Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband sometimes breaks things when angry - should I leave?

105 replies

Stircrazy1984 · 23/01/2025 21:11

My husband and I have been together 15 years, he grew up in a house where his dad was abusive to his mum and his mum would break things from frustration and emotionally lean on him.

As a result, sometimes, when he gets really mad he will smash things up, in our old house he smashed shelves off walls, pounded wicker baskets and one time dropped a plate full of food into our wooden floor, so it shattered in a million pieces, and I told him it couldn't happen again as, our eldest daughter who was a baby in her highchair, could have gotten bits of china in her eye.

We've been here 5 years and I can only recall 3 incidents, he threw his Xbox on the floor when I told him he loved it more than me maybe a year ago, as he spends his life on it, he punched a hole in a door a few months ago and this weekend he threw a large cooking pan, which then bounced and smashed our front window, he then tried to break his phone in half, but I took it from him, then he walked past the pan on the floor and aggressively stamped on it until it was all bent and unusable (it was a brand new one we treated ourselves to). We have a 9 and 6 year old now and I can't bare to think what would have happened if one of them walked through the hall when that pan was flying, and our 9 year old ran and hid and locked herself in the crate with our dog and was clearly affected by it. He did speak to a mental health professional and he has had an assessment with talking space but they don't deal in anger management. He has said I just have to stop whinging at him so much (but I just asked him to be present with the kids and to help me with some housework - I work p/t so do most of it)

My husband says it happened because I was getting at him too much..but I had only suggested that 9am was too early to play on his Xbox and for him to pick up half the dog poos in the garden as I'd done the other half, as we were having guests over for a party a few days later, and he snapped BIG TIME. Burst into tears and said that he works really hard and never gets to do what he wants and that he wants to kill himself...he had been playing his games since midday the day before all day and night until he came to bed late. He has a motorbike, a new mountain bike, a Nintendo switch, his Xbox and a tennis club membership, but apparently he never gets to do what he wants and he says it was how I talk to him...I said I talk to him like that as feel 2nd to the Xbox...proportionally he spends 90% of his free time between Xbox, switch and scrolling through his phone, he has a stressful job and uses it to escape, but by escaping reality he's also missing out on family life.

Anyway, I'm not being myself for fear of setting him off again but he's frustrated at me for not being myself?! And obviously now I have my children to think about and my daughter has told me she's worried when Daddy gets angry again he'll break something again, and he does get angry quite a lot, just not to the 'breaking items' degree.

He thinks I am 'blowing things out of proportion' this time as I haven't just snapped back to normal like nothing has happened this time...is he right? Am I overthinking it? I'm thinking I need to put my kids first and also me as I don't feel I can be myself around him at the moment for fear of him snapping again.

OP posts:
user1492757084 · 24/01/2025 12:18

Move out.
He needs to actively seek professional help, be committed to it and be considered as having success with the program before I would entertain discussions about sharing care of the children or living with him again.
He would always need to have a therapist and learn calm strategies for many years, I think.

OopsyDaisie · 24/01/2025 12:14

festivemouse · 23/01/2025 21:17

Leave 100%

You're in an abusive relationship. He hasn't managed to break the cycle of abuse. You need to report these incidents so they're on an official record so when you separate it can be considered around him seeing the children.

I agree to leave.
But he will still have unsupervised access to the children, it makes no difference if OP has records of any of this unfortunately.....
ETA: he is abusive. He doens t need anger management therapy, it won't help!

HesDeadBenYouCanStopNow · 24/01/2025 12:09

One of the best days of my childhood was when my dad moved into his own house. I loved both my parents but together life was awful, I was afraid often and still have impacts on my life and behaviours now over 40 years later.

You owe it to your children to divorce.

There might be a chance for them to have a loving relationship with him in the future if you do. If you stay together the damage to them will be worse and probably impact them for the rest of their lives.

It's not a healthy relationship between you 2 and it needs to stop now before it gets any worse. I don't give a flying monkeys if he's stressed, it is unaccountable and needs to stop

Lyra87 · 24/01/2025 12:01

I haven't read the full thread, but the fact your 9 year was so frightened she hid should be a wake up call to him and you. I couldn't imagine staying with someone who made my child feel like that. If you stay, your DC may not want to be around either of you when they grow up.

Calamitousness · 24/01/2025 11:55

He is focussed on himself. Poor him. Everybody is to blame for ‘making’ him lose his temper. You’ve stressed him out now.
He’s horrible. He won’t change. I doubt he even thinks he needs to.
Phone a women’s aid if you need help to leave because he is an abuser and your children will grow up abused and then likely repeat the pattern of being an abuser or your daughter will have personality disorder problems and be emotionally unstable all her life. Get out. If not for you, then for them.

ItGhoul · 24/01/2025 11:25

I've been in a similar position to you and I'm sorry, but absolutely MUST leave him. First of all, it's awful for you to live with. Secondly, it's emotionally damaging and potentially physically dangerous for your child. Thirdly, there's a good chance it will escalate into physical violence towards you.

Dror · 24/01/2025 11:22

Your children are being terrorised. Don't give another thought to their abuser, prioritise his victims and get them safe.

Machya · 24/01/2025 11:11

Stircrazy1984 · 24/01/2025 09:52

He's been signed off work for 2 weeks with stress.

So your childrens abuser will be home full-time.

God help those poor children.

Marmaladelover · 24/01/2025 10:16

Stircrazy1984 · 24/01/2025 09:52

He's been signed off work for 2 weeks with stress.

Not much good if he just spends the whole 2 weeks playing on the Xbox . The 2 weeks should be a Reset .

Stircrazy1984 · 24/01/2025 09:52

He's been signed off work for 2 weeks with stress.

OP posts:
ThighsYouCantControl · 24/01/2025 06:40

The thing is, you get a choice whether you finally leave this ticking time bomb or not. Your children don’t. Your children running and hiding in their own home because they are so frightened is genuinely heart breaking. Your parents are meant to be the ones you run to when you’re frightened.

I won’t have a go at you, that would be hypocritical of me as I’ve been in a very similar situation. But I will say the transformation of my own kids when we lived in our own home away from their father was amazing. They were no longer on edge or frightened. Living like that is exhausting.

Mamma38383 · 24/01/2025 05:53

And agree, he is being a terrible model for your kids. He may have learned this behaviour from his mother but he is teaching it to your children.

Mamma38383 · 24/01/2025 05:52

Imagine if your daughter had written this - would you want her to put up with it? Or would you tell her to get out?

Apart from the violence he's blaming you. He's a grown man and he's not in control of himself, and you don't know if and when he will turn from breaking objects to hurting you and your children because he blames you or them too.

LoudSnoringDog · 24/01/2025 05:42

Protect your children.

He's manipulating you.

Michiru · 24/01/2025 05:07

I've been in that kind of relationship.

I kept walking on eggshells in order to not provoke his anger.

I kept trying to keep peace so we didn't - again - have to replace something because he lost his temper.

I left when I saw one of my children imitating this.

What will your child learn? Either, they will end up in a similar cycle (do you want that kind of life for them) or they will end up with similar behaviour.

Oh, and his violence did escalate and he almost killed me at one point. His regret didn't last too long.

I am on my own now, with my children, and finally healing after many years.

Calamitousness · 24/01/2025 05:05

I genuinely am not an ltb person on here unless it’s so very bad and believe me. This is so very bad. Get your children and leave. Phone the police when he’s smashing things. Get a record of his behaviour. It will be useful for court and child custody. But get out.

PleaseAndThankYou12 · 24/01/2025 04:13

I'm so sorry you're going through this.

But please protect yourself and your children and leave.

Sending you love x

SwanSong1 · 24/01/2025 02:57

Absolutely leave, he is an adult and fully capable of controlling his temper.

Sparklfairy · 24/01/2025 02:43

He thinks I am 'blowing things out of proportion' this time

Oh the irony is laughable. Really. Ask him if HE ever blows anything out of proportion? I'd dearly love to hear his answer.

mummytrex · 24/01/2025 01:55

And if he genuinely tries to kill himself (doubtful), then that's on him.

UnicornWorld · 24/01/2025 01:55

I stopped reading at the comment around the China could have hit your baby. You matter too, you know

Run.

mummytrex · 24/01/2025 01:54

So according to him he is blameless and wants to kill himself as it's all your fault..?

Please Hmm. He is manipulating you and trying to train you to put up and shut up.

Read your post back to yourself. In particular:

"our 9 year old ran and hid and locked herself in the crate with our dog and was clearly affected by it."

"my daughter has told me she's worried when Daddy gets angry again he'll break something again,"

If you can't leave for yourself. Do it for your kids. They need to be protected and deserve better than being exposed to this sort of environment. Do you really want them growing up to think this is normal and/or repeating this behaviour??

modernshmodern · 24/01/2025 01:19

Whilst you stay in this marriage you are normalising violence to your kids. Show them they should not accept this treatment.

At any point he could have sought help for his issues

Machya · 24/01/2025 01:13

Your poor children.
God love them.
They will carry this forever.
He's a house terrorist and he has damaged your children irrevocably.
Hopefully one of them will mention it to a teacher who will report it.

Get ahead of this and get out.
He's an abusive angry pig and your poor children are bearing the terrible price every day you stay.

Could your daughter be any clearer.
Poor terrified mite.

GreenLeaf25 · 24/01/2025 01:12

If you don't leave, your children will end up hating you for it. Trust me, I know.