Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Local butchers importing meat from China

114 replies

Glitterybee · 13/01/2025 01:43

AIBU to be absolutely fuming about this?

I spent a small fortune at a local butchers on Saturday and as I went to open one of the items today (chicken), I noticed it said on the pack ‘origin of meat - China’

That then prompted me to check all the packaging and none of the meat is sourced locally. They were all labelled as coming from either China or Poland.

I live in a very rural area with a huge network of farmers. Why on earth would a local butcher import chicken and red meat from other countries? I think it’s a disgrace.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
superplumb · 14/01/2025 10:35

Yuk. Id leave a review online and social media. I bet most would assume it's British. I would assume that tbh. Our local butchers specify the local farms they use. It costs more but I'll eat less of it. Would rather support British farmers not to mention the welfare standard.

StMarie4me · 14/01/2025 03:39

I have checked Aldi and Iceland and they have a lot of British meat. I will be checking in future. Thanks OP.

DorianMeile · 13/01/2025 17:16

I'm veggie so never been in a butchers, but always assumed that the butcher prepared the meat then sold it? Otherwise why not just go to supermarket? Unless they've actually had a whole animal delivered from China! Ugh, I don't know.

X72 · 13/01/2025 16:34

taxguru · 13/01/2025 13:16

Still easier than trying to grow crops on a mountain side or a steep valley!

Sheep and cattle don't do well on steep mountains and wet valleys. The hardy breeds that exist there just do better than other breeds and crops which are impractical. Sheep and cattle do much better on lowland pasture, but the opportunity cost then becomes greater.

Sorry to talk weather. What we produce and where we produce it has much to do with the fact that the western half of the country sticks out into a vast ocean and the prevailing winds brings wet mild weather, very suited to grass production for grazing, while the east traditionally has been drier so more suited to arable and root crops. This is why traditionally dairy production is heavy further west, with more arable on the eastern side (and pigs which don't do well in wet weather) across Yorkshire, Humber, Lincolnshire and into East Anglia.

bluegreygreen · 13/01/2025 15:56

I hadn't seen those labels include origin, hence assuming differently

Needspaceforlego · 13/01/2025 14:55

bluegreygreen · 13/01/2025 13:00

@Needspaceforlego that's certainly how I'm used to a local butcher/farmshop operating, but I'm quoting OP's reference to the packaging - perhaps she could clarify.
We are usually very careful with reading labels, though (coeliac family, usually hunting for gluten-free sausages!)

(Can identify with your username 😀)

I sort of assumed she meant the label once it was weighed.

My local butcher wrap your meet in a package and seal it with a sticky label. That label is printed with the detail of the product, ie 1.58kg shoulder mince @ £× /kg. Total price and date.

ChickenShittyBangBang · 13/01/2025 14:54

Dotto · 13/01/2025 13:28

How does that follow, or matter?

Look at the list of ingredients on a veggie or vegan ready made hamburger then think about what you would put into one, whether it be plant or meat based, if you made your own.

ChickenShittyBangBang · 13/01/2025 14:51

My mum reminds us occasionally that when she was young, chicken was a luxury, bought only if the rellies were coming, had to be ordered, long before Supermarkets, when there were three butchers in the town, or at Christmas Dad would buy a capon, does anyone remember those?

Yes, chicken was a special treat meal and much valued. Now for so many it's a thing to have sauce from a jar poured over it if 'I feel like chicken tonight' on a Wednesday.

We do not value our food enough now, it's too easily available and too cheap. I know there are working people going to food banks who will understandably balk at that but compare food waste nowadays to that of 40 or 50 years ago.

I heard not so long ago that capons were castrated without medication cockerels so not very welfare friendly, hence they're not a thing any more, AFAIK.

TaffetaRustle · 13/01/2025 14:45

I understand why we have to import, although there are arguments against that also but I wouldn't feel too great about eu meat either..

You have to dig a little but the eu isn't one homogeneous mass, there are wildly different standard between the countries and it's hard to implement rules.

Waggytail · 13/01/2025 14:42

There's an excellent podcast by Chris Van Tulleken (of Ultra Processed People fame) on Spotify called 'Fed', all about the chicken industry. How they're farmed, how they're slaughtered, the environmental vs ethical implications of the different ways of rearing them. And also about imports. Anything that comes in from outside the EU would worry me as you wouldn't have the same level of welfare for the birds and there's always concerns about the amount of antibiotics/flavourings/water that are artificially added into the chicken.

I don't eat it anymore but I remember getting a chicken tikka massalla microwave ready meal from Tesco and the chicken in it was RANK. The packet said it was from Thailand. I thought no wonder it's so rubbery and gross, it literally travelled half way across the world to end up on my plate!

taxguru · 13/01/2025 14:36

@TaffetaRustle

I can't believe we are importing Chinese chicken..

Because we can't produce enough in the UK of chicken nor anything else. We're losing farmland to property development, wind and solar farms, the population is increasing. We'd starve if we didn't import anything. We've not been self sufficient in terms of food for a few centuries! Farming more chicken would mean farming less of other crops and animals. Chicken need to be fed, so we'd also have to import more feed to feed them!

TaffetaRustle · 13/01/2025 14:27

I'd be nervous about any eu pork to be honest
A long while ago I was reading about how hard it was to implement food standards across the eu for a number of reasons.
I'm sure I read the UK for instance has some of the highest pork standards in the world.

I can't believe we are importing Chinese chicken..

I think waitrose is the only food producer who doesn't get caught up in the scandals.

I used an award winning butcher and the meat has been superb but I don't feel comfortable because I still don't know where it's from

TaffetaRustle · 13/01/2025 14:21

Op I find that shocking also, I have wondered how we do know the provenance of meat from local butchers.
At least a supermarket is at risk of being found out.
Surley local butchers can do anything?

DoloresODonovan · 13/01/2025 13:59

^ apparently, it is Ukraine which is known as the Bread Basket of Europe and not Poland, apologies all.

DoloresODonovan · 13/01/2025 13:56

taxguru · 13/01/2025 13:19

@LoveHearts69

I would also be shocked at a butcher ordering in meat from China though!

They're not ordering it from China. They'll be getting it from their local wholesale butchers who'll be getting it from larger regional/national wholesale butchers.

If the wholesalers didn't have any UK chicken at the time, they may have had no choice but to buy foreign chicken.

unscrupulous would be to remove it from its wrapper and pass it off as free range

caveat emptor has never had more resonance for us when purchasing chicken !

plominoagain · 13/01/2025 13:54

I live right in the middle of the fens ( basically exactly the same farming conditions as Holland ) It has something like 70 per cent of all the grade 1 soil ( best quality, usually very high yields) and so is being bought up left right and centre by Danish, German and Italian companies. The vast percentage of root crops and sugar beet are grown round here , and it never floods , because the whole area is managed . In the recent flood warnings , despite the rest of the country being flooded , the fens had no warnings at all , apart from the seasonal road closure, when the washes were opened up.

I'm very fortunate in our local butcher. He lists where all his meat comes from and he's very picky - he'll even tell the farms what he wants the stock to eat. Which is why on any given day , he's got a queue out the door .

DoloresODonovan · 13/01/2025 13:53

@Inkyblue123 Waitrose and Sainsbury too, dry and doesn’t last long.

It is grown on the IoW, at The Garlic Farm, or wild along wooded lanes here,

DoloresODonovan · 13/01/2025 13:49

Maliotopolo · 13/01/2025 11:19

Yuk I’d be really unhappy about Chinese chicken.
That said I do buy chicken breasts that are frozen and come from Poland. I buy it for the quality, I don’t know why but I find Polish Chicken to be superior quality ? Taste/ texture.. less plumped up and watery.

Good stuff from Poland ! we are buying the pale Kujawski rapeseed oil at the moment, started off using it for frying eggs, now use it for everything except salads,
paprika, huge jars of pickles, many good things, from the bread basket of Europe
(and flour occasionally when we can source it)

Inkyblue123 · 13/01/2025 13:41

even garlic in Asda and Tescos is China. 🇨🇳 m very picky about where I buy food now. We do a weekly shop at an independent butcher which only stocks uk meat from reputable farms but it costs more. We eat a couple of veggy meals in the week to balance out the budget.

rosieroses · 13/01/2025 13:36

For supermarket packaging, farm names and the Union Jack logo are not a guarantee of British reared meat. Tesco have a whole range of products marketed under fictional farm names. To display a Union Jack on packaging, the product has to be produced in the UK, but the ingredients may not be of UK origin.
If looking at packaging, The Red Tractor logo is the one to look out for, Red Tractor meat is of traceable British origin.

Dotto · 13/01/2025 13:28

DoloresODonovan · 13/01/2025 13:24

eat pretend meat ie Linda McCartney factory produced pap

How does that follow, or matter?

KittenPause · 13/01/2025 13:25

I'm so naive I would presume that all meat from a local butchers is from the UK. I'm disappointed for you.

DoloresODonovan · 13/01/2025 13:24

Thegoatliesdownonbroadway · 13/01/2025 13:18

Go veggie or vegan, then it won't matter to you where the meat comes from.

eat pretend meat ie Linda McCartney factory produced pap

DoloresODonovan · 13/01/2025 13:23

Our lovely local butcher here in South Oxfordshire sells chickens from Yorkshire !
I thought that was far enough !

If you buy chicken in a ready meal, tinned, cheap, check the origin China, Brazil,
where do you think takeaway chicken comes from, when you consider how many chicken based fast foot outlets there are, we cannot produce enough here to satisfy
demand.

My mum reminds us occasionally that when she was young, chicken was a luxury,
bought only if the rellies were coming, had to be ordered, long before Supermarkets,
when there were three butchers in the town, or at Christmas Dad would buy a capon, does anyone remember those?

Local butchers in this instance denotes location rather than source of chicken and I
would feel cheated of my expectations for sure.

Sixpence39 · 13/01/2025 13:21

This is why I find it hilarious when meat eaters kid themselves that every bit of meat they buy is ethically sourced, organic etc when the stats show more than 90% is factory farmed. So many assumptions made about 'local meat' to try to get away from the truth!

Swipe left for the next trending thread