Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The think that if you are a patient in hospital, that it is the height of rudeness and intrusiveness to attampt to chit chat with your roommates

259 replies

user1471516498 · 08/01/2025 19:37

I have a long standing medical condition that means I have to spend quite a bit of time in hospital. Privacy on NHS wards is pretty minimal, so I have always thought that it was polite to keep your curtains closed if possible, and if they have to be open, then you put headphones in, avoid eye contact and generally avoid inflicting yourself on others. And certainly you don't make small talk with complete strangers.
I am not being unfriendly here, I am just treating other people how I would want to be treated. The last thing I want when I am feeling ill is to have to talk to people who I have nothing in common with other than being in the same room.
In all of my many hospital stays, I have never been rude enough to intrude on others, but the two women in my bay are just being insufferable! Is it just me, or is this just downright rude?

OP posts:
Sugarnspicenallthingsnaice · 08/01/2025 23:01

I'm an introvert who hates small talk but I think it'd be incredibly rude and quite weird to keep your eyes forward and not even acknowledge another person lying a few feet away.

GremlinDolphin4 · 08/01/2025 22:57

OP your post made me laugh - you have every right not to engage but often the thing that gets people through a hospital visit is talking to other people on the Ward. I think you underestimate how lonely a large proportion of people are.

I work on a Medical Ward and during Covid we had lots of people on our Ward who did not want to go home, they loved the constant companionship of strangers c compared to the complete isolation at home- what a strange world we had created. People generally need people.

CactusSammy · 08/01/2025 22:56

I recently had an outpatient procedure, and had to sit in the waiting room with several other ladies for about 3 hours.

We started off quiet, but eventually got chatting and had a real laugh. Was also nice to support each other, as lots of us were nervous about the procedure.

Yabu. Lighten up a bit and get chatting, you might even enjoy it.

Teenagehorrorbag · 08/01/2025 22:53

Surely you can keep curtains closed? I've (touch wood) only been in once for a week (apart from having DCs) and in the first ward the woman next to me was clearly extremely unwell - coughing horrendously to the point of vomiting, all day long! I kept the curtain closed between us all the time!!

Turned out she had flu (no.....??) and the ward was closed down and none of us could have visitors or tests. I was later moved to another ward and put in an isolation room just in case I had caught flu - but luckily I hadn't. Thank goodness for curtains!!

But going back to OPs point - I agree that everyone is different. My DH is that weirdo who talks to people on trains.....😯!! If in hospital he would 100% chat all day long to anyone who would listen!

I'm a bit more selective - would be sociable if and when I felt like it - but other times would be reading or on my laptop and expect to be left alone. And if I was really actually unwell - talking would be the last thing I'd want.....

Horses for courses.

CoolPlayer · 08/01/2025 22:48

I’ve really appreciated people chatting to me while in hospital tbh, if I’d had enough chat I’d prob just shut my eyes to rest x

FagsMagsandBags · 08/01/2025 22:47

I was in hospital three times last week over a period of just over ten weeks, two longer stays of four weeks and a shorter stay of two weeks.

People talk to each other because there's little else to do. Some of our visitors talked to us and each other and, etc. Once you're on a ward you have to accept that there will be talking because it's part of the human condition. Yes, if you don't want to talk you close the curtains and/or put headphones on. I did that if I was having a particularly difficult time or needed a good cry. If there were people I didn't want to talk to I kept it to a minimum and because most people were in and out far more quickly than me I didn't get stuck with anyone too awful for too long. The only place I didn't talk to others was on ICU because I had a room of my own and mostly slept. I'm in a small WhatsApp group with three patients who I was on a ward with for about a week and we're all still a little bit in touch. One of the women was going to have the same surgery I'd had which she's since had and I was able to help her with how it would be, when she could get off her feeding tube, when she might eat more solid food, etc. I helped her and it helped me to be able to help. If we'd all sat around in silence that wouldn't have happened and we'd probably all have been miserable as sin.

Unless you can get yourself a private room I'm afraid that you have to accept that you're in the minority and just have to find a way to suck it up or just pull your curtains around you. You're not forced into interaction but you're being unreasonable if you expect it not to happen at all.

I've just read that the woman opposite was throwing questions at you after you said you were too sick to talk. Yeah, she's being inconsiderate and that's not fair on you.

scotstars · 08/01/2025 22:41

People are not being rude they are being polite/friendly. If you don't want to talk you have every right to say so/pull your curtain closed but I have to say it's not what I've experienced.
My dad has had multiple hospital admissions he's not very extroverted but usually by time I go for first visit he knows everyones name, occupation etc. Last time he had been in 1 night when I visited him and another patient had already swapped books

MimiGC · 08/01/2025 22:38

I think you sound rude and unfriendly. In my experience, normal friendly chit chat is totally standard in hospital.
What I find intolerable is the noise from other patients' music, films etc. It's like they have never heard of earphones. I also found it distressing hearing elderly people with dementia crying, moaning and sometimes fighting off the staff. I know they couldn't help it, but it was heartbreaking to witness.

AngelinaFibres · 08/01/2025 22:37

Lobstercrisps · 08/01/2025 19:47

Good lord I absolutely agree OP.

I've never had to experience an NHS ward and been lucky enough to go private 3 times in the last few years.

But I barely even talk to the nurses and make myself into as small and convenient package of a patient as I can. I also decline all offers of food or tea/coffee, the idea of sitting in a bed and eating is grim. If someone tried to small talk to me I would make it VERY clear that I am not the person they are hoping for.

I don't give a hoot if that's rude or not. You won't get better if you are constantly worried about offending someone or feeling obliged to be social.

How very odd you are.

Waterbaby41 · 08/01/2025 22:36

You are being rude and unfriendly. And how do you know you have nothing in common with people you won't even talk to?

Samandytimlucypeterolivia · 08/01/2025 22:36

Personally I don’t like to strike up a convo with strangers, but if they start talking to me I’ll engage. I seem to always attract the chatty types 😂

Grammarnut · 08/01/2025 22:33

Lobstercrisps · 08/01/2025 19:47

Good lord I absolutely agree OP.

I've never had to experience an NHS ward and been lucky enough to go private 3 times in the last few years.

But I barely even talk to the nurses and make myself into as small and convenient package of a patient as I can. I also decline all offers of food or tea/coffee, the idea of sitting in a bed and eating is grim. If someone tried to small talk to me I would make it VERY clear that I am not the person they are hoping for.

I don't give a hoot if that's rude or not. You won't get better if you are constantly worried about offending someone or feeling obliged to be social.

So you starve?

HamAndMustardSandwich · 08/01/2025 22:30

YANBU. I occasionally get rushed in if DH can’t manage my seizures. Probably happens once every 3 years or so. One time this woman wouldn’t stop trying to talk to me and it was awful. I had an agonising headache and, tbh, I was talking gibberish anyway after 7 seizures. I had to press the call button in the end to ask the nurse to shut my curtain so I could try and sleep.

ByQuaintAzureWasp · 08/01/2025 22:30

It's boring in hospital, normal.people want to.chat. if you ate anti-docial, earplugs, eye mask or sign yourself out I'd you hate other humans so much

Butteredtoast55 · 08/01/2025 22:27

The last time I was in hospital there were four of us on the ward across two days and it was a nice balance of chat and silence. I value quiet and privacy but it was nice to break up the time by chatting a little.
As another poster said, we helped each other out and between us were able to provide one - who had nobody to visit and was clearly lonely, vulnerable and hadn't expected to stay in - with toiletries and something to read, as well as a spare nightshirt. It all felt a bit 'Dunkirk spirit' and definitely helped make a hospital stay less dull.

Mrsgreen100 · 08/01/2025 22:25

Being in hospital is a scary experience for many , and actually ime human contact helps
ive met and shared back and forth with others, in hospital and it totally helped normalise what isn’t normal tbh
sorry u find it hard , but people tend to chatter more when frightened and out of their comfort zone , try to be understanding at the same time just explain your need for you time .

ViciousCurrentBun · 08/01/2025 22:25

I remember being the only young woman on a ward, I was 30 and all the other women were retired but most were around 75 plus. I was one of the few allowed out of bed and I loved chatting to them, they would call me over and make a fuss of me. It made it bearable. I’m almost 60 now so I doubt any are still alive, they were very sweet. I was engaged and they loved hearing about all my wedding plans, I was being investigated for something that could have meant I wasn’t going to make my own wedding, turned out thankfully it was something else.

I wouldn't chat early or late or when curtains are closed.

TheGander · 08/01/2025 22:22

Duvet18 · 08/01/2025 21:46

Gently, this sounds like an eating disorder to me (not being able to stand being seen while eating, choosing to eat standing up rather than sitting or lying down when ill, refusing food you haven’t provided and strictly controlled yourself, finding the smell of food ‘disgusting’).

That was clear to me too.

JudgeJ · 08/01/2025 22:21

fourelementary · 08/01/2025 19:45

Yabu as you’ve made up those rules and are now thinking people are rude for not following them?
If your curtains are shut, fair enough. But if they’re open I would not think someone was rude to make small talk.
Some people take comfort from company and sharing concerns or even just small talk.

If my response to all this 'friendly chat' is that I clearly don't want to involve myself then it's rude to continue to try and force your company onto a stranger who may be feeling anxious but doesn't want to engage.
The OP is having other people's rules forced on her.

McCheck · 08/01/2025 22:21

user1471516498 · 08/01/2025 20:38

OP here. Apologies for disappearing, I got taken for a test. I should have added that I had said to the woman opposite that I was feeling hideously nauseous and couldn't talk because it was taking all of my concentration not to throw up, but she kept asking questions. I take on board what you have said though. Once I am feeling slightly more human I will try and talk to her a bit.

that bit of info is important OP. If you feel nauseous then people should give you some rest.

Hope you get well soon OP

Zone2NorthLondon · 08/01/2025 22:21

When your health is compromised and your in a hospital your not compelled to be sociable
If some of you find you can be sociable and engage that’s super however it isn’t mandatory and some people, are simple not comfortable with what is essentially forced chit chat with strangers. Nothing in common other than you’re all inpatient

I didn’t chatty chat on mat ward just because there were other mums and we had that in common. I popped on head phones and read my kindle. I had no desire to have forced engagement simply because we were in proximity to each other

RawBloomers · 08/01/2025 22:21

OP I'm sorry you're unwell and hope you're feeling better soon.

I would probably want to chat, but can see that lots of people wouldn't.

It behoves us all in an environment like a hospital ward to be especially vigilant to cues about what people want and to not impose ourselves on others. I'm sorry your ward companions (just one?) were poor at this. I think being very blunt and clear about what you want them to do (stop talking to you) is the most effective way to handle someone who seems unable to go from the idea that you don't want to talk (whether hinted at or stated outright) to the idea that they shouldn't talk to you.

AsmallabodeIsallweWant · 08/01/2025 22:16

I had only one with my baby when she was 2 months old. Opposite us was a young couple with a toddler. She started talking to me and I engaged with her. It was worth it

McCheck · 08/01/2025 22:12

my husband was in for major surgery and said he liked the camaraderie and occasional chit chat on the ward.

They weren’t allowed to close curtains as nurses wanted to be able to see when someone goes downhill

Zone2NorthLondon · 08/01/2025 22:11

Actually agree with @user1471516498
Hospital is noisy,busy,hectic. It’s not a social centre you’re not compelled to make small talk or socialise with strangers when your health is compromised and you’re away from home

Swipe left for the next trending thread