Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don’t want my in laws to hold my baby, AIBU

360 replies

QuestioningThings1 · 23/12/2024 10:48

We met DHs family at the pub yesterday for Christmas drinks. I passed our 4month old over to DH while I took DD1 to the toilet, when I came back DD2 was being held by SIL. She had my baby right in front of her face so they weren’t kissing but sharing breath and I could have cried on the spot. I didn’t want to make a scene because no one was unwell and baby was happy but DH knows how I feel about germs. I’ve been extra paranoid lately as everyone is getting the flu and saying it’s the worst they’ve ever had it they’ve been bed bound etc. Then we get baby back and then DH is stood up with baby asking others if they want to hold her. MIL had her next at which point baby started crying, thank god I thought while saying I’ll take her back now thank you and I kept hold of her until we went. But again she was very close to her face. I had her on my knee in conversation with DH while his auntie spoke to baby and then when I looked she had her fingers in my babies mouth!! I quickly moved her away and said oh she’s teething and took her away at which point I said to DH I want to go home now. We’d been there 2 hours anyway and I was on the verge of tears at this point. We got home and I couldn’t sleep my heart was beating fast and it still is this morning. I feel so so guilty about not being able to say in front of everyone I don’t want my baby being passed round or not being able to say what the fuck are you doing putting your dirty hands in my babies mouth. I get DH just wants his family to bond with our kids but up until 6 months ago they have not been arsed with our kids and DD1 is 3. We see them for an hour once every 3 weeks. I fell out with DH as soon as we got home because I was so stressed and anxious and he knows how I feel about playing pass the parcel with the baby and I was stressed about the hands in the mouth thing so I guess I took that out on him as well even though that was my fault for not watching.

He said I do it with my family (play pass the parcel) but I don’t. If I need a wee or need to sort DD1 out I say to my family can you hold her while I do x, y or z. Both of my sister have just had babies and if I want a cuddle we will swap. I never walk into a room and say who wants a hold, I will always try and keep her with me when I can because I’m mum and I want her with me. Also with my family I can and do tell them often. ‘Don’t get too close to her face when you’re holding her’, ‘I can smell smoke on you so no sorry’ ‘Don’t kiss her thanks’ ‘Don’t put your hands in her mouth’. I have a very close relationship with my mum and sisters and they know my boundaries and I’m very comfortable to remind them if they forget. I don’t have that same relationship with my in laws, neither does DH. We have a lot of history of them not respecting boundaries and talking behind our backs because we’ve set boundaries and the last time we met up my FIL was coughing into his hands then holding my babies hand. My baby sucks her thumb so I had to take her to the toilets and wash her tiny hands and got upset after just in case anything passed. But again nothing was said to him, my fault again. I know if I say something it will probably jeopardise DHs relationship with his family and they’ve only just started making half an effort with him again.

I don’t know whether I’m just really hormonal still because my body feels like it’s going through a lot at this stage my skin has gone bad my hair is falling out but I don’t trust his family or feel comfortable when they hold my baby.

Am I being unreasonable for not wanting my in laws to hold my baby?!

If they asked to have a hold I think I’d feel differently but It’s always DH asking them

OP posts:
PamelaShipman80 · 24/12/2024 21:31

BIossomtoes · 24/12/2024 19:38

Why? What do you think’s going to happen to it?

Nothing in particular, it just makes me feel very very uncomfortable. I hate the thought of my baby being passed round a group of people. Not enjoyable for the baby is it either, they just want their mum, and surely it’s the baby’s feelings that matter!

DivorcedAndDelighted · 24/12/2024 21:21

Rowen32 · 23/12/2024 12:12

Has everybody missed the part where these in laws couldn't give two hoots until recently and OP's first child is 3 but now are all about the baby, for heavens sake stop with the diagnosing of anxiety and pnd. Yes, she's having a bad moment but these people have suddenly come back into her life, she's not comfortable with them to set appropriate boundaries and they've pretty much ignored her first child, naturally she doesn't want them all over her baby.

Is it possible the baby's grandparents stayed away from the first child because of similar issues, feeling they weren't welcome or trusted with the baby? Regardless, grandparents who love your baby are valuable. They're part of your child's team for life and this is bigger than how the mother feels about it. They're not to be discarded or kept at arm's length without good reason.

Liglig · 24/12/2024 21:11

OP I am happy to hear you are going to get help with your anxiety and that you took comments onboard like a champ. I wish you well, have a lovely Christmas ⛄

Greenshed · 24/12/2024 21:03

Yes, you’re being unreasonable.

Littlebirdy7 · 24/12/2024 20:52

For what it’s worth @QuestioningThings1 i don’t think you’re being unreasonable at all. I felt similarly with my first when they were little. The difference is my DH was on the same page and respected how I felt (though MIL did get close to baby’s face but DH reminded her not to).

however it’s always a good idea to seek support if you’re struggling with your MH or at the very least talk to someone trusted about how you’re feeling, what’s going on for you.

Maybe I’m ‘precious’ too like others have said (dang right I am 😉) but you’re not alone in how you feel and you are in fact, normal, whatever the hell that means. Wishing you and your family a lovely festive season.

laraitopbanana · 24/12/2024 20:32

Hi op,

be gentle in yourself and whatever you are feeling is valid and important. It is a DH issue as if you aren’t « ready » then he shouldn’t propose…try to again share your feelings but remember it is his baby too and he is just trying to get some bonding going on.

maybe holding off « meeting » until you are ready…if you can give a « line » so to speak as to when you will feel more comfortable?

You won’t be able to « hold of » for ever so if it carries on, I would maybe try and think why you feel that way and how you generally feel because I am unsure this particular feeling should stay long.

Good luck op 🌺

Hocuspoc · 24/12/2024 20:15

QuestioningThings1 · 23/12/2024 10:48

We met DHs family at the pub yesterday for Christmas drinks. I passed our 4month old over to DH while I took DD1 to the toilet, when I came back DD2 was being held by SIL. She had my baby right in front of her face so they weren’t kissing but sharing breath and I could have cried on the spot. I didn’t want to make a scene because no one was unwell and baby was happy but DH knows how I feel about germs. I’ve been extra paranoid lately as everyone is getting the flu and saying it’s the worst they’ve ever had it they’ve been bed bound etc. Then we get baby back and then DH is stood up with baby asking others if they want to hold her. MIL had her next at which point baby started crying, thank god I thought while saying I’ll take her back now thank you and I kept hold of her until we went. But again she was very close to her face. I had her on my knee in conversation with DH while his auntie spoke to baby and then when I looked she had her fingers in my babies mouth!! I quickly moved her away and said oh she’s teething and took her away at which point I said to DH I want to go home now. We’d been there 2 hours anyway and I was on the verge of tears at this point. We got home and I couldn’t sleep my heart was beating fast and it still is this morning. I feel so so guilty about not being able to say in front of everyone I don’t want my baby being passed round or not being able to say what the fuck are you doing putting your dirty hands in my babies mouth. I get DH just wants his family to bond with our kids but up until 6 months ago they have not been arsed with our kids and DD1 is 3. We see them for an hour once every 3 weeks. I fell out with DH as soon as we got home because I was so stressed and anxious and he knows how I feel about playing pass the parcel with the baby and I was stressed about the hands in the mouth thing so I guess I took that out on him as well even though that was my fault for not watching.

He said I do it with my family (play pass the parcel) but I don’t. If I need a wee or need to sort DD1 out I say to my family can you hold her while I do x, y or z. Both of my sister have just had babies and if I want a cuddle we will swap. I never walk into a room and say who wants a hold, I will always try and keep her with me when I can because I’m mum and I want her with me. Also with my family I can and do tell them often. ‘Don’t get too close to her face when you’re holding her’, ‘I can smell smoke on you so no sorry’ ‘Don’t kiss her thanks’ ‘Don’t put your hands in her mouth’. I have a very close relationship with my mum and sisters and they know my boundaries and I’m very comfortable to remind them if they forget. I don’t have that same relationship with my in laws, neither does DH. We have a lot of history of them not respecting boundaries and talking behind our backs because we’ve set boundaries and the last time we met up my FIL was coughing into his hands then holding my babies hand. My baby sucks her thumb so I had to take her to the toilets and wash her tiny hands and got upset after just in case anything passed. But again nothing was said to him, my fault again. I know if I say something it will probably jeopardise DHs relationship with his family and they’ve only just started making half an effort with him again.

I don’t know whether I’m just really hormonal still because my body feels like it’s going through a lot at this stage my skin has gone bad my hair is falling out but I don’t trust his family or feel comfortable when they hold my baby.

Am I being unreasonable for not wanting my in laws to hold my baby?!

If they asked to have a hold I think I’d feel differently but It’s always DH asking them

I don't think you are unreasonable to be upset.
I understand some comments here saying it may be a bit of an overkill in terms of detail what works and what not etc..
But main point for me here is that your husband knows you are anxious, and you went out during flu season regardless so dc can bond with his family. Yet he doesn't respect the boundaries you've set so you could feel OK going out to this pub with dc. To me that doesn't sit well, perhaps because I am also on the more cautious side and my dh is very relaxed - so I feel your pain.

Tourmalines · 24/12/2024 20:08

Brainstorm23 · 24/12/2024 19:43

We're on page 13 and people are still replying. Please bear in mind OP has recognised she has anxiety. I don't want to be the thread police but i don't think these responses are going to help her.

It’s always the way. People just read the ops first post and don’t bother reading updates . So the advise is often old news and not relevant anymore . But , that will never change . I see it all the time .

BooBooDoodle · 24/12/2024 20:07

I think you need to see a GP about your anxiety issues. This isn’t normal at all.

GivingYourHeadAWobble · 24/12/2024 20:06

Angiemum24 · 24/12/2024 19:20

If your husband knew how you feel, then he shouldn't have said who wants to hold her. And Auntie doing the fingers in her mouth is wrong. Make sure you give her baby vitamins, prebiotics and keep her feet covered.

If your husband knew how you feel, then he shouldn't have said who wants to hold her.

Errrm yes he should!

He knows no harm is going to come to his child if his mother and sister want to hold her.

Brainstorm23 · 24/12/2024 19:43

We're on page 13 and people are still replying. Please bear in mind OP has recognised she has anxiety. I don't want to be the thread police but i don't think these responses are going to help her.

BIossomtoes · 24/12/2024 19:38

PamelaShipman80 · 24/12/2024 19:35

I get people saying you’re being unreasonable but I’m 100% the same. I don’t want anyone holding h my baby

Why? What do you think’s going to happen to it?

TheTavern · 24/12/2024 19:37

Sorry but you are being a bit OTT

PamelaShipman80 · 24/12/2024 19:35

I get people saying you’re being unreasonable but I’m 100% the same. I don’t want anyone holding h my baby

Soontobe60 · 24/12/2024 19:32

It’s really important for the development of babies’ immune systems that they are exposed to germs from other people as young as possible. Obviously if someone has an illness thats not ideal, but general germs is.
You're being extremely over cautious and not doing your baby any favours.

Angiemum24 · 24/12/2024 19:20

If your husband knew how you feel, then he shouldn't have said who wants to hold her. And Auntie doing the fingers in her mouth is wrong. Make sure you give her baby vitamins, prebiotics and keep her feet covered.

Jorge14 · 24/12/2024 19:03

I’m with you on the fingers in the mouth & I don’t think people should kiss babies on the mouth because of cold sores etc, but…. it’s her family and they love her & wanted a cuddle.

Buffs · 24/12/2024 19:00

Your baby needs germs to develop their immune system. Soon they will be crawling on the floor, putting everything into their mouth. When they start nursery they will be immersed in germs. You need to find some way of understanding and accepting this. As others have said you may have PND or need some help dealing with anxiety.

Toptops · 24/12/2024 18:55

Sorry, you need help

pineapplesundae · 24/12/2024 18:51

Babies need to be exposed to the environment so they build up immunities. Get some help for your anxiety and let your in-laws love the baby.

Tiswa · 24/12/2024 18:34

SparklingPinot · 24/12/2024 18:00

YANBU & I can’t quite believe the volume of posts that disagree with your POV. Fingers in the mouth is a hard no I would have been FUMING. Also pass the parcel with the baby was never for me & agree people putting their mouths too close to babies faces is rancid.

Again it is not about disagreeing with her post or suggesting she should allow it but acknowledging (and the OP herself has done so) that her responses are anxiety induced and not normal

GivingYourHeadAWobble · 24/12/2024 18:27

Waitoneminutemum · 24/12/2024 18:24

I can’t believe some of the responses here no one should be putting their fingers in your babies mouth

Quote one post that says anyone should be putting their fingers in the baby's mouth?

I mean as opposed to those saying the dad should be allowed to let his mum and his sister cuddle his 4 month old baby?

Waitoneminutemum · 24/12/2024 18:24

I can’t believe some of the responses here no one should be putting their fingers in your babies mouth

GiveDogBone · 24/12/2024 18:00

You need to deal with your anxiety and not project it onto your baby. I feel very sorry for them, babies pick up on the cues of their parents and you are in danger of giving them all sorts of anxieties over contact with other people, cleanliness, etc. Seek professional help asap before it’s too late. If you don’t then remember this post when your child is older and suffering from their own anxieties that you have effectively given them.

SparklingPinot · 24/12/2024 18:00

YANBU & I can’t quite believe the volume of posts that disagree with your POV. Fingers in the mouth is a hard no I would have been FUMING. Also pass the parcel with the baby was never for me & agree people putting their mouths too close to babies faces is rancid.

Swipe left for the next trending thread