Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Where am I going wrong in my diet?

110 replies

PrettyHungry · 16/01/2025 13:20

I’ve been dieting since Jan 1st and have only lost 4lbs. I know to some that would seem loads but I would have expected a little more by now.

Ive been really strict. This is my average daily food:

Breakfast - sugar free latte from Starbucks (medium) - 150cals.

Lunch - slice of Jason’s sourdough, topped with smoked salmon and 2 eggs - 400 ish cals. No butter!

Dinner - M&S count on us range ready meal or home cooked dinner with salad. I always make sure half the plate is salad with no dressing - 500 ish cals.

I only have sugar free, zero calorie drinks like Pepsi Max. I only ever snack on berries and not every day, maybe 3-4 days a week if I’m a little peckish in between meetings or in the evening.

That’s just over 1,000 calories a day. Even with a little wiggle room to account for errors in weighing or underestimating, I’m still way under. Any ideas for how I can speed up my weight loss? I don’t like exercising so would rather diet related suggestions.

I’m 5’6 and 11st 4lbs.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PurpleSneakers · 23/03/2025 20:43

This diet isn’t sustainable long term.
Focus on protein for breakfast for satiety and to stabilise BGL.
Cook from scratch - you have control over what you are putting into your meals (ie. sodium content, using healthy oils)
Nourish your body - plenty of fruits and veg for antioxidants.
Drink water - 2.5 L per day.

Flyhigher · 23/03/2025 20:33

Drink water. Not fizzy drinks.

Wantitalltogoaway · 22/01/2025 14:33

changecandles · 16/01/2025 19:16

Starvation mode has been debunked so many times by so many scientists for so long I'm amazed anyone still thinks it's a thing.

It might not be a scientifically accurate term but it’s generally understood that crash dieting like this disrupts your metabolism.

NewMe2024 · 17/01/2025 14:28

TiramisuThief · 16/01/2025 14:43

🙄🙄🙄🙄

Do you never hear people refer to the usual coke as full fat? It's a joke, I'm not literally suggesting it has fat in it. Good lord.

If OP wants to drink something sweet, she's far better off imo having a can of the real stuff.

Yes we all know that SuGAr Is BaaaaaD for you but honestly you have to live a little as well. Don't give up all the treats. A cold can of coke is fine now and then.

It was just a response to the fact that you described Coke as satiating. It isn’t, it’s the opposite - the sugar sets you up for a crash that will leave you craving more.

Fully agree with the general point you are making about taking a balanced view.

FancyAnxiety · 16/01/2025 19:51

I know not everyone is a fan, but WW has worked for me. I hardly eat any UPFs. Whole grain carbs at every meal otherwise I’m miserable. Lots of lean protein and about 5-7 portions of fruit and veg a day. Very minimal fats and sugar. No alcohol.

Lost 20 pounds in 7 months and kept it off thus far. No fasting, starving or meal replacements. Also had some gains in that time because I allow myself meals out and celebrations. It’s a change of lifestyle rather than a crash diet and that’s worked for me. But it is hard work and needs focus. MFP and calorie counting didn’t work for me personally as it led me to disordered eating patterns.

I think you’ve had a lot of good advice on this thread. My suggestion would be to focus on eating healthy with portion control.

PrincessHoneysuckle · 16/01/2025 19:50

Use MFP to input all your calories. Saying 200ish etc isn't accurate enough as you could be 50 calories or more over which will add up.Include weighing butter,cheese,nuts etc as its easy to forget those things

PrincessHoneysuckle · 16/01/2025 19:47

rainbowunicorn · 16/01/2025 16:49

400 won't be far off.
150 - 180 for the eggs depending on size
120 for the slice of sourdough
Leaving around 100 for the smoked salmon which assuming around half a 100g pack would be about right

Sorry I read she had 2 slices of sourdough which would be around 200ish

changecandles · 16/01/2025 19:21

OP meant kindly but you need to get a grip of your lifestyle.

Intense restriction to lose weight. Drinking awful diet sodas and eating UFPs and doing no exercise even walking.

This is shit. Even if you lose weight you won't look your best. You'll look weak and skinny. That's the opposite of hot. And as you age you will end up hunched with prematurely aged skin and brittle bones. You'll shrink more than necessary too.

What a bizarre way to live your life.

Frequency · 16/01/2025 19:16

Someone who is anorexic and long-term calorie restricts severely will of course become very thin. At the same time their body will also do it's best to adjust to the severely low calories and do what it can to conserve energy. It allows muscle to go (muscle uses a lot of energy) grows extra body hair (to help maintain temperature) and leaves people wanting to sleep. People who are anorexic can survive on a remarkably low level of calories because of the adaptation. That also means that when they start eating more they put on weight more quickly than the next person, which is very scary and part of the reason why it's so hard to recover from.

Ime, most people suffering from anorexia do not severely restrict. That is a myth. They do what they call "high restriction" which is eating pretty much the way OP eats.

A calorie is a unit of energy, nothing more, nothing less. If you consume less energy than you burn, your body will burn fat and muscle for energy. I agree that it prefers to burn muscle because it is more energy-dense.

It's basic physics.

OP is losing what she is because her deficit is 2lb worth of fat and muscle less than she eats. She could eat nothing but Mars bars and Pringles and lose as long as she only ate 1000 calories worth.

@PrettyHungry FWIW, I agree your diet is shite and unsustainable long term. I would focus on eating lean protein and fresh whole foods. You will not be getting enough nutrition on what you are eating. If you want to lose more up the cardio and start strength training to protect and build muscle.

changecandles · 16/01/2025 19:16

ohtowinthelottery · 16/01/2025 14:59

Your body will go into starvation mode on that amount of food and slow your metabolism down.

Your weight loss will slow down and once you've reached your target weight you will put the pounds back on very quickly if you return to a 2000 calorie a day diet. You need to eat more.

Starvation mode has been debunked so many times by so many scientists for so long I'm amazed anyone still thinks it's a thing.

Auburngal · 16/01/2025 19:08

I gave up on SW as not suitable for shift workers living on their own.

WW - no classes here since the pandemic and leaders were made redundant and treated like shit.

Hibernatingtilspring · 16/01/2025 19:02

@Frequency because there is a thing called nuance, which is sadly often missing on Mumsnet.

Someone who is anorexic and long term calorie restricts severely will of course become very thin. At the same time their body will also do it's best to adjust to the severely low calories and do what it can to conserve energy. It allows muscle to go (muscle uses a lot of energy) grows extra body hair (to help maintain temperature) and leaves people wanting to sleep. People who are anorexic can survive on a remarkably low level of calories because of the adaptation. That also means that when they start eating more they put on weight more quickly than the next person, which is very scary and part of the reason why it's so hard to recover from.

Of course the average person doesn't calorie restrict enough for their body to change so drastically, but it is possible for some people to adapt to unduly low calories for a long period of time.

BeensOnToost · 16/01/2025 18:56

arcticpandas · 16/01/2025 16:43

Wow. I would be so miserable with that. And hungry!!😄

It's not fun! I'd bloody love to be having my soughdough toast and jam again in the morning! It's only until I can get back to averaging more than 1000 steps a day!

Thankfully I love veg 😆

Sidge · 16/01/2025 18:51

Your diet is shit and you do no exercise or activity.

If I were you I’d stop looking at numbers on a scale and focus on health. No point being slim if you’ve got diabetes and heart disease.

Wantitalltogoaway · 16/01/2025 18:39

Is this a joke?

Ladyofthepond · 16/01/2025 18:37

Your diet will make you lose weight, but if you've been on it for 2 weeks and your already frustrated it's likely you won't commit so a lifestyle change that will maintain the weight loss. Also, if you put weight on during pregnancy I bet it took a lot longer than 2 weeks to go on, therefore it'll take a lot longer to come off.

Tough luck that you don't like exercising, but our bodies are designed to move, and you'll physically look better for doing so; even if it just changes the way you hold yourself. Walking, yoga, bloody gardening if that works! Find what you enjoy and you will enjoy something. I hate going to the gym or fitness classes, but I LOVE training at a boxing gym and I swear an hour at the allotment is better for me than a spin class!

Eat well, as little processed as you can (I still drink diet drinks FWIW, but my diet is probs 80% unprocessed/homecooked otherwise). Bet you could get a cheaper and better breakfast than a coffee. I have greek yoghurt (I buy a 1kg tub from lidl for £1.65), I add some frozen berries that I take out the night before and add a small amount of granola (which I am aware is processed, I could make my own but y'know what life is short).

Personally if I had a stone to lose I'd reduce portion sizes and focus on nutrition for a month, then weigh yourself and see how you're doing.

Zanatdy · 16/01/2025 18:24

PrettyHungry · 16/01/2025 15:03

@rightoguvnor When I did slimming world previously, I kept it off for 2 years. Personally, I think it’s less about ‘how’ you lose it, and more about ensuring you keep to your maintenance calories once you are your target weight. Current weight loss is after pregnancy and gestational diabetes.

My BMR is 1,500, so I should be losing a lot as my deficit is approximately 400 calories a day.

I don’t like exercising, I used to bunk off PE such is my dislike of it! I hate getting sweaty, showering, actually doing the work out, the time, the effort… so I need to be in quite an extreme deficit to account for zero exercise. I do not even do 10k steps a day.

I will be cutting out UPF and zero calorie drinks in the future, but for now, I rely on them because they help to satiate my sweet craving.

At this weight, I look fat. My clothes don’t fit nicely and I carry all of my weight around my stomach so always look 6 months pregnant. I definitely need to lose at least a stone.

If your deficit is less than 400 cals a day that’s less than 0.5lbs you should be losing, so you’re doing well with a small deficit

Partylikeits1985 · 16/01/2025 18:16

So you’ve been dieting just over 2 weeks?
2lbs is fine.

Crash dieting is a waste of time, you just put it back on.

InWithThePlums · 16/01/2025 18:14

(I made a comment but think I’ve misunderstood the poster I was responding to so deleted)

Frequency · 16/01/2025 18:02

Those who believe in "starvation mode", can you explain why long-term anorexics are not obese and why concentration camp victims were so thin?

Auburngal · 16/01/2025 17:53

Reduce the carbs to one meal a day.

Eggs are your answer.

Coconutter24 · 16/01/2025 17:43

Breakfast - sugar free latte from Starbucks (medium) - 150cals.

What milk do you use?

Gnomea · 16/01/2025 17:41

It always shocks me how dieting means health goes out the window. Other than lunch you’re eating crap. Focus on real, nutrient dense foods and let the weight come off on its own rather than starving yourself and living on diet soda, Starbucks thickeners and god knows what and UPF ready meals.

Chillilounger · 16/01/2025 17:37

I thought this was a reverse at first. That's not a healthy diet op. High in fat, probably high in salt, definitely high in upf's. Calories are not the only thing that comes into it. Try upping your protein, fruit and veg to make more balanced meals. Try My fitness pal. It breaks down the nutritional content of what you have eaten as well as counting calories.

Londontown12 · 16/01/2025 17:36

It’s the ish at the end of your calories 450 ISH
it either 450 or whatever it is
coffee is not a breakfast it’s a drink
if u have done slimming world u will know that all that food except the berries and salad is all mostly full of syns ! That’s where u are going wrong it may be low calories but it’s all rubbish