Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be mad my folks gatecrashed xmas?

808 replies

merrychristonabike · 28/12/2024 07:31

Me DH and our kids went to a hotel for xmas - a tradition we adopted to escape the 'where will you be at xmas?' from mum and dad every year. We've invited them and my in-laws before, but it wasn't fun as my parents were clearly put out they were sharing the time with in-laws.
On arrival on xmas eve, my parents were there to 'surprise' us and we were furious. My husband later asked them why they were there and my dad flipped, telling my husband he'd always had his suspicions about him and generally being a dick. Dad didn't wish DH merry Christmas, ignored him at dinner and left without saying goodbye to either of us,
It ruined the 3 night stay. They didn't bring the kids' gifts - I think so we will still have to go see them and I just can't face it. There's a bit of back story to their behaviour, but it's too long for here other than them being overbearing and intense. And I also just want to know AIBU? And what's your advice yo navigate this?

OP posts:
Buffs · 29/12/2024 19:36

Fluffy2023 · 28/12/2024 09:11

I hear stories of people cutting themselves off at Christmas as they want to share the day for themselves. Then I also hear about people desperately sad and alone at Christmas and it breaks my heart.

I must admit, I go a little out of my comfort zone for Christmas with being quite shy and having to be sociable, but it's so worth it to see my 2 year old son happy and spending time with all of his family who adore him. I think if you have littles in the family it makes it magic for everyone.

I personally would feel cruel doing what you do OP. Only because, if you push past the materialistic things about Chritmas, it's a day for love and spending time with family. Some of my happiest memories as a child are of the chaos at Christmas with my grandparents and extended family. Did they probably feel tired on the day or slightly annoyed at eachother? Yes! Did I notice ? No, it's what made me love Christmas!
OP, you are at risk of setting yourself up for a future of isolation. What happens when the children grow up and maybe go travelling for Christmas or what yourselves do? Will you ask your parents for their company then to make yourselves feel better? Or, will they be hurt from you pushing them out and maybe not want to spend it with you? That's assuming you are still lucky enough to still have them for many more to come.

I think if your adamant Christmas is for yourselves only, you need to spend some time with each set of parents another day to make them feel special and loved and make some happy memories with the children. So they have their own special Christmas.

Have you read the post?

Seymour5 · 29/12/2024 19:29

@merrychristonabike the ‘getting above your station’ used to be such a big thing in some parts of society. Quite prevalent where my DH grew up. I find it strange when parents can’t be pleased when their child has a more successful/affluent life, we never wanted ours to have the same struggles we had. A more normal emotion would be pride in their achievements.

I feel genuinely sorry for you, trying to juggle your children’s relationship with your parents, alongside the criticism and disapproval shown to you and your DH. I hope you can find a solution that means some contact, but on your terms.

Retiredfromearlyyears · 29/12/2024 19:24

Don't go pick up the gifts ,if they didn't bring them after "gatecrashing your family hotel stay . Create a wee bit of space for a while. Hopefully you will be able to have a wee calm chat about boundaries. Good luck.

Buffs · 29/12/2024 19:14

YADNBU

Buffs · 29/12/2024 19:13

mitogoshigg · 28/12/2024 08:20

You all need to grow up, communicate effectively and generally be much kinder.

Your parents asking you about Christmas is normal, nothing wrong with that, just answer politely, no need to sneak off. They want to spend time with you so you and they should have come to an arrangement rather than them having to take such steps. Meanwhile they need to learn to share, if both sets of grandparents are there they should be understanding and gracious about it rather than (obviously) jealous.

Surprising you would have been lovely in most families so I'm guessing a much bigger back story than you have written ...

Effective communication and understanding everyone's needs is the solution. Plus why don't people want to spend a couple of days with their families???

A little harsh. You are lucky to have little insight in to dysfunctional families. I spent 60 years trying to communicate with mine before giving up.

Babadookinthewardrobe · 29/12/2024 19:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Yeah, we really are now scraping the bottom
of the barrel of MN with the spiteful posts on this thread, classic example above and one post already deleted from “little mother” because it was just dripping with gleeful spite.

Doesn’t really matter what anyone’s opinion is on the subject in question, but it begs the question just how angry and bitter posters must be with their own lives to feel such a need to crucify a stranger who dares to contradict them. Really very sad individuals.

DisforDarkChocolate · 29/12/2024 19:08

I don't understand why you spend so much time with them @merrychristonabike?

I wouldn't want my children spending time with people like your parents.

WishinAndHopin · 29/12/2024 19:07

Holy shit. Next year your new Christmas tradition will have to be a holiday abroad!

2025willbemytime · 29/12/2024 19:02

I don't have parents - abandoned as a toddler - and even I think you're doing right by laying down boundaries. Please thank your DH for being such a star and start spending more time with his parents.

ErniesGhostlyGoldTops · 29/12/2024 18:58

OneWittySquid · 28/12/2024 08:09

Different hotel next year but you should have spoken out instead of your poor dh he has utilmately been the fall guy here.

Instead of a 'refuge' hotel, after this shitshow, you can start having Christmas at home again without fear of them turning up if you handle it carefully going forward.

This would be my final straw OP. No more contact. Your father in particular sounds really toxic.

pestowithwalnuts · 29/12/2024 18:56

I feel so sorry for you OP. Do you think that your parents have ?
got worse over time ,? Are they the same with your DS ?
I agree with others who say not to say when and where you're going for Christmas.
Is it possible to book a hotel using a different name , providing you pay by cash . I had the horrible thought that you dm would be ringing around to likely hotels to find out if you had booked in.

TheBluntTurtle · 29/12/2024 18:52

Sorry your Christmas was ruined OP. Your parents should have respected your wishes and let you enjoy your Christmas as a family. Just because they didn’t have better plans doesn’t mean they can gatecrash. Do you think they would have done this if they could have spent Xmas with your DS ( I presume that’s your sister)? Who have they spent the last 4 Xmas’ with if not with you?

merrychristonabike · 29/12/2024 18:45

TheTavern · 29/12/2024 18:29

I would start googling ‘hotels Christmas 2025’ in a location as far away from them as possible.

Have they a good reason for not liking your DH? Because if they don’t that is terrible behaviour especially at Christmas and in front of your children. And how could they arrive without presents for your little ones? Shame on them.

Hi. No good reason for not liking DH, no. We have a brilliant, fun, happy and supportive relationship - that I think I've tested unintentionally by putting my folks' feelings first throughout the years.
When we started dating they didn't think he was good enough for me 🙄 and now they think we're 'above our station' and think that we think we're better than them. This is a construct in their minds. We've never intimated anything like that.

OP posts:
Mangapineapple · 29/12/2024 18:44

You are not at all unreasonable. personally if I was in this situation I would have told them politely that it is my family time with husband and kids and clearly communicate to them to not be present in my space. They came to a hotel that you were staying in, so if they want they can continue to stay there but they must give you the space and time you deserve and should not be part of your lunch/dinner etc.

merrychristonabike · 29/12/2024 18:34

Hi. Sorry for not responding directly to a lot of these posts. I can't seem to reply to a post that's already quoted a post - and there are some really powerful and helpful points made in these that I wanted to thank the authors for posting because I felt they understood the situation and that really helped me. Especially from @binkie163 @thepariscrimefiles @Incenseda @2468KMNP @BlueSilverCats @LookItsMeAgain sorry - I couldn't work out how to reply to the posts at the time - and there's a load of others I wanted to reply to too but couldn't.

I joined MN about 7yrs ago and have to admit I don't think I've ever posted or commented - and I'm viewing on my phone - so don't know if that's restricting the usability or just me being a luddite?
I've found posting here a really cathartic experience. Naturally, there are some posts I feel understand my situation and I hugely appreciate their solidarity, advice and support. I also find it comforting - albeit sad - to know there are other people in similar situations with their parents.
And there are, of course, some posts that have hit differently - and I totally accept that. I posted on here to get external perspectives, especially when nobody knows the history (good and bad - because my parents have given me times of happiness and joy in my life and I appreciate that I could come across as ungrateful).

OP posts:
Nantescalling · 29/12/2024 18:34

Justhere65 · 29/12/2024 08:41

Oh for goodness sake! They are just acting as grandparents who love to spoil their grandchildren… weaponising them indeed!

Totally normal grandparents' tactics. Of course they buy the kids' love and it becomes a weapon.

My Granny never forgave my Mum for not bearing her a grandson to carry on the family name !

She would do anything to make me see her as super special. 'I'll cut the crusts off the toast for you: you can eat the yolks and leave the whites, do you want 3 eggs instead of 2; yes you can have all the crackling off the pork; of course you can leave the cabbage/green beans/brussel sprouts etc. ; yes you can have cream instead of milk on your cereal!

TheTavern · 29/12/2024 18:29

I would start googling ‘hotels Christmas 2025’ in a location as far away from them as possible.

Have they a good reason for not liking your DH? Because if they don’t that is terrible behaviour especially at Christmas and in front of your children. And how could they arrive without presents for your little ones? Shame on them.

StarlightStalagmite · 29/12/2024 18:24

Nantescalling · 29/12/2024 18:18

Why do you think she feels she should appease them? Why anyone having a perfectly normal reaction when her DH us called a dick requires therapy, God only knows, there are lots of causes nothing to do MI, unless you are, of course, American.

I'm not saying get therapy because of this Christmas.

I'm saying it might be helpful to have therapy to unpack the toxic dynamic that seems to exist within the family. It sounds like this dynamic is long-standing.

I had therapy for a similar issue myself as I have a mother with a diagnosed personality disorder and grew up in a very toxic family dynamic. Therapy helped me to see the parts we all play in the dynamic and how to stop playing our own role and protect our mental health.

The fact that OP sees parents weekly out of duty/fear of their reaction sounds quite enmeshed.

Nantescalling · 29/12/2024 18:18

StarlightStalagmite · 28/12/2024 08:39

I think some of the posters here don't know what it's like to have controlling and dominating parents.

I do, and to me it's clear they didn't tell you as they wanted to force a situation where you felt obliged to go along with what they wanted.

I think therapy is needed to help you to put in boundaries around this unhealthy dynamic.

For one thing, you don't 'have' to visit them because they conveniently forgot to bring presents with them so you have to see them another time.

To pp saying send kids off for a relaxed day with GP - they don't sound like a very relaxing pair - why should the kids have to be subjected to that?

So yes, really limit what you share with your parents in future about what you're doing (grey rock) and definitely look into therapy for yourself about why you feel the need to appease them.

Why do you think she feels she should appease them? Why anyone having a perfectly normal reaction when her DH us called a dick requires therapy, God only knows, there are lots of causes nothing to do MI, unless you are, of course, American.

laraitopbanana · 29/12/2024 18:15

Hi op,

i think that to navigate this you will need clear boundaries of when and where you see them for Xmas and absolutely no telling of what you are doing elsewhere.

when your DD will grow, it will be harder to keep the secret as no doubt they will prey on her independence to have her either ask if she can see them or where she went. So maybe you will have to just not see them. It is sad really that people with this behavior do not understand that they will drive others away further and further.

it looks like they suffer from this. Maybe consider mediation for you and your parents? Do you know who instigate this in your parents? See if the other one can help...? If they both are so intense...unfortunately... not much to do.

Good luck op 🌺

Nantescalling · 29/12/2024 18:09

merrychristonabike · 28/12/2024 08:30

It wasn't just a meal on Christmas eve. They booked to stay for the whole duration we were there.

OMG - the cheek. What a pair of creeps!

Tikityboo · 29/12/2024 18:09

Brendalovesc · 29/12/2024 17:47

Do you think they did it to piss you off or do you think they where being nice and genuinely though it was a surprise.

clearly your reaction indicates not all is good in the hood between you and your parents.

Here are some of the highlights in the OPs own words of her DF & DM behaviour over the past few days:

there's an incredible lack of self awareness with them - they don't have any friends left.

DF has managed to cut everyone out over the years when they don't align with his ideals - he cuts contact with them, and I think their lack of a social life makes them even more intense with us - we are their life and all they have to focus on.

They don't like DS partner either and bitch about them to us and likely vice versa.

The thought of my dad's reaction to this is frightening.

He's an explosively-angry person.

my dad went mental at him and caused a scene.

She never sees it from any other perspective than her own.

She's always the victim and I'm always the perpetrator in her eyes.

DM's not entirely blameless in that she's also not behind the door in her constant remarks and observations about me/DH/kids etc.

but my parents were rude to ILs.

And last year mum cried every day in the run up to xmas saying it'll be the worst ever because we weren't doing what she wanted.

but that is always met with disdain and ignored or me made to feel bad for even suggesting it.

I've also sat both parents down several times to talk about how their behaviour affects me but again this is overlooked and over ruled.

But my parents were rude, ungracious, made the 4 days awkward

my dad flies into rage and then doesn't speak to me for weeks.

DH was at the end of the line with their behaviour and the way it's been affecting me.

There's been a lot of upset and stress involved with them of late

and it's a never-ending cycle as they don't recognise

and I try to placate them to keep the peace between them and so on it goes to the detriment of my happiness as I've done for years.

I do feel they're manipulative,

domineering,

extremely jealous of my in-laws

and generally self-centred and selfish,

dressed up in victimisation

but they completely dominate a situation,

have made it clear they're not big fans of my DH (of 11 years)

and generally suck the joy out of social occasions with their constant bickering,

them being overbearing and intense

my dad flipped, telling my husband he'd always had his suspicions about him and generally being a dick.

Dad didn't wish DH merry Christmas,

ignored him at dinner

and left without saying goodbye to either of us,

Nantescalling · 29/12/2024 18:04

Saturdayssandwichsociety · 28/12/2024 08:22

Just out of interest, why are they not allowed to spend a christmas with you without your DH parents also being there?

In fairness isnt it quite normal in a lot of families to alternate, eg seeing one side of the family one christmas, the other side the next year? I can see why they feel a bit put out if theres a constant obsession with DH's parents having to be invited to everything they are invited to. Is that something your DH insists on? They aren't trying to 'exclude' your in laws they are probably happy for you to see each side separately occasionally thats all!

What they did was a bit off but tbf i can see why they take issue with your DH as it sounds like you placate them and leave it to your DH to raise issues with them so they probably think he's picking fights about stuff you weren't actually that bothered about.

Where did you read that between the lines? It certainly says nothing to that effect.

BlueSilverCats · 29/12/2024 18:02

Brendalovesc · 29/12/2024 17:47

Do you think they did it to piss you off or do you think they where being nice and genuinely though it was a surprise.

clearly your reaction indicates not all is good in the hood between you and your parents.

Do you think you could read OP's posts at least? It definitely helps.

Mamasperspective · 29/12/2024 18:01

I'd contact your dad and advocate for your husband.

Tell your parents that you purposely go to a hotel to spend Christmas as a nuclear family, so the fact they decided to turn up was a major overstep and super entitled.

I would say that the fact your dad singled out your husband completely deterred from the fact that neither of you wanted to spend Christmas with extended family.

if they try to guilt trip/call you ungrateful over the kids gifts - tell them to take them back.

i would tell your dad that until they both accept some accountability and sincerely apologise, you need to take an extended break from them for now.

Tell them that you and DH are a grown adult couple with your own family now so any decisions you make with regards to your little family, including how you spend holidays, should be respected.