Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel that many men are totally unprepared and unsuited to domesticity?

289 replies

JFDIYOLO · 30/12/2024 02:02

So many instances shared on Mumsnet of grown men behaving like adolescents.

Spending hours gaming, incapable of regulating their emotions, violent outbursts, dick-led decisions, expecting Mummy 2.0 from their wives, utterly lacking in empathy and care during pregnancy, labour, newborn baby & toddler years, father fails ...

But why is this?

Was it always so, or do we just hear way more now from women who are no longer prepared to put up with it and ready to discuss and share advice?

Should there be some kind of exam, a screening process before they can proceed to the next level of In A Relationship?

OP posts:
Workingmum13 · 13/03/2025 19:54

username299 · 13/03/2025 15:54

It doesn't make sense. No concept? They don't know what those shiny round things are? How can they look all pretty for their man if they don't know how to pay for shoes and nails?

You seem dim im really shocked that you didnt know how lack of finacial understanding is the number 1 devestaing impact women find 5hemselves in divorce or sepration..

Workingmum13 · 13/03/2025 19:52

JHound · 13/03/2025 15:25

I have never heard of young women having no concept of finances.

You cant be serious its the number 1 topic on mumsnet and one of the reason women can be left in utter straits when divorced.

OneQuirkyPanda · 13/03/2025 16:33

I think in many cases they were raised this way, my brother was, my wife’s brother was and my best friend’s husband was. Our mums made us cook, clean and do childcare from an early age whereas our brothers were allowed to do nothing and were catered to by us all. I remember having one blazing row with my mum as a teenager about it and she finally admitted she expects me to help her and not my brother “because you’re a girl”. Mums can often be very critical of daughters while praising sons for the bare minimum, while also claiming boys are so much easier to raise, they’re often easier cause much less is expected of them.

My brother does one load of laundry and my mum says he’s the perfect husband and my sister in law is “so lucky”, despite her doing 90% of the domestic labour and working longer hours than him. My best friend’s husband is absolutely useless, but his mum won’t hear a negative thing said about him as apparently “that’s what men are like and she should stop nagging and just get on with it”.

I think behind every lazy useless man is a family who raised him that way.

fairydustt · 13/03/2025 16:20

i worked from home yesterday so I give myself a bit of a lay in, my husband went into the office but I woke up around 5am to him with a face mask on, folding washing and tidying up lol he’s actually more domesticated than I am tbh, he’s tidy, organised, deals with all our bills, does the bins, all the cat litter at the moment as I’m pregnant, does the washing, food shop.. basically everything (I do it all to but we share it totally equally and I don’t have to ask him to do anything, if anything it’s me that sometimes forgets!)

nutbrownhare15 · 13/03/2025 16:11

I think it has always been so due to patriarchy. Women are more aware of the significant domestic inequalities in their lives due to feminism and their being more likely to be in paid work which makes the the him-work 40 hours per week her-house and kids 24/7 dynamic even more blatantly inequitable. 'A woman's work is never done' was a phrase I heard when growing up. These days the narrative on social media seems to be suggesting that it's better not to bother if the partner is going to make your life harder and that's certainly a narrative I'll be instilling in my daughters. Apparently the average husband creates 7 hours of domestic work per week. I don't think women with these kinds of partners are martyrs but I do wonder if they've been socialised to think that change isn't possible due to in built gender roles.

username299 · 13/03/2025 15:54

JHound · 13/03/2025 15:25

I have never heard of young women having no concept of finances.

It doesn't make sense. No concept? They don't know what those shiny round things are? How can they look all pretty for their man if they don't know how to pay for shoes and nails?

JHound · 13/03/2025 15:25

Workingmum13 · 13/03/2025 05:47

Is it fair to say many young women have no concept of finances, and that's much more impactful than men's ability to keep a house? But I think it happens for the same reason: parents: someone who is raising feckless, incapable adults, mums and dads. My son will be cook cleaning alongside us; my daughters will have a solid foundation in real-world finance. Ect. But to be honest, maybe at my age, I don't know men like what she describes. I know very few people who don't both work and who co-parent in full, maybe generationally. Still, it is terrifying to me when women start talking about womens inherent biological roles. Aren't we, as men, trying to move past biological urges and have healthy relationships with both sexes that gave us life? The father is not less important than the mother because he hasn't given birth. A man is the only member of our species that can nurture our young.

Edited

I have never heard of young women having no concept of finances.

JHound · 13/03/2025 15:04

It’s why I am too scared to live with one.

I have been lucky in the past but I think What I experienced was a rarity.

And it seems even if they are domesticated before you get together they “forget” those skills once you get together.

He has his house, I shall have mine and everybody is happy!

JFDIYOLO · 13/03/2025 12:41

Something else I've noticed -

The men who claim 'I'm no good at cleaning, well you're so much better at it than I am, oh look I've messed something up so you'd better take charge of it in future.'

Hand them a pressure washer and goggles though, and oh look - they ARE capable of cleaning.

'I'm no good at cooking, well you're etc etc etc'

Point them at a barbecue though, and oh look ...

'I'm no good at childcare, that's women's work and when we both get in from work that's your extra job.'

Yet somehow when it comes to it, oh look he's suddenly adamantly insisting he's getting and will be able to deliver 50/50...

To the 'not my Nigel, you midandrist' responses - every single one of these scenarios will be striking a YES note right here. (And I CAN now programme the TV)!

OP posts:
The13thFairy · 13/03/2025 11:00

You are wrong. Most men are totally prepared and suited to domesticity ~ as long as it's provided by a woman and they can swan in when they please, eat, sleep, fart, shit and piss and generally make the place untidy, and then go back to their real lives outside the house.

Workingmum13 · 13/03/2025 05:59

I'm sorry typos above. women aren't the only ones who need a nurturing skill set. We need men to be raised to take part in child care and both sexes to have a realistic understanding of what it takes to earn the money you need to live the life you want.

Workingmum13 · 13/03/2025 05:47

Is it fair to say many young women have no concept of finances, and that's much more impactful than men's ability to keep a house? But I think it happens for the same reason: parents: someone who is raising feckless, incapable adults, mums and dads. My son will be cook cleaning alongside us; my daughters will have a solid foundation in real-world finance. Ect. But to be honest, maybe at my age, I don't know men like what she describes. I know very few people who don't both work and who co-parent in full, maybe generationally. Still, it is terrifying to me when women start talking about womens inherent biological roles. Aren't we, as men, trying to move past biological urges and have healthy relationships with both sexes that gave us life? The father is not less important than the mother because he hasn't given birth. A man is the only member of our species that can nurture our young.

Echobelly · 31/12/2024 19:36

Parker231 · 30/12/2024 08:31

I hope you’re not replicating the same behaviours in your DC’s?

Not avoiding as well as I'd like, but better than my parents did, and my DH also makes the kids do quite a lot of stuff so I don't have to!

NeelyOHara1 · 31/12/2024 18:57

Human biology isn't fit for modern day purposes, lol.

Joe7t8 · 31/12/2024 18:34

Itsmitneymitch · 30/12/2024 17:39

That's what we are told.

But I know many many women who have got pregnant in their early and mid forties.

You probably know far more that are sub-fertile by their early 40s. But either they don’t know themselves, or they do but just don’t share the info.

To suggest that women don’t have a biological clock contradicts all modern medical knowledge and research. There’s a reason that most NHS trusts won’t offer IVF to woman over 42.

Earlgreycakes · 31/12/2024 17:06

ObelixtheGaul · 31/12/2024 13:20

I would agree in re: societal expectations and would add that the 'visceral' love for children is expected of women. Not all women feel that after birth and the expectation that they should makes it so much harder to admit when they don't.

I’d also stress that many adoptive mothers who haven’t carried their kids in their womb /breastfed etc love their kids just as fiercely if not more than some biological parents.

ObelixtheGaul · 31/12/2024 13:20

aLittleWhiteHorse · 31/12/2024 11:18

This. It describes my experience exactly, despite your words being described as “distorted” and “misandry”.

I expect I harbour some bitterness but in general I like the men I meet and I am grateful for my wonderful father, brother, brothers in law, nephews and male friends.

The fact remains that societal expectations of men are generally low and some men choose to justify quite terrible behaviour with a “if you can, why wouldn’t you?” attitude. These men simply do not appreciate the privilege of having and caring for children. And they are often unhappy in life and go around creating unhappiness for others.

I would agree in re: societal expectations and would add that the 'visceral' love for children is expected of women. Not all women feel that after birth and the expectation that they should makes it so much harder to admit when they don't.

Parker231 · 31/12/2024 13:18

JHound · 31/12/2024 13:15

Without being in their home 24/7 can you know that they are great fathers?

I see how much time they spend with their DC’s - they know their likes and dislikes, their favourite games, their friends, take them to doctors appointments, shoe shopping, football practice, coach their basketball team. It’s not difficult to spot good fathers. Our families had great role models in DF and DFil.

JHound · 31/12/2024 13:15

Parker231 · 31/12/2024 01:41

The type of men you are meeting is very different from those I know - my DH, DF, male family members and friends.

All great fathers and parents. Married for many years and fully parent their children.

Without being in their home 24/7 can you know that they are great fathers?

Leafy74 · 31/12/2024 11:56

Edit. Lived experience not loved experience.

Leafy74 · 31/12/2024 11:37

JFDIYOLO · 31/12/2024 09:27

My views are from some experience of my own and so many accounts here by women who've suffered every one of these scenarios.

I'm not denying your loved experiences and those of other posters her

However with the best will.it the world you would have to accept that the posts on MN will be massively skewed towards women who have shit husbands.

JFDIYOLO · 31/12/2024 11:37

I think this is the point - if you haven't been on the receiving end, it can seem misandrist to read of experience you've never had to carry yourself.

'I'm all right - so everyone else must be'?

OP posts:
aLittleWhiteHorse · 31/12/2024 11:18

JFDIYOLO · 31/12/2024 00:48

Men can theoretically father thousands of children. They just don't have the reality that each birth could kill them, or leave them with physical trauma like a fistula or a prolapse, often permanent physical changes, post natal depression etc. They may not even know they have children.

Men are more likely to get up and go, abandoning wife and children, starting side families, having new relationships and dropping the older children than women are. Being left holding the baby is generally done to women.

I think they are more inclined to compartmentalise. Wife & kids in one compartment. Bit on the side in another. SO many 'I've discovered my husband is having an affair' threads here.

Even those who push for 50/50 - how often do they realistically stick to that arrangement, and do their half of the parenting?

I am convinced that (whatever they may say), not having gestated, laboured, recovered from the experience, breastfed, been all touched out etc, men do not have the same visceral connection to their children that women have.

I'm also convinced that many men see women and children as things, property, possessions, to be owned, controlled and disposed of at will.

And if a woman leaves (which we know is the most dangerous time), I think they see her taking herself away as him being deprived of his rightfully owned property. And if she takes the children too ...The 'if I can't have them nobody can' family annihilator is overwhelmingly male.

Then there is the well known thing about true colours only showing when she becomes pregnant or the new baby arrives. So many get used to being the centre of attention, and then finding a whole new person has taken that away can come as a nasty shock. And as for the realisation that someone else now has first dibs on the boobs ...

It's almost as though they've sleepwalked into the reality of a screaming pooping weeing wriggling puking sleep denier and it never even occurred to them that this thing that's been happening for millions of years is going to happen to them.

So how the hell do we all get this sorted out?? Where do we even start?

Edited

This. It describes my experience exactly, despite your words being described as “distorted” and “misandry”.

I expect I harbour some bitterness but in general I like the men I meet and I am grateful for my wonderful father, brother, brothers in law, nephews and male friends.

The fact remains that societal expectations of men are generally low and some men choose to justify quite terrible behaviour with a “if you can, why wouldn’t you?” attitude. These men simply do not appreciate the privilege of having and caring for children. And they are often unhappy in life and go around creating unhappiness for others.

Thepeopleversuswork · 31/12/2024 10:18

PerambulationFrustration · 31/12/2024 10:13

@Thepeopleversuswork I feel most men don't care for the additions. A throw here, cushions there, plants and lamps and so on.
I care about these things because I want my home to have a 'feel' rather than just be functional. My Dd gets that too but ds never does even though he's been on countless ikea trips with me as well.

In my experience men moan when these "touches" are absent. My ex husband would endlessly get pettish and stroppy about "needing to do something about this house" while apparently failing to recognise that he had a part to play in this while I was a) the sole breadwinner b) raising his child almost single handedly.

PerambulationFrustration · 31/12/2024 10:13

@Thepeopleversuswork I feel most men don't care for the additions. A throw here, cushions there, plants and lamps and so on.
I care about these things because I want my home to have a 'feel' rather than just be functional. My Dd gets that too but ds never does even though he's been on countless ikea trips with me as well.

Swipe left for the next trending thread