Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of people thinking vegetarian eat fish

333 replies

Dearaugust · 20/01/2025 13:52

Also, people who eat fish but not meat calling themselves vegetarian!

When people find out I’m vegetarian, a lot of people ask me if I eat fish. If I ate fish, then I wouldn’t be vegetarian! It wasn’t a big deal really, but an incident has happened recently where I was choosing a meal for a wedding and there was only meat options and a “none of these due to dietary preferences” option. So I ticked that. The person then contacted DH (it’s his friend who is getting married) and he explained I’m vegetarian. A few days later she said not to worry, they have sorted a fish meal for me. So he’s now had to go back to her again saying I don’t eat fish. What a faff!

I honestly thought it was common knowledge that vegetarians don’t eat fish. But apparently not because i get asked it a lot.

OP posts:
Housewife2010 · 21/01/2025 08:41

cordiallyuninvited · 21/01/2025 08:24

Pescetarians don't 'eat meat but not fish '. They eat fish, not other types of meat.

If fish 'isn't a type of meat', what do you propose it is? It is a type of animal flesh.

So you obviously didn't read my post immediately below this one where I corrected my typo?
Too ready to rush in and argue? 🤣

LoopyLoo1991 · 21/01/2025 08:40

RampantIvy · 21/01/2025 06:15

I'm glad for your daughter that she is a vegetarian. I just hope she's sensible and doesn't shout her choice at anyone in earshot

No, she doesn't. She is socially aware and not self righteous. What she eats is a personal choice. She doesn't object to other people's dietary choices.

I can't believe that you had a colleague who threw out people's lunches. I'm gobsmacked!

The arrest made the local paper I think?
The owner bought us pizzas and other takeouts after her rampage. We didn't get much work done for the rest that day apart from answering calls and emails.

She also had the audacity to attempt to take the firm to an industrial tribunal after all that!

NormaleKartoffeln · 21/01/2025 08:36

cordiallyuninvited · 21/01/2025 08:34

It doesn't always work that way though.

If someone is a vegetarian they should feel confident that when asking for a vegetarian option, their food is indeed, a vegetarian meal.

Allergies are a different example, but if someone is allergic to seafood and orders the vegetarian option, they should again be confident that this option is safe for them.
If people were clear on the definitions, this would not be a problem.

'I'll have the vegetarian option ' is fine to say, if you eat meat usually but just don't want to on the particular occasion. That harms nobody.

'I'm a vegetarian' then eating fish, is the reason some of these occurrences are not uncommon. If folk used the pescetarian word more often, it may help people know what it means.
If you'd rather not 'I eat fish, I don't eat any other meat' is fine too

'Vegetarian' when you eat fish/chicken/whatever and just not other types of meat, is not fine.

See also rather expensive 'naice' restaurant in London where the caeser salad had a big 'V' next to it..I can see how that could cause someone an allergic reaction.

If you work in catering, you should at least have some basic knowledge about food.

If you ask for the vegetarian option it should be meat free, because that's what vegetarian means. It's also ok to say you mostly eat vegetarian but sometimes have meat, if that's what you do. If anything that's further clarifying that meat isn't part of any vegetarian meal. By meat I mean any animal flesh, including fish and sea food.

cordiallyuninvited · 21/01/2025 08:34

NormaleKartoffeln · 21/01/2025 08:25

Anyone who is allergic to any food needs to double check what's in their meal.

It doesn't always work that way though.

If someone is a vegetarian they should feel confident that when asking for a vegetarian option, their food is indeed, a vegetarian meal.

Allergies are a different example, but if someone is allergic to seafood and orders the vegetarian option, they should again be confident that this option is safe for them.
If people were clear on the definitions, this would not be a problem.

'I'll have the vegetarian option ' is fine to say, if you eat meat usually but just don't want to on the particular occasion. That harms nobody.

'I'm a vegetarian' then eating fish, is the reason some of these occurrences are not uncommon. If folk used the pescetarian word more often, it may help people know what it means.
If you'd rather not 'I eat fish, I don't eat any other meat' is fine too

'Vegetarian' when you eat fish/chicken/whatever and just not other types of meat, is not fine.

See also rather expensive 'naice' restaurant in London where the caeser salad had a big 'V' next to it..I can see how that could cause someone an allergic reaction.

If you work in catering, you should at least have some basic knowledge about food.

NormaleKartoffeln · 21/01/2025 08:33

NeverHadHaveHas · 21/01/2025 08:29

FFS catch yourself on 🙄🙄 No one is saying that murder/smoking etc are comparable activities to eating meat or that eating meat is a crime.
What they are saying is that if you do anything - no matter what it is - a little bit, you can’t then use a label which suggests that you don’t do that thing AT ALL. Vegetarians do not eat meat, at all. You do eat meat, even if only on a rare occasion, therefore you are not a vegetarian.

Is it that hard for you to comprehend that 'mostly' means that someone occasionally isn't following the rules of said thing?

NormaleKartoffeln · 21/01/2025 08:32

cordiallyuninvited · 21/01/2025 08:27

It is comparible not because of the content but the theme of it.

'I'm teetotal ' means 'I don't drink alcohol. It doesn't mean 'I don't like going out drinking but I like a glass of wine at home'.
It could result in someone bringing you a bottle of non alcoholic wine when you'd not like that..or someone never offering you wine at a dinner party or something.

'I don't smoke' means 'I don't smoke'. It doesn't mean 'I don't smoke cigarettes but I like a cigar at special occasions'. This could be confusing for people.

Vegetarian means something.. and as a pp said, unless the dictionary definition of it changes, it's important for it to be used correctly.

See now I'm also mostly teetotal, in the same way I'm mostly vegetarian. It's safe to assume I'll happily not drink or eat meat, but on rare occasions I'll have a drink or eat some chicken. It doesn't affect other people in any way because I'm not saying meat is vegetarian or wine is non-alcoholic (though of course there are AF versions).

NeverHadHaveHas · 21/01/2025 08:29

NormaleKartoffeln · 21/01/2025 08:24

Not remotely comparable.
Murder is a crime.
Food choices are not crimes.

FFS catch yourself on 🙄🙄 No one is saying that murder/smoking etc are comparable activities to eating meat or that eating meat is a crime.
What they are saying is that if you do anything - no matter what it is - a little bit, you can’t then use a label which suggests that you don’t do that thing AT ALL. Vegetarians do not eat meat, at all. You do eat meat, even if only on a rare occasion, therefore you are not a vegetarian.

cordiallyuninvited · 21/01/2025 08:27

NormaleKartoffeln · 21/01/2025 08:24

Not remotely comparable.
Murder is a crime.
Food choices are not crimes.

It is comparible not because of the content but the theme of it.

'I'm teetotal ' means 'I don't drink alcohol. It doesn't mean 'I don't like going out drinking but I like a glass of wine at home'.
It could result in someone bringing you a bottle of non alcoholic wine when you'd not like that..or someone never offering you wine at a dinner party or something.

'I don't smoke' means 'I don't smoke'. It doesn't mean 'I don't smoke cigarettes but I like a cigar at special occasions'. This could be confusing for people.

Vegetarian means something.. and as a pp said, unless the dictionary definition of it changes, it's important for it to be used correctly.

NormaleKartoffeln · 21/01/2025 08:25

denhaag · 21/01/2025 08:13

Your live and let live policy falls down if you're served seafood as part of your vegetarian meal and are allergic to it.

Anyone who is allergic to any food needs to double check what's in their meal.

NormaleKartoffeln · 21/01/2025 08:24

Nameychangington · 21/01/2025 07:38

It is relevant, because it's another example of a thing you either are or aren't. You either are or aren't vegetarian. Like, you either are or aren't faithful to your partner - do you think 'mainly faithful' is the same as faithful? If you eat hardly any meat, you still eat meat. Which is your choice, I don't care what you eat, if you don't call yourself something you're not. Have the veggie option when eating out, everyone can, just don't call yourself a veggie.

People who call themselves vegetarian when they are not, cause issues for the people who are because it messes up the definition of a word which needs a clear definition, that's the point of the OP.

Again, your opinion is of no relevance to me. I'm mostly vegetarian.

cordiallyuninvited · 21/01/2025 08:24

Housewife2010 · 21/01/2025 06:39

Fish is not meat.
There is obviously a problem with pescetarians describing themselves incorrectly as vegetarians which impacts on actual vegetarians. I am suggesting that if pescetarians don't want to describe themselves as such they could just say that they don't eat meat. Or they eat meat but not fish. It's just an idea.

Pescetarians don't 'eat meat but not fish '. They eat fish, not other types of meat.

If fish 'isn't a type of meat', what do you propose it is? It is a type of animal flesh.

NormaleKartoffeln · 21/01/2025 08:24

DalzielOrNoDalzielAndDontPascoe · 21/01/2025 07:41

"I'm NOT a serial killer - because most of the time, I don't killer anybody at all!"

Not remotely comparable.
Murder is a crime.
Food choices are not crimes.

GutsyShark · 21/01/2025 08:16

This thread went in an odd direction.

Not sure why people get so excited about what others eat or don’t eat.

I know a lot of meat eaters who are far more fussy than vegetarians.

Eating vegetarian or just more vegetables more often would make us much healthier as a nation. If people achieve that by eating vegetarian then good for them, crack on.

I know there is a stereotype about militant vegans droning on about it but I’ve never met any personally.

denhaag · 21/01/2025 08:13

GreenWheat · 21/01/2025 08:11

Er, yes it is. It's full of people trying to explain why they are right and someone else is wrong. Live and let live, I am not arsehole either.

Your live and let live policy falls down if you're served seafood as part of your vegetarian meal and are allergic to it.

GreenWheat · 21/01/2025 08:11

RampantIvy · 21/01/2025 07:41

Er, no. It isn't.
It is just trying to explain the differences between people's dietary preferences.

That comment says a lot about you.
I'm not vegetarian, but I'm not an arsehole about people who are.

People who call themselves vegetarian when they are not, cause issues for the people who are because it messes up the definition of a word which needs a clear definition, that's the point of the OP.

I agree.

Edited

Er, yes it is. It's full of people trying to explain why they are right and someone else is wrong. Live and let live, I am not arsehole either.

DalzielOrNoDalzielAndDontPascoe · 21/01/2025 08:00

GreenWheat · 21/01/2025 07:12

This thread is very much becoming We are all speshul but some people are more speshul than others....

Not at all - and I say that as an omnivore.

There's a commonly-understood, clear word, that's existed throughout the English-speaking world for a long time, which is a way that people who choose not to eat the flesh of land or sea animals or any of their products for which they have to die to provide describe themselves.

Other people can find a different word for themselves, as they choose, but that word is already taken.

It's like Bob insisting that he's a Muslim - except he doesn't believe in Allah, reckons that Mohammed was just an ordinary man and not a prophet at all, maybe says the odd general prayer every now and then, but nothing like five times a day, gorges himself silly throughout most of Ramadan (although he does occasionally skip brekfast when he wakes up late), never reads the Qu'ran and definitely never wants to go to Mecca as it seems utterly pointless to him.

"Ah, but of course Bob IS a Muslim... he's just a different kind of Muslim from all of the others..."

Ameliepoulainandthephotobooth · 21/01/2025 07:52

My friend says that she’s vegetarian but eats chicken 😂

My Auntie used to offer me fish fingers every time I stayed with her. She thought that they were a treat because my parents give me ‘nut roast and tofu’ 😂

Rewis · 21/01/2025 07:49

I'd say majority of vegetarian I know eat fish. In everyday life I don't care. The problem is when I try to organise an event for hobbies for 30+ people (like a camp) and taken account every food restriction and then they come out and take something not intended for them. Or they can't eat something that has been prepared cause they're vegetarian but don't eat eggs. So I would absolutely love it when you sign your kid up, you'd specify if they are pescaterians or if they're vegetarians minus eggs or anything else.

DalzielOrNoDalzielAndDontPascoe · 21/01/2025 07:48

Housewife2010 · 21/01/2025 06:39

Fish is not meat.
There is obviously a problem with pescetarians describing themselves incorrectly as vegetarians which impacts on actual vegetarians. I am suggesting that if pescetarians don't want to describe themselves as such they could just say that they don't eat meat. Or they eat meat but not fish. It's just an idea.

How is fish not meat?

Which tree or plant does it grow on? Why does it have a face, animal-like vital organs and move around independently? Why does it resist when people kill it for food?

RampantIvy · 21/01/2025 07:41

GreenWheat · 21/01/2025 07:12

This thread is very much becoming We are all speshul but some people are more speshul than others....

Er, no. It isn't.
It is just trying to explain the differences between people's dietary preferences.

That comment says a lot about you.
I'm not vegetarian, but I'm not an arsehole about people who are.

People who call themselves vegetarian when they are not, cause issues for the people who are because it messes up the definition of a word which needs a clear definition, that's the point of the OP.

I agree.

DalzielOrNoDalzielAndDontPascoe · 21/01/2025 07:41

username299 · 21/01/2025 02:43

I knew a woman who insisted she was vegetarian because she only ate chicken and fish.

I've also met people who say they're vegetarian because they don't eat meat often.

🙄

"I'm NOT a serial killer - because most of the time, I don't killer anybody at all!"

Nameychangington · 21/01/2025 07:38

NormaleKartoffeln · 21/01/2025 07:26

It's not relevant to mention smoking.
I'm mainly vegetarian.
You don't get a say on it, no matter how much you think you do.

It is relevant, because it's another example of a thing you either are or aren't. You either are or aren't vegetarian. Like, you either are or aren't faithful to your partner - do you think 'mainly faithful' is the same as faithful? If you eat hardly any meat, you still eat meat. Which is your choice, I don't care what you eat, if you don't call yourself something you're not. Have the veggie option when eating out, everyone can, just don't call yourself a veggie.

People who call themselves vegetarian when they are not, cause issues for the people who are because it messes up the definition of a word which needs a clear definition, that's the point of the OP.

NormaleKartoffeln · 21/01/2025 07:26

NeverHadHaveHas · 21/01/2025 07:17

It is relevant you just don’t understand it.

It's not relevant to mention smoking.
I'm mainly vegetarian.
You don't get a say on it, no matter how much you think you do.

NeverHadHaveHas · 21/01/2025 07:17

NormaleKartoffeln · 21/01/2025 06:57

Where did I say 'I am a vegetarian' though? I didn't claim that. I'm mostly vegetarian not 100% vegetarian. It's more for personal reasons related to food textures etc and not for any ethical stance. The smoking point isn't relevant.

It is relevant you just don’t understand it.

GreenWheat · 21/01/2025 07:12

This thread is very much becoming We are all speshul but some people are more speshul than others....

Swipe left for the next trending thread