Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask your opinions on Sex and the City?

331 replies

mumofoneAlonebutokay · 10/01/2025 21:04

I saw something on tiktok today that said 'Carrie was to Big what Janice was to Chandler' 👀👀😬

I rewatch it all the time tbh, it's my fave show but now that Gen Z have found it, there are a lot of hot takes available online

What do people think of Carrie, now that 20 years have passed? Who's your fave? x

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
8
Kbroughton · 31/01/2025 03:56

Loved it at the time. A bit like some episodes of friends, and then when you realised that in Don't Forget Your Tooothbrush' they WEIGHED women and nobody said anything, and Bridget Jones was fat at 9 stone, you do wonder what the fuck we were all doing in the nineties! SATC was good at the time as it allowed, we thought, a different take in women and sex. Was a mainstream show when women were allowed to be sexual. When you look back though they were really saying there was something wrong with you if you weren't married. But all media is a product of its time. The worse thing for me is that Big LEFT HER AT THE ALTER and she forgave him and married him and we were meant to think this was a happy ending. Hmmmmm.

mumofoneAlonebutokay · 31/01/2025 01:53

Appalonia · 31/01/2025 01:13

My God those women on that podcast are silly. Ok I'm a lot older than them, but I'm listening to them chastising Charlotte for being upset about her partner calling her a
' fing whore' or ' fing' birch when he comes, and they're saying that this is totally normal now and it's just like having sex in the missionary position! Well no it's not. God I hate this stupid ' sex positivity' movememt, which is really driven by hard core porn and which so many young women have bought into. We should NOT be normalizing this!

What podcast? 👀👀

I dunno, she was being precious about a bit of dirty talk but tbf it wasn't really consensual

OP posts:
Appalonia · 31/01/2025 01:13

My God those women on that podcast are silly. Ok I'm a lot older than them, but I'm listening to them chastising Charlotte for being upset about her partner calling her a
' fing whore' or ' fing' birch when he comes, and they're saying that this is totally normal now and it's just like having sex in the missionary position! Well no it's not. God I hate this stupid ' sex positivity' movememt, which is really driven by hard core porn and which so many young women have bought into. We should NOT be normalizing this!

MrsPeterHarris · 20/01/2025 00:19

Completely agree @Crushed23

Crushed23 · 19/01/2025 18:19

Haven't RTFT.

I absolutely love it. I was a latecomer to it because I was a child/teen when it aired. I've rewatched it so many times.

This is a controversial opinion, but I don't think Carrie is any worse than the other characters (one of the main points of the show was that these were supposed to be real, flawed women not perfect princesses), she's just hated more because she's attractive, is the central character, wears the best outfits on the show, has a cracking body, and a fabulous lifestyle.

I also think people get confused about the format of the show. It was not a show about 4 friends. It was a show about Carrie (who is also the narrator) and her 3 friends. So while it seems like she is more self-centred than the others, she isn't, it's just the show is focused on her as she is the main character.

AliasGrace47 · 19/01/2025 17:27

Juliagreeneyes · 11/01/2025 02:51

No way would Carrie have voted Trump! They were all clearly Democrats, even if Charlotte might have started off Republican 😆 Carrie would have so been a Hillary girl.

I once tried to read 4 Blondes - at the time Candace Bushnell books were always being given away for free with magazines (Gen Zers missed the era of the fashion magazine which is partly what formed the culture of the show…and in the early 2000s women’s magazines were a big deal, with a kind of free gift war going on - free books, free CDs, free beach totes, free clothes - I still have an excellent All Saints vest that came free with Elle in about 2005…<sigh>) Anyway, I found Bushnell’s actual writing impossible to get into. It’s written in a really odd style and it’s really hard to keep track of the narrative - not like the TV show at all.

That's interesting BTW about women's magazines...I do sometimes wish they were a Gen Z thing. I guess it's better for the planet, but online magazines just don't have the same feel.. Esp envious of the free gift war- my grandmother has a huge amount of free DVDs she got from various papers in the early 2000s, I'd wondered why they were all raining freebies then...😂

AliasGrace47 · 19/01/2025 17:22

Richardchamberlainrocks · 19/01/2025 13:50

I haven’t read all of the thread so I’m sorry if it’s already been mentioned but did anyone watch Lipstick Jungle? I really enjoyed that but it only ran for two seasons which was a real shame as it was written by Candace Bushnell and I had high hopes for it.

Aha, funnily I got an extract from that for a GCSE revision comprehension once...it was really good, I thought. Still on my to be read...

MrsPeterHarris · 19/01/2025 16:14

I loved Lipstick Jungle too @Richardchamberlainrocks - had Teddy from Grey's Anatomy in it & she was great (& not the whiny annoying character she is in GA!)

Richardchamberlainrocks · 19/01/2025 13:50

I haven’t read all of the thread so I’m sorry if it’s already been mentioned but did anyone watch Lipstick Jungle? I really enjoyed that but it only ran for two seasons which was a real shame as it was written by Candace Bushnell and I had high hopes for it.

mumofoneAlonebutokay · 19/01/2025 13:28

See, I'm rewatching the first series

Miranda wanted a man on her level but couldn't keep one

Her date with Ted Baker (ep 6) was good but she had to bring up his spanking fetish (which is an ick, but she needed more info)

She talked her way out of some good men in her field, rather than chilling and holding back some of her thoughts

She settled for Steve like big settled for carrie 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
GellerYeller · 19/01/2025 12:26

Needhelp101 · 15/01/2025 09:09

Late to this thread but I loved it then and I love it now. The writing is so smart and I love the fact that it really celebrates friendship.

The episode when Miranda's mum dies is really moving.

There are some lovely moments in that episode. Miranda in the changing room, Steve and Aiden showing up to support her and Carrie walking her out of the church. I especially enjoyed the flowers Charlotte arranged, that were not supposed to say ‘you’re dead, let’s disco’.

x2boys · 19/01/2025 11:58

JHound · 16/01/2025 16:30

What “stupidly high” standards did they have exactly?

Miranda always liked Steve. He was the one who had the issue with her outearning him.

Charlotte also just was not super attracted to Harry But I don’t think wanting to fancy your partner is a “stupidly high standard”.

Also she did not really drop her standard as Harry, like all her exes was wealthy, well educated and from a privileged background.

Edited

Charlotte was very attracted to Harry
She just couldn't see why ,because he isn't a conventionally handsome man

Thisinfuriatingplace · 17/01/2025 12:24

JenniferBooth · 12/01/2025 14:46

do you remember this TV show Set in London and New York

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NY-LON

I watched this just before Christmas, watched it when it originally was shown ( couldn’t really remember it) The ending I was so disappointed with

JHound · 16/01/2025 16:30

Guinessandafire · 15/01/2025 10:07

I think the overall message of it gets lost for some that love it.

My work colleagues used to love the ' sexual empowerment' of it all.

For me the message was that none of the four were happy until they realised the reason they were single was that their standards were stupidly high, and their shallow and materialistic taste in men never led to them being happy.

When they started to appreciate the qualities of the likes of Harry and Steve, that's when they found what they were looking for.

I also never forgave Carrie for cheating on Aidan with 'Big'. I think the storyline was well done , because you were genuinely disappointed in her.

What “stupidly high” standards did they have exactly?

Miranda always liked Steve. He was the one who had the issue with her outearning him.

Charlotte also just was not super attracted to Harry But I don’t think wanting to fancy your partner is a “stupidly high standard”.

Also she did not really drop her standard as Harry, like all her exes was wealthy, well educated and from a privileged background.

MrsPeterHarris · 15/01/2025 22:52

I loved it too @Appalonia - have loved all of Sex & the City and also And Just Like That! Fabulous!

Appalonia · 15/01/2025 22:40

I know everyone hates the second film, but I personally found it really entertaining. The part when Charlotte was honest about how hard she found motherhood was very moving. The fashions were fabulous, the problems with Carrie and Big when boredom set in, and her angst over kissing Aidan, the foursome singing I am Woman, the Indian hotel worker who had to work abroad and so rarely saw his wife, and Carrie's generosity towards him. Also how women and their sexuality gets treated in Middle Eastern countries. The bit when the women were smuggled out at the end in burkhas was like something out of a Carry On film!

ThePoliteLion · 15/01/2025 20:20

GogAndMagog · 15/01/2025 09:31

@ThePoliteLion
Don't you think Bridget Jones and SATC also reinforces the age old view the women are always looking out for boyfriends? As that's all they talk about!
Apart from Samantha that is.

I spent all my twenties (SATC era ) with women who were always looking for boyfriends. It was exhausting. I never had one til quite later. Then I thought, phew, now I'll fit in. 🙄
I don't feel there is that pressure now.

I loved the clothes, the friendships, loved it when Miranda called out Carrie on occasion.

As for the comparison with Chandler and Janice (I loved Janice, she was unfailingly herself) I always thought Carrie was to Aiden what Big was to Carrie!! She wouldn't commit to him and messed him about big time!

Bridget, yes, found it a challenge/annoying to be amongst the Smug Marrieds (and that phrase is pure genius). Charlotte wanted to get married. I could never work out what Carrie wanted. Miranda, I thought, didn’t really want a partner. Samantha wanted to be free. While I’m on the board I too have to say how horrible Berger is! His role is brilliantly written and when I was young I just might have found his shtick attractive. Petrovsky also a tin man…

Hollybelle83 · 15/01/2025 18:42

I still love it! Just finished a rewatch not too long ago. Yes bits of it haven't aged well but it's still very entertaining. I actually quite like the first film too.

Interestingly my feelings in the characters has changed loads since watching it back in the day. I still love Miranda the best and Patrovsky can get in the bin (always disliked him). But I used to loathe Carrie and now she doesn't bother me so much. Aiden I always thought was a sweet guy treated really badly, but now I think he's an arse hole. Was Big as bad as I thought back in the day, maybe not.

Who doesn't love Samantha, especially when she does something lovely (giving Miranda the hair appointment) and Charlotte can be annoying but 'I curse the day you were born' is a classic.

Ohnonotmeagain · 15/01/2025 17:35

AliasGrace47 · 15/01/2025 13:18

I think this partly explains the PUA rubbish that developed later. Obvs it's ok if the people take no for an answer, asking someone out isn't PUA by default! But NY has more of a culture of asking out anytime, anyplace, so the PUA stuff seemed slightly less weird over there. Whereas here men asking random women in the street out seems odd in itself.

What’s PUA?

Appalonia · 15/01/2025 16:51

ThePoliteLion · 14/01/2025 21:08

I loved the original series then and still love it now. The writing is whip smart. I was either single or with an ill-suited boyfriend when they first aired, and found SATC a great comfort. I felt it validated my own situation (in the same way that the first two Bridget Jones novels made the very single Bridget so loveable and real). I think before SATC and Bridget, the dominant culture told women that they should be happily coupled up…both were so fresh and groundbreaking. I am grateful to SATC for cheering me up. Now I’m in my fifties and see the problems with Carrie/Big, her personality flaws etc…I was always a bit worried that I was like Charlotte. The Bunny McDougal episodes still make me laugh. AJLT - eugh - no thanks - how could they do that to Miranda’s character. Hmm…maybe I’ll watch the boxed set again…as comforting as a jacket potato with grated cheese. Loving this thread and thank you to the PP for the You Tube recommendation. The Sentimental Garbage podcast does an excellent deep dive into the original series too.

Listening to the podcast today, very entertaining, thanks for the recommendation!😁

AliasGrace47 · 15/01/2025 13:18

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 15/01/2025 09:00

I agree. I never lived there but saw someone there for a while and I got asked out on the street, by barristas, in cafes. I also had female friends there of the same age and the rules of engagement on dating (presuming not exclusive until specifically agreed, very pragmatic deliberations about money, class, shared views etc) as shown in SATC were pretty accurate and generally understood.

I think this partly explains the PUA rubbish that developed later. Obvs it's ok if the people take no for an answer, asking someone out isn't PUA by default! But NY has more of a culture of asking out anytime, anyplace, so the PUA stuff seemed slightly less weird over there. Whereas here men asking random women in the street out seems odd in itself.

Guinessandafire · 15/01/2025 10:07

I think the overall message of it gets lost for some that love it.

My work colleagues used to love the ' sexual empowerment' of it all.

For me the message was that none of the four were happy until they realised the reason they were single was that their standards were stupidly high, and their shallow and materialistic taste in men never led to them being happy.

When they started to appreciate the qualities of the likes of Harry and Steve, that's when they found what they were looking for.

I also never forgave Carrie for cheating on Aidan with 'Big'. I think the storyline was well done , because you were genuinely disappointed in her.

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 15/01/2025 09:58

I haven't watched the new series at all. It would never work for me without Samantha and I am also quite sad to hear how Miranda's arc has gone. I liked that she and Steve gave us a glimpse of a couple actually working on staying together and dealing with real life problems like care of elderly parents.

Needhelp101 · 15/01/2025 09:54

Lottapianos · 15/01/2025 09:35

'I mostly hate-watched And Just Like That but the scene between Carrie and Natasha in the coffee shop was brilliantly written and acted.'

I agree - it was great. Some aspects of AJLT are beyond awful and I've nearly given up on it more than once, but there are some brilliant moments, the clothes are still spectacular, and overall I think its worth the pain 😁

I rewatched it again fairly recently and I actually think as an examination of grief, it hits the spot.
It's just the rest of it that's shit 😁

Swipe left for the next trending thread