Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Blake lively

315 replies

laurwalsh · 22/01/2025 20:45

Has anyone seen the video footage that totally proves Blake Lively was lying about her accusations of Justin Baldoni. Total Amber Heard vibes from this and it's scary to think how many cases that can't be proved have destroyed men's lives.

OP posts:
Nicecuppatea2025 · 28/01/2025 11:50

Doesn’t make BL wrong in her original complaint.

Matronic6 · 28/01/2025 11:17

Based on the messages that have come out recently, they both seem self important, obnoxious and insufferable.

friendshipover24 · 28/01/2025 11:04

Everyone here who is still insisting that Justin Baldoni is evil, go on TikTok & watch Candace Owens‘ coverage of this story. Personally not a fan of her political content but she has based her coverage on facts.

Vavazoom · 25/01/2025 17:51

I think she is very clearly uncomfortable - and if you’ve been in an uncomfortable situation with the same power imbalance - you would probably recognise that.

AnnoyedAsAllHeck · 25/01/2025 17:33

Feelabandoned · 24/01/2025 07:52

There aren’t plenty of examples though - they managed to drag up one interview from years ago and ran with that.

Other than that the accusations were general and vague - “hard to work with” - yes, because she didn’t just accept the way he treated her.

The entire cast of the film in question backed her over him. They don’t seem to have found her “spiteful”.

Edited

And the stars of the "Travelling Pants" saga are also sticking up for BL. For someone "difficult to work with", she certainly has the people she worked with having her back.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 25/01/2025 14:47

Nicecuppatea2025 · 25/01/2025 11:59

Was she? HW’s very long term partner? Finding it hard to find any reports of BL being HW girlfriend … have I missed something? Also, hasn’t BL and RR been together since she was around 25?

Also haven’t seen evidence of her defending HW. I’ve seen her say in a talk show that abuse wasn’t her experience of HW but that’s not the same as defending him.

Edited

Completely agree with this. Have just had a mad google and could find absolutely no evidence to suggest she was HW “very long term partner”. All I can find was that she was on a panel with him when she was 19/20, with Michelle Obama and others at a high school event; that SA wasn’t her experience with him and that SH/SA was in all walks of life and it was devastating to hear. She met RR in 2010 and was with Penn Badgley for 3 years before then. If anyone has evidence of a long term relationship with HW please put a link on here.

but whatever you think of her-it doesn’t matter what she is like as a person or how hard she is to work with; if she was uncomfortable with non scripted sexual acts (which includes kissing) then she is uncomfortable and it’s SA. I thought she seemed uncomfortable in the video and was trying to back off in a nice way, even putting her hands in front of her face.

Lavenderfarmcottage · 25/01/2025 14:31

I feel like the real story is what he said about Jenny Lane’s schnoz. It doesn’t show BL’s reaction and whether she defended her friend.

Coldanddamp · 25/01/2025 13:19

I know why celebrities lie about surgery, I was more making the point that they lie even when they have a different face & it's obvious because image & maintaining that image is everything.

Coldanddamp · 25/01/2025 13:17

What I'm asking I suppose is what people think the benefit could be for Blake Lively to instigate the lawsuit in question, if it isn't true?

Because she wants to protect her reputation as she is saying she was cancelled due to his PR campaign. It's worked as she has gone from a baddie to a victim. Or have you not seen that?

fairycakes1234 · 25/01/2025 12:52

TeddybearBaby · 25/01/2025 10:26

Ok I get what you’re saying I think….. she might be a nasty piece of work but that’s irrelevant in the context of her suffering abuse because both things can be true at the same time?

So, are you willing to wait and see what all the evidence shows to make your mind up? Are you of the mindset to believe all women? Genuine question!!

That's usually what happens, you want for the evidence and outcome as none of us really know what is going on?

TeddybearBaby · 25/01/2025 12:33

I don’t know about PR etc. but she’d go from villain to hero wouldn’t she in the public sphere….. that is what happened in a way isn’t it……

TeddybearBaby · 25/01/2025 12:31

whathaveiforgotten · 25/01/2025 12:05

Because the benefit to them is that they won't be criticised for using a controversial drug and can maintain the image that they are physically superior / gifted to us mere mortals!

There's a clear benefit to the lie there.

What I'm asking I suppose is what people think the benefit could be for Blake Lively to instigate the lawsuit in question, if it isn't true?

Revenge possibly, anger. JB smeared her unfairly in her mind and she couldn’t let it go. I’m not saying that! I don’t know what happened or who to believe yet.

She’s part of one of the most powerful couples in the world, maybe her / their ego couldn’t take the audacity 🤷🏻‍♀️

whathaveiforgotten · 25/01/2025 12:05

Coldanddamp · 25/01/2025 11:41

Why do so many celebrities lie about plastic surgery or ozempic?

Because the benefit to them is that they won't be criticised for using a controversial drug and can maintain the image that they are physically superior / gifted to us mere mortals!

There's a clear benefit to the lie there.

What I'm asking I suppose is what people think the benefit could be for Blake Lively to instigate the lawsuit in question, if it isn't true?

Nicecuppatea2025 · 25/01/2025 11:59

Petra42 · 25/01/2025 08:57

Her hand was forced in that she had to stop defending him because of the media backlash. Same for Gwyneth. The reality is she was his very long term partner. I think BL and RR are usually very shrewd with their image but have made a huge error here.

Was she? HW’s very long term partner? Finding it hard to find any reports of BL being HW girlfriend … have I missed something? Also, hasn’t BL and RR been together since she was around 25?

Also haven’t seen evidence of her defending HW. I’ve seen her say in a talk show that abuse wasn’t her experience of HW but that’s not the same as defending him.

TeddybearBaby · 25/01/2025 11:44

whathaveiforgotten · 25/01/2025 11:26

You're right I didn't answer the question as it was directed at another poster. I absolutely agree with their statement below and feel exactly the same.

And yes, I'll admit that I am fairly biased towards believing the woman, based on the balance of probability, most of the time

Sorry, my mistake 😂

Coldanddamp · 25/01/2025 11:41

Why do so many celebrities lie about plastic surgery or ozempic?

Coldanddamp · 25/01/2025 11:40

@whathaveiforgotten yes it has been largely favourable, the plantation thing was well managed & forgotten. This time BL was in effect cancelled in internet terms and she really did step back. I think the strategy was this film was her platform to announce "I'm back, it's my turn at career success, etc". Hence the marketing tie ins with hair, cocktails etc it's a normal PR marketing strategy. After the backfire I do think she wanted to exonerate herself.

I assume they didn't expect JB to fight back, airing your dirty laundry public doesn't tend to go well though for anyone.

Interested in why anyone thinks she would lie?

I don't know if she is lying but I wouldn't ever expect honestly from Hollywood. the business is seedy & shady and very much about spin.

whathaveiforgotten · 25/01/2025 11:26

TeddybearBaby · 25/01/2025 11:18

@whathaveiforgotten I don’t think you answered my question so I’m going to assume you believe all women, which is fine of course, just wondering! Why would BL lie? I have no idea because I’m not her but people lie for all sorts of reasons and it’s usually to get what they want I’d say. Not sure if this is fact, just my guess. Along with money goes lots of other things for famous people like image and ego, there’s loads of things, must be really difficult at times actually.

@BlueSilverCatsThank you for your messages. I definitely understand what’s being said more now. I try to take a step back and think let’s see / hear the evidence first. It’s such a delicate subject and I try to keep that in mind.

You're right I didn't answer the question as it was directed at another poster. I absolutely agree with their statement below and feel exactly the same.

And yes, I'll admit that I am fairly biased towards believing the woman, based on the balance of probability, most of the time

whathaveiforgotten · 25/01/2025 11:25

Coldanddamp · 25/01/2025 11:20

they don't need publicity

People in Hollywood need good press if they want to be movie stars

I probably didn't word that clearly enough.

Absolutely they will always want publicity, I guess my point was that they don't struggle to get it and it has always been largely favourable, so they didn't need the publicity this specific situation would create.

Interested in why anyone thinks she would lie?

Coldanddamp · 25/01/2025 11:20

they don't need publicity

People in Hollywood need good press if they want to be movie stars

TeddybearBaby · 25/01/2025 11:18

@whathaveiforgotten I don’t think you answered my question so I’m going to assume you believe all women, which is fine of course, just wondering! Why would BL lie? I have no idea because I’m not her but people lie for all sorts of reasons and it’s usually to get what they want I’d say. Not sure if this is fact, just my guess. Along with money goes lots of other things for famous people like image and ego, there’s loads of things, must be really difficult at times actually.

@BlueSilverCatsThank you for your messages. I definitely understand what’s being said more now. I try to take a step back and think let’s see / hear the evidence first. It’s such a delicate subject and I try to keep that in mind.

BlueSilverCats · 25/01/2025 10:36

@TeddybearBaby your first paragraph nails it.

As for your questions, I obviously have an opinion right now , but I am happy to review all the evidence when it becomes available and reconsider or even change my mind.

And yes, I'll admit that I am fairly biased towards believing the woman, based on the balance of probability, most of the time.

whathaveiforgotten · 25/01/2025 10:35

@TeddybearBaby

Blake Lively and her husband are worth around $350 million.

What do you think her motivation would be for making public, serous accusations like this against a man if they aren't true?

That's a genuine question too.

They don't need money, they don't need drama, they don't need publicity. They are multi millionaires who already get lots of press coverage that was, before this situation, largely favourable to them.

Why would she lie?

TeddybearBaby · 25/01/2025 10:26

BlueSilverCats · 25/01/2025 10:20

It's not that she’s a saint or paragon of virtue. In fact, I haven't seen many people claim that .

It's about moving away from the myth of the "perfect" victim. It's irrelevant how likeable she is or not.

A lot of posters comment along the lines of "she might've been sexually harassed/I don't know / it's possible but..... she's a dick." As if that somehow justifies it or explains it or makes it less bad.

As a society, We always fucking do this. Unless a victim IS saint like and a paragon of virtue we start doubting and asking questions. What was she wearing, what was she doing there, how much did she drink , how friendly was she , why has she waited so long, what underwear was she wearing, who did she sleep with, why did she still talk to him and so on. The list is neverfuckingending.

Ok I get what you’re saying I think….. she might be a nasty piece of work but that’s irrelevant in the context of her suffering abuse because both things can be true at the same time?

So, are you willing to wait and see what all the evidence shows to make your mind up? Are you of the mindset to believe all women? Genuine question!!

Feelabandoned · 25/01/2025 10:25

TeddybearBaby · 25/01/2025 09:08

Can I genuinely ask a question, mainly to the BL defenders just because they seem so angry for want of a better word…..

From my perspective I don’t know what happened 100%. I saw BL’s initial complaint and fell for it completely if I’m honest. Then I saw JB’s response and what really pissed me off was BL’s team leaving out certain responses, taking out emojis so they were shown in a different context etc. Why do that? Didn’t like it at all.

Where is the hesitation to accept that BL has made mistakes like we all have? I just feel fascinated about where this level of fixation comes from.

Totally changing the subject but it reminds me of ‘The View’ I don’t watch it!!! But I saw clips of them saying what a great guy Biden is and how he’ll make his son go through an investigation because he’s not corrupt like Trump, then he pardoned him and they said well he is his son I don’t blame him. The show is an absolute joke but I’d have so much more respect for people who accepted failures and didn’t make excuses. For example ‘I do support Biden and I think he would make a better president but I must admit he disappointed me there’.

Whatever you think, BL has not come across well at certain times, why is she being heralded as a saint, this paragon of virtue? Even though none of us know yet. There’s not nearly enough information for us to.

No one is “heralding” BL as a “saint or paragon of virtue” @TeddybearBaby - they are saying that her personal qualities and things she said in interviews years ago aren’t in any way relevant to how she was treated by JB.

I have absolutely no idea whether BL is a nice person or not.

But what I do know, for a fact, is that JB paid for a PR campaign to make people think that BL is not a nice person, so my starting point is to question any narrative that seems to be based on that PR campaign.