Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not think the UK is as bad as everyone makes out?

165 replies

turkeypasty · 16/01/2025 09:13

Sorry if this is an odd question but everywhere on mumsnet you see rants about how terrible everything is. I am European and could move abroad, but my son and husband (and myself) are super happy here in the UK, the primary school is lovely, we live in the North in the hills and get plenty of outdoor time... We earn ok but not massively and seem to live a good lifestyle- do you think that people just like to moan or have I got very low standards?! There seems to be issues in every country you live surely... It makes me genuinely think if I should move abroad whilst my son is still young, but then why should we if we are happy here? Just really interested in opinions!

OP posts:
devilspawn · 16/01/2025 09:53

turkeypasty · 16/01/2025 09:48

Thanks for your reply @TheYearOfSmallThings . Yes I agree- especially on the job opportunities bit- there is a lot more variety than where I am from and more flexible in terms of WFH etc. I also think people don't realise that a lot of other countries are having the same / similar problems.

At least they have the same/similar problems with better weather.

redbokoblin · 16/01/2025 09:51

fridaynight1 · 16/01/2025 09:32

Compared to many other countries lifestyle is good.
Compared to how it used to be 25 years ago it’s shit.

This is the crux of it.

People are unhappy because it's declining, not because it's inherently a bad place to live compared to the rest of the world.

It's still one of the wealthiest countries in the world, with little risk of natural disasters, war on our soil, etc.

But relative to its standing in the world a few decades ago, it's a mess, and it's getting worse. People here are unhappy because they are used to better.

NordicwithTeen · 16/01/2025 09:51

I actually think the issue is the political scene has become so polarised, it feels like you have to be vastly left or right. No one votes centric because of something that happened over two decades ago. This means every few years the new party comes in and reverses everything just done, meaning we are spending loads of ££ and standing still.

Also the effects of Brexit are hitting hard now. There's no wiggle room for the resultant rising costs in the average household budget.

Daisyduke99 · 16/01/2025 09:49

It’s just so expensive. Lots of people have to be really careful with their money every month. It just isn’t like that in other places. Of course everywhere has its downsides and nowhere is perfect.. but yeah. The UK seems to have a lack of opportunities.

Life overseas is far easier in many respects.

SallyWD · 16/01/2025 09:49

What I'm seeing from these posts is just how different people's experiences are. People talking about rubbish, poor NHS care and knife crime. None of that is an issue where I live. Streets are very clean. I don't see rubbish on the floor. No knife that I know of in my area. It's sad that we can live in the same country and have vastly different experiences.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 16/01/2025 09:49

I also think people don't realise that a lot of other countries are having the same / similar problems.

That is definitely true.

Plouik · 16/01/2025 09:49

I agree OP and I think the negativity is part of the problem. The British have never been particularly sunny and optimistic, culturally, but they used to have a lot of national solidarity and confidence. It’s easy to see that if you lose that confidence it becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.

If you actually look at the hard facts we are all really lucky in this country. Almost everyone can get a job if they want one, education is good, food is cheap, almost everyone can afford a roof over their heads, healthcare is free, it’s safe to walk the streets, we are free to say and believe anything we like. If you are positive and hard-working you can go far. It’s absolutely not perfect but compared to 100 years ago it’s paradise.

If you look at the OECD quality of life index, we’re not right at the top but we’re nearly there. I hope to educate my children well so the world is their oyster. I want them to be free to choose to live here or not. For myself, I wouldn’t live anywhere else.

eqpi4t2hbsnktd · 16/01/2025 09:49

I might come off as incredibly entitled here... (I am... I know...)
What is making me hate the UK atm is I work my ass off. Earn well. Have no time and no money.
My annual bonus takes me into the 60% tax bracket and I get fuck all for that. We use my work private healthcare and pay out of pocket for GP appointments.
Yes we have a free school place but any additional childcare / club is more £££. We send out girls to a private tutor to make up for the total lack of 1:2:1 in School... they are drawing in an inner city 9 form school.
I feel like we are paying too much to cover corporations not paying tax and covering people who don't contribute at all!

I have always felt really left leaning but the decline in living standards in the UK is making me look like a raving Tory (I hate me too....)

TheYearOfSmallThings · 16/01/2025 09:49

HermioneWeasley · 16/01/2025 09:44

It feels like there is very little future for the Uk. I do worry for my kids. Knife crime is rife. Rape is decriminalised. The NHS is broken with no ideas (or political will) how to fix it. Councils are bankrupt and ineffective. Roads are in appalling conditions. Civil service is bloated and out of controls. Education standards are poor. No prospect of economic growth. Massive welfare/ benefits bill that can’t be sustained. Falling birth rates. Increasing influence of political Islam.

You see posts like this make me wonder, what country do you think your children would be better off in?

turkeypasty · 16/01/2025 09:48

TheYearOfSmallThings · 16/01/2025 09:46

YANBU, OP - and I am saying that as an Irish person who, on some level, is looking to find fault with the UK. But actually I live here because there are lots of jobs and the standard of living is pretty good, schools are decent, I can walk the streets in safety, and I don't like extreme weather so I'm fine with the climate here.

I am wondering about all the threads seeking to stir up negativity about the UK, and also the deluge of miserable people rushing to reinforce the negativity. Is it just whingeing poms? Or is there some anti UK propagandist at work?

Thanks for your reply @TheYearOfSmallThings . Yes I agree- especially on the job opportunities bit- there is a lot more variety than where I am from and more flexible in terms of WFH etc. I also think people don't realise that a lot of other countries are having the same / similar problems.

OP posts:
turkeypasty · 16/01/2025 09:46

SallyWD · 16/01/2025 09:44

What is your personal experience with healthcare though? It differs greatly depending on area. Personally I have had excellent care. I had cancer and was diagnosed within two days, surgery within one month, excellent follow up care. I got much better care than all the Americans I know on a Facebook group for this cancer, and they're paying a fortune for healthcare.
My DS needed surgery last year. It wasn't urgent but it was done within a month.
Last month I was very unwell with dizziness and nausea and got an appointment within two hours. I always get appointments easily and if not, there's a walk in clinic within a mile from my house. Never had to wait more than 20 minutes at a walk in clinic.
A and E wait times are awful but if anyone's in genuine danger of death they will be seen immediately.

Yeah I know what you mean, it really does vary. I have had a bit of both- what I do find is that the NHS staff is second to none compared to lots of other places I have seen- the way they work under pressure and their immense empathy. We have so far had some very good experiences and some that weren't.

OP posts:
TheYearOfSmallThings · 16/01/2025 09:46

YANBU, OP - and I am saying that as an Irish person who, on some level, is looking to find fault with the UK. But actually I live here because there are lots of jobs and the standard of living is pretty good, schools are decent, I can walk the streets in safety, and I don't like extreme weather so I'm fine with the climate here.

I am wondering about all the threads seeking to stir up negativity about the UK, and also the deluge of miserable people rushing to reinforce the negativity. Is it just whingeing poms? Or is there some anti UK propagandist at work?

Mauro711 · 16/01/2025 09:45

I also think it's good that people are vocal about all the things that aren't working for the people who live in the country. There is no point in saying there are countries that have it worse, it's not a race to the bottom and you shouldn't compare yourself to a poorer country. There is money in the UK, it's just distributed in a shambolic way and that shouldn't be tolerated.

I don't know any war-free country in Europe that has declined the way the UK has in the last few years. I know we were all hit with rising interest rates, more expensive food and energy bills etc but not to the level the UK was and where I am we are now moving in the other direction with lower interest rates and better wellfare again. The UK seem to still be in a decline.

SallyWD · 16/01/2025 09:44

turkeypasty · 16/01/2025 09:32

Totally agree that A&E waits and GP apps are a big problem. These kind of things are what makes me think if it would be better to move before it gets any worse.

What is your personal experience with healthcare though? It differs greatly depending on area. Personally I have had excellent care. I had cancer and was diagnosed within two days, surgery within one month, excellent follow up care. I got much better care than all the Americans I know on a Facebook group for this cancer, and they're paying a fortune for healthcare.
My DS needed surgery last year. It wasn't urgent but it was done within a month.
Last month I was very unwell with dizziness and nausea and got an appointment within two hours. I always get appointments easily and if not, there's a walk in clinic within a mile from my house. Never had to wait more than 20 minutes at a walk in clinic.
A and E wait times are awful but if anyone's in genuine danger of death they will be seen immediately.

HermioneWeasley · 16/01/2025 09:44

It feels like there is very little future for the Uk. I do worry for my kids. Knife crime is rife. Rape is decriminalised. The NHS is broken with no ideas (or political will) how to fix it. Councils are bankrupt and ineffective. Roads are in appalling conditions. Civil service is bloated and out of controls. Education standards are poor. No prospect of economic growth. Massive welfare/ benefits bill that can’t be sustained. Falling birth rates. Increasing influence of political Islam.

Lampblue · 16/01/2025 09:41

Yep I love where I live and think we have a great lifestyle, and our children are having an amazing childhood here. I have travelled a lot, lived abroad and chose to settle in a lovely little coastal town in England. I often think people who complain constantly about this country are the ones who’ve never left it! (Other than their once a year all inclusive). There are issues of course but everywhere has issues, this isnt exclusive to the uk. Even the weather is no where near as bad as people act like it is!

3rdCoffeeThisMorning · 16/01/2025 09:39

And the rubbish everywhere. Disgraceful and does give more vibe of deprived country. Saw cleaner poorer countries.
I think it's vombination of many things when it comes toa feeling rather than actual economic numbers.
Dirt, pollution (can't swim in most rivers now based on maps) etc getting worse on top of cal do add to general bleak feelings of despair.

Toddlerteaplease · 16/01/2025 09:38

Besides what other countries favourite super villain is a penguin disguised as a chicken?

Mauro711 · 16/01/2025 09:37

I agree that there are areas of the UK that is absolutely stunning but that matters less if the country isn't functioning. If young people can't afford to move out, if elderly people who fall and break a hip has to wait 14 hours for an ambulance, if a young child with a chest infection can't get in to see the GP, if a young middle earning family can't afford to have a second child because of the childcare costs and so on then there is very little consolation looking a pretty green hills and quaint stone cottages. I think that's the difference between the UK (at least England) now and the majority of european countries on a similar wealth level.

Pleaselettheholidayend · 16/01/2025 09:37

I think it's just become a bit of a meme online plus our culture lends itself to doing ourselves down - has the benefit of not living with overwhelming, blind patriotics all the time but it does get tiring the knee jerk response is how everything is terrible and we're all going to hell in a handcart. I've heard variations of this sentiment since I was a kid.

I think the truth is the West is in decline and we are feeling the squeeze and most people across Europe feel down about their prospects at the moment. I still like where I live and have no burning desire to leave. When you detach from the internet most people are nice and polite, I have a vast array of goods and services at my fingertips and I live in a country with beautiful landscapes and an a fascinating history. Really could be worse!

LittleRedRidingHoody · 16/01/2025 09:36

I'm sure some people complain for the sake of it, but I haven't seen that. Where I am (nr London) the NHS is in crisis and has been for a while - they missed DMs illness for so long that when they finally discovered it, it was terminal. Our local primary is lovely - but the secondary nearby has a horrible rep, lots of anti-social behaviour and a very low rate of students going on to Uni. We're in an area with quite high crime rates and the police don't seem to have enough manpower to do anything about it.

I am getting annoyed that I pay 45% tax, but lots of public services are not up to scratch so end up paying out of pocket for them anyway - private medical cover, lots of things to keep DM clean/alive as there's only so many times she can be refused for PIP. Nephew has SEN and state education is just not fit for his needs, if we didn't step in and help with private school in the future I'm not sure what would happen! I'm all for everyone paying tax, and I understand I'm in a privileged position to be on that sort of money anyway, but it does sting when the system then doesn't work the way it's supposed to! Overall though as much as I find there are reasons to have a moan, I won't be going anywhere 😂 Though it would be a consideration if I didn't have DS/DM.

3rdCoffeeThisMorning · 16/01/2025 09:35

As EU I do look bit "well obviously" at people about rising food prices since they were always artificially low compared to the continent, but at the same time the quality of life is dipping. So that moan, I support. I mean like how the fuvk can people in rich country not afford heating their houses to even 18c is beyond me

turkeypasty · 16/01/2025 09:34

fridaynight1 · 16/01/2025 09:32

Compared to many other countries lifestyle is good.
Compared to how it used to be 25 years ago it’s shit.

Yeah I have heard this a lot- it's interesting to get perspective like this as I have not lived here for that long

OP posts:
fridaynight1 · 16/01/2025 09:32

Compared to many other countries lifestyle is good.
Compared to how it used to be 25 years ago it’s shit.

turkeypasty · 16/01/2025 09:32

22nws · 16/01/2025 09:29

You sound like you live in quite a nice place that works for you. I personally think that in general, the UK is in major decline. Can’t get GP appt, A&E waits are ridiculous, specialist/operation waits are months or years. Everything is a scrap/difficult - parking, traffic, most customers service consists of “not my department/responsibility”.

My ds is looking for student accommodation in a popular city. Mouldy, ridiculously small, in dodgy areas where litter is piled in the gardens etc - I’m disgusted. He doesn’t need a palace, just something basic, safe and functional in a reasonable area.

Each of these issues (and loads of others not mentioned) eats up time and energy. Things that should be so basic - a 2 minute phone call or ticking a box or parking a car - are so difficult. Basic stuff (eg electricity or olive oil) has become so ridiculously expensive. That’s the crux of it really - to get basic stuff done, it feels like you have to climb a mountain.

Totally agree that A&E waits and GP apps are a big problem. These kind of things are what makes me think if it would be better to move before it gets any worse.

OP posts: