Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

One child has inherited AGAIN

885 replies

EWAB · 10/01/2025 16:20

A decade ago my younger son benefited from a massive inheritance.

Essentially my MiL bypassed her three children and left everything to her 6 grandchildren.

The grandchildren: 2 siblings, 3 siblings and my younger child.

SHE WAS ENTITLED TO DO AS SHE PLEASED. IT WAS HER MONEY.

The fallout was quite seismic for lots of reasons. My partner felt that as he only had one child the family of the brother with 3 children benefitted disproportionately.

It was said at the time and I believe this to be the case that the will was designed like this. to stop my elder child from a previous relationship from benefiting as he might have done 40/50 years later if the money had gone directly to my partner.

As for my relationship, my partner refused to consider changing our wills leaving more to elder child who was at the time very unlikely to inherit from his own father. He is now on property ladder but any inheritance will pale into insignificance compared with younger child’s

Well it’s happened again!

Late MiL’s half brother has left his entire estate to the MALE grandchildren of his siblings. Younger son and partner’s nephew and we think 2 or 3 others.

HE WAS ENTITLED TO DO WHAT HE WANTED WITH HIS OWN MONEY.

I genuinely can’t contemplate my two sons having such vastly different lives.

I want advice to come to terms with it . I have disabled voting. I can’t talk to anyone.

OP posts:
MartonCaffeine · 11/01/2025 19:19

InterIgnis · 11/01/2025 19:08

It isn’t hers to redistribute. What does ‘deserving’ have to do with anything? He doesn’t need to deserve it to have it, and him having it doesn’t mean that OP is required to compensate his brother, who hasn’t even been treated unfairly. The brothers have been treated differently by relatives they don’t have in common, which is entirely different proposition to their own mother treating them unequally.

Rather than a lesson in fairness, such action is more likely to create bad feeling and destroy relationships.

I admit it's imperfect, but it seems to me the current situation is very likely to create bad feelings and destroy relationships on its own already. One brother is being taught that he's automatically entitled, and the other undeserving.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 11/01/2025 19:15

Pepsiewomen · 11/01/2025 18:15

Omg have you no feelings for this woman at all it's not the DC fault either , I myself had one son when I met my husband and then had another son after we were married, then my hubby went on to adopt my first son and our will is made out to them both receiving equal also the same with my mil as she has left equal amounts between her 4 grandchildren with two of them being my son's and the other two children being his brothers children.
This to me shows that I married into a loving family who treated a child that wasn't blood related to them but was still in their hearts part of the family and was loved just much as my other son was loved .

Your husband adopted your first son. That changed everything. I wish that people would stop equating step-child with adopted-child. Adopted children are given the same legal and financial rights as a biological child.

A step-child does not have these protections.

TheOnionEyes · 11/01/2025 19:10

InterIgnis · 11/01/2025 19:08

It isn’t hers to redistribute. What does ‘deserving’ have to do with anything? He doesn’t need to deserve it to have it, and him having it doesn’t mean that OP is required to compensate his brother, who hasn’t even been treated unfairly. The brothers have been treated differently by relatives they don’t have in common, which is entirely different proposition to their own mother treating them unequally.

Rather than a lesson in fairness, such action is more likely to create bad feeling and destroy relationships.

Yes, I totally agree

Pupinskipops · 11/01/2025 19:10

Oof, the fallout from the consequences of inheritances, intended or otherwise, can be so harsh. No advice, I'm afraid, except to offer you and your eldest son my sympathies. I'd be feeling the same pain as you.

ThisQuickPlumFinch · 11/01/2025 19:09

You say they are entitled to do what they want with their will, then complain about it?

You can't have it both ways.

InterIgnis · 11/01/2025 19:08

MartonCaffeine · 11/01/2025 18:48

It's a sorry state of affairs that it's happened. If the money is accessible can you try redistributing it? E.g. youngest has less/nothing spent on them, they have to self fund everything? Might seem unfair but what has one of your children done to deserve the money that the other hasn't? It'd be a lesson in fairness (and economy)

It isn’t hers to redistribute. What does ‘deserving’ have to do with anything? He doesn’t need to deserve it to have it, and him having it doesn’t mean that OP is required to compensate his brother, who hasn’t even been treated unfairly. The brothers have been treated differently by relatives they don’t have in common, which is entirely different proposition to their own mother treating them unequally.

Rather than a lesson in fairness, such action is more likely to create bad feeling and destroy relationships.

BlackBean2023 · 11/01/2025 19:03

@SchoolDilemma17 I am not suggesting he blames his brother, or anyone. But jealousy is a normal, understandable, emotion in the circumstances.

SchoolDilemma17 · 11/01/2025 19:02

TheOnionEyes · 11/01/2025 19:01

I do think we open ourselves up to this when we get into blended families. I think we have to understand that the children may not receive equal amounts when it comes to inheritance. 2 families can be on quite different financial spectrums. Grandparents usually consider their biological grandchildren. I don't think they are wrong to do that. An ex partner will consider their biological children and not the children that his ex goes on to have children with.

All of these things and more create this inequality

And nobody should plan their life or their children’s around a potential inheritance. People can do with their money what they want!

SchoolDilemma17 · 11/01/2025 19:01

Bellyblueboy · 11/01/2025 18:57

Why? Out of curiosity.

should ‘step’ grandchildren inherit from potentially four sets of grandparents? What about people who have three or four marriages?

And that’s also unfair. One DC inherits from 3 sets for example and their half sibling from 2 sets only 😉🤷🏻‍♀️

TheOnionEyes · 11/01/2025 19:01

I do think we open ourselves up to this when we get into blended families. I think we have to understand that the children may not receive equal amounts when it comes to inheritance. 2 families can be on quite different financial spectrums. Grandparents usually consider their biological grandchildren. I don't think they are wrong to do that. An ex partner will consider their biological children and not the children that his ex goes on to have children with.

All of these things and more create this inequality

Bellyblueboy · 11/01/2025 18:57

CatherineDurrant · 11/01/2025 18:50

Obviously, their money so their decision.

I have to say however that I am very sad for "stepgrandchildren" who are treated as "less than" than biological grandchildren.

Why? Out of curiosity.

should ‘step’ grandchildren inherit from potentially four sets of grandparents? What about people who have three or four marriages?

SchoolDilemma17 · 11/01/2025 18:55

CatherineDurrant · 11/01/2025 18:50

Obviously, their money so their decision.

I have to say however that I am very sad for "stepgrandchildren" who are treated as "less than" than biological grandchildren.

Why should they be treated the same?They are not their grandchildren, but the children of someone their son chose to date.

Of course you don’t feel the same unless in very exceptional circumstances.

QuimCarrey · 11/01/2025 18:55

HollyKnight · 11/01/2025 18:45

Technically calling her partner's mum "MIL" isn't correct either. This thread is basically "My boyfriend's mum gave his inheritance to his son because of me and now his uncle has done the same thing. I'm devastated that my other son from a previous relationship doesn't have exactly the same amount of money in the bank. Should I interfere again and cause more trouble?"

This.

Whydoeseveryonewanttoargue · 11/01/2025 18:54

My first response is so what? I don’t mean that unkindly. Kids in families have different “outcomes” all the time. It’s just money. Money doesn’t but happiness but yes it affords choices.

My point is why are you letting this bother you? Yeah it’s unexpected and shocking but it is what it is - seemingly unfair but as long as your kids are happy and healthy that’s all that matters.

CatherinedeBourgh · 11/01/2025 18:52

I love the idea of inheriting from step parents.

My mother had 3 partners, my father 5. All my half siblings are very wealthy. I'd be loaded! I would have got some of what each of them got, I'd probably have more than them.

Sadly, reality is that that is not how it works. Nor should it be.

Barrenfieldoffucks · 11/01/2025 18:52

ACynicalDad · 11/01/2025 18:51

Apart from the males only bit there is nothing surprising here.

Agreed.

ACynicalDad · 11/01/2025 18:51

Apart from the males only bit there is nothing surprising here.

CatherineDurrant · 11/01/2025 18:50

Obviously, their money so their decision.

I have to say however that I am very sad for "stepgrandchildren" who are treated as "less than" than biological grandchildren.

MartonCaffeine · 11/01/2025 18:48

It's a sorry state of affairs that it's happened. If the money is accessible can you try redistributing it? E.g. youngest has less/nothing spent on them, they have to self fund everything? Might seem unfair but what has one of your children done to deserve the money that the other hasn't? It'd be a lesson in fairness (and economy)

TheOnionEyes · 11/01/2025 18:47

flowerfairy6004 · 11/01/2025 18:21

OP I understand why you feel so bad for your older son. I would feel like that if I remarried and had another child and my firstborn was left out especially if we’d been married for a long time and my child had grown up as part of the family for a long time. You’re concerned that they’d feel cast aside and could form resentment if their younger sibling could have advantages they’re denied such as paying off university fees or having a deposit for a home. I can understand your partner’s family making their decisions - I personally think it’s a bit cruel if your son had grown up in the family for a long time. I do think your partner is being insensitive though - he met and married you and did so knowing and choosing to be a stepfather. He and you went on and had a child together but blended families should work that all kids are seen as collectively ‘yours’. I can see it might be different if you get together when you’re much older and all the kids are already adults but this isn’t the case in your situation if I’ve understood correctly. As others have said I think the best thing would be to sit both brothers down and explain that you love them both equally and that you both just want to give them an equal opportunity in life and therefore you want to balance the scales and give assistance in the form of money to the oldest so they can have the same opportunities that the youngest has due to his two inheritances. Being open and allowing them to get the opportunity to ask questions and state their feelings means they won’t get a shock in future when the will’s being read and allows them to know why you’re making the decisions and hopefully will stop any future animosity between them. Talk frankly to your partner he has to be honest just like if you adopt a child they are yours regardless of biology does he see your older child as ‘his’? Hope you find a resolution that makes both your sons feel seen and loved equally. Good luck.

I do understand what you have said here. However, this could cause problems too.

Let's just say the SF leaves to his SC, and then the biological father and biological grandparents leave for their son/grandson, and of course the OP leaves to her DC1 too. He may end up getting so much more than the younger son.

I just think when you have blended families, it's going to be difficult to know what to do in these instances. It won't usually work out equal, but that's not to say it's not fairly carried out by some.

HollyKnight · 11/01/2025 18:45

Technically calling her partner's mum "MIL" isn't correct either. This thread is basically "My boyfriend's mum gave his inheritance to his son because of me and now his uncle has done the same thing. I'm devastated that my other son from a previous relationship doesn't have exactly the same amount of money in the bank. Should I interfere again and cause more trouble?"

Whippetlovely · 11/01/2025 18:45

I agree with pp you are being dramatic. Many siblings take different paths and one could be much richer than the other regardless of any inheritance. I don't like these posts saying they will give one child more in their own will. Regardless of any wealth of your children you should always split your will between them fairly. Otherwise you could cause huge issues with the siblings once you have passed away I think it's very cruel actually.

SchoolDilemma17 · 11/01/2025 18:45

BlackBean2023 · 11/01/2025 18:42

My DH's half brothers (DH was 2 when DMIL remarried - he's 40 now, BILs are 36 and 32) inherited almost £500k each last year from their paternal grandparent and DH got £10k.

It is was it is but won't lie that my DH has felt jealous and has distanced himself from his brothers to help manage those feelings.

But why blame the brothers? Unless they influenced the will?

I think it is a bit unusual to expect to inherit from step grandparents unless you are very close. Mine had 10 grandchildren, of course I didn’t inherit. No idea who did.

BlackBean2023 · 11/01/2025 18:42

My DH's half brothers (DH was 2 when DMIL remarried - he's 40 now, BILs are 36 and 32) inherited almost £500k each last year from their paternal grandparent and DH got £10k.

It is was it is but won't lie that my DH has felt jealous and has distanced himself from his brothers to help manage those feelings.

SchoolDilemma17 · 11/01/2025 18:40

EWAB · 10/01/2025 19:31

I am genuinely not arguing that he should have inherited from his stepfamily.

I came on here because I am upset that my children will have such different lives, which of course many full siblings do, like my own but this disparity has not come about through different choices.

This latest inheritance, I could not have predicted in a million years

Indeed lots of siblings have different lives. It’s not an issue until you make it one.

My BIL is a multi-millionaire, my DH is not, it’s not an issue!