Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do DH and I need power of attorney for each other?

133 replies

Midlifecareerchange · 14/01/2025 16:51

Inspired by the AIBU about the benefits of marriage.

Dh and I have mirror wills. Our solicitor has now suggested power of attorney forms and I'm trying to figure out if there's any downside. It feels really wrong to me to sign anything that would give away my rights and power financially or in the case of healthcare, even if those things are hard to invoke and need to be signed off by medical professionals. I think of all those women who got carted off to asylums in the past when they got a bit grouchy and troublesome. I'm very grouchy at times 😬 DH and I are early 50s. I thought it was something you do in your old age if losing your marbles.

We have some assets in joint accounts and some in separate. We both have logins for both just in case needed. We are married.

YABU: sign the forms
YANBU: don't sign them

and yes I will also clarify the pros and cons with said solicitor when I get a chance.

OP posts:
Elsvieta · 14/01/2025 21:43

Midlifecareerchange · 14/01/2025 19:13

More examples of specific situations especially in relation to healthcare decisions would be great thanks all. So not 'it was important that we were able to make decisions' or 'it was awful that we couldn't make decisions' but what the decisions - real or hypothetical could be?

Things like if someone needs care (and no capacity to make their own decisions), what sort of care are they going to have and how is it going to be paid for? Residential care, or in their home? If it's a home, which one? Suppose the person has dementia and money in the bank which could be used for care but no capacity to handle their own finances. The spouse, with POA, can access the money and arrange the care. If a house was jointly owned, the spouse could make the decision to downsize and free up some money for care, and the same sort of thing with any other joint assets.

Elsvieta · 14/01/2025 21:38

Yes, you need them (both kinds - there's one for legal / financial affairs and one for health). They have to be signed while you have full capacity - no getting it after someone has started to develop dementia or similar. Also bear in mind that there are lots of other ways for a person to lose physical / mental capacity, sometimes suddenly. You nominate three people, so spouse first and then the other two. I know someone who's been incapacitated by a stroke (very sudden, he was very fit) and his wife just can't get anything sorted out. Do it ASAP.

Midlifecareerchange · 14/01/2025 20:55

incidentally I've been on mumsnet for over 14 years and this is my first AIBU always been terrified of starting a thread here 😂 but thanks you've all been very patient with me although I'm still worrying about dh locking me up in an asylum for being a pita if I sign

OP posts:
aramox1 · 14/01/2025 19:37

Yes. If one of you is hospitalised and unconscious etc you will need it to deal with finances.

funnelfan · 14/01/2025 19:36

Well, you could look at the medical histories of your parents, grandparents etc to see if there are any conditions that tend to run in the family to give you an idea for specifics, but commonly it’s things like:

If incapacitated, do you want every effort to be made for you to live at home with external support, or would you want to move to specialist facilities? I know someone with Parkinson’s who was very physically incapacitated towards the end of their life, but absolutely clear that he wanted to be at home and he had carers coming in to look after him. However it was very hard on the family because his hospital bed took over the lounge and the whole house and their lives were arranged around him and his illness with no escape or break for them.

if you get some form of dementia, do you want every effort to be made medically right until the end? Or would you want the decision to be made on a case by case basis, depending on whether the likely outcome would restore you to the best that you could be or not. Eg, if you got diagnosed with cancer, would you want palliative care (ie medication for comfort and pain only) if you had already lost capacity, or would you want surgery/chemo? My mums GP gave the hypothetical example of her falling and breaking her hip - while medically she might survive the operation, she would not remember and/or understand why she was in pain, be able to cooperate with her physio exercises, the anaesthetic may cause delirium or a worsening of the dementia etc and so she would in all probability remain bed bound anyway, which would be the same outcome as not operating.

Midlifecareerchange · 14/01/2025 19:13

More examples of specific situations especially in relation to healthcare decisions would be great thanks all. So not 'it was important that we were able to make decisions' or 'it was awful that we couldn't make decisions' but what the decisions - real or hypothetical could be?

OP posts:
funnelfan · 14/01/2025 19:10

I know of a situation where someone was unexpectedly incapacitated in their forties leaving them unable to communicate. It has been a nightmare for their spouse for any situation where the call centre wants to speak to the account holder and they often get stuck in a “computer says no” situation because the alternatives of communicating by email or letter just don’t get answered like a phone call.

I’ve activated PoAs for my mum - I did the finance one with her bank while she was compos mentis as she was losing her sight and wanted me to deal with her paperwork, and this was allowed because of the box ticked on the LPoA form. But I only did exactly what she asked and only took over making decisions relatively recently when it became clear her capacity had gone.

you can leave explicit instructions in both forms, but you do have to trust your attorney(s) to follow your wishes and act in your best interests. I think it also helps to make sure you have communicated those wishes to other loved ones so that everyone is clear, especially if they relate to your wishes on healthcare in the event you are incapacitated. The last thing your Attorney(s) need is arguing with other people who disagree with your wishes. I’m lucky in that my DB is also next-of-kin and we agree as mum didn’t leave any explicit instructions, trusting me to do what’s best.

Sunnnybunny72 · 14/01/2025 19:03

We did our during the boredom of Covid. Early fifties.

CharityShopChic · 14/01/2025 18:59

DH and I have them for each other, we are both 50. We have had them at least 5 years as it was sorted out pre-Covid.

We decided to do it after one of DH's colleagues had a cycling accident overseas, suffered a catastrophic brain injury and now needs round the clock nursing care in a home. He has a child who was about 3 or 4 when it happened. His wife couldn't access his money. Nobody at work was - legally - allowed to discuss her husband's pension or salary, which had been paid into an account in his sole name and the he'd transfer some into a joint account. She couldn't even cancel the Sky TV as it was in his name. Yes it got sorted eventually as it all went through the courts and it because obvious that the guy had lost capacity and wasn't going to regain it, but it took at least 6 months to sort it all out - at a time where his wife was going through the worst time ever.

It's most definitely NOT only for people who are old and ill.

Midlifecareerchange · 14/01/2025 18:56

And to clarify yes I understand things that might lead to loss of capacity such as stroke, brain injury, dementia. It's the types of healthcare decisions that those things might lead to that I'm not so clear on

OP posts:
Midlifecareerchange · 14/01/2025 18:52

So no one feels or knows of any examples where POA has been invoked against someone's wishes?

I've looked up the Kate Garraway story. Re- mortgaging/ selling property/ changing utilities. I'm starting to get it.

Still on the fence re medical wishes but I suppose if you actually completely lack capacity then you can only hope you've listed all eventualities. I hate hypothetical disasters and am unwilling to think about them so thanks again for the examples people have given.

OP posts:
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 14/01/2025 18:51

Dh and I did ours some years ago, but admittedly we were both getting on a bit by then.
Having said that, although it’s unlikely, anyone could suffer e.g. a severe stroke or a bad accident, or other condition where you were unable to make your wishes known.
So - as long as you trust your dh - TBH I can’t seen any downside.

We’ve added paragraphs to ours, to state in what cases (e.g. being unable both to care for ourselves and speak with full mental capacity for ourselves) we want no ‘striving to keep alive’.

pilates · 14/01/2025 18:42

^
and a fraction of the price

hashimotosucks · 14/01/2025 18:39

HardyAnt · 14/01/2025 18:23

Those who have a POA in place, have you used the online government one, rather than doing it via a solicitor?

Yes I did it online then you print the forms and get people to sign which is a bit of a faff as has to be in a specific order but not hard to do

BruFord · 14/01/2025 18:37

I know it’s a grim subject, but I’ve talked to my DH about the level of medical treatment I want if I’m unable to make decisions. I should also put it in writing so there’s no doubt.

If I had dementia and then developed cancer, for example, I would only want to be kept comfortable rather than treated as I already wouldn't be “me” iyswim.

ThatsWhatImTalkinAbout · 14/01/2025 18:35

when DH was very ill at one point I did have access to his finances as I had his phone and his logins. So specific examples that having logins wouldn't cover would be helpful

if you had to contact customer services at his bank /online banking query / Electricity Gas company, they will only speak with the account holder or PoA if you have registered PoA document with them.

Midlifecareerchange · 14/01/2025 18:26

@Seawolves im so sorry thank you for sharing this

OP posts:
HardyAnt · 14/01/2025 18:23

Those who have a POA in place, have you used the online government one, rather than doing it via a solicitor?

Axelotl · 14/01/2025 18:22

My mum got this set up when she was in her 60s, with her husband and me as an attorney - joint and severally. Her husband also has one with mum and his DC as an attorney.

This makes sense as if her husband dies before her, the LPA still stands as I'm an attorney.

museumum · 14/01/2025 18:21

If you are unconscious you can’t make health decisions on a case by case basis. Would you rather the doctors decide without input from DH or would you rather talk about things in general with DH now so he can represent your wishes?

For eg my parents are both religious and that affects the decisions they would make whereas I am atheist. if I were to undertake poa for my parents I would need a conversion with them first about their boundaries around sanctity of life etc.

my DH and I are closer in beliefs and what we’d want.

Lorrdydoowhatevs · 14/01/2025 18:17

My son and DIL have POA for both of us. It seems far more sensible.

CallMeDaphne · 14/01/2025 18:17

Would strongly recommend PoAs for everyone, and crucially you need to get them registered with the Office of the Public Guardian.

menopausalmare · 14/01/2025 18:16

Definitely! If your husband becomes incapacitated, you cannot sell the house and downsize without his permission. When dad was in a care home, there was a couple in the same predicament. Married for years but the wife couldn't authorize the sale and she was completely stuck until her husband died.

Brombat · 14/01/2025 18:14

Dementia, stroke, anything where you've lost capacity...

My in-laws planned for everything except mil thinking she's perfectly fine and totally helpless.

If you are worried about your wishes, do a detailed advanced directive too.

The bar for capacity is really low, so you have to be in a pretty bad way for it to be used. However, as in our case, the bad way has been going on for a few years now...

Swipe left for the next trending thread