Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex husbands demands

231 replies

lespameo · 20/01/2025 21:40

Would like some perspective on this please...

Have been split for 6 years/ divorced for 5 and it's not been an amicable split really as he loves to argue over the smallest of things and I think he despises the fact he isn't in control of my life anymore. (control being the main reason for the split and documented in the divorce papers).

We share 2 x dc who he chooses to see EOW but only on the basis that I drive half way (drop off 6pm Friday, get back Sunday lunch time, dependent on ds football match). He moved 45 mins away to live with his new partner and her 2 dds and is getting married to her this summer.

I have been with my new partner for 5 years.

XHs wedding is scheduled in August and today he text to ask that I collect dc from the wedding reception in the evening. I wasn't aware of the specific date until today, and I have already got tickets for my partners and my favourite band. it's my partners birthday that day too.

The wedding is scheduled on his normal weekend to see the kids, hence me booking the tickets, months ago.

He is arguing the toss with me that I should cancel my plans and that I'm being unreasonable as 'it's his wedding day' (wedding number 3 may I add).

The DC will be 10 at the time of the wedding. I've suggested he asks a family member to take the DC home and that as it's his weekend, it's not my fault that I've already made plans and that I'm not purposely being difficult.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Anxious2024 · 24/01/2025 06:21

@lespameo I know one of your dc is 10 - how old is the other one?

Mine were 12, 14 and 16 when I got divorced from my emotionally abusive ex and they have basically lived with me and seen him when they want to since. I have no contact with my ex at all.

What I am trying to say is that there will come a time in the not too distant future when you won’t have to have any contact with your horrible ex.

In the meantime I second the pp who said to grey rock him.

He sounds selfish, unpleasant, narcissistic and controlling.

NWQM · 24/01/2025 06:20

lespameo · 21/01/2025 12:50

@Springflowersmakeforbetterhours this is the message I got from him when I suggested a family member...

Oh come on, it’s my wedding day?! If the boot was on the other foot you know I would do the same for you as some things are much more important. You’re basically asking someone in my family (who will also be at the wedding) to compromise their own day because you aren’t willing to help me out?

I hope you can hear loads from Mumsnet shouting 'no, you are.' He has made a huge assumption that you will facilitate his vision for his day. It sounds as if you have done all you can. You have been clear, fair and have a plan B. I would probalay reply to one more message if he sends one. Next time don't solve it. It's his weekend. I think you should be saying....as I have already explained as I was not aware of a request for flexibility in childcare arrangements. I have pans already as the date is a significant one. They do not allow me to met your request your request.

I wouldnt say any more. Do not solve the problem. You will not be able to to his satisfaction. Just keeping doing what you do in terms of keeping him informed of important things etc. Whatever you did before.

If broadly the contact works for the children and you - as irritating as the journey sounds - the mediation may indeed serve no real purpose. I know you would like the children - as they want to - to see him more but if he is going to awkward and do things like refuse to let them speak to you to punish you then really the atmosphere for them could be very difficult. They are coming to an age where they can make choices

DorothyStorm · 24/01/2025 06:18

Confusedasusual46 · 24/01/2025 00:07

I would defo pick them up. It’s hos wedding day for goodness sake. Yes he is annoying and controlling but on his wedding day I’d make a once in a lifetime or four times in a lifetime exception to be totally honest

It is just a case of picking them up… from their father’s wedding (where he is making them unwelcome right at the start of his new family life), but op would have to cancel plans she has already made and paid for.

why do you think the children’s father should not arrange childcare for the evening? It would be very simply to do, babysitter to the hotel for the evening. Why do you think that childcare on his weekend that he wants then there for, isn't his responsibility?

Dinomum79 · 24/01/2025 05:59

It sounds like he has narcissistic qualities and enjoys making you annoyed . He knows the half way point annoys you so will keep doing it. I suggest making his requests seem no bother or say that would have been fine but whoops something came up last minute and you can’t . Don’t give him any of your emotions. He managed to have an effect on you pre Xmas . I think just decide if you are doing something or not (ie if it’s in the best interests of the kids) and go with that but keep a poker face .

For the wedding I wouldn’t want the children to think they are in the way and it would spoil my night out. If your parents are happy to then I wouldn’t want the ask them to collect them.

good luck - he sounds like an arse!!

Noodles1234 · 24/01/2025 05:43

YANBU
he has to be the parent here and deal with the situation himself, it’s his weekend.

he’s just being an A’se because he has a small excuse to exert some control again.

it’s his weekend so he arranges something, fair he has asked you, but you cannot and it doesn’t have to be you.

blooming cheek you drive to his wedding! I guess to collect kids, just feels weird.

Cakeorchocolate · 24/01/2025 00:28

Definitely not BU. Don't give in.

He planned his wedding for when his kids can be there but doesn't want them there for the whole thing, his job to make alternative arrangements for them then.
(I wonder what the arrangements are for the brides daughters.)

Enjoy your event.

(A cynical person might think he's just trying to get you to his wedding day in some capacity. )

Also re the court/mediation. It would be perfectly reasonable for you to refuse any further attempts at mediation given you've already tried it and he refused to make any compromises.

WellsAndThistles · 24/01/2025 00:24

Make a fist, extend middle finger, job done. Tell him to keep the kids an extra night...

Cakeorchocolate · 24/01/2025 00:21

Confusedasusual46 · 24/01/2025 00:07

I would defo pick them up. It’s hos wedding day for goodness sake. Yes he is annoying and controlling but on his wedding day I’d make a once in a lifetime or four times in a lifetime exception to be totally honest

Well more fool you. She has plans on her weekend without her kids. His problem to sort childcare if he doesn't want his children to be there for the whole event he planned on his weekend with them.

Welshmonster · 24/01/2025 00:20

It’s his problem. Not yours. As they get older they will start to see him as the selfish person he is.
you have tickets and that’s the end of discussion. I bet he wants them at the wedding for photos and show everyone what a good dad he is. Then he’s dumping them.

he should have checked it was ok before he booked the wedding.

my dad was supposed to pick me up and wasn’t going to. My mum made him tell me as she was fed up of being the bearer of bad news. Say you aren’t driving the kids anymore and it’s up to him.

Confusedasusual46 · 24/01/2025 00:07

I would defo pick them up. It’s hos wedding day for goodness sake. Yes he is annoying and controlling but on his wedding day I’d make a once in a lifetime or four times in a lifetime exception to be totally honest

TipsyJoker · 21/01/2025 21:58

MozartsMeatballs · 21/01/2025 18:39

NO! You are definitely not BU. He sounds very, very much like my controlling abusive ExH (who left for the OW 12yrs ago but still expects me to prioritise his wants and needs).

They are so good at behaving like an a-hole and then making you feel like the unreasonable one to the point where you are literally questioning whether you're being a total knob.

I actually stood up to my ExH today, over him (yet again) unilaterally changing his contact days and having our 12yo deliver the message. I've always tried to avoid conflict because I didn't think it was good for the children. Now I think that letting him treat their mother like a doormat is not good for the children.

After a 'toddler tantrum' earlier today, I've heard nothing, and DD3 came home as planned (rather than attend a freezing training session with him and DD2 - presumably because he didn't want to go on his own)

Well done 👍

Elsvieta · 21/01/2025 20:37

Tell him you'll do whatever he wants for his next wedding, and in the meantime he's got eight months to work this out. Don't let him get to you.

TheFormidableMrsC · 21/01/2025 20:21

@POTC I'm not saying they are a new thing . I was saying in my experience (and long drawn out proceedings in court), that is what happened to me. Ex had to collect and drop. Similar for my handful of friends in the same situation. That was all.

Hankunamatata · 21/01/2025 19:49

lespameo · 21/01/2025 12:50

@Springflowersmakeforbetterhours this is the message I got from him when I suggested a family member...

Oh come on, it’s my wedding day?! If the boot was on the other foot you know I would do the same for you as some things are much more important. You’re basically asking someone in my family (who will also be at the wedding) to compromise their own day because you aren’t willing to help me out?

I'd go with - I am not avaliable that weekend.
And keep replying that whenever he brings it up

loveawineloveacrisp · 21/01/2025 19:48

user1492757084 · 21/01/2025 07:21

It's okay for him to ask. It is his wedding day and it was a way that he could inform you of that too.

You could wish him a Very Happy Wedding Day but say that unfortunately you have made plans that you don't wish to change.
Suggest he asks his parents or siblings to take the kids home with them.
Be helpful in picking the kids up, just this once, if you can on the Sunday. - meet granny half way or something.

I see no reason to be unkind. You might need a favour of him one day. Make sure the kids have a card for him and SM.

Edited

Are you the ExH?

Op, I've been there with the controlling. Stop letting him continue to interfere in your life. The only way to deal with these pricks is by grey rocking them.

GrandmotherStillLearning · 21/01/2025 19:35

DorothyStorm · 20/01/2025 21:46

‘Sorry that doesn't wrok for me. Have a wonderful wedding day though.’

This

A simple :
No. I am sure their family on your side can help. I've made plans.

Soontobe60 · 21/01/2025 19:30

If I could vote I’d vote YABU - but only in that you're having a ‘discussion’ with him about this event, and that you're doing the drop offs / pick ups every time. He’s still controlling you.
Your next (and last) message on this matter should be as follows:
”Dear ex, as you are getting married on your designated weekend, you will have to organise childcare for DC with your own family. In addition, I will no longer be dropping the DC off for your contact days. You will need to arrange to pick up your DC at 6pm on Friday and I will collect them at 4pm on Sunday. There will be no further discussion on either of these issues.”

andthat · 21/01/2025 19:08

Assert those boundaries @lespameo!

’Would have loved to help but have a prior engagement…have a great day!’

POTC · 21/01/2025 19:04

TheFormidableMrsC · 21/01/2025 13:30

@Snoopdoggydog123 That was exactly the case for me in terms of travelling and others I know who have obtained a CAO. I'm willing to accept that might have changed but it's not how the judge saw it in my case.

OP, mediation is not advised in situations like yours. My ex just didn't turn up so that was the end of that. I'd personally be looking to formalise things to stop his control of you and your life.

20 years ago after being awarded full custody of my youngest brother (who was 10 at the time and my mum had walked out when he was 3), my dad was ordered to drive halfway for drop off/pick up fortnightly. That meant 1.5-2 hours just to get to the meeting point, the same back again, then repeat it all again on the Sunday. Courts ordering meeting halfway even when the absent parent is the one who chose to move isn't a new thing.

MozartsMeatballs · 21/01/2025 18:39

NO! You are definitely not BU. He sounds very, very much like my controlling abusive ExH (who left for the OW 12yrs ago but still expects me to prioritise his wants and needs).

They are so good at behaving like an a-hole and then making you feel like the unreasonable one to the point where you are literally questioning whether you're being a total knob.

I actually stood up to my ExH today, over him (yet again) unilaterally changing his contact days and having our 12yo deliver the message. I've always tried to avoid conflict because I didn't think it was good for the children. Now I think that letting him treat their mother like a doormat is not good for the children.

After a 'toddler tantrum' earlier today, I've heard nothing, and DD3 came home as planned (rather than attend a freezing training session with him and DD2 - presumably because he didn't want to go on his own)

backawayfatty1 · 21/01/2025 15:01

No chance I would do it!

I habe 2 step sons who love with us 50/50 & 1 DD. I planned my wedding around them being present. We arranged childcare for our wedding eve by asking granny. No, we would never have asked other parents to "take them".

He sounds like an absolute twat

sheldonRockz · 21/01/2025 14:33

lespameo · 21/01/2025 13:17

@Penguinmouse he absolutely wouldn't do anything to help me out and nor would I ever ask him! I laughed out loud when I read the message.

@lespameo The petty in me would be rounding up all the receipts from when he’s refused to help me out. Then I’d be and saying “help you out? Like when you helped me out when x,y,z” and list all the times he refused to help.

Audacity of some of the deadbeat pricks

jollygoose · 21/01/2025 14:14

I loved the answer one poster made which wad "I promise to help with the next one," brilliant.

Horses7 · 21/01/2025 13:53

Don’t do it!!

thepariscrimefiles · 21/01/2025 13:51

user1492757084 · 21/01/2025 07:21

It's okay for him to ask. It is his wedding day and it was a way that he could inform you of that too.

You could wish him a Very Happy Wedding Day but say that unfortunately you have made plans that you don't wish to change.
Suggest he asks his parents or siblings to take the kids home with them.
Be helpful in picking the kids up, just this once, if you can on the Sunday. - meet granny half way or something.

I see no reason to be unkind. You might need a favour of him one day. Make sure the kids have a card for him and SM.

Edited

OP's ex-DH was a controlling arsehole when she was married to him and still is now they are divorced.

He is the one that moved away but he makes OP drive half way every other weekend. She does this because otherwise he wouldn't bother seeing his own children.

She has no reason to be kind as he hasn't ever done a kind thing for her. She has a prior engagement on his weekend to have the kids.

Swipe left for the next trending thread