Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s very bleak to be saving this and getting absolutely nowhere? What’s the point?

185 replies

Wehah · 13/01/2025 22:17

I don’t know if I’m being overly sensitive as I am a single parent (with maintenance as people seem to ask that on here!). But I can’t ever seem to get ahead financially. I have been fortunate to save 1,500 a month for the last year or so. I thought this was going to be great as it would get a good savings buffer going and me and dd could even go abroad perhaps and I could start to add to her savings too. I was looking forward to having 10k in the bank as a safety net and then a little extra to save elsewhere.

But no… what’s actually happened is 3k on a boiler… I know that’s more like a one off cost but it doesn’t stop there. I needed two trees removed which cost 1k, I had a huge energy bill from December which has wiped out 400 of this months savings already. I had to pay for extensive dental treatment with a root canal as I couldn’t get it on the nhs. Then finally I had to pay over 90 more for car insurance (no explanation as to why and despite calling round many many many places to get it cheaper).

The reality is that I am getting nowhere with savings. It will take me forever to save won’t it? What’s actually the point? I will never be able to save more than 1,500 which to be honest I thought was a huge amount! But perhaps I am very wrong about this. How do people get financially secure? I’m nearly 40 now and can’t actually believe I have this much money to set aside and it’s going nowhere. I just want to give up and the future feels so uncertain.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Resisterance · 15/01/2025 14:01

I feel you, @weeha. I am in the same boat really as a lone parent (also with some maintenance), and it is really hard to get ahead. Especially with the COL crisis.

What people often don't realise is that the household costs arent that different to run a home as one parent only (apart from the 25% council tax discount) but with only one income coming in, so it really can feel like being on a financial hamster wheel. Couples and families often have two incomes coming in for the same home, which mitigates issues slightly if there are boiler breakdowns, etc.

I am renting rather than owning so our experiences differ there but I've just been paid 2k for a freelance job today (a month's worth of work) and its almost all gone again now in the same morning ... hmrc tax payment, food shopping, credit card bill, etc. It is so dispiriting. And without a second income, it is like trying to stay afloat when there's a hole in the boat.

Sending you solidarity and hope it all improves one day.

Abitofalark · 15/01/2025 13:38

What's 60000 divided by 18000? 3.333333333333333333333333... That's 3.33333333333333333333333 years to reach the goal. The very snails would weep at the slowness of pace. The boiler might have added how many 3s behind the decimal to that elongated period of painful waiting? A holiday would surely play havoc.

jolota · 15/01/2025 13:12

£1500 a month is an amazing amount to save.
I think you need to consider what your financial situation would be now if you hadn't already saved that money and been able to easily pay for the boiler and other expenses. You're in a good position.
For context, my husband and I saved up around £60k but it took us about 4 years pre kids, and we lived very very frugally during that time, it also overlapped with covid (limited opportunity to spend but we both continued working) and a big salary increase for my husband in the 3rd year of our savings.
It is demoralising seeing your savings go down, but some years are just worse than others. We had to replace our boiler and do a roof repair back to back, first time we'd dipped into our savings for years but it was almost £10k.
The reality is that being able to put that amount of money into savings means you are financially secure even if the progress feels slow.

YearningForAWinteryWinter · 15/01/2025 10:30

Op if you do have that much available for savings every month and your main priority is mortgage related, why not look to overpaying your mortgage by a chunk every month. You'll pay it off so much quicker and may not need to take a break from paying it.

dontcrowdthemushrooms · 14/01/2025 20:49

This post smacks of a humblebrag. You’re saving £18,000 a YEAR and claiming you’re not getting anywhere?! Even if you have to then take ~£5k a year out for unexpected expenses, you’ll still meet your £60k target in about 4 years.
About 25% of UK adults have less than £1000 in savings. You’re saving more than someone on minimum wage earns.
Get a grip!

Caterina99 · 14/01/2025 20:22

At the rate you’re going, you’ll be up to 60k in not much longer than 3 years. You can pay a block of your mortgage and save yourself a load of interest. Maybe split the payment into different “pots” £500 for long term (pay off mortgage etc), £500 for unexpected big expenses like boilers, trees, dentist etc and £500 for a holiday and other fun things. You can definitely have a lovely holiday abroad for 3k for 2 of you. Any leftover money can go into the long term pot.

I assume you also have a work pension and are on track with state pension.

I get its frustrating to spend your hard worked for savings on boring stuff like a new boiler. But that’s an investment into your property too. It should be more efficient.

In 5 to 10 years your discipline and savings could make you so much wealthier. I don’t think it’s pointless at all.

Mischance · 14/01/2025 16:52

You did well to save enough to cover these contingencies - which is what savings are for.

thepariscrimefiles · 14/01/2025 16:46

Anniedash · 13/01/2025 23:52

Is thread has turned into the usual ‘at least you are still breathing’ with no acknowledgement of what OP is saying.

OP, if you work and are self sufficient, then you have a point. People working, paying their way and trying to secure themselves in this country are being shafted by the corrupt government and freeloaders.

How has OP been 'shafted' by corrupt government and freeloaders? Did they break her boiler?

thepariscrimefiles · 14/01/2025 16:36

Wehah · 13/01/2025 22:32

I feel like most people ARE financially secure though? And now I’m trying to save 1,500 a month (which is unlikely to ever increase from this) it feels like the end of the road, where do I go from here if I can’t get secure with that?!

Most people aren't financially secure. Many people are in much worse financial situations than you. You are in a good position financially if you can afford to save £1500 a month, even if you have had to spend some of it on unexpected emergencies. If you hadn't saved this money, you would have needed to borrow the money to pay for a new boiler and to have the trees cut down which would have cost you much more due to paying interest.

PlopSofa · 14/01/2025 16:30

Hello2025helloworld · 14/01/2025 11:07

It's RBS/natwest "adventurous investor" fund, in an ISA wrapper. Has performed really well over past 18 months, much better than standard savings account. Of course, past performance no guarantee of future performance!

Thank you 😊

S&P500 has gone up 23% this last year which is phenomenal. Usually only goes up 11% on average per year but as you say can go up and down.

sadly I don’t have much in it, but I’ll be looking to add to my holding on pull backs through this year.

I’ll also have a look at this one you mentioned. Thanks again

GentlemanJay · 14/01/2025 15:23

Saving 1500£ a month. I feel so sorry for you. Lol.

Robogob · 14/01/2025 15:21

Fuckin hell, £1.5k a month and moaning. You’re just deliberately winding people up now.

Yeahnoforsure · 14/01/2025 15:17

Wehah · 14/01/2025 13:18

Thanks for giving my head a wobble!

i absolutely know it’s not a small amount to save 1,500 but that was really my point. It feels hopeless than even doing that doesn’t get you security. That was more my point. I thought I would be feeling really secure and calm about the future but I’m not. I know it’s not nothing though.

I understand completely how you feel about managing to save so much, and feeling secure, if only for a short while. Pre Covid, Pre Supply Issues, Pre Shortages and then the dastardly COL crisis, many of us could save a decent amount, and it felt so good, such a nice secure feeling, and it motivated us to do even better, make the little sacrifices that would allow for more savings.

All that is off the table now, for many of us, if not the majority,
All the BS that's being thrown as us now, the frightening amount of money one should have 'in the bank' for the future, for when things go wrong, is quite frankly, not only sobering but very concerning.

Best of luck OP, hopefully the bigger expenses you've had will ease up for a bit, and allow you to reach your comfort zone once more, but to get ahead and stay ahead will be very difficult.

Porkyporkchop · 14/01/2025 15:15

lots Of people are in the same boat. Cost of living increases and emergency funds needed, it’s a cycle of never getting ahead. Lots of people feel the same way.

ChristmasFluff · 14/01/2025 14:07

You could put £25 (or more if you want) of your £1500 per month into a unit trust or something that you cannot access until it matures in 20 years. Then you have savings for emergencies, and a lump sum as you get towards retirement.

Won't solve your feelings of security now, but will help in future. You have to watch when you cash them in though - the can go down as well as up (and also depend on how good the fund management is), but overall the return is usually way better than standard savings.

Your bank will probably give you investment advice for free, so it's worth contacting them for help too.

marmitegirl01 · 14/01/2025 14:05

I save £150 a month for emergencies and felt quite pleased I have got up to £2000. I am awaiting the big expense, I'm sure any minute now !! But at least I'll have something to contribute.
I'd love to be in your position. Bet you've got decent pension too ! 🥴

Lilly11a · 14/01/2025 13:51

Wehah · 14/01/2025 13:18

Thanks for giving my head a wobble!

i absolutely know it’s not a small amount to save 1,500 but that was really my point. It feels hopeless than even doing that doesn’t get you security. That was more my point. I thought I would be feeling really secure and calm about the future but I’m not. I know it’s not nothing though.

How would you feel if you allocated your savings jobs . I used to have one pot and I got upset of I had to spend any .

So I now have holiday fund and house fund and it's ok to spend from those .

But I also have a much smaller amount ( £150) a month I put away that is not to be touched unless I lose my job . I ve been putting some money away since 2016 although I think I started at £50 a month - I have 11k in there now . That's not 60k but still a short term nest egg

Didimum · 14/01/2025 13:50

I think I just wanted enough to pay my mortgage for a few years without working, so I wanted 60k in the bank ideally.

OP ... come the eff on. This is nice and everything, but hardly anyone can afford this. You are financially secure – you've achieved that. Some years will be worse than others for unseen expenditure. That's life.

Hipalong · 14/01/2025 13:49

Wehah · 13/01/2025 22:44

I’m not actually saving it though. That’s the point. I still don’t have a substantial buffer and it feels like I certainly won’t now

I don't think you have a good grasp on how money works.

Willyoujustbequiet · 14/01/2025 13:45

Wehah · 13/01/2025 22:32

I feel like most people ARE financially secure though? And now I’m trying to save 1,500 a month (which is unlikely to ever increase from this) it feels like the end of the road, where do I go from here if I can’t get secure with that?!

You do realise that's more than many people have to live on?

You are in a very fortunate position.

squidgie · 14/01/2025 13:43

And you ARE secure!

TheCompactPussycat · 14/01/2025 13:42

I think that you are

a) being very defeatist, and
b) are too focussed on instant gratification

I also think you need to reconsider your definition of financial security. Saving up enough money to have a couple of years paying the mortgage whilst not working isn't financial security. Because at the end of it you will have no savings and no job - basically, financial insecurity.

I would have thought overpaying your mortgage would be a better way to go, with a view of being able to reduce your working hours without reducing your lifestyle once it's paid off. It won't be instant gratification though. It will take time.

Avenuesandboulevards · 14/01/2025 13:39

Wehah · 13/01/2025 22:33

@YearningForAWinteryWinter this is best case scenario for me though. It’s not going to get better than 1,500 a month and it’s got me nowhere. We won’t be going on holiday for example. Feels utterly pointless

Well going by your extra spends you have still managed to save some money. £1500 a month is a huge amount to have spare, I don't understand what you are worried about
Yes, so of it will need to be used for emergencies but you are still saving some

flipent · 14/01/2025 13:35

If you set yourself the target that to be financially secure you need to go from £0 to £60k in the bank, you're always going to feel like that is too far to reach.

Targets need to be achievable in stages.

  1. Have £1,000 in the bank. (Sounds like you are here already)
  2. Have 3 x monthly salary in the bank
  3. Have 6 x monthly salary in the bank

Or which ever milestones work for you.

If you want a holiday with DD you need to factor that in.

  • Once I've got 3x monthly salary in the bank, future savings go into the holiday fund to £2,000 then back to the next target.

Yes, you will have unexpected bills that come up - being able to pay them from this fund is financial security. I don't think you understand how many people live pay cheque to pay cheque and would be in significant debt if faced with the costs you've incurred.

Not having to use to debt for these costs is being financially secure.

RunningJo · 14/01/2025 13:28

Wehah · 13/01/2025 22:32

I feel like most people ARE financially secure though? And now I’m trying to save 1,500 a month (which is unlikely to ever increase from this) it feels like the end of the road, where do I go from here if I can’t get secure with that?!

I can't save that much a month, so you're doing well, and yes I get fed up of how quick even seemingly little things eat into savings. I am not talking about holidays, just general boring stuff like a new washer for example.

Grateful always to have savings, and to be able to use them, I just think the problem is everything is so expensive now that savings soon disappear when you have a couple of things to pay out for - and often not nice things - just boring house stuff. It can feel a bit 'what is the point' when all you have to show for the dip in savings is a boring household item. But as others have pointed out, at least you had the money to fall back on and didn't have to panic as to how you were going to pay for your boiler. So savings are always a good thing, even if they end up being spent on 'grown up' stuff.

Swipe left for the next trending thread