Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be a teacher who is now looking for a career as a barrister or a solicitor

180 replies

Amammai · 18/01/2025 22:44

I’m posting from a point of the complete unknown.

Would a move from being a primary school teacher (18 years experience) to a solicitor or barrister be a completely ridiculous move?

An Instagram recruitment post from the CPS caught my eye and I’m now down a rabbit hole of research. Something about these roles has really caught my interest and I think this could be a potential career pathway for me.

There are many aspects of teaching I still love but after 18 years, I am questioning how much more I can give to the role.

So, has anyone trained as a solicitor or barrister at a ‘later point’ (I’m 40!) Would the move from teaching be doable? Am I kidding myself I could actually do it??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
honeylulu · 12/02/2025 19:56

MrsPinkCock · 12/02/2025 17:11

I’m currently trying to recruit for around 0-4PQE, up north, and the applications are from people expecting 60-75k, when in most cases they only have six months real experience and would require very heavy supervision. I’m amazed anyone would accept 50k in the city!

You are right, and they mostly don't accept it, hence the problem! Insurance law work was traditionally a nice mid point between high street and proper city work but it's no longer sustainable due to the rates. Roll on retirement!

TizerorFizz · 12/02/2025 18:26

I don’t think they do! DD has friends working for city solicitors (2 with American firms), they are very soon on £150,000 plus and then swiftly upwards. My God they work though!

MrsPinkCock · 12/02/2025 17:11

honeylulu · 12/02/2025 14:33

Solicitor here.

You may be overestimating the salary (compared to a senior teacher) and underestimating the workload. There are solicitors in the public sector (not just CPS but local authorities etc) and the workload and conditions are decent but the pay is a lot less than commercial lawyers in the City, where the hours are commensurately excessive. To be fair though, I don't know much about the public sector so it might be worth researching further.

I work in the City but for mainly insurer clients. Pay is OK at my level (salaried partner - £130k) but I sometimes think not amazing for 20+ years experience, high responsibility and high hours/stress. Often 60+ hour weeks at busy times and no less than 40 at less busy times and no school holidays for reprieve. I do enjoy it though. I think you really have to love this job to keep going. My friend who is a bilingual PA for a financial organisation in the City strictly 9-5, earns nearly the same salary as me. Are you fluent in another language OP? Just saying ...

We have real trouble recruiting and retaining juniors though as pay has really stagnated because insurance firms have not increased rates for getting on for 20 years. A NQ salary of £50k sounds good until they realise they have to bear the cost of commuting to or living in London and work a 50 hour week.

We did have a trainee a few years ago who had been a teacher. She did qualify but then went back to teaching as she found the hours and commuting (she had a primary school aged child) too difficult.

I’m currently trying to recruit for around 0-4PQE, up north, and the applications are from people expecting 60-75k, when in most cases they only have six months real experience and would require very heavy supervision. I’m amazed anyone would accept 50k in the city!

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 12/02/2025 14:37

I'm a solicitor and I would not do this.

You could apply for the civil service, perhaps in an education related role to start with, and then over time try to engineer a move to another policy area which interests you.

honeylulu · 12/02/2025 14:33

Solicitor here.

You may be overestimating the salary (compared to a senior teacher) and underestimating the workload. There are solicitors in the public sector (not just CPS but local authorities etc) and the workload and conditions are decent but the pay is a lot less than commercial lawyers in the City, where the hours are commensurately excessive. To be fair though, I don't know much about the public sector so it might be worth researching further.

I work in the City but for mainly insurer clients. Pay is OK at my level (salaried partner - £130k) but I sometimes think not amazing for 20+ years experience, high responsibility and high hours/stress. Often 60+ hour weeks at busy times and no less than 40 at less busy times and no school holidays for reprieve. I do enjoy it though. I think you really have to love this job to keep going. My friend who is a bilingual PA for a financial organisation in the City strictly 9-5, earns nearly the same salary as me. Are you fluent in another language OP? Just saying ...

We have real trouble recruiting and retaining juniors though as pay has really stagnated because insurance firms have not increased rates for getting on for 20 years. A NQ salary of £50k sounds good until they realise they have to bear the cost of commuting to or living in London and work a 50 hour week.

We did have a trainee a few years ago who had been a teacher. She did qualify but then went back to teaching as she found the hours and commuting (she had a primary school aged child) too difficult.

TizerorFizz · 12/02/2025 13:44

If the OP wants to be a barrister, the training centres have careers advice and people can start networking. The Inns of court are there for you too. Qualifications are only part of the cv and what’s needed. DD volunteered at a cab amongst other things. It’s a case of building up a worthwhile cv if you don’t have Oxbridge law degree.

Whyamiherenow · 12/02/2025 07:48

Not your question but someone I manage was a solicitor for a long time. Re trained as a primary school teacher and did that for a few years. Returned to work as a solicitor who I now manage. I believe the move to return to work as a solicitor was largely money driven. So I guess it depends what you would like to do and achieve from it.

You are never too old to pursue your dreams if it really is your dream.

Perhaps try some volunteering? And / or pick up a distance learning course with CILEx law school - they aren’t too expensive and are reputable.

TizerorFizz · 12/02/2025 00:07

DD does no legal aid. Once in a blue moon maybe when it doesn’t go elsewhere. It’s not her area of practice. I do know she’s done some high profile cases pro bono for cv! Legal aid will not pay the mortgage.

WomanFromTheNorth · 11/02/2025 23:51

TizerorFizz · 09/02/2025 09:38

Any decent family barrister earns more than a teacher! If you specialise in divorce you certainly should! Some little backstreet solicitors is another matter. As I said doing legal aid work is barely paying the bills!

Barrister maybe, but not a solicitor doing legal aid family work. I've done both and there's not much difference in salary.

TizerorFizz · 11/02/2025 23:45

@LavenderHaze19 I too believe many teachers think they work more than anyone else. Law is long hours and if you are a barrister and self employed, no fees if you don’t work!

Chambers of barristers don’t sponsor anyone. The Inns of Court offer competitive scholarships towards course fees and some are means tested and some are not. If you are a really good candidate, you might get a very large scholarship.

LavenderHaze19 · 11/02/2025 22:02

Most of my teacher friends think that every other profession is paid a lot more money for doing a lot less work and under less pressure than teaching. - it simply isn't true. In a few cases maybe, but not across tbe board. Be very clear about that.
Whilst I know that teachers spend time working during the holidays, they aren't doing 12-14 hour days throughout the holidays - don't underestimate the value of the break from the relentless pressure for many more weeks that you would in another high pressure profession.

I think there’s a lot of truth in this. I’m not suggesting that teaching is an easy job, it’s definitely not. But I have noticed that in the teaching profession there seems to be a victimhood culture. A lot of jobs are extremely high-pressured and stressful, and come with only 4 or 5 weeks’ annual leave, which you may or may not be able to take at a time to suit you (I’m currently battling with my employer over when I can take my annual leave this year). Lots of people aren’t guaranteed any holiday round Christmas - or even holiday on Christmas Day if you work for the emergency services or the NHS for example.

LavenderHaze19 · 11/02/2025 21:53

Sorry if this has already been mentioned, but law school is incredibly expensive unless you get sponsored through it by a law firm or chambers (and I’m not actually sure whether chambers typically offer sponsorship).

wigjockey · 11/02/2025 21:48

Yes the Bar Council report I posted was making the point that 20-40% needs to come off gross earnings to understand what someone is actually making in income (before tax). So that would include rent, clerking fees, insurance, practising cert, research materials, etc. My accountant (who specialises in barrister accounts) tells me around 25% is typical at the commercial bar. Other areas of practice will differ.

LondonLawyer · 11/02/2025 20:22

HausofHolbein · 11/02/2025 15:44

Bloody hell. I'm in a huge (mixed) set and our rent is about 17%. 40% is insane and not something I'd ever heard of.

(I obviously don't include practicing cert, insurance, tax, travel, etc in that).

I think the 40% was including all of that, though, in the links someone posted, not just rent. Rents I've heard of are 14-22% ish (I'm no expert on "Chambers' rents: a comparative study")

TizerorFizz · 11/02/2025 19:23

@HausofHolbein DD hasn’t either but - the newly qualified end of the criminal bar make very little. So that’s probably where the figure comes from.

HausofHolbein · 11/02/2025 15:44

Bloody hell. I'm in a huge (mixed) set and our rent is about 17%. 40% is insane and not something I'd ever heard of.

(I obviously don't include practicing cert, insurance, tax, travel, etc in that).

TizerorFizz · 11/02/2025 14:59

@LondonLawyer Yes. I do see all of that. Fixed tenancy costs are more expensive for those at the baby junior end though. A % is fairer.

LondonLawyer · 11/02/2025 14:49

TizerorFizz · 11/02/2025 13:23

@LondonLawyer Thats a big jump to 40% though. It’s surely only that if you are earning at the lower end? DD rarely does overnights. Long criminal trials are different and it wholly depends on where you practice, courts you go to and what solicitors use you. It’s not a standard set of costs. Also Chambers cover some costs.

Varies hugely. The costs of insurance and practising certificate go up as fee income goes up. Insurance also varies MASSIVELY depending on the area of law and limit on cover. Some barristers will travel a lot more, at greater expense, than others.

Words · 11/02/2025 13:36

My friend works for the CPS . Over 30 days' holiday, plus flexi, work from home three days a week unless at court. Good policies regarding sickness, disabilities, caring needs etc.

As in any job, a good manager can make the world of difference, and a bad one not so much.

Salaries are solid but not startling as far as I can tell. As with anything you would start on the very routine stuff but she played her cards right and now has a very interesting, if heavy, caseload.

TizerorFizz · 11/02/2025 13:23

@LondonLawyer Thats a big jump to 40% though. It’s surely only that if you are earning at the lower end? DD rarely does overnights. Long criminal trials are different and it wholly depends on where you practice, courts you go to and what solicitors use you. It’s not a standard set of costs. Also Chambers cover some costs.

LondonLawyer · 11/02/2025 13:03

TizerorFizz · 11/02/2025 10:58

@wigjockey I guess for some it might be but DD is a barrister and her outgoings are nowhere near that. She pays 20% to chambers and has other expenses but not 40% and pays tax on substantial earnings

I was extremely interested to look at earnings data too. Hers appears very high for age! I’m rather pleased for her. Less good is the position of women and earnings overall but DD is bucking that trend too. So I guess it’s like most careers, you make your own luck. Being self employed galvanizes some! The CPS would be well below I would guess.

However for the purpose of this thread, overall a teacher who really wants to be a barrister should consider what area of law and cost of training as well as likelihood of getting pupillage. Go into an area of law you know something about and play to your strengths. So commercial is probably out. The most likely to succeed will get a healthy financial scholarship from the Inn of Court they join and all of this should be investigated.

Chambers' contributions vary - some are % of all fee income, some are flat fee, some are a mixture of both. DD's 20% is highish but not outside the normal range, as I understand it. On top of that are insurance, practising certificate, IT costs, travel to court, accommodation if overnights, CPD, all sorts of things.

DivergentTris · 11/02/2025 11:33

I work closely with the CPS and I would NOT go and do it having experienced working with them as a partner agency - I do not rate them at all.

TizerorFizz · 11/02/2025 11:26

Just starting out and not on fixed % would be very difficult. It’s always difficult after pupillage anyway.

wigjockey · 11/02/2025 11:10

TizerorFizz · 11/02/2025 10:58

@wigjockey I guess for some it might be but DD is a barrister and her outgoings are nowhere near that. She pays 20% to chambers and has other expenses but not 40% and pays tax on substantial earnings

I was extremely interested to look at earnings data too. Hers appears very high for age! I’m rather pleased for her. Less good is the position of women and earnings overall but DD is bucking that trend too. So I guess it’s like most careers, you make your own luck. Being self employed galvanizes some! The CPS would be well below I would guess.

However for the purpose of this thread, overall a teacher who really wants to be a barrister should consider what area of law and cost of training as well as likelihood of getting pupillage. Go into an area of law you know something about and play to your strengths. So commercial is probably out. The most likely to succeed will get a healthy financial scholarship from the Inn of Court they join and all of this should be investigated.

Good for her. It sounds like she is doing well.

Every chambers has a slightly different fee structure. Some just apply a %, others have a fixed rent element. If you are just starting out or have a bad year, a fixed element can obviously mean you are paying a higher percentage of your fees to chambers. And then you have other expenses on top.

I agree with your last paragraph. The Inn scholarships look good on your CV as well as providing financial assistance.

TizerorFizz · 11/02/2025 10:58

@wigjockey I guess for some it might be but DD is a barrister and her outgoings are nowhere near that. She pays 20% to chambers and has other expenses but not 40% and pays tax on substantial earnings

I was extremely interested to look at earnings data too. Hers appears very high for age! I’m rather pleased for her. Less good is the position of women and earnings overall but DD is bucking that trend too. So I guess it’s like most careers, you make your own luck. Being self employed galvanizes some! The CPS would be well below I would guess.

However for the purpose of this thread, overall a teacher who really wants to be a barrister should consider what area of law and cost of training as well as likelihood of getting pupillage. Go into an area of law you know something about and play to your strengths. So commercial is probably out. The most likely to succeed will get a healthy financial scholarship from the Inn of Court they join and all of this should be investigated.