Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Childminder and holidays

168 replies

FandyRenoli · 14/01/2025 10:04

Name changed for this as don't want me or childminder to be identifiable. It's long so buckle in!

LO is 1 year old (just) and started with the childminder in September. I'm a single parent, no wider family childcare support. The childminder is new to childminding but does have extensive experience in the childcare industry and excellent qualifications and references. She is married with primary school aged children. LO started with her the week she opened. Childcare is in extremely short supply in our area and I was very happy to find someone so good.

I should start by saying that the childminder (CM) is lovely and the care she provides for LO is amazing. On that front I'd recommend her to anyone.

When we went to look around she said most of the bookings she had were wrap around school care so for most of the day it's LO and one other. At that point I checked that she isn't term-time only as this just wouldn't work for me. She assured me she wasn't and said she would close between Christmas and New year, had two weeks holiday booked in the summer, and might take "the odd day here and there" for a long weekend away or similar, but would give plenty of notice plus bank holidays. All good.

At Christmas she was actually closed from 20th December to 6th January (so not just between Christmas and New year) but we managed.

At Christmas she also sent out a list of the dates she would be closed in 2025. This came to 40 days plus 8 days bank holidays. I really wasn't expecting anywhere near this many- it's nearly double my annual leave allowance and there is absolutely no way I will be given that number of extra unpaid days even if I could afford them (which I can't).

The pattern is also very focused on school holidays. She will be closed either the entire half term or the majority of it for all three half terms - February, May and October - plus a week at Easter, a couple of weeks in the summer and all of the Christmas school holidays.

I will absolutely not get annual leave now for February as this was booked up by other staff months ago, and May and October are key times in my industry where annual leave is only approved in emergencies - one of the reasons I checked CM wasn't term time only.

I messaged CM (politely) about this pointing out I'd checked she wasn't term-time only and that I just couldn't get this amount or pattern of time off.

She replied that she isn't term time only (though by my calculations she's shut for 70% of the school holidays), that she's entitled to annual leave (I agree) and that this is the usual amount of time off for a year round childminder (I'm not sure about that one).

So am I being unreasonable to be surprised/taken aback by this amount pattern of leave, and by the limited notice for leave in February?

What are other people's experiences of this?

Would I be unreasonable to expect some level of compromise from her to resolve this?

OP posts:
NC10125 · 19/01/2025 08:11

Are you in a job where you can work from home?

If so I’d plan to work from home those three weeks and look for a local teenage babysitter who can come to your house and look after her whilst you’re working. There’s less of an issue with trusting/experience if you’re in the house. Or join a gym with childcare and work from the gym. Or if you don’t have lots of meetings spend the day with her just checking emails and then work after bedtime. None of which are perfect!

If you can’t work from home you’re going to need to leave it until the last minute before the February one and then tell them your childcare has fallen through and be absent. After 15 years they won’t sack you but it’s not ideal!

Id book as many of the other weeks off work as possible now, using parental leave if needed, so it’s just the three weeks you have to cover as an emergency.

Id also pop my name onto waiting lists for nurseries you like and plan to change as soon as possible.

Strugglingforanamechange · 19/01/2025 08:10

YANBU but she’s not going to compromise by the sounds of things! I would look for a nursery asap. We used a childminder for a while but switched for just this reason. I think especially when you don’t have a back up nursery is safer. What would you do if your childminder was sick for example?

hockityponktas · 19/01/2025 08:08

It’s tricky because the childminder is self employed and sets her own rules!

However I do believe she should be clear in her contract about how much leave she will take. Have you checked what it says in the contract?

when I was a childminder I was really upfront that I worked mainly term time only but would have some days where in the holidays where I was available. I didn’t charge if I wasn’t available.This meant I got mainly teachers and this suited me fine.

does the childminder have any childminder contacts that she could give you that would be able to cover her holidays? They may some term time only contracts and could squeeze you in for the holidays?
Don’t lose an otherwise excellent childminder over this!

Moonshower · 19/01/2025 08:07
  1. I would ask if current CM could consider doing any dates in FEb half term as a one off as your struggling to get this sorted. If you don’t ask you don’t get.
  2. Not ideal but can you work from home for any dates in Feb half term, LO will just have to watch a lot of telly. You could maybe flex your hours to work more once they are in bed?
  3. Longterm you need a different childcare provider, pop names on nursery lists. I would also ask if they can ad hoc cover Feb half term. I would expect annual no but again worth asking.

Your CM should have provided dates she’s closing when you asked, I would be annoyed too. She can set her own dates it’s her business but more transparency was needed around school holiday's.

CautiousLurker01 · 19/01/2025 07:50

Ex CM and friend of plenty of current CMS. Your contract should specify the maximum no of days she can have for annual leave in the year - ie, 20 or 25 days over the year. Sorry, but the number of days she is taking would be unacceptable for any business unless you have agreed she has 40days/8 weeks annual leave at the start.

I’m afraid you will need to find an alternative CM/setting. She is in a business, providing a service that enables you to work within your contractual obligations (ie you need a CM who takes a similar amount of holiday to what you are entitled to with your employer) with just the occasional time when you/DP or a family member have to step in my prior arrangement because CM’s sick leave or the off leave day clashes.

iwillfghhjjj · 19/01/2025 07:49

Also you could speak to other childminders to see if they can cover some of her holidays. They might not have a permanent position but might be willing to do adhoc cover so u have a back up.

user1492757084 · 19/01/2025 07:47

Can you take the baby to work? or work in with a co-worker who has children? Ask around your workplace if there are any known options you could utilize.
Can you take unpaid leave?
Are there any good (experienced and trusted by neighbours) babysitters. Older teens or SAH Mums or Grandmothers in your neighbourhood who would like the infrequent work.
It's very difficult for you.

Mollysay · 19/01/2025 07:47

Horserider5678 · 19/01/2025 07:40

The childminder may well have taken these dates for a reason. Just because she’s a childminder it doesn’t mean she’s at the beck and call of her clients. OP needs all day care for the majority of the year, so really needs to put her child down for a day nursery. I find it hard to believe she has absolutely no one who could step in!

Whilst this is of course true, saying you're not term time only and then taking well over half of the school holidays off isn't fair. Being open and honest is all it takes and then it's not an issue.

Mollysay · 19/01/2025 07:45

It's frustrating she wasn't open and honest about it when you first enquired, you can't force her to open though. I'd get onto every waiting list possible in the area and as a PP said ask if she knows anyone in her network who can offer holiday care in the meantime.

iwillfghhjjj · 19/01/2025 07:42

It's unfair as it's not what she told you. Did your contract state holiday entitlement? When I was a childminder I took 5 weeks a year, two at summer one at Xmas and Easter and a floating 5 days ( for odd days needed)

You need to find alternative childcare asap. If you haven't sorted t for feb your only option would be to phone in sick

Horserider5678 · 19/01/2025 07:40

TooManyChristmasCards · 14/01/2025 10:43

Long shot, but ask around on your local groups.

Some TA might be wanting to earn extra cash for example.

Or beg. Explain to the childminder that you are REALLY in trouble, and can't afford not to work, could she "help you out" (even if she should do her job but an argument won't help).

Edited

The childminder may well have taken these dates for a reason. Just because she’s a childminder it doesn’t mean she’s at the beck and call of her clients. OP needs all day care for the majority of the year, so really needs to put her child down for a day nursery. I find it hard to believe she has absolutely no one who could step in!

NetZeroZealot · 19/01/2025 07:39

Obviously it’s not ideal for you but she can choose to run her business however she wants.
she should have been clearer upfront but if it doesn’t work for you then you need to find another solution.

CatG021024 · 19/01/2025 07:30

Unfortunately, sympathising with you here is not going to solve your childcare problem. I would start looking for an alternative and regarding February, if you cannot find childcare you will have to take leave from work, what else can you do if you have no alternative to care for your child. I would feedback to the child minder regarding the impact, however, she has given notice of her leave, perhaps with the next provider ask for longer notice for their close down / leave dates.

YenSon · 19/01/2025 07:30

Did you sign a contract? My childminder was term time only (I’m a teacher so fine with me) but if ever she was sick or her children were sick she could offer a childminder in her network. I never used this but many childminders have a network of friends who can provide this cover for each other. Is there someone she knows who works all year? Alternatively, you could find a nursery or a nanny.

mumofboys8787 · 19/01/2025 07:29

OP I can sympathise because I also live in an area with heavily oversubscribed childcare, but you keep saying ALL other nurseries and childminders are full - but how do you know? Are you telling me you’ve called every single nursery and childminder in a reasonable distance? Even when they’re all full, somewhere normally has space. I say this as a mother of 3 who has ALWAYS managed to find somewhere. You just need to properly sit down and look.

Staying with the current CM clearly isn’t an option so go find somewhere else

Amba1998 · 19/01/2025 07:25

I would expect the usual 24 plus BH

40 is a lot!!

LegoBingo · 19/01/2025 07:20

NarNarGoon · 14/01/2025 10:18

YANBU but there is not really a compromise to be found here. She has let you know when she is unavailable, what you do with that is up to you. You either find alternative care for those days or you find an alternative care provider that better suits your needs - it is not her job to work in with your needs or compromise.
This is one of the problems with a sole childcare provider compared to a centre with numerous staff.

This really. Can you find a nursery?

You being a single parent isn't relevant here to her either

Overthinker191728 · 19/01/2025 07:17

My childminder shuts 2weeks (ish, sometimes less than 2weeks) for xmas, and has one week in june and one week in sept. She doesnt open for bank hols. So she has 4weeks plus bank hols

madamovaries · 19/01/2025 07:17

YANBU

We had a similar problem with the childminder we had for our first child but she wouldn't even give notice before texting in cancelling! There was always something that stopped her working. It meant I'd often have to pull all nighters to get work done after looking after my son all day. It was exhausting.

Our new childminder for our second child is brilliant and takes 4 weeks holiday a year plus bank holidays and a very rare sick day (our son is with her 4 days a week), plus a little extra time off over Christmas. She is so nice she tried to take the sick day unpaid but I insisted we pay her. I guess my point is that a good relationship fosters generosity on both sides. Your childminder has not been honest. Sometimes my childminder has my son with her own children (who are in school) though whether this is allowed would depend on ratios. Have you suggested that to her or is that a non-starter?

Edizzler25 · 19/01/2025 07:01

I’d stick it out with the childminder and get your child’s name on a nursery list in the meantime ASAP.

She is taking the piss IMO. Do you pay for her when she’s on holiday? I had to for my ex CM but she never took anywhere near that many holidays.

if she’s new she won’t last long with this… it’s a key factor for working parents…

Emmz1510 · 18/01/2025 23:31

Yanbu but this is why I decided against a childminder- being so tied to their holidays.
She should have made this clearer when you met with her.
Time to make alternative arrangements.

WEB83 · 14/01/2025 15:38

YANBU. It sounds like your CM is working around her own children’s school holidays, which is fine, that’s her choice but it doesn’t leave you with many options. You are going to have to speak to your employer and see what you could come up with between you - would WFH be an option for some of the CM’s leave? You should maybe put your LO’s name down at a nursery now so at least the ball is rolling with that.

nmechg · 14/01/2025 15:28

TheGoogleMum · 14/01/2025 10:47

If it helps for comparison my childminder closes for 2 weeks over Xmas (school hols), 2 weeks in summer and 1 half term

Same here

NoEffingWay · 14/01/2025 15:16

This is why we ended up putting DS in nursery-they were much, much easier to deal with and hardly ever closed.

Richtea67 · 14/01/2025 15:08

We had this almost exact experience with out youngest DD's childminder. Our eldest had a different CM and this was not our experience at all with holidays being an issue. In the end we moved her to a nursery, which has been brilliant, and so much easier as also don't need to cover CM illness (or when CM children are ill). Such a shame, as you seem very happy with her otherwise.