Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To never want to visit Qatar?

216 replies

RareLilacFinch · 28/12/2024 00:37

The incessant full-page ads I’m getting on MN encouraging me to visit Qatar have got me thinking about why I’d never want to go there.

As a woman, there are obvious reasons - not wanting to be under the “guardianship” of my husband, and the forced gynaecological examinations of a plane full of Australian women being the tip of the iceberg - on top of the hideous human rights abuses of migrant workers, and the general suppression of free speech.

So AIBU - am I missing something?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
BusterGonad · 28/12/2024 16:02

Maybe I'm just extremely unlucky. I don't know why these 2 things were so annoying to do. It was 9 years almost ago almost 10. I could visit my usual medical centre alone, but for the one with the ex NHS doctors I definitely needed my husband there to sign up the family. I remember clearly as I was so upset. I never returned as I was fed up of the whole place by then. I didn't trust my other doctor either so just left it.

Mnetcurious · 28/12/2024 15:59

Yanbu. I don’t understand why any woman would choose to visit this country, or others like it.

Shmithecat2 · 28/12/2024 15:56

JHound · 28/12/2024 14:20

Are you confusing Qatar with Saudi Arabia?

I know a married woman living in Qatar with her husband and she has never mentioned any of this. Nor did any of the expats when I have visited for work.

I lived in Saudi from 2013 to 2020 - I didn't need my husband for any of those things 🤷‍♀️

Shmithecat2 · 28/12/2024 15:53

BusterGonad · 28/12/2024 04:30

My health insurance was seperte but for some reason to register at the hospital of my choice, not medical centre I needed my husband there to sign the paperwork. Why would I lie? Same at Ooredoo. Maybe your husband is lucky as he presumably has a penis?

Blimey, that's bonkers. Even in Saudi as a sponsored spouse, I could do all that by myself!

JHound · 28/12/2024 15:45

BusterGonad · 28/12/2024 15:29

Did/do your married friends work? I'm glad no one had the hassle. Maybe for them they didn't mention it as it wasn't a big deal? It pissed me off as I just wanted to see a decent doctor.

One of my married friends works now (at her daughter’s school) but only in the last few years. Before that she was a housewife (which was part of the reason they moved there as they found being a single income family very difficult in the UK). They have been there well over a decade now.

JHound · 28/12/2024 15:44

cakeorwine · 28/12/2024 15:34

So a safe and welcoming place for most tourists but not all.

Any other groups you think might not find Qatar a welcoming place, let alone a safe place, if not welcoming?

No.

mitogoshigg · 28/12/2024 15:43

Agree completely, no desire to use their planes (nor any other gulf carrier) either. Flying Singapore to Oz

cakeorwine · 28/12/2024 15:34

JHound · 28/12/2024 15:25

I have zero idea. I would say a large number of places are not particularly trans friendly at the moment.

But for most tourists? Absolutely fine.

I don’t think there is any country on the planet that every single demographic group that exists would be absolutely fine there.

So a safe and welcoming place for most tourists but not all.

Any other groups you think might not find Qatar a welcoming place, let alone a safe place, if not welcoming?

wizzywig · 28/12/2024 15:30

Conversely I find Qatar, Oman etc to be a really popular tourist destination for the British Muslims I know as they don't need to worry about food, people staring at what they wear. They seem at peace at ignoring the blatant discrimination. Not for me though

BusterGonad · 28/12/2024 15:29

JHound · 28/12/2024 15:17

Interesting. You are the only married woman I have heard of living there that this happened to.

But yes absolutely of this was to be my experience there I would choose not to live there.

Edited

Did/do your married friends work? I'm glad no one had the hassle. Maybe for them they didn't mention it as it wasn't a big deal? It pissed me off as I just wanted to see a decent doctor.

JHound · 28/12/2024 15:25

cakeorwine · 28/12/2024 15:23

Do you think trans people should go there as well?

I have zero idea. I would say a large number of places are not particularly trans friendly at the moment.

But for most tourists? Absolutely fine.

I don’t think there is any country on the planet that every single demographic group that exists would be absolutely fine there.

SleepyHippy3 · 28/12/2024 15:23

BelgianBeers · 28/12/2024 08:42

There is a push for tourism from the Taliban and shamefully quite a few female influencers have joined in supporting them after funded trips.

I was reading about this. This actually blows my mind.

cakeorwine · 28/12/2024 15:23

JHound · 28/12/2024 15:16

I would think gay people should potentially avoid it (although really it’s more about whether or not you make your sexuality explicit and most don’t - I have a gay male friend who has done numerous events in Saudi Arabia and the UAE with no issue) but then that could be said about the Caribbean too, but I genuinely think in general Qatar is a safe and welcoming place for tourists.

I have visited many countries and Qatar is definitely not one I would hesitate revisiting.

Do you think trans people should go there as well?

JHound · 28/12/2024 15:17

BusterGonad · 28/12/2024 14:56

I'm pretty sure of the country I lived in for 2 years! Why would I get confused with Saudi? I've never lived in Saudi. What a ridiculous comment. I never said my husband had to accompany me day to day, I said to get simple things like the Internet installed and the contract signed he had to do it, even though it wasn't by direct debit or credit check affair. For me to visit a particular hospital that had European trained doctors my husband had to sign the paperwork for me and my son to be treated there, for enrollment/paperwork purposes on the first visit. I'm glad your friend hasn't had such frustrations, it doesn't mean that I didn't. Why do you doubt me? He did not have accompany me day to day. Why on earth do you think I meant that? For me frustrations like this just added to the fact it wasn't the place for me. Admittedly once it was done, it was done but the other aspects were still annoying. Tbh Muslim countries are not for me for many other reasons.

Interesting. You are the only married woman I have heard of living there that this happened to.

But yes absolutely of this was to be my experience there I would choose not to live there.

JHound · 28/12/2024 15:16

cakeorwine · 28/12/2024 14:38

Do you believe that Qatar is a safe, welcoming place for all tourists?
Or would you advise some to avoid it?

I would think gay people should potentially avoid it (although really it’s more about whether or not you make your sexuality explicit and most don’t - I have a gay male friend who has done numerous events in Saudi Arabia and the UAE with no issue) but then that could be said about the Caribbean too, but I genuinely think in general Qatar is a safe and welcoming place for tourists.

I have visited many countries and Qatar is definitely not one I would hesitate revisiting.

BusterGonad · 28/12/2024 15:10

Oh and the servants thing, in Qatar they are lovingly called Maids, they generally work 6 days a week, get about $400 a month and I think a return flight home once a year (if I remember rightly but it was about 8 years ago) I could be wrong as I never had one though. They work long hours and are lucky if they get to go home once a year to visit there kids in the Philippines. My friend had a maid, she specifically chose one who had kids in the Philippines because she thought they'd be better at looking after her own kids. That made me feel incredibly sad. When the family no longer needs a maid they do sometimes put a post out on expat Facebook groups saying how good she is, loyal, hardworking etc. So she gets a good family next time.

BusterGonad · 28/12/2024 14:56

JHound · 28/12/2024 14:20

Are you confusing Qatar with Saudi Arabia?

I know a married woman living in Qatar with her husband and she has never mentioned any of this. Nor did any of the expats when I have visited for work.

I'm pretty sure of the country I lived in for 2 years! Why would I get confused with Saudi? I've never lived in Saudi. What a ridiculous comment. I never said my husband had to accompany me day to day, I said to get simple things like the Internet installed and the contract signed he had to do it, even though it wasn't by direct debit or credit check affair. For me to visit a particular hospital that had European trained doctors my husband had to sign the paperwork for me and my son to be treated there, for enrollment/paperwork purposes on the first visit. I'm glad your friend hasn't had such frustrations, it doesn't mean that I didn't. Why do you doubt me? He did not have accompany me day to day. Why on earth do you think I meant that? For me frustrations like this just added to the fact it wasn't the place for me. Admittedly once it was done, it was done but the other aspects were still annoying. Tbh Muslim countries are not for me for many other reasons.

cakeorwine · 28/12/2024 14:38

JHound · 28/12/2024 14:21

Yep. I used that example because in the all the “panic” about Qatar and the treatment of Aussie tourists they neglect the UK has done the same - except to kids.

The negative comment about “people having servants there” was also baffling as if people don’t employ nannies, cleaners and gardeners in the UK.

What’s the difference?!

Edited

Do you believe that Qatar is a safe, welcoming place for all tourists?
Or would you advise some to avoid it?

eastereggg · 28/12/2024 14:35

I think any normal person would avoid avoid avoid the UAE as a whole

Betchyaby · 28/12/2024 14:30

Totally agree. I wouldn't visit any Islamic countries.

JHound · 28/12/2024 14:21

NautilusLionfish · 28/12/2024 03:44

Oh come off it JHound (am being sarcastic). People here don't care about it. Or will pretend there was a good reason for that. Child Q was black after all. And subsequent inquiry showed that foe black children, being strip searched was no an uncommon experience.

While I agree with reasons people don't want to visit Qatar, Dubai but putting it as if "modern" slavery, trafficking of women doesn't happen here is being hypocritical. And increasingly the UK is depending on severely underpaid mostly foreign cleaners, nannies. Paying them wages they can hardly live on and feeling superior about it because we dont call them servants. We all need to do better. And to look deeper. Not just at others but also at ourselves. Is it worse in the countries mentioned here. Absolutely. But it happens here.
Oh about buying the world cup. Whoever stopped Western countries hosting sports events even as they oppressed and killed others (too many countries to mention) including in Iraq, while Western corporations currently use slave labour to get rare earth in DRC, cut off people's hands in the then Congo, and massacred people in Kenya, Malawi, Zimbabwe, pretty much every African country?

Edited

Yep. I used that example because in the all the “panic” about Qatar and the treatment of Aussie tourists they neglect the UK has done the same - except to kids.

The negative comment about “people having servants there” was also baffling as if people don’t employ nannies, cleaners and gardeners in the UK.

What’s the difference?!

JHound · 28/12/2024 14:20

BusterGonad · 28/12/2024 03:07

I think what the poster means by guardianship is women are beneath men. To get the Internet fitted you need to take your husband to the store, to go to the hospital you need to take your husband with you to be put into the system, to get my sons eyes checked (children can only get there eyes checked in hospital), once again my husband would have to come with us to get him an appointment. No joint bank accounts, only allowed in husbands name. Almost everything had to be done with my husband there. Obviously if you are working in Qatar as a single woman this doesn't apply to you but as a non working wife I could do fuck all without my husband being there. Extremely frustrating for both of us.

Are you confusing Qatar with Saudi Arabia?

I know a married woman living in Qatar with her husband and she has never mentioned any of this. Nor did any of the expats when I have visited for work.

JHound · 28/12/2024 14:18

TandyhatesAmanda · 28/12/2024 03:16

And housewives do not need their husbands to be with them, not ever. It's just not true. Maybe 20 years or so ago but that's not how it is. Im sorry but that's just not true. Hate the ME by all means, raise concerns about genuine issues but at least research the facts.

Yep my friend lives in Qatar and has never mentioned any need for guardianship or her husband needing to accompany her everywhere. She would not be there were that the case.

Pipconkermash · 28/12/2024 13:14

FictionalCharacter · 28/12/2024 01:10

Wow. What would have happened if they'd said no?

They all did. They were forced. One woman said she felt like she’d been raped.

Lentilweaver · 28/12/2024 11:22

Projectmee · 28/12/2024 10:48

Exactly. People forget that some are targeted more than others.

I don’t know the stats on this but anecdotally it would seem a disproportionate amount of non-white westerners bear the brunt of their inconsistent corrupt justice system.

And if you’re non-white/non-Arab AND you don’t have a western passport - that of course puts you into an even more vulnerable position.

Apparently Pakistanis are treated particularly bad there. I was actually slightly surprised to hear that as I’d have expected some religious solidarity.

I agree with all you say, especially after the Marcus Fakana case.

There is another angle though. As a non-white person who was not born with a Western passport myself, it is very difficult and expensive to get a tourist visa to a white country. I work in a diverse organisation and the PoC do not have the energy to get visas for the UK or Europe, while producing bank statements, letters from employers, property documents etc. So our annual conferences are held in Dubai, Bangkok, KL and other countries that do not have ridiculous visa regimes. Also centrally located for Asians. I think the UAE makes a lot of money from conferences and meetings.

My own extended family from India find it difficult to visit me in the UK. Therefore we often meet in countries with less than great human rights records. Like Turkey. It's not ideal but often that is what passport privilege means.