I will try and stick it out for mat leave but if it takes longer then expected then try and move

OP posts:
Cashew1 · 25/01/2025 19:19

I used to work for a horrible team of partners in a city firm (magic circle) so left for in-house. Ten years later and I'm actually back to private practice at a smaller city firm after meeting the partners and team and loving them. I think as others have said it really comes down to the team.

nestaarchy · 25/01/2025 19:18

minipie · 24/01/2025 23:11

Slight tangent but as an ex city litigator- please move jobs NOW. I didn’t, I hung on because we were TTC and I wanted the mat pay and didn’t want to join a new place and then get preg too quickly. In the end it took 11 months to get pregnant… I clung on for 2 kids and then burned out from trying to juggle 2 non sleeping kids with City litigation. At that point I didn’t feel up to interviewing for in house, I became a reluctant SAHM. I really really wish I’d moved at the stage you’re at now, into a job that actually works with kids.

Agree by the way that endless mark ups are the way it is. I’ve had partners remove from the third draft sentences they had themselves inserted in the previous mark up… Does sound like yours are particularly rude about it though. We had a couple of those, they were notorious but luckily I didn’t work for them.

I've spoken to DH and if it doesn't happen by summer, then I'm going to look for new jobs. That will have only been 6 months TTC but I don't want it to dictate my life when I'm not loving my firm. (I've had fertility testing done too and everything looks good so hopeful that if I had to move all would be ok long term).

OP posts:
nestaarchy · 25/01/2025 19:17

curious79 · 24/01/2025 23:11

There are lots of different team cultures in different firms. Maybe you have a particularly critical group of partners, so is it worth moving elsewhere? At 4pqe you will be a very attractive hire and you can’t be fired for being pregnant. Equally there is value in learning to accept what you cannot change, including the fact that even when you do things just as asked, you will get inevitable feedback and changes. Many lawyers are absolute buggers when it comes to reworking / redoing documents - just can’t help it! And disputes in my experience often attracts real perfectionist pedants.
Finally, is there any possibility you’re not interpreting instructions correctly? Always worth considering. I do know many partners who complain that lots of the younger cohort are very thin skinned, say they want feedback but really just want a lot of positive affirmation.

More generally building up your resilience and learning to manage any anxiety will be very important. That starts with your own inner voice

This comment really resonated with me, thank you.

I think I am interpreting instructions correctly - I will always pop over to their desk, email or have a teams call to confirm before I start the work. After reading this thread, I genuinely think it might be that it's collaborative and is going to be changed anyway, nothing to do with my ability

OP posts:
nestaarchy · 25/01/2025 19:15

LondonLawyer · 24/01/2025 23:03

It sounds as if you are doing a good job - and no doubt if you weren't, you'd have been told so! I think quite often it's the case in these types of work that you agree to draft something according to Plan A, it's drafted, and on revision and consideration, the flaws in Plan A become clear and therefore you get a list of XYZ that needs to be altered.
It's not personal, it's a style and a pattern of hard, focused work, not an attack. Litigation is fast-moving and changing, but it doesn't mean you aren't good at it. It does suit some people - I certainly don't mind it, because it is low on verbiage, focused, and doesn't particularly upset me. I don't think I'd be a particularly good people-manager or team leader, though, and fortunately for all concerned I'm not.
I'm a lot more senior than you, which almost certainly makes it much easier.
Is it possible you'd enjoy a different area of law more? There are a lot of different possibilities, can you look at a sideways shift?

I think I'd quite like to move in house in a law firm, so risk and compliance type work. I find that super interesting

OP posts:
Ossoduro2 · 25/01/2025 19:13

Make a game plan for your career and just focus on that. It really helps you ignore the aresholes when you are working towards your own objectives. For you it should be getting as much experience under your belt and raising your profile before you go on mat leave to put you in the best possible position to get a job elsewhere after mat leave!

nestaarchy · 25/01/2025 19:12

onetrickrockingpony · 24/01/2025 21:15

Agree with PP that it’s often only when looking at what they’ve asked for will a senior person realise it’s not the right approach. I re do pieces of work all the time and it’s hard not to get frustrated. Try and change your response though “Ok got it Jill, the brief has changed since we last spoke, I’ll adjust. If anything else changes, please let me know soonest so I can incorporate that into the new draft”. What you have done isn’t wrong, law moves at pace and it can be a changing situation. Try not to take it personally. If the work was truly rubbish, they wouldn’t be asking you to do it at all.

I am definitely going to try this. I take a lot of handwritten notes but I think I should do more emails to record how discussions are progressing

OP posts: