Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this a financial mistake? Help please

183 replies

Subjk · 17/01/2025 13:29

I have a 2 year old and have recently been gifted 80k. If I paid off some of my mortgage with this I would owe 150k. I’m 35.

The schools round here are absolutely awful. I can’t move area as I need family support so I have to stay.

Yesterday I looked round a private school which is 20k a year including vat. Me and ex are on good terms and he pays 1,200 a month. He won’t pay school fees but has said he will increase monthly payments to 1,500 if I choose private.

What would you do? I don’t have a high income my take home is 2,400. I am worried for dd and feel a bit lost with what to do. Please help!

OP posts:
NosyJosie · 18/01/2025 23:30

You can’t afford private school. Simple as that.

You also can’t afford to make that big of a financial commitment for 13+ years of school based on your ex. His circumstances can change. What if you or he has more kids?

Knock some off your mortgage, start a junior isa/child trust fund for your kid, put some in pension savings for yourself, have a small emergency fund in case you lose your income.

Quiinkong · 18/01/2025 23:10

Subjk · 17/01/2025 13:29

I have a 2 year old and have recently been gifted 80k. If I paid off some of my mortgage with this I would owe 150k. I’m 35.

The schools round here are absolutely awful. I can’t move area as I need family support so I have to stay.

Yesterday I looked round a private school which is 20k a year including vat. Me and ex are on good terms and he pays 1,200 a month. He won’t pay school fees but has said he will increase monthly payments to 1,500 if I choose private.

What would you do? I don’t have a high income my take home is 2,400. I am worried for dd and feel a bit lost with what to do. Please help!

Best savings accounts: 5.1% easy access or 4.77% fixed rates https://search.app/dHpZmQ4A7WpDUDGu8

Chip has a savings account 4.85% with 3 withdrawals a year or 4.71% unlimited withdrawal. The interest will be nearly 4k a year if you put the 80k all in.

Laurmolonlabe · 18/01/2025 23:00

Private primary school education is a waste of time- primary school is just t get them reading and writing and adding up, even if they are awful in your area a little extra tuition will bring DD up to speed.
I would invest the money for her future- if the investment goes well you may be able to afford private secondary school for her, if that seems needful, or it could help her onto the property ladder.
Taking home £2400 per month, with your ex paying £1200 in per month means you should be overpaying your mortgage substantially every month already, as you have £3600 coming in and can't be paying much more than £1200 on your mortgage.

Toptops · 18/01/2025 22:50

Oh, and we both worked full time so no sahp

Toptops · 18/01/2025 22:48

ForRealCat · 17/01/2025 13:54

I'd overpay the 10% on your mortgage that you can do without penalty, max out an ISA an then bung the rest in premium bonds. I'd then use the interest on the savings accounts to overpay the mortgage in the next couple of years.

80k wont go far on private schooling, but if you can reduce your mortgage substantially by time your child is 5 and starting school you'll have a lot more disposable income which can make the world of difference.

Don't spend your money on private education - why would you?
Send your kid to the nearest best primary and put your effort into backing them up with reading, homework etc.
Do the same with secondary and you can put that money towards their deposit.
I'm forever surprised at the thing on Mumsnet that private is better somehow than state.
We have 3 kids who all went to state schools, despite an offer from a relative to pay for private.
That didn't sit well with us and our values.
We don't live in a posh area at all, just chose the schools that suited our kids and they were happy with.
They've all done very well, youngest despite all the acronym disabilities you could name, about to get a doctorate.

Teenagehorrorbag · 18/01/2025 22:43

Agree with PPs - your child will be fine at a state primary. Unless your local schools are full of drugs and violence then I would save your money. If you feel she needs private for secondary then save for that, I think that is where you really get value for the money.

But do look into your local secondary schools in detail. If you have other children by the time your LO starts secondary - then what?

Horses7 · 18/01/2025 22:33

Buy a smaller/cheaper house in a good area/good school area.

Dogsbreath7 · 18/01/2025 21:41

Pay down the mortgage - that will increase free income to pay for tutoring.

coukd also consider 6th form for private with longer time frame to save. Whats your postcode- you may find that unis may give lower offer if in a certain quartile.

Mrsgreen100 · 18/01/2025 21:38

Minor private school, cost from 10 years old though to sixth form .
close to 350 thousand, including uniform ( endless)
and trips ( regular) all the way out extra costs you can’t even imagine!
wish I’d paid off my mortgage and had a lump sum invested for my son ,
the state school in our area was , is horrendous, drugs knife crime etc
so I felt I had no choice,
it’s left me broke and wishing I had simply moved tbh
the one thing I hadn’t considered in great measure was the fact that my sons class mates where from very wealthy families ,
all holidaying in expensive exotic places
birthday parties lavish etc , still have not had a holiday in 15 years
theres more to life tbh ,
if you can get tutoring outside of school if you’re worried about education standards
id go that route In hindsight

Althenameshavegone · 18/01/2025 21:29

50k in premium bonds, 20k in stocks and shares isa (vanguard or similar), £5k in a decent savings account or cash ISA and £5k in junior S&S isa for your DD. If you’re On a Fixed rate mortgage then next time it’s up for remortgage I’d potentially pay off a chunk from the premium bonds to see if it gets you a better rate. Otherwise drip feed savings into the stocks and shares isa. That’s of course if you’re ok with risk etc.

FozzieP · 18/01/2025 21:18

Your £80000 would pay for four years and what then? Treat yourself and then put it in your mortgage.

CharlotteCChapel · 18/01/2025 21:01

We sent our eldest to a private school, he got a scholarship so we paid half fees. It was the same school that DH and DFiL went to. I had no say in the matter. With help from the ILs we could afford it. However by the fourth year he was there (not yr 4 but what we called the 4th form) the fees had risen so much it was difficult to pay for them. DH refused to pull him out as we would have to pay for the next term anyway.

As I result of this we have a son who is angry about going to the school as he felt out of place. Things like other children discussing their ski trips when he stayed at his grandparents for a couple of days.

There will be people on here saying you can only get a decent job if you went to a private school. Bollocks, my private school educated son thinks the world owes him a living whilst my son who went to the local comp is going to start his doctorate this year

LondonLawyer · 18/01/2025 20:47

Elle2018 · 18/01/2025 18:07

It’s not just the fees that are expensive with private schools it’s the other costs too, uniforms, trips etc plus if you can’t fund into secondary then there isn’t much point just funding primary. I’d look at the mortgage, if your current interest rate is less than you can get in a savings account I’d put the money in savings and pay off the mortgage when rates move the other way or when you next remortgage or go onto a new deal.

I don't think that's necessarily true - I know plenty of people who do or have done private primary and state secondary. Like us. Our sons both went to the same private primary, DS1 has just left a state comprehensive and DS2 will be going to the same comp next year.

There are also lots of people who live in areas with grammar schools who do private primary and grammar secondary.

Curtainseeker · 18/01/2025 20:43

Enquire about bursaries at the private school now that may give you an idea if they’d offer you a discount based on your income/expenditure and assets

Britinme · 18/01/2025 20:04

I'd do a combination of what's suggested above by @Lovetoplan2 and @Y737 . Pay down the mortgage with £50k (which will save you a lot of interest payment in the long run), put £20k in a stocks and shares ISA and put £10k in an interest-bearing account you can add to as necessary from your maintenance payment to act as a cash cushion in case your DC needs extra help with maths or English.

Y737 · 18/01/2025 19:47

If I didn’t like the school, I would put £10k aside for a private tutor in case child if you think falls behind at any stage and needs extra tuition in maths and English in final years before secondary school

Lovetoplan2 · 18/01/2025 19:36

Subjk · 17/01/2025 13:29

I have a 2 year old and have recently been gifted 80k. If I paid off some of my mortgage with this I would owe 150k. I’m 35.

The schools round here are absolutely awful. I can’t move area as I need family support so I have to stay.

Yesterday I looked round a private school which is 20k a year including vat. Me and ex are on good terms and he pays 1,200 a month. He won’t pay school fees but has said he will increase monthly payments to 1,500 if I choose private.

What would you do? I don’t have a high income my take home is 2,400. I am worried for dd and feel a bit lost with what to do. Please help!

I would put 20k in a stocks and shares ISA invested in a fund such as VUSA and use the remaining 60k to pay down the mortgage.

Janus · 18/01/2025 19:31

I think I’d pay off a chunk of the mortgage but keep
some in reserve too. Tutors can really help, in our experience we used them for gcse maths and one A Level (for different children). Also if your child goes to uni then accommodation is now crazy and often big deposits need to be paid for the following year house but in the first year. You will need reserves. Then there’s the cost of driving lessons, etc, it never ends!!

BeMellowOchreZebra · 18/01/2025 19:31

Subjk · 18/01/2025 19:09

Thank you! I am on the side of the mortgage now and then saving again all over for secondary perhaps

Private schools have their advantages but what makes the biggest difference in a child's life is quality time with parents.

Pay off some of the mortgage then when your child is old enough, take them to see the world and do stuff together. Make memories.

I inherited a bit from my grandad and am planning on doing some travelling with my kids.

CheesePerlease · 18/01/2025 19:29

Private doesn't necessarily mean better

CheesePerlease · 18/01/2025 19:28

Spend money on tutors instead, when they need it.

JuniperKeats · 18/01/2025 19:26

Pay off your all or part of mortgage, you will save more than investments can generate.

Lovelybitofsquirrel3 · 18/01/2025 19:25

I think if you want to invest in your childs education it's best to give them a tutor, books, and things you can buy yourself

Subjk · 18/01/2025 19:09

Thank you! I am on the side of the mortgage now and then saving again all over for secondary perhaps

OP posts:
Single50something · 18/01/2025 18:56

The fees are much lower in early years..but they go up with age. It's also the extras..I went to private school in 6th form and a friend went on a scholarship. His mum worked all hours for the extra bits..uniform/lots of sports kit/trips/crammer course as one teacher was rubbish and the school knew we'd all fail the subject etc etc.
Maybe see if in time can get a scholarship and then use some money for extras. The money will soon go :(