Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think autism gets worse with each generation

494 replies

eastereggg · 30/12/2024 16:08

Genuine question.

Why does it seem that autism gets worse with each generation?

Example: a mother is a late diagnosed autistic but her child is very clearly autistic and displays much more severe characteristics than she did. The grandmother would probably be diagnosed autistic today as well.

There seems to be a recurring pattern that I'm seeing where autism is getting more severe with each generation. Is there an explanation for this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
AvidBee · 30/12/2024 17:08

My dad is absolutely, 100% autistic. Safe foods, special interests etc etc.

I am autistic, and my brother probably is too. No more worse or "better" than the other.

x2boys · 30/12/2024 17:08

ReadyforSpringNow · 30/12/2024 16:30

Autism is due to chemicals in the food change? WTF.
Educate yourself.
Autism is linked to inherited genetic mutations that run in families and develops in the fetus and you cannot develop it in later life.
It doesn't just appear.. you are born with it.

Thsts,not quite true my son has a chromosome deletion linked to his,autism ts,a De,novo.in his,case,neither me or his,Dad are,autistic snd,whilst he,does,have a,second cousin who is,autistic ,this,is ,only one other incidence in quite a,large extended family.

TheHeadOfTheHouse · 30/12/2024 17:07

I agree, Autism seems to be getting more severe as time goes on.

so many non verbal children now, waiting years for a place at an SEN school whilst a mainstream school is doing their best to accommodate them.

years ago people with Autism coped much better with everyday life than what they do now. It was unheard of to be having ear defenders, screaming fits lasting for hours, unable to communicate with people etc etc.

Stonefromthehenge · 30/12/2024 17:07

Not getting worse in my family, previous generations of undiagnosed autistics in my family have suffered severe mental illness. I suspect what your talking about is the other side of this; not being recognised along with a more conformist society led to huge pressure to conform or mask as we would call it. This may have allowed your family members to go under the radar or to minimise their own suffering. It also led to severe mental illness for some. Any weirdness was a huge cause of stigma and shame.

WonderingAboutThus · 30/12/2024 17:05

My theory is that two generations ago, the dating pool was much more restricted so many more neurotypical people ended up married to autistic people.
Now autistic men and women meet at university and hit it off. Also their friends are autistic. Less mitigating influence of neurotypical neighbours and so on.

Gem359 · 30/12/2024 17:04

This isn't what I've found in my family. None of the older generation are diagnosed with ASD (but youngest 2 with dyslexia) but I think several are undiagnosed and have really suffered from that. It is a big family (my gran had 8 children) and there is drug and alcohol abuse, nervous breakdowns, terrible anxiety, OCD and suicide.

DS on the other hand was diagnosed at secondary school age and has had huge amounts of support and understanding. He isn't any more severely affected and thankfully is coping much better thanks to the support and understanding he has. The other younger members of the family with suspected ASD aren't any more severely affected either and are coping better as they are more supported generally.

LlynTegid · 30/12/2024 17:04

I wonder if in previous generations there were more job opportunities that had a level of routine and less unpredictability. Aside from fewer people having a diagnosis.

Recognising it is a spectrum.

Starryspam · 30/12/2024 17:04

IMO rubbish

GagaBinks · 30/12/2024 17:04

I'm utterly gobsmacked at people believing it's because of food 🤦‍♀️

helpfulperson · 30/12/2024 17:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

The first one of these - two autistic parents. I can't find it but read a book a few years ago about how the internet etc made it easier for people to find similar people to share their lives and have children with, therefore the ASD genes would get stronger. And the difficulty is that ASD people are often attracted to ASD people because they understand each other instead of , for example Cystic Fibrosis, when generally if people have that gene there is nothing that particularly attracts them to those with the CF gene.

StarCourt · 30/12/2024 17:03

@tinselAndCrackers who says '
Autism is due to chemicals in the food chain '

DD is autistic and that's not an explanation that's ever been offered to me

CollyModdle · 30/12/2024 17:01

Interesting.

All the young people I know with AS and related conditions have someone in an older generation that has associated traits.

Do people on the spectrum have children who are NT?

Ds’s long term girlfriend, parent and sibling have strong traits, that serve them well and contribute to their successes.

But I wonder about the next generation.

Life with a non-verbal, very meltdown-prone young adult is incredibly hard, based on one friend’s experience.

Sorry if I have used wrong terms etc.

Greyrockin · 30/12/2024 17:01

I was diagnosed late with autism and inattentive ADHD (in my late 50's). As a child I was drugged up with anti-depressants from age 4 - 10 years old as I screamed a lot (apparently). I was also physically punished at school when I showed ADHD behaviour (zoning out and scribbling on my desk earned me a smack across the head from my teacher). I was raised in care and any 'behaviour' could earn you a smack or whack on the legs with the wooden spoon. So obviously I learnt to not mis-behave. Looking back a lot of the other kids I was in care with were also ND but there was zero understanding of the spectrum, especially in relation to girls, as it was seen as a male condition. The only autistic child I was aware of was non verbal and stimmed constantly.

Thankfully times have changed, but I a lot of late diagnosed ND adults will have had to mask heavily prior to seeking a diagnosis.

Nn9011 · 30/12/2024 17:00

I don't think it's the genetics that are changing, I think it's society. Capitalism has impacted neurodivrrgent families because the mother is the main caregiver and now with mums having to work also I'm sure they are even more burnt out and overwhelmed. Schools are bigger classes, less financial support - 1-2-1 support is expected to help the whole class instead of just their SEN child. The world is much more overstimulating and busy.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 30/12/2024 16:59

You're right it is inherited but aren't there also other risk factors such as having children later, possibly a link to upf? If that's the case then possibly there could be an interaction of genetic and environmental factors at play.

lleeggoo · 30/12/2024 16:58

Whoknew24 · 30/12/2024 16:37

I have t read all comments and will get hate for this. But watching people in either friend or family form I feel they’ve escalated the situation.

one particular woman I know told me she gets the DLA higher rate, carers allowance, carers element on UC and a mobility car full UC etc . She told me she has zero work commitments and has expressed how finically lucrative it is. Now this is absolutely not the case for everyone, but I do believe in SOME cases it’s financially beneficial and that some parents do harbour their own children for financial gain. Some also love being apart of something and to share their child’s journey etc, again on watching these videos etc it again screams more about the parent/parents need for attention and a lot of the time stifling their children.

Financially beneficial?

To have a disabled child?

Fuck me.

CarefulN0w · 30/12/2024 16:58

So many factors here - and an interesting topic. On the one hand as a student nurse in the 1980's I looked after people who had been in psychiatric institutions for decades, until they closed. It is likely that some of these people would meet the criteria for diagnosis of ADHD or Autism today, but weren't able to form relationships. It is also true that average age of parents was younger a generation ago and that conditions are more likely to be identified.

On the other hand, DC were able to go home for lunch, had less pressure about exams and were able to leave school at 15/16 and get a job. If people weren't good at maths or reading, they could still find meaningful employment. They were less disabled by society's expectations, as people accepted them as they were.

And while it is true to say that Autism isn't caused by food, I find the emerging evidence about gut health and brain health fascinating.

Finally, parenting is relevant. Parenting is hard. It might be rewarding and fun, but there is also a lot of mind numbing routine which any of us find hard at times. And some people find harder than others.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 30/12/2024 16:57

There seems to be anecdotal evidence of this in and around silicon valley too. Two clever techy autistic parents and then a more high needs autistic offspring.

I think the tech industry has a lot to answer for, personally. 40 years ago people like my DH would’ve been sitting in a garage somewhere trying to get one computer to talk to another, with very little consideration for social norms or much else, not necessarily earning very much. Now he and his colleagues are on very attractive salaries at companies you’ve heard of, working in Shoreditch or the City. They’re much more likely partners. So these classically Aspie blokes get married and have children.

No data clearly, plenty of anecdote.

WhatterySquash · 30/12/2024 16:56

I have looked into this in some depth for reasons to do with my work, and it is extremely complicated and seems to have many factors. It's hard to untangle factors like more sensitive diagnostic procedures and awareness, greater acceptance, and possible environmental factors. There's even a possible evolutionary factor that has been suggested - with the rise of academia and computing as professions, autistic people gained a greater likelihood of having successful careers and prestige, making them more likely to marry and have kids etc. so changing the gene pool and increasing incidence.

There absolutely have been some studies that have supported a link between some food additives eaten when pregnant and the incidence of autism in the baby - though more research is needed, that shouldn't be dismissed out of hand. There is also evidence that being born prematurely increases the likelihood of ASD and other ND conditions. As time goes on more and more babies survive premature birth so that is likely to contribute to the rise in diagnoses.

I stress I'm not asserting any of these theories as 100% true or fully evidenced, but there definitely are a range of factors that probably interact in various ways and it's not straightforward. I also agree there may be a factor of greater acceptance meaning that children are not expected to learn to suppress or manage their difficulties in the same way they used to be.

Vinvertebrate · 30/12/2024 16:56

Whoknew24 · 30/12/2024 16:37

I have t read all comments and will get hate for this. But watching people in either friend or family form I feel they’ve escalated the situation.

one particular woman I know told me she gets the DLA higher rate, carers allowance, carers element on UC and a mobility car full UC etc . She told me she has zero work commitments and has expressed how finically lucrative it is. Now this is absolutely not the case for everyone, but I do believe in SOME cases it’s financially beneficial and that some parents do harbour their own children for financial gain. Some also love being apart of something and to share their child’s journey etc, again on watching these videos etc it again screams more about the parent/parents need for attention and a lot of the time stifling their children.

And this has precisely….what relevance to autism prevalence?

FWIW my DS8 is autistic and in special education. I have spent over £30k on diagnosis, OT, SALT, play therapy, ADHD assessment and meds, specialist toys and equipment. He can’t use regular childcare or do simple things like queue or stand still. I get middle rate DLA, which iirc is the princely sum of about £240 a month. I would have to receive it for 3 lifetimes to actually fund the out-of-pocket costs of having a disabled autistic child.

If you actually had to care for a dysregulated child with autism on a regular basis, I suspect you’d be singing a rather different tune.

Huffalumps · 30/12/2024 16:55

Has anyone mentioned age and adaptation? Although a person carries autism throughout life and never gets 'cured', many do adapt. I've seen this in my family. By 60+ they have some combination of masking techniques, workarounds and simply self knowledge about what they like/works for them. All the adults I know are undiagnosed. In my family and sister's, the kids were worse at school but now in later teens have come to adapt more to NT life. As they are average/above average IQ they will likely learn to adapt to the world a little better. I suspect by the time they are in later life they would present as less ND-y

romdowa · 30/12/2024 16:52

I can only speak for myself but I think its because in this generation nobody is trying to slap the autism out of their children. By my sons age I was absolutely terrified to put a foot wrong and was forced to mask in order to not be punished. Plenty others I know who are discovering they are nd say the same . I've never laid a hand on my son and he's not afraid to be himself quirks and all.

SensibleSigma · 30/12/2024 16:48

Ifeellikeateenageragain · 30/12/2024 16:37

The number of ND people who have children with other ND people I think. Just lately figured out my DH is likely ND, mostly after noticing his DC from his first marriage show a lot of traits. I had assumed it was their DM who is VERY high functioning masking ND.

.... which I suppose also raises a query about me!! 😄

And me! I was quite sure it was DH’s family ( and it definitely is) but then my brother’s DC are ND, and my sister’s DC (so it could be us). But BiL’s niece is ND as well, which suggests it’s his side…

I suspect it’s both sides and that we’ve paired up through acceptance of ND traits that might have put more NT potential partners off!

Mamaxo · 30/12/2024 16:46

My daughters diagnosed autistic I'm not but suspect that I am. I wouldn't say that it's more serve with generations I would say my mother didn't know about autism so I didn't have the help or support but as a adult I have serve anxiety, ocd and depression. Even from the age of 9 I thought about unaliving myself. If I had been diagnosed as a child and had help and support who knows I could have been a lot different now. But I think I just get on with it because it's all I've known to do 😂

TheMarzipanDildo · 30/12/2024 16:44

Can’t say I’ve spotted this, but the obvious answer is the people who are really affected by their autism (I.e, are not verbal, or have violent outbursts or severe educational difficulties) are also less likely to have children than someone with mild characteristics. So it looks like it’s a generational thing, but isn’t.

Swipe left for the next trending thread