Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To complain about a GP calling me this?

367 replies

lolit · 31/12/2024 21:37

He called me a good girl while examining me. Should I complain or am I overreacting?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
pimplebum · 31/12/2024 23:55

I am a mum to small kids and spend my life saying good girl / boy ! Occasionally it slips out of my mouth at work when talking to secondary age kids as a habit , I’ve only had to apologise once and thankfully the teen in question accepted my explanation that I have small kids and had said it a thousand times over the weekend with potty training and was quiet tired , so it just slipped out

could the doctor have small kids and be tired ?
personally I feel complaints should be saved for transgressions that are worth spoiling someone’s day over

TriesNotToBeCynical · 31/12/2024 23:53

RainbowSquare · 31/12/2024 22:15

I mean, you've every right to complain but just expect a pithy response from the practice manager. I complained regarding a very traumatic 24 period when an elderly relative slowly passed away at home and the response from the GP to administer final meds (morphine) was shambolic at best and got the most half hearted fk you letter.

Get a sense of perspective. And as for it being a sexual tone, thats likely how you chose to interpret it. There's every chance he would say good lad to guy under 40 but that doesnt annoy the feminists.

Practice managers may deal with complaints but it is the GP partners (or a higher health authority body in some cases) that is actually responsible for the content of the response. And professionally responsibly for any inadequacies or misconduct discovered. The practice manager is rarely a partner and usually an employed office manager basically. If not happy with the response the complaint can be taken to a higher level or to the General Medical Council. Edit: or both.

Thoughtsonallsorts · 31/12/2024 23:53

lolit · 31/12/2024 21:37

He called me a good girl while examining me. Should I complain or am I overreacting?

Please stop this absolte rubbish.
An older Doctor empathising with you & you've taking this as an insult. He sounds like a lovely GP

Oioisavaloy27 · 31/12/2024 23:52

Totallymessed · 31/12/2024 23:50

Really? You think a doctor doing a prostate examination or other intimate examination would call the man a good lad? I mean: doctor has his latex gloves on and his finger up the man's arse.... and calls him a good boy?

It's a completely different scenario to a football manager discussing the players. Obviously.

OP it's possible it was completely innocent, in which case the doctor would want to know he behaved inappropriately and made you uncomfortable. Or it wasn't, in which case a record of his behaviour needs to be kept. Please don't feel like it's too minor to complain about.

That is why it is important for the op to say where she was being examined but op is deliberately evading the question.

Totallymessed · 31/12/2024 23:50

shuggles · 31/12/2024 23:12

I think it's highly likely that he would refer to a young man as a "lad," yes.

Men are referred to as "boys" all the time. I've worked with women in differing contexts who referred to male colleagues as either "boys" or "lads." On TV, I hear various football managers refer to their players as "the boys."

I'm not sure why any of it is offensive.

Really? You think a doctor doing a prostate examination or other intimate examination would call the man a good lad? I mean: doctor has his latex gloves on and his finger up the man's arse.... and calls him a good boy?

It's a completely different scenario to a football manager discussing the players. Obviously.

OP it's possible it was completely innocent, in which case the doctor would want to know he behaved inappropriately and made you uncomfortable. Or it wasn't, in which case a record of his behaviour needs to be kept. Please don't feel like it's too minor to complain about.

Oioisavaloy27 · 31/12/2024 23:50

Catfox1 · 31/12/2024 23:28

The OP doesn’t seem to suggest they are making the complaint because they thought it was patronising or misogynistic. To
me it reads as though the OP thought it was a sexual advance (may not be the right term but that’s how it’s coming across) in which case a complaint would be justified.

She is suggesting it was said in a sexual way whilst being examined in a vulnerable position but won't say what. Not sure why the op even asked the question it is quite telling that the op was always going to complain.
I think people are getting fed up with people complaining about absolutely everything and getting offended by everything. At the end of the day Gp's are human too.

SilenceInside · 31/12/2024 23:49

The type of examination doesn't change the fact that the comment was at a minimum patronising/condescending and sexist. The exact context may make the comment worse, but there's no obligation on the Op to be specific about the exact type of examination.

shuggles · 31/12/2024 23:48

@Bellyblueboy I had a doctor outright call me "fat." Judging by the responses in this thread, some people would have collapsed on the floor if they heard that. But I have had a different upbringing, so my thought was "well yes, I am indeed fat, so what he's saying is correct."

Redmat · 31/12/2024 23:48

I'd have taken it as a reassuring, kind remark, especially if the examination was an uncomfortable one.
I don't spend my life looking to be offended. What a waste of your doctors surgery's time.

shuggles · 31/12/2024 23:46

@Catfox1 To me it reads as though the OP thought it was a sexual advance (may not be the right term but that’s how it’s coming across) in which case a complaint would be justified.

Yes, men in clubs and on dating apps always make sexual advances by starting the conversation with "good girl." It has a positive effect every time.

StrikeForever · 31/12/2024 23:44

2dogsandabudgie · 31/12/2024 23:37

I thought all GPs had to have another person in the room when carrying out intimate examinations, to protect themselves as well as patients.

I had a breast examination by a female GP and she asked another female staff member to be present.

Which is why this probably wasn’t any kind of intimate examination.

StepAwayFromMyCoffee · 31/12/2024 23:41

The professionally offended strike again 🤦‍♀️

surreygirl1987 · 31/12/2024 23:40

Gorgeousfeet · 31/12/2024 23:31

Oh fucking hell.

I have been called more “ offensive “ stuff than this. 🙄

So have I. Doesn't mean this shouldn't be reported though. I'm glad the OP is going to say something.

RainbowSquare · 31/12/2024 23:40

2dogsandabudgie · 31/12/2024 23:37

I thought all GPs had to have another person in the room when carrying out intimate examinations, to protect themselves as well as patients.

I had a breast examination by a female GP and she asked another female staff member to be present.

Pretty certain not, and in any case the OP obtusely isnt saying what the mysterious examination was. Could have been an ingrown toenail.

StrikeForever · 31/12/2024 23:39

CurlewKate · 31/12/2024 23:24

Don't complain. Do email the practice manager saying that calling adult women "good girl" is something that should not happen in a professional setting, and please could he/she have a word with colleagues..

This 👆 A formal complaint is OTT for this. Think about the effect of the human being at the other end.

Bellyblueboy · 31/12/2024 23:38

Gorgeousfeet · 31/12/2024 23:35

Bad but outing. .

I am so sorry. Your GP should not be calling you offensive names. They should treating you with professionalism and dignity.

I hope you have changed practices at least, if you didn’t complain.

I work with a lot of peoples on very challenging circumstances - I have never addressed a colleague or client in any way which could cause offence. There is simply no excuse.

RainbowSquare · 31/12/2024 23:37

You seem to think the GP will GAF. He's likely a partner i.e. owner. The practice manager will just write a response, tell him about it, he'll laugh, she'll laugh and if you're lucky it'll get stuck on a record that CQC will have a laugh at if they bother to even open the complaints log.

2dogsandabudgie · 31/12/2024 23:37

Oioisavaloy27 · 31/12/2024 23:20

Are you deliberately evading the question of which part of your body was being examined he said this? Because he could have been examining your knee! Which would be totally different from him examining your breast then saying it.

I thought all GPs had to have another person in the room when carrying out intimate examinations, to protect themselves as well as patients.

I had a breast examination by a female GP and she asked another female staff member to be present.

AdoraBell · 31/12/2024 23:36

That would make me puke. I’m bolshy so I would have asked him why he uses that term with patients and do the male patients being called good boy accept that?

Gorgeousfeet · 31/12/2024 23:35

Bellyblueboy · 31/12/2024 23:32

That’s awful. By your GP? What did he/she call you?

Bad but outing. .

BoundaryGirl3939 · 31/12/2024 23:35

How old was is? And how old are you? I'm just wondering if he was viewing you as somebody similar to his daughter.

ScaryM0nster · 31/12/2024 23:33

lolit · 31/12/2024 23:23

Anyway, this thread was very helpful, even the comments telling me to get over myself helped me see how normalised this is, which is exactly why I need to put in a complaint. I need to do my small part in changing this because it is NOT OKAY.

I have written my complaint and will send it tomorrow. I will not be returning to this thread because I need to spend my NYE doing something positive instead of thinking about this.

Don’t send it as a formal complaint until you’ve taken a pause and decided that it’s a really good use of at least 8 hours of GP practise time to deal with your complaint.

You might feel it merits that.

Or you might feel that some informal feedback might be more balanced.

Or you might decide that viewing it in the context of several commenters who could see themselves making the same comment that it’s not actually a big deal.

Or that you feel vulnerable during examinations and may benefit from requesting a chaperone in future.

Bellyblueboy · 31/12/2024 23:32

Gorgeousfeet · 31/12/2024 23:31

Oh fucking hell.

I have been called more “ offensive “ stuff than this. 🙄

That’s awful. By your GP? What did he/she call you?

SilenceInside · 31/12/2024 23:32

It's not a hill anyone would die on. It's a straightforward situation where the GP surgery will deal with the complaint/feedback in their normal way.

Gorgeousfeet · 31/12/2024 23:31

Oh fucking hell.

I have been called more “ offensive “ stuff than this. 🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread