Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

adult son’s age gap relationship

132 replies

scottiemum3 · 27/12/2024 17:31

Hi everyone, I’d appreciate your advice and thoughts.

I have three adult sons in their 30s. My oldest (38) has asked for my advice - I’m one of the only people he really goes to for serious conversations.

He is dating a woman, 24. We found out a few months ago through a family friend. He was keeping the relationship secret because he was embarrassed about the age gap. However, they are clearly so happy with each other. She really wants to stay with him, and even spoke to me about this.

However my DS keeps saying he is too old for her, that it can’t last, that it would be better to end it now so she can find someone her own age. Also - he is wealthy, she is a very attractive, all of which is playing into a cliché.

They both want to have children and settle down. It is the first time my DS has really found someone who is right for him.

He asked me for my thoughts. Of course, I tried to emphasise that it is his decision. But I worry he might try to end a wonderful relationship, and even the chance for family life at a good age to be a father, because he is concerned about how the age gap looks, or what other people say, and he trusts my judgement.

I don’t know that many people in ‘real’ life in age gap relationships, so I would be grateful if anyone could share their experiences.

I realise this makes it seem like I interfere a lot in my children’s lives - that’s not true! Usually this son in particular is very independent. I totally realise he is an adult and able to make his own decisions. It’s just that I don’t have much to draw on, so would appreciate hearing from others.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BIossomtoes · 30/12/2024 15:10

I'd be absolutely horrified if my 22 yr old came home with a 55 year old in tow.

Most people would now but the world was very different 80 years ago.

Gloriia · 30/12/2024 12:37

Ahwig · 29/12/2024 23:59

My aunt was 22 when she got married. My uncle was 55. He was 82 when he died so they had 27 years together.
She lived in a 2 bedroom tenement flat in Brixton with my grandparents and 2 sisters, he had his own house which was extremely unusual in the 1940's.
He was a confirmed bachelor and had never wanted to get married, but once he met my aunt, everything changed for him.
Neither of them wanted children. They were married within 6 months of meeting and had a very happy life together. .

22 and 55?! That is some age gap. I'd be absolutely horrified if my 22 yr old came home with a 55 year old in tow. Do you think living in an overcrowded flat in Brixton when her 55 yr old dp had a house may have swung things in his favour a bit?

In the op's case of her ds's 14 yr gap that is far more acceptable. Still a bit weird but at least they'd look a similar generation.

Ahwig · 29/12/2024 23:59

My aunt was 22 when she got married. My uncle was 55. He was 82 when he died so they had 27 years together.
She lived in a 2 bedroom tenement flat in Brixton with my grandparents and 2 sisters, he had his own house which was extremely unusual in the 1940's.
He was a confirmed bachelor and had never wanted to get married, but once he met my aunt, everything changed for him.
Neither of them wanted children. They were married within 6 months of meeting and had a very happy life together. .

purpleblue2 · 29/12/2024 22:35

I’ve got a child with someone who is 40 and I’m 29, he is an idiot on all accounts but there’s nothing to do with our ages

DreamTheMoors · 29/12/2024 22:32

scottiemum3 · 27/12/2024 21:04

Thank you so much for all your thoughts and kind responses.
Reflecting on this now, I realise my DS must have been thinking about all of this a lot recently, as there have been a lot of family gatherings, seeing family friends and so on over Christmas, plus a few weddings we’ve all been to this year. So it might be particularly at the forefront of his mind. She looks so young and beautiful and they do attract a lot of comments.
He has dated a lot previously, and is worried about looking like a ‘creep’ (as someone put it here).

I wasn’t very clear, but my AIBU was: AIBU to encourage him to stay with her

I think you should encourage your son to follow his heart, and where that will lead him.
Maybe that will be with this woman, maybe another. Your son, his heart.

Nc261224 · 29/12/2024 20:42

@scottiemum3 I'm from northern Europe myself, similar age gap between me and DH. I do think that young people tend to be ore mature from where I come from. And more direct. But it's not normal to approach the family members of a man you fancy to vonplain to them that he is not responding in kind 🚩
Regarding age gap, I had experienced some prejudices, for example people that barely know us assuming that I am with him for money (he had none when we met), or just a tone of conversation that I "snagged" him implying I went "hunting" for him which was not the case.

Caterguin · 28/12/2024 18:33

YankSplaining · 28/12/2024 13:49

He’s in his late 40s, you’re already worrying you might have to be his carer someday, and you’re not sure you’d marry him again?

This sounds like your relationship has deeper problems.

No, just practical. At 25 I didn't have any real idea about how much bodies change from mid 40s onwards and again mid 50s. His medicine cabinet is very late middle age. Neither of us wants to be the other's carer; we've had this discussion. But chances are more that it will be me, which would be less likely if we were similar ages. I look at relatives in their 70s and 80s and think about how I'll only be in my 60s then. And already, I look after myself better.

Retirement will be a hurdle, although I think my pension is healthier than his. Not sure how long we'll have to do fun Retirement stuff though.
I'm not going to divorce him over it, but I probably should have thought beyond "I really fancy this man, 10 years is nothing. " Because 10 years might narrow in 30s/40s, but it widens again.

Purplevelvetshoes · 28/12/2024 16:42

scottiemum3 · 28/12/2024 16:23

Oh gosh, I didn't ser it as that. It was out of character for her to come and speak to me, but she is from a culture where they are very open and direct about everything, in a way that perhaps we Brits are quite avoidant! She's got tons of admirers so she would certainly have a lot of options as a single woman. Whenever we have been out for meals or similar men just fall over her

Nope she still sought out his mother when he didn’t want a relationship. Did you encourage him to see her?

He maybe be bewildered this young beautiful woman who men faun over is chomping at the bit to get in to his family and life but in reality he’s just not that in to the age gap.

Just because she is has admirers doesn’t mean she hasn’t found it hard in the past to find a stable relationship. Beauty doesn’t equal emotionally stable women or even a catch

ThatKhakiMoose · 28/12/2024 16:27

BIossomtoes · 28/12/2024 09:33

He won’t be getting his pension until she’s 54. And no man her own age is going to want her at that point, they tend to want someone younger.

Excellent, she'll avoid the kind of man who won't date someone his own age.

scottiemum3 · 28/12/2024 16:23

Shrinkingrose · 28/12/2024 13:54

That’s utterly creepy, she came to speak to you when he didn’t want to go out with her, can any part of you see how wrong that is?

Oh gosh, I didn't ser it as that. It was out of character for her to come and speak to me, but she is from a culture where they are very open and direct about everything, in a way that perhaps we Brits are quite avoidant! She's got tons of admirers so she would certainly have a lot of options as a single woman. Whenever we have been out for meals or similar men just fall over her

OP posts:
Calmhappyandhealthy · 28/12/2024 14:49

They originally met through friends when she was 23 and he was trying to distance himself from her then because of her age. She was very upset and even came to speak to me about it (unsolicited by me but appreciate her confidence)

Hmmm.

Shes controlling and she knows her end game 🤮🙄

I'd encourage your son to leave her

lanthanum · 28/12/2024 14:07

We have family friends with a bigger age gap than that - they've been married for 32 years now. I suspect the period of time between his retirement and hers must have been rather weird to get used to, but they're both retired now.

YankSplaining · 28/12/2024 13:54

ThatKhakiMoose · 28/12/2024 07:51

Men who are happy with an age gap when it's them who's older are never keen to have a relationship with someone with the same age gap but older than them. So it's OK for their young partner to put up with someone much older, but they wouldn't want that for themselves.

OP, if your son had already had kids, so fertility was a non-issue, do you think he'd want to marry someone age 52?

These age-gap relationships are all based on lust on the part of the man, and we all know it, which is why people make comments.

“We all know it” - speak for yourself. I don’t believe they’re “all based on lust on the part of the man,” and neither do a lot of other people.

Shrinkingrose · 28/12/2024 13:54

That’s utterly creepy, she came to speak to you when he didn’t want to go out with her, can any part of you see how wrong that is?

YankSplaining · 28/12/2024 13:49

Caterguin · 27/12/2024 18:47

I was 25 when I met dh. He is 10 years older. Generally, I have outearned him. In fact, me outearning him early on gave him the kick up the arse to improve himself - he took the a levels he dropped out of in his teens etc. We've had periods where we both earn the same, but I'm currently ahead by a long way.

I didn't realise he was 10 years older when we met. I was attracted by his looks, conversation and the chemistry. Further on, it was the way he looks after me. I bring the dynamism; he brings stability. Together 20+ years and 2dc. Numerous pets.

However.

The gap has had its problematic side as he's got older, especially his late 40s, and I'm aware that I may end up his carer; not necessarily have a fun retirement and be alone for a long time.

Not sure I'd do it again.

He’s in his late 40s, you’re already worrying you might have to be his carer someday, and you’re not sure you’d marry him again?

This sounds like your relationship has deeper problems.

ExitPersuedByAMemory · 28/12/2024 13:37

YDBear · 27/12/2024 18:28

Nobody will think about age gaps when he is 68 and she is 54.

@YDBear It will be very obvious at various points in life though. When he becomes 40, she’ll just be 26. When he’s 50, she’ll just be 36. Until she reaches her 40s, the age gap will be increasingly obvious. Not to mention the fact that she’s just getting started and OP’s son is more established in his career.

Purplevelvetshoes · 28/12/2024 13:21

Icanlarf · 28/12/2024 13:13

I don’t agree with ‘if it does not feel right it is not right’ otherwise he would not be asking. Being cautious about such a huge step in his life is very wise. Asking advice from people he trusts is a sensible road to take. It does seem like he is trying to protect her which is good. Unfortunately this stort of gossip is sly and slips under the radar. In your positions, if I heard it, I would deliver a very sharp slap down.

I’ve worked all my life in male dominated areas - have many males in my family. When a guy wants a women he couldn’t give a shiny shit about what other people think.

After the back story I think this girl already feels like a burden and possibly a liability to him and he is looking for a way out.

SoNiceToComeHomeTo · 28/12/2024 13:20

A gap of 14 years isn't that uncommon and sometimes works fine. I'd suggest to him that he shouldn't rush things by getting married or trying for a baby, or limit her opportunities for developing new interests and friends before settling down to have a family.
But I wonder if the crux of his hesitation is that he's scared of being left for someone more attractive as he moves through his forties and she's still in her twenties. That is a risk and perhaps he can't bear to take it.

Icanlarf · 28/12/2024 13:13

I don’t agree with ‘if it does not feel right it is not right’ otherwise he would not be asking. Being cautious about such a huge step in his life is very wise. Asking advice from people he trusts is a sensible road to take. It does seem like he is trying to protect her which is good. Unfortunately this stort of gossip is sly and slips under the radar. In your positions, if I heard it, I would deliver a very sharp slap down.

Nc261224 · 28/12/2024 13:06

Purplevelvetshoes · 28/12/2024 12:49

It doesn’t feel right to him. If it did he wouldn’t be asking.

My advice would be ‘Son if it feels right why are you even asking? What doesn’t feel right?’

This should open up a wider discussion. Deep down he might actually feel she is just after his money

Good point! Ask open ended questions

Nc261224 · 28/12/2024 13:05

Similar age gap as me and my DH. He's made me very happy for the past 15 years.
He won't feel the ahmge difference if she is emotionally mature for her age (and at 24 she is not a baby!)

Seventimesaday · 28/12/2024 13:01

There are 12 years between DH and me. We got together when I was 25 ( day after my birthday) and married 18 months later. He was worried at first about the age gap, but we had so much in common that it didn’t seem such a big gap.
We have been married 32 years. The age gap is more noticeable now as he is retired, but I work part time and he is still very fit and active, does the majority of dog walking and household tasks when I am at work. It’s great getting home after a long day to a hot meal waiting on the table!

mlc0 · 28/12/2024 13:00

I met my husband when I was 25 and he was 38! 3 years on we are now married with a baby due in 9 weeks!

Purplevelvetshoes · 28/12/2024 12:53

scottiemum3 · 28/12/2024 12:47

Yes, that is his / he general concern.
They originally met through friends when she was 23 and he was trying to distance himself from her then because of her age. She was very upset and even came to speak to me about it (unsolicited by me but appreciate her confidence). She doesn't have much in the way of family and I think has found stability in our family.

After this update I’d be concerned to he honest. He wants a wife not a child he has got to look after. Coming to speak to you whilst upset that he chose to distance himself self whilst not even in a relationship shows she has no emotional maturity or respecting his boundaries. His family isn’t hers to adopt.

I wonder if he can feel this and really wants to run for the hills

Purplevelvetshoes · 28/12/2024 12:49

scottiemum3 · 27/12/2024 17:31

Hi everyone, I’d appreciate your advice and thoughts.

I have three adult sons in their 30s. My oldest (38) has asked for my advice - I’m one of the only people he really goes to for serious conversations.

He is dating a woman, 24. We found out a few months ago through a family friend. He was keeping the relationship secret because he was embarrassed about the age gap. However, they are clearly so happy with each other. She really wants to stay with him, and even spoke to me about this.

However my DS keeps saying he is too old for her, that it can’t last, that it would be better to end it now so she can find someone her own age. Also - he is wealthy, she is a very attractive, all of which is playing into a cliché.

They both want to have children and settle down. It is the first time my DS has really found someone who is right for him.

He asked me for my thoughts. Of course, I tried to emphasise that it is his decision. But I worry he might try to end a wonderful relationship, and even the chance for family life at a good age to be a father, because he is concerned about how the age gap looks, or what other people say, and he trusts my judgement.

I don’t know that many people in ‘real’ life in age gap relationships, so I would be grateful if anyone could share their experiences.

I realise this makes it seem like I interfere a lot in my children’s lives - that’s not true! Usually this son in particular is very independent. I totally realise he is an adult and able to make his own decisions. It’s just that I don’t have much to draw on, so would appreciate hearing from others.

It doesn’t feel right to him. If it did he wouldn’t be asking.

My advice would be ‘Son if it feels right why are you even asking? What doesn’t feel right?’

This should open up a wider discussion. Deep down he might actually feel she is just after his money

Swipe left for the next trending thread