Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a Porsche?

115 replies

NaMaStayInBed1 · 19/01/2025 10:40

This is a bit deep so please be kind!

I grew up in a council house in the 80s/90s with the housewife Mum and manual low paid worker Dad, all good. In secondary school, I went to a school at the other side of town where most parents owned their house. As I got to 14/15 I began to feel inferior and poor, my school trousers had holes in the crotch whilst my friends wore Tammy Girl. I went on to have a child at 18 and threw myself into being a Mum and fighting the stereotype of a teen Mum, would go to many baby groups. Because of my age, I again felt inferior and I was a size 20 so lacked confidence. I later went to Uni and have a fantastic career and have lost weight and feel good. Still don't own my home but live in a lovely area, we may buy but mortgage rates and economic instability have put us off - rent is cheap and we dont have to worry about unexpected repairs.

I currently drive an Audi, and previously a Merc. I'm looking at my next car and want to step up in prestige so for a long time have said it would be a Porsche family car.

I heard someone say the other day on TV "stop spending money on things you don't need to impress people you don't like" and it has made me question my motives!

TLDR: My career and car make me feel like I can hold my head up high. Things that need me feel inferior: growing up in a council house at school with mostly fanilies who owned their homes, being a teen Mum, being obese. I am very proud of my career and now want a Porsche to replace my Audi. I have always felt that people have looked down on me/had an inferiority complex and things like this grow my confidence.

YABU: you probably don't really want a Porsche, you are just trying to impress people

YANBU: A Porsche is a sign of doing well and will make you feel good to reach a new goal

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
jasjas3008 · 20/01/2025 08:12

No one is impressed by a Porsche SUV, could just as easily be a Hyundai at first glance.... you want, no need, a 911, thats the only Porsche worth having.

But in the UK, a total waste of time, poor roads, heavily congested and you could go to jail if you used just a small amount of its performance

Stick to a VW Golf etc.

BrickBiscuit · 20/01/2025 08:07

ssd · 19/01/2025 16:35

Did you read what i said?
"Buy your porsche and get on with showing off"

Its obvious why she wants it but its her money so why not

That's not the point. It could backfire, as OP doesn't seem to know the car tropes.
Range Rover: Chelsea tractor, can't park for toffee;
Audi: new money, no indicators;
Lexus: drug dealer;
Boxster: poor man's Porsche;
and so on.

littlemisssunshine247 · 19/01/2025 22:28

Is the OP coming back or was this just a waste of everyone's advice I wonder?

deeahgwitch · 19/01/2025 18:53

Zanatdy · 19/01/2025 10:42

If I didn’t own my own home then I wouldn’t be spending money on fast expensive cars personally.

This 💯
By owning our home ( we have a mortgage ) it means ultimately we can leave the house to the children for whatever it will be worth when we're dead.
It should give them a few bob.
I know care home fees might swallow it all up but fingers crossed there will be something left.

PurdyPaws · 19/01/2025 17:05

Work on your self esteem. You don't need a certain type of car to prove anything. It's a highway to nowhere. Put the money into your house deposit instead.

CandidHedgehog · 19/01/2025 16:49

ssd · 19/01/2025 16:35

Did you read what i said?
"Buy your porsche and get on with showing off"

Its obvious why she wants it but its her money so why not

I read what you said but you don’t appear to have understood what I said. Buying a Porsche won’t work for showing off because many people don’t see Porsche drivers the way the OP thinks they do.

How people view what you are wearing / driving etc. is fairly important when the reason for doing so is to impress people!

superplumb · 19/01/2025 16:43

I must be old fashioned but buying expensive cars while renting to be is nuts.
Id always get property secure before spending on expensive cars.

Like a poster mentioned above...it isn't like the 80s..most cars on the roads are lease or pcp so not exactly impressive nowadays in the same way it used to be.

ssd · 19/01/2025 16:35

CandidHedgehog · 19/01/2025 16:25

The thing is though, the OP isn’t saying she wants a Porsche because of the engineering or the handling or similar. She says she wants a Porsche because of the badge and because what other people will think of her driving it.

It’s therefore hardly surprising that people are telling her what they would think if they saw someone driving a Porsche.

Did you read what i said?
"Buy your porsche and get on with showing off"

Its obvious why she wants it but its her money so why not

VivX · 19/01/2025 16:33

Definitely buy a house before a fancy car.
Buying a flashy car before a house just says terrible financial priorities.

CandidHedgehog · 19/01/2025 16:25

ssd · 19/01/2025 15:27

Only on mn would you read an audi is embarrassing and you can get a poor mans porsches...

Op why are you even asking here, surely you know mn is the most class obsessed site there is, full of posters asking how they cant afford kids whilst earning 100k a year?

Buy your porsche and get on with showing off

The thing is though, the OP isn’t saying she wants a Porsche because of the engineering or the handling or similar. She says she wants a Porsche because of the badge and because what other people will think of her driving it.

It’s therefore hardly surprising that people are telling her what they would think if they saw someone driving a Porsche.

LadyLolaRuben · 19/01/2025 16:03

I've been considering a porsch but as others have pointed out, I've decided to get my next house sorted first. Houses with deposits, legal fees, decorating etc is expensive. That's before having a good pension, savings and emergency fund in place.

At the end of the day, as PP has said a porsch is just a VW - as nice as some of them are. Don't forget running costs.

I've had a few prestige cars and the down sides are jealous people/ vandals and not always being able to relax when parked in certain places when there's no other choice. Also, when alone I've been conscious of having a car outside the house at night that thieves may want the keys for.

I decided it wasn't worth the hassle.

Dont chase the badge. There's plenty you've got ahead of you that requires money and will give a better financial return. If a porsch is about your childhood I'd consider counselling...

BIossomtoes · 19/01/2025 16:03

A porsche will only impress wanna be rich people

It will also impress people who are into nice cars.

EternalSunshine19 · 19/01/2025 16:00

Zanatdy · 19/01/2025 10:42

If I didn’t own my own home then I wouldn’t be spending money on fast expensive cars personally.

This!
I would rather own my own home than an expensive car. I know this is some status symbol to you, but nothing depreciates more than new car. its a waste of money.
If your rent is cheap thats great, but the landlord might want their home back or to sell one day. Its unstable and who wants to be renting for the rest of their lives?

LoveMySushi · 19/01/2025 15:55

A porsche will only impress wanna be rich people. So it depends what your end goal is.
To me a porsche doesnt scream rich, because i wouldnt struggle to afford it (well depends what kind of porsche of course). There is such a high price difference between the most expensive and the cheapest porsche 🤷🏻‍♀️
Most people i know who have money dont study other peoples cars and think “wow, a porsche, she must be doing well”
unless its a very special one.

Especially if you dont own your home yet, they will just think you have no clue how to handle your money.

Nofixedname · 19/01/2025 15:51

Get a Porsche, then you will want a Ferrari, then get a Ferrari, you will want a Rolls...
Two cars in the drive & F all in the fridge springs to mind too.

Nomorecountingbeans · 19/01/2025 15:51

Zanatdy · 19/01/2025 10:42

If I didn’t own my own home then I wouldn’t be spending money on fast expensive cars personally.

This OP

aim for the stable home for your children.

I can relate to you as I also grew up very poor with rich peers. I wasted wayy too much money in my early 20s to try and compensate in some way.

cars depreciate in value houses tend not too, that’s if you are buying the car outright! If you’re thinking of doing car finance then def not! Some of those agreements are basically renting the car.

Newusername3kidss · 19/01/2025 15:49

Please don’t buy a Porsche. I say this with kindness as I am from a working class background so I get it but there is nothing impressive about getting a Porsche and still renting a house. True success / wealth is owning own home, good pension, savings. We are wealthy. I have an old car as honestly don’t care about cars. My husband has a Tesla as it’s appropriate for him to drive an electric car with his work. We paid off our house, have brilliant pensions, ISAs, investments and travel a lot. Cars just don’t matter that much. Use the money to buy a house / get stability with savings / investments. A car loses value the moment you drive it off the forecourt

Drfosters · 19/01/2025 15:45

I totally get where you are coming from but I’m not convinced the car will give you the validation you need. It is a bit like young girls carrying around designer handbags that cost thousands but they live at home with their parents and can never dream of moving out.

you are doing very well for yourself but you need to consider you need to keep up the momentum. Save for the house deposit and those sort of costs.

i once bought myself a watch as a bit of a present to myself. Cost a few grand but gave me a bit of the validation internally that I had worked hard for something that was just for me. Watches also tend to hold their value well.

EvilNextDoor · 19/01/2025 15:40

Putting aside the house issue and issues you need sorting with therapy..

I have a Porsche and love it but I wouldn’t buy one again.

They are expensive and depending on the model have a lot of issues do your research and basic maintenance is 20/30% more expensive.

Do not touch the electric ones - even on pcp your car is not worth the outstanding money owed.

They are not the car they used to be

GrumpyPanda · 19/01/2025 15:32

Buy it if you really really like the car and not the prestige, but definitely go for a second hand model. Absolutely no point in buying anything younger than 3 years old unless you can claim it as a business expense.

Ledwood85 · 19/01/2025 15:29

Some interesting takes in this thread! Some practical, some envious. Wow.

As a car person myself, OP, I get it.

But, as others have correctly stated, a nice-to-have like this should come after you have all your financial ducks in a row and everything else is set.
Absolutely agree with the PP who said something like this should be a cash purchase - like any other treat (fashion item, bag, swiss watch).

Some models won't depreciate, some will even appreciate (although it sounds like you'll be looking at an SUV rather than a GT sports car, so yeah - you'll lose money). Maintenance is agonizingly expensive. Never allow yourself to get lured in by a bargain used car. "There's nothing more expensive than a cheap Porsche" is a term my mechanic uses.

But all that said, you need to buy something for the right reasons. If you want to make YOU happy and are doing it because it's something that has always been a "you" thing, then yes - if you're in a position to go for it, then go for it.
Don't do this to impress others, don't do it from a place of insecurity.

ssd · 19/01/2025 15:27

Only on mn would you read an audi is embarrassing and you can get a poor mans porsches...

Op why are you even asking here, surely you know mn is the most class obsessed site there is, full of posters asking how they cant afford kids whilst earning 100k a year?

Buy your porsche and get on with showing off

BrickBiscuit · 19/01/2025 15:11

Research what model you buy, or petrolheads will mutter 'Poor man's Porsche' as you drive past.

Mirrorxxx · 19/01/2025 15:10

An Audi is already an embarrassing try hard car. Please don’t waste money on a car when you don’t even own a home

MoveToParis · 19/01/2025 15:09

CandyLeBonBon · 19/01/2025 10:42

You'd be better off spending the money on therapy to deal with your crippling insecurities.

You've done well for yourself but instead your need for external validation is your entire identity. THAT's very unhealthy and very unsustainable. If you lose your job or get a health issue that stops you working, your entire identity goes out of the window.

Yes this is it.