Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband says any man would cheat given the opportunity

266 replies

Esgd27 · 12/01/2025 01:53

I’m a bit gobsmacked. Been with my DH for 30 years and have 2 grown up kid. Our relationship is generally ok.
We were watching a TV show tonight in which a woman hired a private detective to seduce her husband to see if he was faithful to her. My DH said it was unfair as it was entrapment. I said it was a bit odd but I guess the fictional wife had some concerns and was testing her husband. My DH doubled down by saying that all men would cheat given the opportunity. I challenged him and asked if he felt like that (ie he would cheat given half a chance). He said that he would and that any man would.
A very frosty exchange followed. He raised his voice and then tried to backtrack saying that wasn’t what he’d said and he didn’t mean it. But he did definitely say it. He’d drunk a bottle of wine so no doubt that exacerbated his truculence. He then went to bed in a huff.
I’m don’t particularly think he’s been /being unfaithful - and as a slightly plump balding 60 year old I don’t think he’s exactly Casanova.
I’ve tried to tell myself that it was just a slightly drunken silly remark. But I am still fuming - I thought it was a pretty rude and disrespectful thing to say to your wife. Particularly as he doubled down and didn’t apologise. He just didn’t seem to care or think what he was saying and it raised some concerns with me about his underlying moral code.

OP posts:
Esgd27 · 12/01/2025 10:18

Thanks for all your replies.
I get all the ‘maybe most men would given the chance….’ comments. But I think it’s a bit different to privately think this compared to saying it in this way to your wife. That still seems to me pretty rude and disrespectful. Exacerbated by no acknowledgement why I might have a problem with this.
Needless to say no apology forthcoming this morning. Just a terrible atmosphere. Am now feeling like I’m in the wrong to have called him out on his assertions. Definitely shades of gaslighting.

OP posts:
Lightswitchup · 12/01/2025 10:17

Yes I think most men would given the right circumstances. I have been cheated on by husband of near thirty years so I might be biased in my opinion. A lot of women would too but women tend to have different priorities.

GenderRealistBloke · 12/01/2025 10:17

pikkumyy77 · 12/01/2025 02:24

I think you are reading too much into what sounds like a pretty conventional case of masculine ego puffery mixed with pathological macho posturing. He didn’t mean he would cheat—he wanted to assert his right to be a bit of a lad, like other men. While a normal person might take pride in being moral, attached, honorable snd faithful there are lots of men who find those virtues dull and emasculating. So he rhetorically laid claim to his man card and asserted that all men would cheat if they could. I think he’s more buffoon than sinner. But i couldn’t respect him as my husband.

Maybe... but I think you are being too kind to him. The fact he buys into the idea, and is asserting his 'right' in that way is itself a big issue. As it speaks to how he sees his relationship and how he sees cheating. And it has real-world implications too. Someone who thinks everyone else is doing something bad (evading tax, shoplifting, cheating) is far more likely to actually do it.

If I told my wife I had a right to control her finances, and that all men know really that that's their role in the household, it would be a big red flag even if I didn't in fact starve her of cash.

BIossomtoes · 12/01/2025 10:11

Angelinadarling · 12/01/2025 10:01

i asked my exh if he would ever be interested in another woman.
He replied “yeah…i became blind when i married you”.
He met someone alse.

You asked a stupid question and received a sarcastic reply. Would you ever see another good looking, sexy man and think “Oh, look at you!”. I won’t believe you if you say no.

Branleuse · 12/01/2025 10:06

I don't think its true that any man would, but i think a lot would.
Also women, because i think infidelity is very common in both sexes.

RubyOrca · 12/01/2025 10:03

BIossomtoes · 12/01/2025 09:20

Lots of sanctimony here. It’s pretty obvious that there are times in any long marriage when both partners will meet someone and think “Oh, if I was single I definitely would”. I know I have in the 25 years I’ve been married and I know my bloke has too. Monogamy for decades is hard.

But that’s very different to I would cheat. Attraction doesn’t remove the ability to think for yourself. You can choose not to have sex or intimacy with someone.

Angelinadarling · 12/01/2025 10:01

i asked my exh if he would ever be interested in another woman.
He replied “yeah…i became blind when i married you”.
He met someone alse.

LondonPapa · 12/01/2025 10:01

Esgd27 · 12/01/2025 01:53

I’m a bit gobsmacked. Been with my DH for 30 years and have 2 grown up kid. Our relationship is generally ok.
We were watching a TV show tonight in which a woman hired a private detective to seduce her husband to see if he was faithful to her. My DH said it was unfair as it was entrapment. I said it was a bit odd but I guess the fictional wife had some concerns and was testing her husband. My DH doubled down by saying that all men would cheat given the opportunity. I challenged him and asked if he felt like that (ie he would cheat given half a chance). He said that he would and that any man would.
A very frosty exchange followed. He raised his voice and then tried to backtrack saying that wasn’t what he’d said and he didn’t mean it. But he did definitely say it. He’d drunk a bottle of wine so no doubt that exacerbated his truculence. He then went to bed in a huff.
I’m don’t particularly think he’s been /being unfaithful - and as a slightly plump balding 60 year old I don’t think he’s exactly Casanova.
I’ve tried to tell myself that it was just a slightly drunken silly remark. But I am still fuming - I thought it was a pretty rude and disrespectful thing to say to your wife. Particularly as he doubled down and didn’t apologise. He just didn’t seem to care or think what he was saying and it raised some concerns with me about his underlying moral code.

I’m any man, and no. No, I would not. What do I gain? Very little but can lose a lot. It’s like those stupid, would you cheat for £1m videos which makes zero sense to me as £1m isn’t a lot of money, it wouldn’t even pay expenses for the house I already own.

Yeah, cheating is not on and I wouldn’t cheat if given the chance.

DorothyStorm · 12/01/2025 09:54

You only know what you know. I know personally two happily married couples, long term years married, where both husbands have regular affairs and one night stands. Wives havent a clue. Both director level roles and unpredictable hours and work nights away, so their behaviour doesnt change.

we also know one study found 30% of men questioned would force a women to have sex with them if they knew they would get away with it.

we also know 70000 men were in a group about raping women.

i doubt these men would have any issues with affairs and ons.

HappyPanda613 · 12/01/2025 09:50

I think what makes this difficult to grasp for many women on this thread is that, in all honesty, they know this to be true and they don’t want it to be. It’s just another one of these inconvenient facts of life that we wish didn’t exist but sadly it does. Your husband, your father, your sensitive and caring brother who always attends local feminist rallies, would cheat if they could get away with it.

RubyOrca · 12/01/2025 09:50

What does he say sober?

I’d be having a sober conversation about whether he’s been faithful through your marriage, and whether he considers monogamy to be the goal and expectation of the marriage.

would he cheat given the opportunity? cause it’s hard NOT to have the opportunity.

BIossomtoes · 12/01/2025 09:49

WillBeatJanuaryBlues · 12/01/2025 09:45

Yes I think if they had no chance of being caught many would

And so would many women. I can’t be the only one who’s seen how some married women behave at conferences.

Notonyourjelly · 12/01/2025 09:49

EdnaTheWitch · 12/01/2025 02:34

I’ve just asked mine, half comatosed, and he says no 🤷🏻‍♀️

Mine said no as well when I asked him years ago.

He's now very much an exh as he cheated more than once.

Tandora · 12/01/2025 09:47

WalkingThroughTreacle · 12/01/2025 02:16

LTB, change the locks, get your ducks in a row, smash the penis beaker and deploy the penguin bollards. It was a stupid remark on the back of a frivolous and largely pointless, wine-fuelled disagreement on the back of a fictional TV show. He clearly can't speak for all men and unless he has actually been in the situation he can't even speak truly for himself.

This.
It would give me the ick but it was a stupid comment in the context of a trivial conversation. I wouldn’t attach importance to it per se.

WillBeatJanuaryBlues · 12/01/2025 09:45

Yes I think if they had no chance of being caught many would

HangryLikeTheHulk · 12/01/2025 09:43

BlueSilverCats · 12/01/2025 09:14

All men? No. Plenty would though.

That's why I find the mentality of keeping them on a "short leash" so to speak and fending other women off in order to reduce "opportunity " baffling.

A man that doesn't cheat only because he hasn't had the opportunity to do so, is still a cheat.

Let’s take a few words out:

”A man that doesn’t cheat […] is still a cheat.”

Makes no sense.

Live247 · 12/01/2025 09:42

I would say 80% of men would cheat in right circumstances. It's amazing how open men are with each other about this.

Some of the things people I know get upto, behind their wife's back, is actually mindblowing.

Of the blokes I know who do or have cheated on their partners. Only 1 out of about 10 have ever been caught out and that was after a years.

myplace · 12/01/2025 09:40

FigTreeInEurope · 12/01/2025 09:20

This is so offensive, although i do read enough MN to understand women's view of men's fidelity. All men would not cheat at all. I have felt for many years now, as though my actual sexuality is deeply tied to my wife, the thought of being with someone else is actually unthinkable. If i found myself suddenly single, i think it would take years to feel comfortable with someone else.

Personally, i think men that cheat, do so because there is something wrong in their life, or fundementally with their character. I know that within my male friendship group you would be hugely shamed and ostricised for it too.

There’s a massive clustering effect, I think. None of my friends have divorced. None have had affairs. None have been cheated on (as far as they know). We are all perhaps a bit boring, very busy, and with other priorities.

In other circles it seems to be very much an option.

People are saying that in their male workplaces, many do. In DH’s male workplace, they aren’t allowed to talk in that way. At all. It makes him slightly uncomfortable for fear of talking about something he shouldn’t- he really doesn’t need to, because he never would, but he’s a worrier 🤣

Different groups develop cultures I think.

SoldierofFortune · 12/01/2025 09:36

Hmm. I have been with DH since I was 18, married 30 years and never cheated.

However, as a thought experiment. If I was still young and beautiful and I was on a solo trip abroad - say, a conference - and met a beautiful man with zero connections to my real life and he was interested in me, would I cheat as a one-off? I don't know, but it might be a fantasy to do so. In reality I went on several solo trips for conferences etc and never even flirted with anyone. I have a huge amount invested in this relationship and wouldn't want to jeopardize it. But on the other hand, the thought of being desirable and desired, the thought of passion and being swept away, is quite seductive.

In reality I wouldn't do it because of the risks and the threat to my stability and relationship, and that I love my DH and would hate to hurt him. But if it came with an absolute guarantee that no one would find out, nothing would change, I would not be eaten up with guilt....maybe I would have?

Elphamouche · 12/01/2025 09:34

The only man I know who has said this, is one who had been cheating for 15 years! Bollocks would they.

Shoezembagsforever · 12/01/2025 09:30

Dontknowwhattocall13893 · 12/01/2025 09:22

Thieves think everyone steals

In other words
People that do shitty things or want to do shitty things think everyone does it.

This is a very good point too.

whyamiawakestillitssolate · 12/01/2025 09:30

When my DH and I went to counselling after I found out about his affair (he was vocally anti-cheating and I was a “my DH never would, we’re happy and have lots of sex so he doesn’t need to” wife) our counsellor said his experience over many years is the reason men cheat or don’t is generally as simple as opportunity with someone they find attractive and the idea they won’t get caught. Very depressing really.

Shoezembagsforever · 12/01/2025 09:28

I think your DH was being goady but misinformed.

When in groups (work, hobbies, sport) men tend, if they're not particularly strong characters, to mirror the dominant behaviour, which may be one of objectifying women and which has probably given your DH that impression.

What men nearly all tend to do though is fantasise a lot about cheating and indulge in porn to varying degrees, but not so much in real life.

Holu · 12/01/2025 09:26

Some men are serial cheats and will dip and in and out. They won't ever leave their wives. They simply want sex with other women. Some will only cheat for exit affair because they fundamentally aren't happy with their marriage but do want to be married. Given the chance to be with someone they're more suited to they will cheat briefly and go. I'd put at least 75% of men into either of the above categories. Women are fools who give up their own independence and stay home long term. You're just so vulnerable.

LadyKenya · 12/01/2025 09:22

MarkingBad · 12/01/2025 02:03

I don't think all men would given the opportunity. I've seen plenty of men turn down an opportunity.

It depends on who may have been offering the opportunity though. It would not surprise me that most men would probably cheat if the "right" woman was up for it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread